Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01564 · Session 4

Save Loch Ness and the Great Glen

Closed Submitted 11 Mar 2015 Rural Affairs
Signatures
1
3,097 online signatures with a country
Comments
521
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take steps to designate the Loch Ness and Great Glen as a National Scenic Area; to recommend a priority application is made to UNESCO for the area to be afforded World Heritage protection; and to take appropriate steps to discourage further wind turbine developments and support the restoration of sites damaged by wind turbines.

What the petitioner did first

1. Letters of comment and opposition on an individual basis by Friends of the Great Glen on planning applications in the Great Glen through the Highland Council planning system, for example on Beinn Mhor, Invermoriston, Bhlaraidh, Stronelairg, and the extension to the Millenium Wind Farm. These applications have been recommended for approval, despite considerable public objections, for example over 1200 in the case of Beinn Mhor.

2. Correspondence with local MSP on wind farm developments in the Great Glen.

3. A complaint was lodged with the Highland Council on the visual impact of the Millenium Wind Farm and this was later referred to the planning process (the planning application is still active).

4. Letter to the SNH Chair asking for more active defence of wild land and internationally acclaimed landscape sites in the Great Glen and specifically Stronelairg.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 26 May 2015
    1 mention
  2. 22 Sep 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 14 Sep 2017
    1 mention

Signatures by country

3,097 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,320 42.6%
  2. United Kingdom471 15.2%
  3. France376 12.1%
  4. England342 11%
  5. Germany113 3.6%
  6. Canada79 2.6%
  7. United States73 2.4%
  8. Australia68 2.2%
  9. Poland43 1.4%
  10. Ireland33 1.1%
  11. 35 other countries179 5.8%

Comments

521 comments, oldest first
521 comments · showing 201–250
  1. Brian Cherek 3 Apr 2015
    This plan will simply turn The Highlands into an industrial wasteland and destroy the amazing birds of prey of Scotland. The introduction of these wind farms would be a crime on a scale never seen in this country and would only line the pockets of certain individuals from the people who can least afford it, the public. The evidence worldwide now shows the hazards and risks associated with wind farms and their technology. It doesn't take a lot to look it up and read the facts for yourself. The Scottish government cannot say at a later date that they didn't know what the risks were as an idiot could find the evidence.
  2. Tom reid 3 Apr 2015
    Stop ruining our countryside with an inefficient source of energy!!!
  3. Axel FRANK 3 Apr 2015
    Summer 1978. It's one of my best souvenir... I had eleven years old...in travel with my parents in Scotland. It's pure and beautyfull... Something you can't remove off my mind and my soul....
  4. Stewart Yates 3 Apr 2015
    This is horrific. And not to mention absolutely absurd, to build so far from the point of demand! Why? Money. Big (subsidised) bucks for big business. No. Stop this. Please. You are destroying the very thing that Scotland is known for and admired around the globe. Stop this. Please. Enough. Please stop.
  5. Brian Tyrell 4 Apr 2015
    I object to all wind turbines and the exorbitant cost and destruction to the environment and I belive the true fact are witheld, another man made disaster in the making, money over all else I despair.
  6. Michael John Hall 4 Apr 2015
    The once delightful journey up the motorway from England to Scotland has been destroyed by uncontrolled wind developmets. How sad that this is spreading into even more scenic areas. The Scottish Government should hang its head in shame,
  7. Ronald L Hart 4 Apr 2015
    A windfarm is proposed near Corsock, is there a campaign to stop it?
  8. D Powell 4 Apr 2015
    Granting permission for this outrage amounts to the triumph of ill-conceived dogma and ignorance over democracy and the landscape which makes Scotland unique.
  9. Anthony Trewavas 4 Apr 2015
    The proposed turbines around Loch Ness indicate the madness that this government purveys as a generating policy. But then none of them are qualified to control something so necessary and complex as electricity supply. Two extra nuclear power stations would have obviated all these turbines but then no one in this government is competent to make any decision about nuclear power.
  10. robert hogg 4 Apr 2015
    We have to stop the march of these wind turbines. otherwise we will not have any wilderness left in Scotland. Tourists come to scotland for the landscape not to look at wind turbines. Stop this now.
  11. Anthony Fitzherbert 4 Apr 2015
    A PROPOSED VANDALISM OF A WONDERFUL AND TREASURED PIECE OF MOUNTAIN SCENERY TO SATISFY THE GREED OF THE DEVELOPERS AND THE PROPRIETORS OF THE LAND THAT WILL COST US ALL A FORTUNE AND DO NOTHING TO SAVE THE PLANET
  12. Bruce Chisholm 4 Apr 2015
    Enough is Enough
    - we must keep the countryside as countryside & stop repeatedly spoiling it. Make the area an NSA & once & for all resolve the matter protecting the area for future generations.
  13. Erica Sarney 4 Apr 2015
    I am disgusted by the blight on the landscape of wind farms in Scotland. I urge you to protect this area from devastation by wind farm development
  14. Alan Johnson 4 Apr 2015
    Wind farms do not save the environment, they destroy it
  15. Christian RIOLS 4 Apr 2015
    Actual wind farms are nothing else than big business threatening both ours landscapes, birds and chiros. We are also fighting against in southern France where are living so many large raptors and other living treasures !
  16. john askey 4 Apr 2015
    What priorities do we have here when over 1 million people sign a petition to keep a so called celebrity but only just over a 1000 sign one to preserve one of the most beautiful areas in the world!
  17. Lafarge Yvette 4 Apr 2015
    Cessez de détruire ces beaux paysages par des machines industrielles inutiles

