Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01648 · Session 5

Nursery business rates

Closed Submitted 16 Mar 2017 People & Communities
Signatures
0
2,480 online signatures with a country
Comments
263
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to abolish or freeze business rates for nurseries.

What the petitioner did first

I have contacted my local MSP and councillors with my concerns. I have also worked alongside the National Day Nurseries Association to try and resolve this issue.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 15 Jun 2017
    1 mention
  2. 9 Nov 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,480 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,988 80.2%
  2. United Kingdom473 19.1%
  3. England16 0.6%
  4. Wales3 0.1%

Comments

263 comments, oldest first
263 comments · showing 201–250
  1. Kellie Macleod 20 Apr 2017
    Parents cannot afford higher nursery fees. It becomes unsustainable to work. Working parents pay taxes already so need to stop being hit twice!
  2. Lucy 20 Apr 2017
    Increasing the overheads faced by private sector nurseries undermines the 'principles of quality, flexibility, accessibility and affordability' that informs the Scottish Government's vision for transforming early learning and childcare, as set out in their Blueprint for 2020.
  3. Alana Farmer 20 Apr 2017
    I cannot believe that with the government's drive to close the attainment gap and increase childcare provision that they would not abolish the rates for nurseries altogether.

    These monies do not cover refuse collection which is an additional cost or water usage. We are being hit harder than ever whilst trying to make childcare more affordable.
  4. Rachel 20 Apr 2017
    The cost of childcare is already expensive and with this increase a lot of hard working parents will have no option but to give up work so they can look after their children as nurseries will no longer be affordable. Cannot see any logic in this increase.
  5. Lottie m 20 Apr 2017
    Working parents are all ready paying enough for nursery fees which I believe are perfect to the level of care on offer without these businesses having to pass on high rates in the fees surely care provision in Scotland should be supported not punished!
  6. Nicola Moore 21 Apr 2017
    Signed
  7. Saima Kiyani 21 Apr 2017
    I tootally agree that nurseries should not have this rates increase
  8. Ruth Dewar 21 Apr 2017
    At a time when the private sector nurseries are under extreme financial pressure, support by abolishing or radically reducing small business rates is essential in helping maintain viability. The private nurseries sector is an essential element in the government's plan to roll out the doubling of funded hours in the early years. Unless such financial support is given many small businesses may not survive the transition.
  9. Rachel Sutherland 21 Apr 2017
    If nurseries are to be supported, an increase in business rates goes against this.
  10. Jo maunder 21 Apr 2017
    The councils are getting richer
  11. Gaynor reid 21 Apr 2017
    this it's a disgrace , especially when we are trying to promote early years learning .private company struggle as it is usually small company's trying to do there best. If we lose these valuable childcare providers the government will really struggle to get the new increase child care hours proposed as there will not be enough Nursery's to provide this.
  12. Elaine Sagar 22 Apr 2017
    Taking away rates and enabling us to reclaim vat on purchases would help towards the losses we face from the fixed government payments for our hourly rates
  13. Przemek 23 Apr 2017
    It will affect nursery prices and us, users,after all. We will have to pay more for nurseries. More and more people will take a decision not to work and live on benefis as It will be a better deal than sending children to nursery. Is this going to be goverment strategy?
  14. Margaret Malcolm 24 Apr 2017
    There is a need for more Nursery provision. Much of this will come from the private sector and a rate increase is likely to curb expansion
  15. Rachel Fraser 25 Apr 2017
    Signed
  16. Jackie Archaibald 25 Apr 2017
    At a time when the private sector nurseries are under extreme financial pressure, support by abolishing or radically reducing small business rates is essential in helping maintain viability. The private nurseries sector is an essential element in the government's plan to roll out the doubling of funded hours in the early years. Unless such financial support is given many small businesses may not survive the transition.
  17. GR Mackie 25 Apr 2017
    With so much uncertainty currently prevailing in the sector and help to minimise price increases for families is essential. The building rates and the long standing VAT issue would be a great sign of support from the Scottish Government for our businesses. After all, did someone up here not say they want the best start for our children in life??
  18. Richard Russell 25 Apr 2017
    We are struggling with recent huge increases in Minimum Wage and Living Wage
    - 2 in the last year, but many over the last few years
    - and other costs which are spiralling
    - power, waste removal, etc.
    A large Rates bill could tip us over the edge.

