Petition · PE01564 · Session 4
Save Loch Ness and the Great Glen
Signatures
1
Comments
521
Considered
3 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take steps to designate the Loch Ness and Great Glen as a National Scenic Area; to recommend a priority application is made to UNESCO for the area to be afforded World Heritage protection; and to take appropriate steps to discourage further wind turbine developments and support the restoration of sites damaged by wind turbines.
What the petitioner did first
1. Letters of comment and opposition on an individual basis by Friends of the Great Glen on planning applications in the Great Glen through the Highland Council planning system, for example on Beinn Mhor, Invermoriston, Bhlaraidh, Stronelairg, and the extension to the Millenium Wind Farm. These applications have been recommended for approval, despite considerable public objections, for example over 1200 in the case of Beinn Mhor.
2. Correspondence with local MSP on wind farm developments in the Great Glen.
3. A complaint was lodged with the Highland Council on the visual impact of the Millenium Wind Farm and this was later referred to the planning process (the planning application is still active).
4. Letter to the SNH Chair asking for more active defence of wild land and internationally acclaimed landscape sites in the Great Glen and specifically Stronelairg.
2. Correspondence with local MSP on wind farm developments in the Great Glen.
3. A complaint was lodged with the Highland Council on the visual impact of the Millenium Wind Farm and this was later referred to the planning process (the planning application is still active).
4. Letter to the SNH Chair asking for more active defence of wild land and internationally acclaimed landscape sites in the Great Glen and specifically Stronelairg.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
26 May 20151 mention
-
22 Sep 20151 mention
-
14 Sep 20171 mention
Signatures by country
3,097 online signaturesComments
521 comments, oldest first521 comments · showing 151–200
-
Helen Reeves 1 Apr 2015More evidence proving sustainability of Wind Farms WITHOUT government or any other subsidy is needed. More evidence proving Wind Farms do NOT affect wildlife nor humans nor the environment in any way is needed before any Wind farm is allowed to go ahead.
Are Wind Farms truly, truly the way forward or they a short term solution to a very long term problem? Who will dismantle them and repair the wrong created by them? -
G Speirs 1 Apr 2015I am appalled at the wanton destruction of our 'wild and beautiful' landscape. All the efforts of the previous generation to save our green places are being destroyed in the name of 'green energy'. These areas will now be reclassified as 'industrial', so what happens once the wind folly ends????
-
Jo page 1 Apr 2015The level of wind turbines proposed is completely unacceptable. Pure destruction of the landscape. This area should be protected.
-
E Griffiths 1 Apr 2015The whole windustry is based on lies, deception and torture
- yes, TORTURE. ETSU noise guidelines are designed NOT to measure the bulk of the noise emitted by industrial wind powered subsidy farms. -
ian miller 1 Apr 2015Wind Turbines release enormous CO2 emissions in their manufacture installation & commissioning, totally out of proportion to that saved throughout their short lives, while utterly destroying our Scottish Natural Heritage..
-
B Griffiths 1 Apr 2015If this goes ahead I will never go on holiday to this area again. I have loved it since childhood.. what utter desecration of a beautiful area. Unbelievable. Heartbreaking.
-
andy leader 1 Apr 2015This is vandalism.
-
Lynne barrie 1 Apr 2015please stop this it is a natural beauty spot
-
Maggy ERNST 1 Apr 2015Our common duty is to preserve our heritage against swindle of wind farms
-
Marjorie Gordon 1 Apr 2015Wind farms will spoil this beautiful area. Let everyone appreciate the beauty of this country and especially this tourist area, without the eyesore of so many wind turbines. How could anyone think this is right?
-
Elaine Kneller 1 Apr 2015This area needs protecting, the wildlife needs protecting. Please stop the wind turbines.
-
Fiona Urquhart 1 Apr 2015These Turbines have done nothing but torn communities apart and are ruining the last bastion of wilderness in Britain and Europe!!
-
Celia Hobbs 1 Apr 2015Please stop this destruction of Scotland's iconic landscapes.We have spent nearly ten years fighting three wind farms and having won two now face another appeal next month. The wind farm proposals are three miles apart. There is something very wrong somewhere when the Councils have objected each time and the public have responded with a minimum of 94% against. I fear for the future of this country when local democracy does not count.The local people know the value of landscape to their well being and their tourism industry.The wind industry tried to maintain for years that house prices were not affected but now of course it has been proved they do. Similarily they say tourism is not affected. Of course it is
- the Commonwealth Games and Ryder Cup will have masked the true figures this year. The Moffat study showed tourists a photo of a view from a hotel bedroom window with and without turbines. Over 60% said they preferred the view without.How can a nationalist Government destroy the country's greatest asset?
