Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01780 · Session 5

Consultation on the closure of large shops on New Year's Day

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2019 Business & Industry
Signatures
0
2,040 online signatures with a country
Comments
188
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to launch a consultation on implementing legislation already in place to ban large shops from opening on New Year’s Day.

What the petitioner did first

Usdaw has previously written to James Hepburn, Minister for Business, Fair Work and Skills, asking that the Government launch a consultation on the issue.
The organisation has been advised that the Government does not intend to commission research into the impact of trading by large stores on New Year’s Day.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 20 Feb 2020
    1 mention
  2. 8 Oct 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 16 Dec 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 10 Feb 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,040 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,408 69%
  2. United Kingdom575 28.2%
  3. England49 2.4%
  4. Northern Ireland2 0.1%
  5. France1 0%
  6. Greece1 0%
  7. Netherlands1 0%
  8. New Zealand1 0%
  9. Wales1 0%
  10. Germany1 0%

Comments

188 comments, oldest first
188 comments · showing 101–150
  1. Pamela Watson 28 Dec 2019
    I have to use a holiday day as I refuse to work new years day, it's just greed from retail
  2. Eòin McIntyre 28 Dec 2019
    Agreed.
  3. Betty Hainey 29 Dec 2019
    They should also be off on Boxing Day and have 2 days off at New Year.Employees deserve a break after the biz if the Christmas shopping frenzy!
  4. Natalia Mckendrick 29 Dec 2019
    Larger shops should never have been allowed to open on new year's day. People that work in retail have it hard enough of it being so busy this time of year.
  5. Irene forsyth 29 Dec 2019
    Shops should be shut 2 days Christmas and 2 days New Year
  6. Ms Christina Dunsmuir 29 Dec 2019
    I Agree that all Stores & work places should be closed on 1st Jan
  7. Marie Ohara 29 Dec 2019
    Having new years day off allows people to enjoy time with loved ones... Do you really need to visit a shop on new year's day... Really...
  8. Eileen Allan 29 Dec 2019
    I work in a supermarket and find profit comes before family. We are disposable assets
  9. Moira Willox 29 Dec 2019
    Should be compulsory.for everyone
  10. Eileen Harvey 29 Dec 2019
    What about the small stores
  11. Graham Gardner 30 Dec 2019
    Get it done
  12. Helen Milne 30 Dec 2019
    Should not be madeto work
  13. thomas suttie 31 Dec 2019
    Big supermarket chains have to much power
  14. James Valentine 31 Dec 2019
    No need for shops to be open just corporate greed in my opinion.
  15. Julie Pattinson 31 Dec 2019
    All retailers should close on new years day and respect that this is a public holiday in Scotland. England stores are closed on Easter Sunday!!
  16. Marion Murdoch 31 Dec 2019
    my country of scotland isn't here so I can't sign the petition which I would most certainly have done
  17. James Richards 9 Jan 2020
    We have sales all year round. The Internet has changed everything regarding retail. Opening on such days represents a race to the bottom. And of course, give time off to hardworking staff. The world will not stop spinning if large business all close on a few select days of the year.
  18. Moira Maxwell 9 Jan 2020
    Worked retail now for 15 years now and not once do I feel like it Christmas or new year as always having to work hours which leaves me unable to have that special time with family.
  19. Ian Keightley 9 Jan 2020
    Shops should stay closed on news year's day so we can spend money time with our families
  20. Ian Flower 9 Jan 2020
    Shut shops
  21. Alan Rorrison 9 Jan 2020
    100% agree!
  22. Carole Wood 9 Jan 2020
    Let's spend time with family and friends
  23. Mr John Mclean 9 Jan 2020
    All these big retail companies make enough money and profits all the year round so it's about time the retail workers and the public services have a good Christmas and new year the same as all the big directors and bosses from these companies as well afterall its Christmas and new year for everyone
  24. Peter Randell 20 Jan 2020
    Long overdue
  25. Hugh Rodger 20 Jan 2020
    It has my full backing
  26. Karen Ballard 20 Jan 2020
    Should be closed Boxing Day and 1st and 2nd January this time of year is meant to be family time so let give people chance to spend quality time
  27. John Mclean 20 Jan 2020
    These large retail companies make enough money throughout the year they can afford to close for a day and the directors and the high earners don't have to work so I don't think this is fare afterall it is our new year as well
  28. James Irvine 20 Jan 2020
    People spend enough time at work festival season is time to spend with family
  29. garry mcdonald 20 Jan 2020
    The festive period holidays should be for everybody to enjoy.
  30. Mrs Gillian Hutchison 20 Jan 2020
    I work in a large food store and would not welcome having to work on new year day.
  31. Elizabeth wood 20 Jan 2020
    People fought for years to get these days off years ago and companies have slowly sneaked them back in and suppose to be voluntary. Try telling a manager that
  32. Richard Stephen 20 Jan 2020
    Completely agree
  33. Ian Johnston 20 Jan 2020
    To make it fair for all
  34. Frances MCGRILLAN 20 Jan 2020
    All shops should be closed not just the larger ones
  35. Elaine Bellingham 20 Jan 2020
    Festive time is for family and friends to get together , people buy enough shopping to last them for days .
  36. Jacquline Ferris 20 Jan 2020
    As this is a time when owners get to sit and enjoy there family why can't I do the same
  37. Jane Rutherford 20 Jan 2020
    Shop is always very quiet on New Year's Day with customers being under the impression the shop is closed.
  38. Elaine Kerr 20 Jan 2020
    No need to open new years day we deserve the time off
  39. James Smith 20 Jan 2020
    Spend time with family
  40. Robert Goldie 20 Jan 2020
    Should include Boxing day as well
  41. Patricia McDowell 20 Jan 2020
    Would be great to enjoy the holidays with your family rather than looking after other people's who might I add don't even appreciate that someone you love is left sitting alone whilst you provide them a service.
  42. Susan grant 20 Jan 2020
    Missed time with family after them travelling 300 miles.
  43. mrs Heather Elizabeth Vance 20 Jan 2020
    Would ne nice to be able to visit family I only used to see at new year
  44. Margaret Glen 20 Jan 2020
    Big fat NO
  45. ann muirhead 20 Jan 2020
    Give us our new year back
  46. Aileen foster 20 Jan 2020
    100% agree that it should be open
  47. Robina Clark 20 Jan 2020
    New Year day is a special day like Christmas day and should be shared with family and friends as the start of a Year is very important for families to commit to supporting each other and not giving up this this special time for companies to make bigger profits for shareholders and the Board.
  48. Fiona MacDonald 20 Jan 2020
    Working in retail the run up to Christmas is bad enough it would be nice if we could have more than one day to get over that and spend time with our family
  49. Robyn Cooper 20 Jan 2020
    Doesn't affect me too much but everyone should definitely get an opportunity to spend some real time with their loved ones instead of being forced to work on one of the quietest days possible.
  50. Joyce Grant 20 Jan 2020
    I don't think it is right that anyone has to work boxing day new year's day and the 2nd of January. In this day and age we should be thinking about family and loved ones. When I was a child I remember all businesses had early finish times running up to Christmas then more or less shut for the festive period or ran skeleton staff on less hours