Petition · PE01648 · Session 5
Nursery business rates
Signatures
0
Comments
263
Considered
2 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to abolish or freeze business rates for nurseries.
What the petitioner did first
I have contacted my local MSP and councillors with my concerns. I have also worked alongside the National Day Nurseries Association to try and resolve this issue.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
15 Jun 20171 mention
-
9 Nov 20171 mention
Signatures by country
2,480 online signaturesComments
263 comments, oldest first263 comments · showing 151–200
-
Megan Braithwaite 12 Apr 2017While I understand the govt has provided provision for free childcare for 3 & 4 year olds in Scotland, in reality this is not accessible due to oversubscription, lack of facilities who run this and the completely unworkable 3 hours a day over 5 days being offered instead of flexibility (or offering 2 7 hour days) which would allow mothers to actually return to work. So privately funded nurseries are all that's left for working mothers and these are already ridiculously expensive, meaning what little wages I get is almost all taken by nursery fees. Raising this would make it even more prohibitive and seriously lead me to reconsider whether I can afford to work. Please don't do this, or enable the funded place to be more useable and universal instead.
-
Sara-Jane Mackay 12 Apr 2017This is not only crippling for small businesses but will have a knock on effect on childcare costs for working families.
-
Emily Williams 12 Apr 2017If the increase is passed on to parents, it means that parents will be effectively priced out of the workplace.
-
L Fleming 12 Apr 2017To increase the rates on nurseries is to directly tax the working family, l was under the impression that this was not what this Government was promising?
-
Stacey 12 Apr 2017Shocking!
-
Rizwan Saeed 12 Apr 2017Increase will have to be passed to working parents. We deliver a key service that allows parents to go work and provide a better quality of life for children. Day nurseries should be either exempt like schools or at least substantial relief should be made available
-
Karen Hooton 12 Apr 2017The government want the best place to grow up to be Scotland, that means having good quality childcare (they are our future workers after all), fees parents pay should go on paying the staff a good wage to provide exceptional care not more money for the government.
-
Rachel Hewitt 12 Apr 2017For many families nurseries are the only option to allow parents to work and earn money to keep their families afloat. The cost is already so high, sending more than one child is not a viable option as it would negate many salaries including my own. Childcare facilities should be exempt of these extra charges.
-
F Wallace 12 Apr 2017I object as the increase will be passed onto parents.
-
Suzanne Costello 13 Apr 2017The cost if childcare is already prohibitive to many meaning people either can't afford to work or work to maintain their profession with very little pay during the first few years of their children's lives. This cost will be directly passed on to already struggling working parents.
-
Shonagh Terry 13 Apr 2017I believe that good nursery care is a modern day necessity but the cost is rising all the time. It's not a viable option for many and if this goes ahead it will mean many families will feel the short term cost of mothers giving up positions altogether as it becomes economically untenable, nurseries closing with the loss of skilled nursery nurses, long term financial loss through mothers dropping out of employment and losing career advancement and employers losing staff. It's effect on the economy is also not to be underestimated as a factor here. Its a no win scenario all round.
-
lucy mclaren 13 Apr 2017Childcare costs mean that my take home pay is minimal. A rise in costs which could be passed on to parents would result in it not being viable for me to continue working.
-
Sammie Dyson 15 Apr 2017Signed petition
-
Nick Clark 16 Apr 2017Nurserys should not have to pay ridiculous high rates as they are so important to the local community. Why doesn't this government realise that if people cannot work they cannot pay their taxes and have to rely on benefits, the knock on affects are huge. It's do very expensive already.
-
Anthony RAJAKANI 16 Apr 2017This increase is going to affect small businesses
-
Douglas Knox 16 Apr 2017I hope that if the Scottish Government can introduce a business rate cap for pubs then they can offer a cap to nurseries which are doing so much good for delivering Scottish Government objectives. For example pre school education and helping the SG make Scotland the best place to bring up young children.
Nurseries cannot afford business rate hikes without passing them on to parents which in turn will make child care even less affordable. -
Briony Fisher 16 Apr 2017Snp need to get this sorted or many women will have to give up work because nursery fees will be so high, they're already too high!
