Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01564 · Session 4

Save Loch Ness and the Great Glen

Closed Submitted 11 Mar 2015 Rural Affairs
Signatures
1
3,097 online signatures with a country
Comments
521
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take steps to designate the Loch Ness and Great Glen as a National Scenic Area; to recommend a priority application is made to UNESCO for the area to be afforded World Heritage protection; and to take appropriate steps to discourage further wind turbine developments and support the restoration of sites damaged by wind turbines.

What the petitioner did first

1. Letters of comment and opposition on an individual basis by Friends of the Great Glen on planning applications in the Great Glen through the Highland Council planning system, for example on Beinn Mhor, Invermoriston, Bhlaraidh, Stronelairg, and the extension to the Millenium Wind Farm. These applications have been recommended for approval, despite considerable public objections, for example over 1200 in the case of Beinn Mhor.

2. Correspondence with local MSP on wind farm developments in the Great Glen.

3. A complaint was lodged with the Highland Council on the visual impact of the Millenium Wind Farm and this was later referred to the planning process (the planning application is still active).

4. Letter to the SNH Chair asking for more active defence of wild land and internationally acclaimed landscape sites in the Great Glen and specifically Stronelairg.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 26 May 2015
    1 mention
  2. 22 Sep 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 14 Sep 2017
    1 mention

Signatures by country

3,097 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,320 42.6%
  2. United Kingdom471 15.2%
  3. France376 12.1%
  4. England342 11%
  5. Germany113 3.6%
  6. Canada79 2.6%
  7. United States73 2.4%
  8. Australia68 2.2%
  9. Poland43 1.4%
  10. Wales33 1.1%
  11. 35 other countries179 5.8%

Comments

521 comments, oldest first
521 comments · showing 251–300
  1. patricia Laederich 5 Apr 2015
    There are many places for windfarms. There is only one Loch Ness.
  2. Guérin Hubert 5 Apr 2015
    SVP, laissez le Loch Ness intact

    Please leave Loch Ness intact.
  3. William J taylor 5 Apr 2015
    For almost all of my working life I have been. Professional aviator. For more than 20 of those years I worked for the small but very significant Scottish Airline 'Loganair'! In 20 x 4 seasons I have seen Scotland at its worst and at its best and, though an Irishman, have come to love it as much as any Scot. I have seen this country from a perspective that very very few will have enjoyed and I can tell you that the continued construction of these generating sites, of arguable efficiency, is a blight on the landscape and an insult to Scotland. The landscape of this beautiful country is being destroyed for a questionable gain and it is time to stop. Build these wind farms out at sea, but please do not desicrate one of the most beautiful countries in the world with what is an abomination!!
  4. Irene Bond 5 Apr 2015
    I will NEVER VISIT this area should it be industrialized in this way
  5. Henrik Svanholm 5 Apr 2015
    More and more Danes are against windturbines because the politicians prefer to support the Industry instead of protect people from lowfrequent noise.
  6. Nick Cooke 5 Apr 2015
    This problem is compounded hugely by Scottish Government Ministers regularly approving appeals by wind farm developers against planning refusals from local Councils. The blind dogma being promoted by this SNP administration is fuelling the proliferation of wind turbines when their cost efficiency and environmental benefits are highly dubious in relation to wave or tidal power. The only real winners are the major corporate developers who can take advantage of the subsidies funded by us the taxpayers. It is a replication of the scandalous 'tax break forestry' regime of the 1970s and 80s all over again, and will have a similar end result.
  7. Etienne Meunier 5 Apr 2015
    les éoliennes industrielles sont une escroquerie scientifique et financière

