The next continued petition on our agenda today is PE1780, by Stewart Forrest on behalf of the Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers, calling on the Scottish Government to launch a consultation on implementing legislation already in place to ban large shops from opening on new year’s day.
The petition was last considered in October 2020. Since then, the committee has received submissions from the Minister for Business, Fair Work and Skills, the Scottish Retail Consortium, the Scottish Trades Union Congress and the petitioner.
In his submission, the minister explains that this is not the time to run a consultation, given the significant challenges that are faced by the retail sector in relation to the coronavirus pandemic and the on-going uncertainty regarding Brexit trade negotiations. However, the minister states that he will be
“seeking further views and opinions from unions and retailers and will advise the committee of my findings in due course.”
Although the petitioner does not believe that the current coronavirus measures should be a factor, as the first possible date that a ban could be brought into force is on new year’s day 2022, he welcomes the submission from the minister as he believes that it endorses the action called for in the petition. I know that my colleague Neil Bibby has been exploring the issue and has raised it with the First Minister.
10:45
My feeling is that things have changed completely from when this petition was first lodged. The legislation has been sitting on the shelf since 2006. I was in the Parliament when we discussed it at that time, the issue of what to do about Christmas was agreed, and we decided to consult on the new year issue. My view is that we are in particular and different times—I am aware that the Presiding Officer has said if a recommendation was laid, while it would be very unusual it could be considered—and I think that it is within the capacity of the Parliament to consider the possibility of large shops not being open this new year.
The reason why I think that that is important is that, although we hear a lot about front-line workers in health and social care—and we salute them—we must also remember the people keeping our streets clean, the posties and, in particular, I would argue, the shop workers who have been on the front line of dealing with this situation. It would be good if we could see whether it is possible for that decision to be made ahead of this new year. It is not in the remit of the Public Petitions Committee to do that; I accept that. However, I would like to be able to afford Parliament the opportunity of doing that.
I do not accept the minister’s argument that this is not the time. We are putting through huge amounts of significant legislation and regulation quickly and we will be able to give the minister information to give an indication of what that consultation might result in. The Scottish Retail Consortium has said that it does not support the proposal, trade unions have said they do and I sense that the public will support it as well. Consultation could be done extremely quickly. As far as I know, there is nothing outlined in the legislation on how long the consultation will take. Given how fleet of foot we have proved ourselves to be during the coronavirus, I am sure that we could meet that.
My view is that the petition is important and we can accelerate the process, which would recognise the very particular circumstances that we are in. I want the committee to write to the Scottish Government and to the Presiding Officer to say that we believe that Parliament should be afforded the opportunity to make a decision on this. While it is for the committee to decide whether it agrees with that or not, I think that we should be recognising the very important issues that are behind this petition.