    Stop destroying these beautiful landscapes with unnecessary industrial machinery
  18. David W Potts 4 Apr 2015
    The SG should ensure that sensitive areas such as this are protected for the future. In the long term these developments will have a detrimental impact on tourism.
  19. Sue Smith 4 Apr 2015
    This is tragic and, yes, it does make you want to weep. What a disgraceful destruction of an iconic Scottish landscape? And a sure way to bite the hand of tourism that feeds so many businesses :(
  20. Gloria McGuigan 4 Apr 2015
    I feel that the snp obsession with wind turbines has already destroyed the natural beauty of our countryside and enough is enough
    - the tourists come to see the beauty not the turbines
    - snp are a disgrace
  21. George F Wood 4 Apr 2015
    This historic site should not be spoiled by the erection of wind-turbines !!!.
  22. neil macleod 4 Apr 2015
    Loch Ness is famous throughout the world and should not have its unique views spoiled by windturbines
  23. Anne White 4 Apr 2015
    Please, please stop industrialising this beautiful country. As a frequent visitor to Scotland, I look on with dismay as more and more of your country looks like a wind factory, totally detracting from the reasons people visit. Please--STOP IT!
  24. Jean Kedar 4 Apr 2015
    This is one of the most iconic areas in Scotland. Please keep it free of turbines!
  25. Andrew Kedar 4 Apr 2015
    No hideous turbines in this majestic scenery!
  26. David leadbetter 4 Apr 2015
    Subsidised wind power is a wholly discredited technology . The desecration of our natural heritage by the Current Scottish Government is a betrayal of the Scottish people.
  27. Nadine Matrullo 4 Apr 2015
    Il faut respecter ces paysages extraordinaires et ne pas les polluer avec ces machines à fric !