    industrial wind turbines are scientific and financial scam
  8. Teresa Kemp 5 Apr 2015
    Wind farms destroy the environment. Create toxic lakes in China. Tons of concrete poured into the land. Steel production creating toxins. Decimating wild life, birds and bats. Negative knock-on effect to the sustainability of the eco-system. Negative health effects on the human population. Raises utility costs creating fuel-poverty. Lowers housing prices adjacent to the wind farms. Vast amounts of money goes to the developers, whilst the countryside is ravaged by building an industrial power plant. Most of the turbines cannot be recycled at the end of their life, and end up in landfill sites. Why are we destroying our landscapes for these inefficient machines? Come up with a better solution than this.
  9. Leeson Carlyle 5 Apr 2015
    Windfarms are power generating stations. Nuclear fission reactors are power generating stations. Both have visual and environmental drawbacks. Just as exceptional care is taken in the planning of our nuclear power capability, so the same level of due diligence must be applied to our wind generation capability. I'm not intimating zero wind powered generation, but its planning should be centrally managed on a strategic scale.
  10. David Mortimer 5 Apr 2015
    I am from Australia, have visited Loch Ness many times and have always been enthralled by its wild beauty. Environmental vandalism caused by the totally useless power generation that is wind farms, must be stopped now.
  11. Angus Maciver 5 Apr 2015
    At present the RSPB and others are surveying the population of Golden Eagles in Scotland.
    Does the Scottish Government realise that large industrial turbines being installed in mountain areas throughout Scotland will cause a loss of habitat to this iconic species and no doubt over the coming years will cause the death to them and other large raptors like Sea Eagle, Osprey , Peregrine Falcon and Buzzard.
    At the planning stage there is supposed to be an environmental assessment which will factor in the number of large birds expected to be killed at any windfarm within a 12 month period.
    Will the Scottish Government make available the figures of such deaths annually and if no one is counting, why not. It is a national disgrace.
  12. Pat Wells 5 Apr 2015
    Time to end the Scottish Government's planning dictatorship for wind farm developments. Time to look objectively at the science and develop policies which will GENUINELY reduce carbon emissions. Time to stop the large-scale destruction of Scotland's precious natural heritage with industrial-scale power stations in totally inappropriate locations. The SNP's legacy becomes more shameful with every wind farm approved by ministers.
  13. Brian Croker 6 Apr 2015
    Wise up people-Bloom Energy has pioneered an on site box 4" (100mm) cube that can provide sufficient electricity for a small house. Just increase the box size to meet greater need. God has overtaken our inadequacy & stupidity. Amen.
  14. Janobai Smith 6 Apr 2015
    Loch Ness, which is situated in the land of my forebears, was a highlight of my visit to Scotland. I am very sad to hear that there are now plans to build industrial wind turbines in this special place.
  15. Martin Hayles 6 Apr 2015
    I travelled through this area back in '87. Simply beautiful. To desecrate this area with Industrial Wind Turbines will, someday in the near future be viewed as a criminal act of intentional vandalism.

    I trust these criminals will be held to account as they know that windmills have nothing to do whatsoever in reduction of CO2.

    Also, for nearly 2 decades CO2 output has continued to rise whilst warming has not.
  16. Graham Anderson 6 Apr 2015
    How can you all be so short sited. Our land is our heritage , once destroyed , it's gone forever. We have enough water in Scotland to put Hydro schemes in which don't destroy our landscape. It's just greed and money that is driving this suicide mission. Planners and government think about your grand children.
  17. Rhona Clark 6 Apr 2015
    How do we exist when the tourist stop returning when they can only see the White monstrosities. They are noisy too. Horrendous.
  18. John Chalmers 6 Apr 2015
    I have a cottage in Tomich and for 60 years have spent much of my spare time Enjoying the wonderful scenery in the area which must be one of the most beautiful places in Scotland and a great attraction to visitors from many countries who have come to enjoy our cottage. Apart from destroying the beauty of the countryside these enormous turbines will destroy the tourist industry in much of Scotland. Please do not allow this dreadful threat to our landscape take place. Some things are worth much more than money.
  19. John Tyler 6 Apr 2015
    Have just visited Fort William & the Great Glen to find it stunningly beautiful. Surely the protection of this scenery should be the number one priority in assessment of alien structure applications.
  20. Brian Sandison 6 Apr 2015
    Please, do we really want the thousands of tourists who visit Loch Ness every year to have this view spoiled? They may not come back and even more importantly, they may tell their friends not to come. Please consider this urgently!
  21. Mark Whitlock 6 Apr 2015
    It a place of natural beauty, I have traveled many places in the world, but nothing as beautiful as this can be seen with your eyes, man will distroy the world.
  22. Remko Stibbe - the Netherlands 6 Apr 2015
    I am shocked to learn that one the most beautiful and wild lands of Europe might be destructed forever because of this not well thought of windmill project. We love to come to Scotland and esp to this region. Well, not anymore if the windmill project will come into realisation.

