Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01648 · Session 5

Nursery business rates

Closed Submitted 16 Mar 2017 People & Communities
Signatures
0
2,480 online signatures with a country
Comments
263
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to abolish or freeze business rates for nurseries.

What the petitioner did first

I have contacted my local MSP and councillors with my concerns. I have also worked alongside the National Day Nurseries Association to try and resolve this issue.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 15 Jun 2017
    1 mention
  2. 9 Nov 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,480 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,988 80.2%
  2. United Kingdom473 19.1%
  3. England16 0.6%
  4. Wales3 0.1%

Comments

263 comments, oldest first
263 comments · showing 101–150
  1. Graham McEwan 7 Apr 2017
    Do the right thing for the benefit of the kids.
  2. Lynsey 7 Apr 2017
    With 2 children in full time childcare if this forces our nursery to increase fees I may be forced to give up work. Nursery fees are our highest monthly outgoing at the moment.
  3. David Burke 7 Apr 2017
    The rising cost of child care is a scandal,
  4. Jean brodie 7 Apr 2017
    Shocking
  5. Debbie Halden 8 Apr 2017
    Support for nursery
  6. Julie 8 Apr 2017
    Our nursery fees are one of our largest out goings if they increase I will have to stop working which is then one less physiotherapist in the nhs
  7. Stuart macdonald 8 Apr 2017
    What the Government are doing is outrageous, considering families struggle enough as it is to work and keep their children in safe learning environments, whilst they do.
  8. Linda Davidson 8 Apr 2017
    Working parents are vital to the economy. Extra business in Scotland is shameful, it leaves nurseries and other businesses to increase rates which many parents can't afford, working parents receive little help as it is. Please do something to stop this rise or you will be pushing working parents to stop working and claiming benefits, that will really help the economic status of Scotland..
  9. Gordon Downie 8 Apr 2017
    I really think the Nursery Rates should be reduced significantly.
  10. Katie Sutherland 8 Apr 2017
    Childcare should be a priority. It's an essential, not a luxury for Scotland's economy
  11. Kathy 9 Apr 2017
    Nurseries will c!ose and this will mean mums and dads will have to give up working because of no child care. Unemployment figures will rise as a result
  12. Philip 9 Apr 2017
    It's absolutely key for child care to be affordable. Important for equality and crucial for family budgets and peace of mind.
  13. Judith rankin 10 Apr 2017
    I think it's a disgrace that early yrs in nurserys is potentially being compromised because of greed.
  14. sylwia 10 Apr 2017
    Why sector who allows parents to work and women to be in employment is punished at the end . Only private nursury right now providing care for little one which suits working families and children .
  15. Victoria 10 Apr 2017
    yet again taxing the people who contribute to society and the economy to make up for the people who won't and don't
  16. Sindra 10 Apr 2017
    You are giving the perfect reason as to why parents are actually better of staying home and not working and collecting benefits
    - How does this benefit society, or even more how does this give a child the best start in life??!
  17. Mhari Robinson 10 Apr 2017
    If you want to tackle equality look directly at what you can do to make childcare in Scotland more affordable for women. Please do not make childcare more expensive
    - which is exactlywhat this increase in rates will do.
  18. Steve mckenna 10 Apr 2017
    This is crippling small buissiness and will have a adverse effect on childcare services
  19. Dan Tredinnick 10 Apr 2017
    Unaffordable.
  20. Roberta Taylor 10 Apr 2017
    As the owner of a nursery employing 40 staff, the increase will have to be passed to the parents etc as we are just surviving at the moment and cannot afford this increase.
  21. Wendy Milne 10 Apr 2017
    Overheads kill private nurseries. Monies need to be spent on improving rates of pay for nursery staff.
  22. Pamela Black 10 Apr 2017
    Education empowers
    - gives us opportunity, inspiration and equity for all
    - this is our future
    - your future
    - your legacy !
  23. Denise 10 Apr 2017
    Shocking to yet again increase childcare costs for working families! The rates go up fees go up to cover! How can Edi have such a big jump?
  24. Gill MacAskill 10 Apr 2017
    Disgraceful
    - nursery fees are heavy enough.for parents
  25. Veronika 10 Apr 2017
    I can not see any logic in increasing business rates for the nurseries...It is a social sector. There are Business rates reliefs for disabled, for charities, etc. Why, when there is such a gap between wraparound childcare available and the demand for it
    - there is no relief for those, who do provide this service, who do look after children and giving them a best start in their life, whilst their mums and dads are working with a peace of mind and pay their tax?
  26. Jaffar Hamoudi 10 Apr 2017
    Child care costs in the U.K. are already the highest in the western world so hard pressed workers no parents can't afford another rise. The Scottish government needs to urgently step in to prevent this unfair which many hard pressed working parents can't afford.
  27. Carol Stirrat 11 Apr 2017
    Fees are expensive enough as it is. It hardly makes it worthwhile working.
  28. Russell Main 11 Apr 2017
    The early years of child development are so important, we put our kid in nursery two half days because of this despite it being very expensive. For rates to go up because of where the school is located is terrible and not considering that it's a nursery shoes the system is broken