    We must respect these extraordinary landscapes and not pollute the money with these machines!
  28. John Lennon 4 Apr 2015
    I left Scotland a number of years ago and come from that area, I return every year and have brought many of my Australian who in turn took theirs. If these wind farms are allowed it will rob not only me of my return to Scotland by will rob tourism in the area, people will never again be able to see these glens in all of their beauty, it must not be allowed and the corrupt and inept politics should be held accountable by means of an inquiry to audit the approval process. Please Please for our and our fore bearers future don't allow this unnecessary greed to ruin these glens, we must all at least plead because protest is not working.
  29. Karen walker 4 Apr 2015
    Enough is enough no more in our countryside ..
  30. Judi Smith 4 Apr 2015
    Loch Ness and the Great Glen and a huge tourist attraction and bring in a lot of revenue for Scotland. Why,oh Why is this most stunning of areas being blighted be these huge ugly turbines. Why don't they put the blessed things in Wales, in the Peaks, on Dartmoor, East Anglia. It makes me so cross. Anything abhorrent
    - oh let's put it in Scotland. It's about time that attitude changed.
  31. Michael Smith 4 Apr 2015
    Definitely should be stopped.
  32. Shannon Swaab 4 Apr 2015
    Scotland with Loch Ness and the Great Glen is one of the last wildernesses and is a favourite holiday destination for people from the Netherlands. Please leave it as it is.
  33. Alan Evans 4 Apr 2015
    The steady desecration of valuable Scottish landscape by wind turbine development is one of the most spectacular failures of the Scottish Government. It is time to call a halt to this especially as off-shore turbine development is about to commence on a massive scale.
  34. Paul Sim 5 Apr 2015
    My wife and I have spent many a happy week in the Highlands. We have recently returned from our latest 10 day trip, and the windturbines are getting more numerous. NOT just around Loch Ness. If they continue building, it will have a huge impact on the land, the people and wildlife. WE MUST conserve the Scottish Highlands for future generations...And not to line the pockets of the few.
  35. Rosemary Sherwin 5 Apr 2015
    Have visited Loch Ness region on many occcassions and still marvel at the scenery. Please don't ruin it with these useless turbines that do nothing but ruin the landscape as well as slaughtering birds and bats.
  36. Loretta Edmonston 5 Apr 2015
    I live near a windfarm that I tried hard to stop. The noise is unrelenting, our television, computer etc. are constantly interferred with and the effects of the infrasound,my main worry, are largely unknown.
  37. Peter Swan 5 Apr 2015
    We have to find a way to save and generate our energy that does not continue to destroy so many of the beautiful areas of Scotland. We are rapidly turning Scotland into one giant windfarm.
  38. David Bromley 5 Apr 2015
    Why this obsession with carpeting the country with wind turbines? They will never provide more than a small fraction of our energy needs not matter how many are erected. The environment loses out to big business yet again!
  39. Gilbert Naudet 5 Apr 2015
    I spent my professional live in energy studies. Wind power is not vailable from energy, enviromental and economy point of wiev, you can be sure..
  40. Chris ROQUES 5 Apr 2015
    same problems here in " Baie de Somme"
  41. Steve Davison 5 Apr 2015
    It's almost unbelievable that the Scots would destroy one of the biggest tourist attractions they have by turning it into an industrial wind farm landscape. Politicians should hang their heads in shame.
  42. leslie john mason 5 Apr 2015
    you have to live in a town to appreciate what is in the country,do not spoil it with man made items
  43. Roger Pirrie 5 Apr 2015
    Disgraceful!
  44. Geoffrey Kolbe 5 Apr 2015
    Loch Ness is a national treasure and should not be despoiled
  45. Joani SIMON 5 Apr 2015
    Il faut absolument cesser d'implanter ces engins de mort qui tuent les oiseaux, le gibiers, et les humains à cause des infrasons émis et dont personne ne vous parlera, mais moi je suis radioamateur.

    It is imperative to stop implementing these deadly devices that kill birds, game, and humans because of infrasound emitted and nobody will talk to you, but I am amateur.
  46. Michael mcdonald 5 Apr 2015
    Please do not allow wind turbines to destroy the beautiful Scottish scenery. This great area that attracts thousands of tourists.
  47. Jacqueline Annette Rovensky 5 Apr 2015
    As a British Citizen as well as an Australian Citizen I am concerned about the encroachment of Industrial Wind Turbines into the environment, and especially where that environment is of important scenic beauty. Further the encroachment of these IWT's will not enhance the environment in anyway, they are unable to reduce CO2 and cause immense damage to bird life. They also emit a signature noise which is now recognised as infra-sound which causes health issues in humans with possible as yet un-researched distress to animals and birds. For Loch Ness and the Great Glen to be damaged in such a way will be recorded in history as a deliberate act of environmental vandalism, and those who sanction it will take their place in history as ignorant people with no understanding of duty of care to the environment.
  48. Erica Jones 5 Apr 2015
    Although I now live in Canada I was born in Scotland & lived in the Highlands until my mid-twenties.I still visit every couple of years & think this beautiful area should remain as pristine as possible-- scenery & wildlife habitat.
  49. Ann Christie 5 Apr 2015
    While I support the Scottish Government's drive towards energy independence, it always seems to be at the expense of iconic areas of our country. Why not around towns, where there are sufficient industrial areas that can absorb the impact of wind farms easily? Please leave the Great Glen and Loch Ness alone. These are vital to our tourism as they are, not polluted by yet more wind farms.
  50. lorina garden 5 Apr 2015
    Why I will not vote SNP, how can they be allowed to ruin our countryside with these monstrous structures.