    Did you factor in the costs of a much a collapsing tourism, not only for these regions but for Scotland as a whole? As a lot of people are combining visiting Loch Ness and the Great Glen with going to other places in Scotland as well? What about the costs of the scenery being spoilt?

    Please re-consider this project.
  23. Jim Hutson. 6 Apr 2015
    The hills will be scared forever with all the roadworks interlocking all the turbines. That in itself is an environmental disaster. One can only imagine the amount of money that will be passed under the table to secure this mess.
  24. Richard Hodgson 6 Apr 2015
    Please don't kill the beauty of my homeland
  25. Pamela Dobbie 6 Apr 2015
    We are now overrun with wind turbines here in Aberdeenshire. Please do not allow this to happen in such an iconic place!
  26. Larry Lorusso 6 Apr 2015
    Leave it alone!
  27. Keith MacKenzie 6 Apr 2015
    Being from Inverness, I appreciate the natural beauty of the Great Glen. Cycling out to Loch Ness was mandatory for me, the peace, tranquility and unspoilt scenery are deeply imbedded in my memory and would like future generations of people to see as well as appreciate. I am in favour of wind turbines but their is a place for them, the Great Glen is not the place!!
  28. Shelagh D Iwanowicz 6 Apr 2015
    It will be thirty years this year since my husband and I first visited Glen Strathfarrar and the beauty and unspoiled wild landscapes have drawn us back every year since.

    Glen Strathfarrar together with Glen Affric and Glen Cannich, the local people, their farms and businesses are a unique and wonderful example of how the two can live in harmony and be of benefit to each other and to the Scottish economy.

    This proposed development will put an end to this and all in the area will suffer and tourism will decline too.

    I value the communities who work and live there. This proposed development will have severe impact on people and families, business enterprises, the treasured countryside and the tourism industry

    This area of beauty & wild nature must be preserved for local communities and future generations.

    Please listen to me and others who are against this development and protect this area from this development. This wild land must be saved for the benefit of local people, businesses and future generations. Also for people who travel from all over the world to visit the unspoilt Scottish Highlands.