Please save what is left. I used to feel my heart soar when we left Moffat and climbed the Devil's Beeftub and know we were back in Scotland.Now I just feel sad as the turbines appear along the route. We have saved the Pentland Hills so far but it is in the hands of one man what this area will look like for the next twenty five years. -
Elizabeth Riley 2 Apr 2015As the daughter of a Scottish emigrant I was really saddened to see these "blots on the landscape" popping up wherever we went on our final pilgrimage "home" in 2014. My granddaughter came with us in 2008 when the pristine environment was pretty much unblemished, but she remembers very little of that trip. What will be left for her to see in her planned trip of 2020? It's heartbreaking! I realise we must stop polluting the atmosphere and move towards renewable energy but we must not do this at the expense of beautiful environments.
-
Butré Anick 2 Apr 2015It is a shame and a sham that the Scotish Parliament pretends
to be ecologist , pretends to care about its land . Detroying "Lock Ness" with wind turbines is inconcievable -
Torbjorn Eriksson 2 Apr 2015The same sad song here on our treasure island, Holmon! www.friavindar.se
-
John Steven 2 Apr 2015Nessie will rise to it and protect her glen
-
STRUAN STEVENSON 2 Apr 2015THIS IS THE SNP's REAL LEGACY FOR SCOTLAND
- DEVASTATION! -
Bea Holden 2 Apr 2015Planning guidelines need to be overhauled urgently. Areas like this with high scenic value and important for tourism should not even be considered by developers. Guidance for developers needs to be clear that they will not be successful in this area.
-
Elizabeth Dunlop 2 Apr 2015I object to my country being turned into an industrial park. Visitors come to Scotland primarily for the scenery,. Please do not destroy our greatest asset.
-
Margaret Harding 2 Apr 2015these iconic landscapes appreciated by visitors and inhabitants for 1000s of years should not be desecrated by windfarms
- which are environmentally destructive to birds, visually hideous and habitat destroying because of roads needed to be built and foundations to be put in which take up hundreds of acres of habitat and are not even able to operate in times of high pressure with no wind or too much wind and are cost efficient to the owners operators only because of subsidies and for no other reason. -
Jean Friess 2 Apr 2015Il est inconcevable et inadmissible qu'un site aussi emblématique que le Loch Ness soit sacrifié sur l'autel des énergies dites renouvelables : au nom de la protection des paysages, il faut sauver ce merveilleux site de la cupidité des opérateurs et de la stupidité d'élus qui , la plupart du temps, ne prennent pas en compte les paysages et la biodiversité dans l'élaboration de tels projets.
It is inconceivable and unacceptable that a site as iconic as the Loch Ness be sacrificed on the altar of so-called renewable energy: the name of landscape protection, we must save this wonderful site operators of greed and stupidity of elected officials who usually do not take into account the landscape and biodiversity in the development of such projects. -
douglas henderson 2 Apr 2015Loch Ness is an important site for tourists and the great glen also windmills will destroy the features of the area the wildlife will also be affected
-
David Walmsley 2 Apr 2015The steady ruination of the Scottish countryside and in particular areas such as the Great Glen by inefficient, subsidised turbines that enrich the few, create fuel poverty, will come home to roost when tourism and the income which flows from it ceases.
-
Lenny Cowieson 2 Apr 2015Loch Ness is a world renowned tourist destination why in the world does our government not protect this area ? These developments are fuelled by corporate and personal greed in pursuit of a dubious technology.
-
Lesley Green 2 Apr 2015I could think of a worse idea. Disgraceful that it has even been considered. The landscape would be completely ruined and tourists would probably avoid the area.
-
Terry Andrews 2 Apr 2015"You don't know what you've got 'til it's gone"
- and if windfarms are allowed to bristle all over the Loch Ness surroundings, that's the chief appeal
- gone for good. You can't manufacture wilderness. You can only respect and preserve it. Unless you think disneyfied "theme parks" a bigger draw?? -
Katy Ingham 2 Apr 2015About time the exceedingly generous subsidies for these inefficient monstrosities ended, and people wake up to who is really financially benefitting from this environmental tokenism.
-
COLIN AITKEN 2 Apr 2015ENOUGH IS ENOUGH
- BUILD THEM IN THE CENTRAL BELT AND LEAVE OUR LAST REMAINING WILD SPACES ALONE. -
John Alexander 2 Apr 2015Wind turbines are inefficient and an eyesore. There popularity is based on keeping electricity generation in the hands of the big national suppliers. Protect our countryside and adopt other clean methods of electricity generation.
-
Isabel Campbell 2 Apr 2015We must stop the proliferation of wind turbines around Loch Ness. Scotland already generates enough green energy to sustain itself.
-
Irene Stewart 2 Apr 2015The scenery of wild Scotland is it's greatest asset. The damage caused by wind farms far outweighs the derisory amount of electricity they produce
-
Byron Davies 2 Apr 2015I am a tourist and I visit area several times a year, the Alps may now get my patronage in future
-
Fabienne Chapuis Hini 2 Apr 2015please, please, I beg you not to realize these foolish winpark witch are going to destroy these so beautifull place of nature with these marvellous lake. It is not worth it
-
Karin Eriksson 2 Apr 2015It's a shame! Stop this madness now!!
