Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01780 · Session 5

Consultation on the closure of large shops on New Year's Day

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2019 Business & Industry
Signatures
0
2,040 online signatures with a country
Comments
188
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to launch a consultation on implementing legislation already in place to ban large shops from opening on New Year’s Day.

What the petitioner did first

Usdaw has previously written to James Hepburn, Minister for Business, Fair Work and Skills, asking that the Government launch a consultation on the issue.
The organisation has been advised that the Government does not intend to commission research into the impact of trading by large stores on New Year’s Day.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 20 Feb 2020
    1 mention
  2. 8 Oct 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 16 Dec 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 10 Feb 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,040 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,408 69%
  2. United Kingdom575 28.2%
  3. England49 2.4%
  4. Northern Ireland2 0.1%
  5. France1 0%
  6. Greece1 0%
  7. Netherlands1 0%
  8. New Zealand1 0%
  9. Wales1 0%
  10. Germany1 0%

Comments

188 comments, oldest first
188 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Alan Bowes 19 Dec 2019
    The 1st 2nd and boxing day should all be holidays and corporate company's should be first to close for family time.
  2. Nita Patterson 19 Dec 2019
    Yes to both statements
    - shops should be closed on New Years Day + 2nd January
  3. Jennifer Gormley 20 Dec 2019
    It would be so good for retail workers to spend some much needed time with family and friends through the festive period.
  4. kathleen reeves 20 Dec 2019
    no need for shops to be open on new years day everyone deserves to spend time with their family
  5. Karen Petrie 20 Dec 2019
    To ask the big supermarkets to close on just 2 days a year to allow their staff time with family and friends is not a lot to ask for. I'm sure all the CEO's of these companies cherish what time they get with their families so why should their employees be any different.
  6. Michael Ashcroft 20 Dec 2019
    A family member works retail.Every year they work New years day.l agree shops should close.
  7. Nessa abblett 20 Dec 2019
    No one should have to work on new years day we work hard all year and deserve time off to be with our familys.
  8. jayne wesley 20 Dec 2019
    I work in retail we need more time with our families
  9. Tracy GIlbert 20 Dec 2019
    The Scottish Government can enact this piece of legislation and allow all their constituents a few days off with their families. support retail workers.
  10. Hazel Gunn 20 Dec 2019
    Also shouldn't have to reequest a days holiday to get xmas day off when the store is closed anyway
  11. Jim Campbell 20 Dec 2019
    It's unfair that that shops open new years day we work hard in the month of December and our reward Xmas day off give it time and companies will take that also
  12. Jim Campbell 20 Dec 2019
    We work hard all year and even more so in December and our reward one day off in the entire year my company just took away new year's day how long before they try Xmas
  13. Alasdair Campbell 20 Dec 2019
    On New Year's Day people should be able to spend time with their families and not have to deal with bosses demanding that they work.