-
S winton 16 Apr 2017This rise in rates for nurseries is outrageous it will obviously be passed onto parents as businesses are unable to absorb such an outrageous increase. The cost of childcare in Edinburgh is already too high. The government want to encourage people to work but how can they when childcare is so expensive. Surely it is more important for rates to be capped for nurseries who provide education and not for pubs which are purely for pleasure
-
Bryony Smith 16 Apr 2017Small businesses such as nurseries, can't absorb these huge rises and therefore the cost will be forced onto parents, through increased childcare costs. Childcare costs are already very high, and to pass on the cost to parent, isn't fair. The rates should be reduced, not increased!
-
Julie Duffy 17 Apr 2017Freezing nursery rates is important for working parents. We already spend £800 per month and could not afford any more. This would result in a potential loss of job.
Ultimately it could result in more people asking for benefits due to lack of work. -
Sonia Rutherford 17 Apr 2017It seems ridiculous to have policies which directly contradict each other
- trying to boost early years provision with various funding initiatives while at the same time increasing nursery overheads to make this harder. This isn't just illogical and a blow to working parents
- it's a waste of money for taxpayers to implement contradictory policies. -
M Summers 17 Apr 2017The cost will no doubt be passed onto parents and this discriminates against those who cannot afford to absorb the additional cost.
-
Karen cameron 17 Apr 2017I completely object to the business rate increases for Scottish nurseries as this will be partly passed onto parents!
-
Lynn Gaffney 17 Apr 2017Nursery rates are already high enough. They can surely not increase anymore as they will be come unmanageable for lots of families.
-
Joyce rutherford 17 Apr 2017These increases are a disgrace for nurseries already under pressure to supply excellent facilities for our country's children
-
Laura Katie Lea wood 17 Apr 2017Get this sorted
-
Richie wilkes 17 Apr 2017This is unfair to people who wish to continue with career
-
Samantha Campbell Casey 18 Apr 2017This will directly impact on parents as the cost of increased business rates will be passed onto parents. Nurseries provide an essential service to working parents and also provide valuable pre school education. The costs are already high and should not be forced to be higher by this changed. Reduce or abolish the rates for nurseries.
-
G Butcher 18 Apr 2017It seems that the nursery fee system is giving something with one hand and then taking it back with the other, the net effect of increasing business rates (that will inevitably increase the daily fees to parents) means we don't actually receive any government help towards nursery costs. This has a direct effect on how people can live their lives and the extent to which they can add to their family. It's heart breaking really.
-
Pamela McGowan 18 Apr 2017The cost of childcare is already prohibitive: the majority of my monthly salary already goes towards my son's nursery fees. This rates increase will be passed onto parents, and many of us will be forced to consider whether it pays to be in work or not. I don't want to be forced into giving up my hard-won career due to the inevitable price hike. Nurseries should be exempt from this increase, which is in direct contradiction to strategies aimed at getting more parents in to work.
-
Andrew Brown 18 Apr 2017Unjustified rise in rates that significantly impact on nursery provision and working families.
-
ruby ahuja 18 Apr 2017Increasing business rates will negatively impact affordability.
-
Dominika 18 Apr 2017The cost of childcare is alredy above minimum wage and is creazy high! 100% of my salary is going thorwards childcare cost. Average full time childcare cost is over £1000 per month per child! If the fees are going to increase a lot of people who presently struggle to pay it will not be able to afford it and will be force to stop working. This will only increase unemployment within parents and benefits claims...
-
Alexander Sutherland 18 Apr 2017These new rates are a double Mammy whammy especially for the less well-off providers!
-
Anon 18 Apr 2017I am a highly educated and very experienced healthcare professional. My two kids' nursery fees are already so high that they completely wipe out my earnings from working full time. I often wonder why I bother. Why do I miss all this precious time with my kids for literally no financial benefit? To make matters worse I work at an NHS hospital where I have to pay a small fortune to park my car. I feel like I'm being bled dry, financially and emotionally. Please, please don't make life even harder for working parents by pursuing this policy which will lead to further rises in the cost of childcare.