-
francois guillot 2 Apr 2015PLease just stop destroying our world
-
Mrs L. Harris 2 Apr 2015This is ridiculous that turbines could go on Loch Ness! What next, on Arthur's Seat? Loch Ness is often one of the first things many people who don't live in Scotland think of when talking of Scotland. Wind turbines are known to be NOT cost effective especially in the extreme temperatures we experience in the colder months when they simply cannot run due to no wind! Yes, Loch Ness should be protected from the scams that are wind turbine farms and any other such schemes that may come along. Please protect Loch Ness as it is for future generations -this is the least we can do.
-
Karen Panich 2 Apr 2015Loch Ness and the Great Glen have much to offer tourists and this is a major concern. Without the beautiful scenery, I would be concerned over the attraction to this area by tourists, a major income for Highlanders. In addition, having lived there for 8 years, I would say, it is the number one attraction for living there. Will house prices be affected by such a big change? This will have a major impact.
-
alex mcleod 2 Apr 2015Windpower development in UK is a monster out of control driven by the usual big business culprit....GREED and ablily assisted by the political puppets looking for a leg-up once they get the boot from Parliament
-
Neville RIGBY 2 Apr 2015Wind turbines are an unnecessary intrusion into the landscape which threaten to destroy the visual amenity and debase the natural beauty of the Great Glen. The tourism economy on which so many depend is being undermined by thoughtless and opportunistic development not only through wind turbines and the superfluous grid pylons that go with them, but unnecessary housing development both by speculative builders and greedy landowners cashing in on selling plots where there is no explanation for planning permission having been granted other than vested interest. The Great Glen needs to be saved from the shabby commercialisation that will become it's ruin.
-
Susan Murray 2 Apr 2015Windfarms are NOT the sensible way forward. We already have too many ruining the landscape. Loch Ness is particularly a spectacular tourist area which would be ruined by wind turbines
-
Karen Bancroft 3 Apr 2015Scotland is renowned for its natural beauty attracting visitors from all over the world. Tourism is one of Scotlands biggest earners. The Scottish Government funds public sector enterprises such as Scottish Natural Heritage, their purpose is to promote, care for and improvement of the natural heritage. Help people enjoy it responsibly. Enable greater understanding and awareness of it. Promote its sustainable use, now and for future generations. Why would the Government then eradicate their investment for the Scottish people and their visitors by allowing Scotland to have an Industrial Landscape?
-
tom Jacobs 3 Apr 2015I know civilisation has got to move on and adapt to the increased demand for energy but not at the expense of beautiful natural areas such as the Great Glen or any of the incredible areas within the Scottish Highlands. These areas have a diverse array of wildlife and habitats and once destroyed will never be the same again. We WILL regret destroying out countryside and special areas of natural beauty in the future if we don't fight to save them now.
-
Dee Babin 3 Apr 2015Where IS the department of joined up thinking, to protect environment and our heritage. Who is able to stand up to this power-hungry, short-sighted , profit driven sector? The out-dated technology of these greedy people does nothing to support a sustainable future. I agree with what has been said below, but who is listening?
-
Ira Fishman 3 Apr 2015Please don't let others to destroy the natural beauty that is such a vital part of Scotland. These wind turbines are truly a blot on the landscape, and not just in Scotland. Moreover, they are not a proven source of reliable and cost-effective energy according to many scientists in the field. Though Don Quixote is known for his fictional antics in Spain, today he would certainly give Scotland a hand in an attempt to rid the countryside of these monstrosities that are already in place. Enough is more than enough.
-
Rachel Connor 3 Apr 2015This is not a 'green' development, this is simply 'greed' development at the expense of our iconic landscape, and our environment for decades to come. There are predictable serious effects on drinking water, wildlife and the people who call this land 'home'
- ignored by our Government and disregarded as 'collateral damage' by the developers. -
Donald MacKenzie 3 Apr 2015Wind farms are subsidy engines and do not "save the planet". Once you take into account carbon losses from ground disturbance at turbine sites and access road networks they do not contribute to a carbon reduction.
-
Keith Cowieson 3 Apr 2015The areas proposed for development are rich in iconic Scottish birdlife
- golden eagle, osprey, hen harrier, black and red-throated diver, golden plover and curlew amongst many others. Birds and wind farms do not mix well
- we know this from our own and other nations' experience. And then there is the visual blemish on a world-famous area of outstanding natural beauty. Finally, tearing up the peat covered hills to build tracks and windfarm bases would release significant quantities of CO2
- peat is one of the best natural sequesters of carbon. This is ill-conceived on so many levels.... -
Annette Mansie 3 Apr 2015Our daughter was born in Inverness, and we have always loved the highlands, and wind farms are unsightly.
-
Chaperon du larret Natalia 3 Apr 2015When will it stop?this kind of energie kills thousand of birds....I'm sick of it!!!!