    As a small business, we are presently exempt from Rates
    - RV just within the band
    - and we are extremely worried by yet another mandatory cost coming into play.
  19. Steven Ferguson 25 Apr 2017
    Abolish Business Rates for nurseries... the UK already carries the most expensive childcare costs on Europe.
  20. Fiona Hamil 25 Apr 2017
    Support the reduction or abolishing fees for small businesses
  21. Nichola McCann 25 Apr 2017
    Without private nurseries, the state nurseries couldn't handle the number of places required. To possibly lose many private providers because of these rates will have a huge impact. Either council's will be required to absorb the additional fees parents are forced to pay to cover it, or the nurseries close and children will go without provision.
  22. Emma 25 Apr 2017
    Rate increases lead to fee increases, loss of profits to those trying to keep fees down, rises in tax credits claims, lowers the rate of parents seeking full time employment and so on and so forth. Abolish the rates or freezing or significantly reduce them or you risk rising costs I'm other areas of the budget
  23. Abigail suttie 25 Apr 2017
    Shocking
  24. Urszula Kozak 25 Apr 2017
    I say NO to nursery rates
  25. Caroline Berrie 25 Apr 2017
    Trying to balance full time work and a mortgage with childcare is becoming increasingly difficult and and reduction in childcare costs woukd help.
  26. Leanne McGoff 25 Apr 2017
    Signed
  27. Linda Paterson 26 Apr 2017
    Absolutely shocking that my rates have trebled. This will have a very detrimental effect on my business. Also no notification was given on this until a letter was received advising of new rates. Rates and VAT should be abolished for nurseries.
  28. Lauren Mcdade 26 Apr 2017
    My childcare is already double my mortgage. Stop penalising working parents.
  29. Katrina Wilson 26 Apr 2017
    I support the petition
  30. Fergus 26 Apr 2017
    By increasing business rates for nurseries this additional cost will be passed on to parents to pay for childcare costs. We both work and have very limited family support so rely heavily on nursery childcare. This is yet another cost which hard pressed families will have to soak up, diminishing disposable income and affecting local spending into the economy!
  31. Caroline Linnie 26 Apr 2017
    Signed
  32. Laura Barron 27 Apr 2017
    If the government wants people to get back into work after having a baby then a reduction in childcare costs is essential to make working worthwhile !
  33. Elaine baillie 27 Apr 2017
    Raising child care cost is just going to cause less people returning to work as they will only be working to pay for child care and be no better off
  34. Maria Vati 27 Apr 2017
    As parents who do not have family around we rely heavily on nursery to look after our child while we are at work. More importantly, having the option for nursery allows us to go to work and contribute to the society. I do wonder how parents will feel if their salary just about covers the fee for the nursery. Would u or other parents want to go to work.
  35. Kirsten Kininmonth 27 Apr 2017
    Over 10 years we have paid tenths of thousands of pounds in childcare, with no help what so ever due to both working. If costs rise more this will become even more difficult. Working families will once again be squeezed.
  36. Alison Hewat 27 Apr 2017
    Nurseries are an essential part of being able to work when you have children below school age. It is nonsensicle to increase the costs of running them when you are trying to encourage parents to use them. The Government should rethink this policy. It would be better still if they abolished the rate for essentials rather than increasing it.
  37. Nicola Elliot 27 Apr 2017
    I for one could not afford to have the cost of childcare increase! This would impact negatively on my ability to retain employment and family life. Support and encourage parents to remain in employment surely...
  38. Brian Nisbet 28 Apr 2017
    Childcare fees in Edinburgh are already more than the Scottish Average. Business rate increases will only make it harder for private nuseries to operate and maintain a good standard of care. If these rate increases are then passed on to working parents it will make it more difficult to stay in full time employment.
  39. Lesley Stuart-Gammie 28 Apr 2017
    Without private nurseries, hundreds of thousands of people simply would not be able to work.
  40. Paul Chambers 29 Apr 2017
    The proposed increases are unreasonable and make child care unaffordable. This goes against the aims of the National Improvement Framework.
  41. Janet Harvey 29 Apr 2017
    When nurseries have no alternative other than to raise fees in order to balance their finances how can parents afford to have children properly looked after in order that they both remain in employment . At the moment often one parent merely remains in employment in order to pay just their childcare to ensure they remain in employment When fees are yet again hiked they will not be affordable and parents only option will be to give up their employment or put themselves in a dept loop crisis they will not be able to survive just to feed cloth and keep a roof over their head. Logic is unemployment figures will rise How can that then help the overall balance of the governments finances ?
  42. James Myles 1 May 2017
    The government have said they are dedicated to help working parents with childcare costs, but by increasing the Rates for nurseries they are indeed increasing the childcare costs as nurseries will have to increase their fees in order to break even
  43. Mrs Natasha E Roger 1 May 2017
    Having Twins and working this is going to cause a huge complication for us and our whole family due to simply not being able to afford childcare. Help those who want to return to work after having a child and the tax income revenue will go out allowing bigger budgets to go towards the sectors most needed by communities.
  44. Debbie 2 May 2017
    As working parents, nursery is a vital part of our children's childcare. The increase in business rates hitting nurseries is far too big. Nurseries will be forced to increase their charges which in turn will force some parents to give up work and pull their children out. Not only do the children and parents suffer but in turn it will mean there is less tax and national insurance being paid into the economy.
  45. Holly Hunter 2 May 2017
    As a single parent trying to work from my son being 11 months old nursery fees going up have made it very difficult for me. In a country where we want to encourage people to work a lot of people can't because of how expensive private nurseries are.
  46. Robyn 2 May 2017
    having to weigh up whether it is worth my child having social and educational skills, and me going out to work... can barely make ends meet as it is! where is the motivation or encouragement?!
  47. Grant Chisholm 2 May 2017
    Absolutely appalling to raise business rates when small businesses are struggling so much to stay open now. We need to support our community shops when there is so much online competition.

    This will also severely got my 18 month old boys nursery which I find absolutely appalling when all I want is for my boy to learn and grow in a safe environment but may not be able to if we cent afford fee hikes to cover business rate increases!
  48. Yvonne Cook 2 May 2017
    The rate increase for nurseries, is terrible. Private nursery fee are so expensive already & raising the fees will end up costs the parents more, I am already struggling to pay two sets of fees & make it worth while to work if they increase any more I will have to give up work which I am not wanting to do.
  49. Jenny Terris 2 May 2017
    Prices have already been raised, raising them further is not productive and will make more parents reliant on benefits. The government need to help parents not hinder them further by increasing prices!!!
  50. Nicola Slater 2 May 2017
    Rising childcare costs actively discourage parents returning to work. This government should be looking at ways to encourage women in the workplace. Council run nurseries do not provide the hours required to sustain a 9-5 job and leave parents with only private nurseries as an option