-
Steve Farquhar 18 Apr 2017Without suitable alternatives on offer private childcare needs to be made more affordable and accessible for working families. This would have multiple knock on benefits for all parties involved
- families, nursery businesses and the government. A price increase is completely contradictory to this so all those opportunities to do the right thing will be lost. -
lesley browne 19 Apr 2017The cost of childcare is already prohibitive: the majority of my monthly salary already goes towards my son's nursery fees. This rates increase will be passed onto parents, and many of us will be forced to consider whether it pays to be in work or not. I don't want to be forced into giving up my hard-won career due to the inevitable price hike. Nurseries should be exempt from this increase, which is in direct contradiction to strategies aimed at getting more parents in to work.
-
Gordon Calder 19 Apr 2017The rate rises will feed thro to working parents, the nurseries will have to pass on the increase in one form or another. Electoral suicide Comes to mind.
-
Alison black 19 Apr 2017This seems unfair & Could make private nursery even more expensive resulting in less families being able to afford this way of child care .
-
Andrew Buchan 19 Apr 2017I find this utterly shocking and disgraceful to target hard working families in the manner they are doing,
Disgusting!!!!! -
Rosie Elliot 19 Apr 2017It is ridiculous that the Scottish Government talk about and write a Blue Print that continually talks about affordable, quality childcare, and still cripple us with the high cost of rates. We should pay no rates and pay our quality staff the salary they deserve. We need highly motivated, quality, effective staff. Nicola Sturgeon needs to take this on board before she introduces 1140 hours. Private nurseries will be out of business. Well done to our Scottish Government!!!!!!!
-
Lorraine Menzies 20 Apr 2017I try my best to keep nursery fees as low as possible for parent's. I also believe staff are the most important part of a quality nursery and deserve a decent salary. Increase of rates will have a detrimental effect on parents having fees increases and staff salary affordability.
-
Greta Mulhall 20 Apr 2017Our daughter is paying exorbitant nursery fees for our two granddaughters in Edinburgh...she cant afford them now so any increase wd be devastating.
-
Michael Powell 20 Apr 2017Grossly unfair and unhelpful
-
Elvera Geen 20 Apr 2017Cost of childcare is already prohibitive. High quality childcare should be accessible to all.
-
Jennifer Campbell 20 Apr 2017Rates are a huge monthly cost. It would be good to reduce this. Costs are handed down to Parents. With increased pre-school in 2020 there will be many private nurseries closing unless we get some help.
-
Linda Pirie 20 Apr 2017Private nurseries are hit hard in that unlike other businesses they CANNOT claim back VAT, they are rated higher than schools and to be suddenly faced with a massive hike of 84% is absolutely diabolical considering the government have taken many other (extremely profitable businesses) totally out of rates. It is hard working families who need full day care and it is them who will be faced with increases in fees. The government want people to work, so they should support childcare to be affordable and not TAX TAX TAX those who are working hardest to give their children a good home and family life . Private nurseries should be exempt from Rates and be made zero rated for VAT to support Good Quality affordable childcare.
-
Karen Riozzi 20 Apr 2017I have a nursery in a rural area and keep my fees as low as possible. I have increased them only twice, for a small amount, in the past six years. I am very conscious of the struggle it is for parents to cope with rising costs. I find it a real struggle as well as my costs have kept rising at an alarming rate compared to my charges. The rates have been particularly crippling. I am at the stage where I have to decide to drastically increase the fees or just give up, which won't help anyone. The local authority also took funding away in favour of the state nurseries. My parents are waiting to hear about the Childcare Account that Nicola Sturgeon promised but it now looks like this won't be happening until 2020, which means another three years of parents missing out. The whole thing is quite demoralising.
-
Leanne Mutch 20 Apr 2017Private childcare is already expensive without these excessive rate rises. I thought the idea was to do more to help working families, not penalise them!
-
Gary Harrison 20 Apr 2017This increase will have to be passed on to parents causing an increase in childcare costs. This will not help working parents and clearly will result in some giving up employment due to the increases as will not be financially worthwhile staying in employment.