    Many thanks,
    Shelagh D Iwanowicz
  29. Jonathan Wynne Evans 6 Apr 2015
    It is perfectly staggering that the Scottish Government is encouraging the devastation of the Scottish landscape heritage with these uneconomic bits of scrap while prating about looking after Scottish interests. Wake up!!
  30. RD CONYBEARE 6 Apr 2015
    Wind turbine and solar farm construction has got out of hand. Companies are usuing limited resourses as an excuse to make huge profits regardless of the way these installations affect the local area.
  31. Pascale Ravé 6 Apr 2015
    Winds turbines, ecological excuse or economic interests ?
    Will our kids have the same happiness that us like wild Scotland ? Who likes Scotland get up !
  32. John Clarke 6 Apr 2015
    Due to the insistence of the SNP to destroy our beautiful landscape with such eyesores, they will not getting my vote in any election.
  33. Rod McLeod 6 Apr 2015
    There are far too many already, No More. The Scottish Tourist Board is very quiet with regards future Windfarm developments as they are concerned about their funding from the Scottish Government. Local people and tourists and people who care about the local environment and economy do not require anymore scars on the hillsides. An utter disgrace if this was allowed to happen.
  34. Alan O'Hagan 6 Apr 2015
    Enough is enough. The people who are letting this happen to our beautiful country are idiots.
  35. Vanessa Sigsworth 6 Apr 2015
    Why isn't this a World Heritage Site? It's world famous
    - don't let them line theirs pockets and make it infamous.
  36. EVRARD MICHEL 6 Apr 2015
    those windmills are a plague destroying the most scenic landscape of earth as in our country in Auvergne
  37. Irene Cochrane 6 Apr 2015
    Please don't ruin our beautiful natural area with wind turbines.
  38. donald Mack 6 Apr 2015
    Having lived a large part of my life in the area i know it well and strongly believe this glen & local area should be free of this destructive commercialisation for later generations to enjoy & appreciate. this quick buck development should not be asllowed.
  39. Susan Chisholm 6 Apr 2015
    I frequently visit family in the area and spend time in the hills enjoying the beautiful scenery.It makes not sense to ruin the very thing that visitors come to the area to experience. wind turbines are by no means proven to be efficient but are known to damage wildlife.
  40. chrissy de decker 6 Apr 2015
    We lived in Scotland for 9 years very near to Loch Ness,and it's the most beautiful country for me!! it would be a great shame if those windmills go ahead !! There are so many other natural resources that Scotland can use!!
  41. John Cole 6 Apr 2015
    There are not many true natural, unblighted, areas left so don't spoil this one
  42. May McIntosh 6 Apr 2015
    In 15 years time when these turbines need repairs are we to be left with broken down wrecks littering our precious hills.
  43. Wendy Edmond 6 Apr 2015
    Although we live in Rutland now my husband is a Scot, we have lived in Scotland, and holiday in The Highlands every year. The proposed desecration of The Highlands beggars belief, and cannot be allowed to happen.
  44. Gary Dickson 6 Apr 2015
    If my tourist £ counts for anything, then no more please!
  45. Kevin Williams 6 Apr 2015
    The Scottish Government announced a new planning policy banning wind farms in national parks and national scenic areas. They need to adhere to that policy and should be reminded of it, because it appears that in this instance they have conveniently forgotton it. If they put a policy in place they should stick to it otherwise how can we believe a word they say.
  46. Calum Rettie 6 Apr 2015
    why when we live in an island must the island be covered in so many of these unsightly structures? Surely harnessing tidal energy would be a far more efficient, sensible and aesthetically pleasing option!
  47. Alastair Runcie 6 Apr 2015
    The proliferation of wind farms in many beautiful areas of Scotland are complete waste of time effort and money. Furthermore they are a hideous blot on the landscape for which our SNP government must take the blame for their part in this environmental disaster.

    Alastair Runcie
  48. MARY Runcie 6 Apr 2015
    Our beautiful country is being ruined in the name of an unreliable intermittent form of so called "green energy"that despoils the land for miles around.The area in the south of Scotland has been turned into a giant industrial landscape,and it is now time to say STOP!The area around Loch Ness and the Great Glen is world renowned for it's beautiful landscape,so please do not ruin it for future generations.It makes me want to weep for our country and what is happening to it.Please listen to the opinions of experts with a relevant scientific background and not the ill informed,and stop this madness now.
  49. matthew morency 7 Apr 2015
    i live in southern ontario canada and come from a rural area now absolutely infested with wind turbines. THERE ARE NO MORE BIRDS!.To say the least this is disturbing. Inflicting that kind of changes along with blinking lights and noises that animals are sensitive to whether we are or not on Loch ness is criminal and irresponsible. btw i also live near power plants which now have higher emissions due to starting and stopping all the time to accommodate wind turbines.
  50. Albert Rogers 7 Apr 2015
    Has anyone considered the difficulty of replacing the coal burning that overwhelmed the clipper ships, with wind turbine energy that could not possibly power a ship to compete with the Cutty Sark?