    I'm sure politicians and civil service workers have those days off. It is a bank holiday and they should be allowed time off.
  14. Jim Berrington 20 Dec 2019
    Believe everyone should be able to spend time with there family
  15. Declan Shields 20 Dec 2019
    Hogmanay and New Year is a special time of year in Scotland. I feel it is right that this should be protected and encouraged with the closure of shops to allow more people to enjoy the celebration.
  16. Heather Quinn 20 Dec 2019
    Family time together is important x
  17. Lynda Holmes 20 Dec 2019
    No-one should be made to work in a shop on 1 and 2 Dec. STATUTORY? Good luck, hope you win. Solidarity
  18. Mhairi Ross 20 Dec 2019
    It would be nice to spend new year with my family in Edinburgh
  19. Margaret Nicholson 20 Dec 2019
    No one should work on New Year Day especially retail.
  20. Ian Manion 21 Dec 2019
    As an USDAW member I support my Scottish colleagues
  21. Monics Genelli 21 Dec 2019
    Please stop large shops New Years day
  22. Mike Danson 21 Dec 2019
    Let's reclaim the Scottish New Year from the capitalists for the citizens.
  23. Mike Danson 21 Dec 2019
    Let's reclaim the Scottish New Year from the capitalists and for the citizens.
  24. Archie McDonald 21 Dec 2019
    I have always said that all Big major supermarkets should close on 25th & 26th of December and 1st & 2nd of January
  25. Debra McMahon 21 Dec 2019
    Out with the family aspect, there's no need to open. No public transport available so ridiculous to expect staff to travel.
  26. MARK CULLINANE 21 Dec 2019
    Give families a holiday
  27. Margaret Brannan 22 Dec 2019
    No need for shops to open 1st or 2nd January
  28. Terry Dolan 22 Dec 2019
    Absolutely ridiculous having to work on the 1 st January having had to do it in the past ,it should remain in the past
  29. Jacqueline Wright 22 Dec 2019
    When growing up shops were never open on new years day. Greed has taken over!!
  30. Joosung Lee 23 Dec 2019
    A proper holiday for all workers!
  31. Miss Deborah K Murray 23 Dec 2019
    Think be a better for people to be with familys i doub shopper cant wait one day.
  32. Steven ingram 23 Dec 2019
    All workers need this
  33. Margaret sneddon 24 Dec 2019
    I have worked in retail for years and it has had an impact on family life as cannot enjoy boxing day as always have to work.
    Cannot enjoy a gid xmas break as you know you have to work.
    Retail life is hard and as we are accommodating members of public firms various sectors in retail we also as workers have a right to properly enjoy this time of year.
    It's a tough industry and can have an impact on mental health so the extra time off would be fully appreciated by all in retail .
  34. Madelyne Simpson 24 Dec 2019
    Keep shops closed on New Years Day!
  35. Neil ford 24 Dec 2019
    Do the directors or chief executive work on these days or are they enjoying time with family
  36. Michael Orr 25 Dec 2019
    Close the shops for our festive season .
  37. Neil ford ford 25 Dec 2019
    Hope msp,s enjoy Xmas and new year because its the shop workers make it possible for this to happen .stop and think of us at this time of year
  38. Robert renwick 26 Dec 2019
    No one should need to work any of these days not just retail. I understand emergency services are needed but they could even have every 2nd year pt if you work Xmas you get new year off etc. They say we aren't slaves but make us work like slaves
  39. Richard Mcewan 27 Dec 2019
    All for it
  40. Ann Cousins 27 Dec 2019
    All retail staff need more time with family
  41. Robert Burns 27 Dec 2019
    there is already too much time to shop. people need more family time. lets get a four day week
  42. Mary Buchan 27 Dec 2019
    Would love time of with my family
  43. john carr 27 Dec 2019
    There is no need it's just greed
  44. Allan Duncan 27 Dec 2019
    All stores should be closed on all major holidays
  45. Alex Bruce 27 Dec 2019
    I have already fought for this and won seems big companies can treat their staff how they like. Corporate greed is unbelievable I'm sure the C.E.Os are not in the office. They will be sitting at home with wives families and friends enjoying the holidays. It's time big companies treated staff with respect and if they did staff would be happier and in turn do more for the company
  46. Patricia Sheridan 27 Dec 2019
    Yes all shops should be close as it is family time X
  47. Julie Pattinson 27 Dec 2019
    Please give respect to the people of Scotland who deserve the acknowledgment of new years day as a public holiday. English stores are closed on Easter Sunday. Why should Scotland not have the same acknowledgement.
  48. Carol O'meara 28 Dec 2019
    Family time
  49. Paul Holden 28 Dec 2019
    Its time to halt retail greed and thoroughly promote time off with families by closing all unnecessary workplaces at Christmas holidays.
  50. Fiona forbes 28 Dec 2019
    Boxing Day too, I Day with your family is not enough. Sales all the time now, so Boxing means nothing anymore