Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01648 · Session 5

Nursery business rates

Closed Submitted 16 Mar 2017 People & Communities
Signatures
0
2,480 online signatures with a country
Comments
263
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to abolish or freeze business rates for nurseries.

What the petitioner did first

I have contacted my local MSP and councillors with my concerns. I have also worked alongside the National Day Nurseries Association to try and resolve this issue.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 15 Jun 2017
    1 mention
  2. 9 Nov 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,480 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,988 80.2%
  2. United Kingdom473 19.1%
  3. England16 0.6%
  4. Wales3 0.1%

Comments

263 comments, oldest first
263 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Frances Armit 6 Apr 2017
    How can we operate a nursery business under such constraints as this. As a private nursery we are not subsidised by the government and cannot meet the challenges at the moment.
  2. Sandra Doherty 6 Apr 2017
    Private nurseries are under enough financial pressure without having to pay out even more in BR. The Government need to do something now to stop this happening .
  3. clive kemp 6 Apr 2017
    This 'Tax' on children's education needs to be abolished.
  4. Linda 6 Apr 2017
    The central government is pushing up business rates but the deputy first minister's promise of free childcare is pushing up the fees.
  5. Imogen will 6 Apr 2017
    If our nursery is forced to close I will not be able to work. I'm self employed so my business would fold. . How dose this help the economy?
  6. Claire Morrison 6 Apr 2017
    I thought the government want people to work. If I was unable to afford childcare then I would be another unemployed person in society and I personally need to work for my wellbeing. I am contemplating having another child however if childcare becomes unaffordable then this undoubtedly will not be a possibility for me
  7. Nicola Hamilton 6 Apr 2017
    It just doesn't balance well for all parties. Childcare needs to be affordable and of excellent quality. By doing this small will struggle and even close meaning parents choices for the best nursery is limited. Some of these small nurseries are excellent and it will be a loss for children, as we all know the early years are vital in shaping their future.
  8. Laura nisbet 6 Apr 2017
    Nursery schools do a great & are not able to pay staff enough for what they do
  9. Christine shand 6 Apr 2017
    The business rates increase will impact on the families with regards increases in fees which will put a strain on the future of children's education if they can't afford to sent their children to nursery and there is also a real possibility that jobs could be lost as a result of trying to meet these preposterous demands. End these rates NOW!!
  10. Stacey Myles 6 Apr 2017
    My partners Nursery had the rates increased by 170% meaning the monthly requested payments are financially unmanageable without increasing fees and effecting families.
  11. Teri Devine 6 Apr 2017
    The increase in rates is ripping the heart out of every town, city and village across the country. Small businesses cannot survive with the increase of business rates. I have had this years notification to increase my nursery premises rates by 170% which will in turn have to mean a restructure of fees for families.
  12. Amanda 6 Apr 2017
    How are small private nursery's that are not government fund going to be able to provide affordable childcare.
  13. Amanda Steven 6 Apr 2017
    The private nursery where we send our son has been hit and think it's a disgrace. They need more support as this has an effect on children's education long term. I have already written a complaint to Scottish government regarding the free childcare system which is a shambles and doesn't consider many factors. Working parents rely heavily on private nurseries as the service provided is far more than the council nurseries in many ways.
  14. Kerry Allan 6 Apr 2017
    This is not acceptable given that many many "small businesses" make far more profit than nurseries which the cost for many parents is the make or break for returning to work after having children. This should seriously be re considered.
  15. Susan Mackie 6 Apr 2017
    Families are already being crippled by fees this will just make it worse at a time where more than 50% im most cases of salary is already going in fees
  16. Melissa 6 Apr 2017
    How does this help families that try to work!
  17. Stuart 6 Apr 2017
    Maybe the SNP should get a grip of this rather than chasing unwanted referendums.
  18. Joanne 6 Apr 2017
    Expecting nurseries to pay a 140% increase in rates is ridiculous
  19. Lisa Sangster 6 Apr 2017
    One parent will not be able to work due to lack of childcare because it will become unaffordable, staff will lose their jobs & local businesss & communities will therefore suffer. Such a shame for business owners & staff who build up years to succeed with qualifications & experience, for it to end because of business rates...
  20. Mrs Christine Anderson 7 Apr 2017
    These rates are ridiculous, how are we as parents expected to return to work when it will be impossible to put our children to nursery due to the fee's being even higher than they already are. I thought the government we suppose to support people returning to work, not to make It the most difficult thing to do. IT is absolutely ridiculous.
  21. Crawford collin 7 Apr 2017