  29. Sine Munro 11 Apr 2017
    Nurseries are incredible expensive to run and therefore the cost of using them is already on the brink of being unaffordable. It already costs £100 a day to send my 2 to nursery and we have a modest income. Any increase to nursery fees would mean that I would be forced to give up my part time business to care for my children at home full time. That can't be good for the economy!
  30. Maureen moir 11 Apr 2017
    Unaffordable , will have to be passed onto parents fees . Ridiculous
  31. Lyndsay Grant 11 Apr 2017
    Given the Scottish Goverment is pushing for more emphasis on childcare development and an attempt to cut down on alcohol consumption, I am at a complete loss to understand why licensed premises are being given preferential treatment with their rates being discounted, yet childcare establishments in general are facing massive rises in rates. As a small business owner this will have a detrimental effect on my business. Clearly the Scottish Giverment is not prioritising childcare education!
  32. Gary Anderson 11 Apr 2017
    Given the Scottish Governments pledge to be the best place to raise children it is telling that pubs have their rates capped but childcare providers who educate the future of our country are subject to huge business rates increases. This will have to be passed on to parents who already have to pay a lot for childcare.
  33. Katie 11 Apr 2017
    Significant fee increase passed to parents this year due to business rates increase. This makes it very difficult to working parents. Even on a good salary it makes me question whether it is worthwhile continuing
  34. Catherine Gee 11 Apr 2017
    Don't make my child care costs prohibit me from continuing to work.
  35. Janet McDonald 11 Apr 2017
    The rising cost of the business rate is scandalous, this will affect working parents if the fees are not affordable
  36. William 11 Apr 2017
    The government cannot provide universal nursery provision through the public sector but wants to tax more heavily the businesses providing the childcare provision that the Scottish economy desperately needs.
    Bizarre government.
  37. Linn Elder 11 Apr 2017
    This is a tax that will punish working parents, when the nursery fees are already at a level when working often doesn't make financial sense.
  38. TOKONI STEVENSON 11 Apr 2017
    THE PROVISION OF COST EFFICIENT CHILDCARE IS DIRECTLY RELATED TO THE PROPERTY TAX ASSOCIATED WITH CHILDCARE FACILITIES. cHARITIES PAY NO COUNCIL TAX BUT NUSEREYS SERVE THE WORKING POPULATION AND FAMILIES
  39. PAUL STEVENSON 11 Apr 2017
    CHILDCARE COSTS NEED TO REDUCED TO HELP MOVE TOWARDS BETTER EMPLOYMENT UPTAKE AMONGST PARENTS
  40. Rebecca Goss 11 Apr 2017
    Nursery fees have already risen substantially to accommodate (albeit extremely important) living wage and national minimum wage increases and also pensions auto enrolment costs. Parents simply cannot afford to pay more for hugely expensive childcare and it makes no economic sense in the longer term to have people having to absent themselves from the job market for extended periods purely on basis that they cannot afford childcare.
  41. Lorraine Gillespie 11 Apr 2017
    One of our nurseries has seen a 100% increase in its annual rates bill. Unaffordable. Will need to be passed onto parents in full.
  42. Richard Watson 11 Apr 2017
    it makes no sense whatsoever. More parents will not be able to afford nursery fees meaning nurseries will suffer as well as parents. We'll see more single income households which means any gains made by bumping rates will be lost to diminished income tax from families.
  43. Catherine Wilson 11 Apr 2017
    It's all about education
    - so said the SNP !!!!!!
    How is this huge increase supposed to help ?
  44. Paul Wilson 11 Apr 2017
    This yet another tax raising issue to pay for the Government (SNP) policies aimed at securing votes from lower income families using promises than they cannot afford, at the same time putting smaller succeesful businesses at risk. Costs are passed on the hard working middle class families who are already experiencing high taxation than other parts of the UK.
  45. Colin Johnston 11 Apr 2017
    The proposed rates hike is excessive and will threaten the viability of nurseries. Good quality nurseries are already at a premium. They are responsible employers, valuable educators, and dedicated carer's. They provide a service that enables parents to participate in the economy with peace of mind. They have a greater than face value and their loss would have implications for many.
  46. Kerry McNeil 11 Apr 2017
    The resulting increase in nursery fees will mean it is not worth many parents going to work! All this chat about increasing free nursery hours in direct contradiction to this
  47. Sarah Isted 11 Apr 2017
    Childcare is unaffordable as it is. You want parents to go back into the workplace but you make it impossible for nurseries to run sustainably, to a high standard with no money?
  48. myra anderson 11 Apr 2017
    Unaffordable
  49. Caroline Hamid 11 Apr 2017
    Working parents struggle to pay for the best child care possible. This change would lead to severe hardship for many. Or 1 parent staying at home to take care of the child and due to only having 1 salary would likely be entitled to income support. No savings there. Only hardship and stress for all.
  50. Cd 11 Apr 2017
    I am not earning after childcare and transport fees as it is.. please stop any further increases , we the squeezed middle can not cope! I will be forced not to work