    on top of increased wage costs , company pension increases this could be the final straw
  22. Carol Burns 7 Apr 2017
    SHOCKING
  23. Catherine Groat 7 Apr 2017
    Staff could lose their jobs as owners could be forced to close as they cannot afford these crippling rates.
  24. Gillian Campbell 7 Apr 2017
    Nurseries are vital for parents returning to work and this rate increase is going to cripple them
  25. S. Stopper 7 Apr 2017
    Our private nursery has stated that they have a 50% increase in rates. This level of rate increase for nurseries cannot be absorbed by them and will have to be passed onto the working parents which may result in it being no longer viable for both parents to work for many families. Alternatively many nurseries may be forced to close leaving parents without childcare. One nursery in my local area has already announced that it will be closing at the end of June due to the recent rate increases. I am sure there will be more.
  26. Linda 7 Apr 2017
    This will make childcare unaffordable and take away parental choice. Leaving only local government nurseries and not enough spaces.
  27. Jessica van Lieshout 7 Apr 2017
    Increasing business rates will affect nursery fees, resulting in increasing costs for parents
  28. Fred Evans 7 Apr 2017
    Another stealth tax on the parents who have to pay for these increases!
  29. Anon 7 Apr 2017
    If this results in an associated increase in nursery fees, then we will need to revisit whether it still makes sense for my wife and I to both be working. It may make more financial sense for one of us to stop working. Doesn't seem to jive with the government's promises around affordable childcare and encouraging working families.
  30. Kevin 7 Apr 2017
    An increase in 3% last year and an increase in 5% this year. The price of child care is already ridiculous! Some people don't even get a salary to live on as much as I pay in child care! Where does it end!
  31. Donna Christie 7 Apr 2017
    This is closing businesses and making returning to work uneconomical for parents.
  32. Sarah 7 Apr 2017
    Soon Mothers (and some Fathers) will have to stop working as childcare is becoming very unaffordable.
  33. Julie Bilsland 7 Apr 2017
    Nursery fees are crippling us at this current time
  34. Alex Johnston 7 Apr 2017
    Nurseries are not like other businesses and regular business rates should not apply to them.
  35. Gayle millar 7 Apr 2017
    Renfrewshire nurseries have been in discussion with Scottish government since the announcement of the 1140 hours. As a private provider we will not be able to operate and be in partnership with our local council Tender-ship (if you can call it that!) when we rely so much on wraparound costs to operate our business .
  36. Ailsa Puckrin 7 Apr 2017
    Childcare and Education should be exempt from rates without question.
  37. Alan Wallace 7 Apr 2017
    It is unacceptable for the Scottish Government to expect small businesses to be able to afford the huge increases in rates especially as the nursery business is so heavily regulated and cannot reduce their staff numbers without affecting the number of children they can accept.
  38. Vanessa 7 Apr 2017
    Childcare is already far too expensive.
  39. Rhona 7 Apr 2017
    As a private nursery provider we are already struggling against the rates that the council provide, this is yet another step to make our job harder
  40. C G Wood 7 Apr 2017
    Nursery fees are extortionate as it is so to add an increase in the business rates to these establishments ultimately means it has to be passed on to the families as an increase in the fees which is proving difficult to justify and very difficult to pay.
  41. Frank Anarfi 7 Apr 2017
    This will undoubtedly impact on early child education, which is a key manifesto pledge of SNP. So reconsider please.
  42. Beverley Notman 7 Apr 2017
    Any increase in rates is going to be difficult for everyone. The small business and working families
  43. Suzanne Campbell 7 Apr 2017
    Nursery fees are expensive already and parents are going to have to take the hit for these business rate increase
  44. Lucy 7 Apr 2017
    Nursery fees are high enough for working parents. If you put the rates up there is a good chance our fees will increase.
  45. Emma 7 Apr 2017
    Childcare is already a huge cost for working families so increasing prices will force many parents to stop work.
  46. Colin 7 Apr 2017
    This is going to drive small businesses to the wall Crazy
  47. Lyndsey Clark 7 Apr 2017
    Private nurseries are a crucial partner in the delivery of early years education in Scotland. It is in the interests of all that these vital businesses are supported to deliver their contribution to society and that they are able to cover costs and pay a living wage to staff and invest in their properties and gardens as learning environments for our young children.
  48. Kelly cunningham 7 Apr 2017
    How will anyone be able to pay for nursery? It's a struggle as it is
  49. Donna Gairns 7 Apr 2017
    While I am all for small businesses paying their way and contributing through rates, I believe that private nurseries should not be included in this. Without good reasonably priced childcare, the economy will suffer as it will be far too expensive for parents to work! And since local authority childcare doesn't have the capacity or flexibility to provide childcare for many families it's down to the private sector to do this.
  50. Nicola koszowski 7 Apr 2017
    Childcare will become too expensive for most families who can just afford it at the present time.