Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01564 · Session 4

Save Loch Ness and the Great Glen

Closed Submitted 11 Mar 2015 Rural Affairs
Signatures
1
3,097 online signatures with a country
Comments
521
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take steps to designate the Loch Ness and Great Glen as a National Scenic Area; to recommend a priority application is made to UNESCO for the area to be afforded World Heritage protection; and to take appropriate steps to discourage further wind turbine developments and support the restoration of sites damaged by wind turbines.

What the petitioner did first

1. Letters of comment and opposition on an individual basis by Friends of the Great Glen on planning applications in the Great Glen through the Highland Council planning system, for example on Beinn Mhor, Invermoriston, Bhlaraidh, Stronelairg, and the extension to the Millenium Wind Farm. These applications have been recommended for approval, despite considerable public objections, for example over 1200 in the case of Beinn Mhor.

2. Correspondence with local MSP on wind farm developments in the Great Glen.

3. A complaint was lodged with the Highland Council on the visual impact of the Millenium Wind Farm and this was later referred to the planning process (the planning application is still active).

4. Letter to the SNH Chair asking for more active defence of wild land and internationally acclaimed landscape sites in the Great Glen and specifically Stronelairg.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 26 May 2015
    1 mention
  2. 22 Sep 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 14 Sep 2017
    1 mention

Signatures by country

3,097 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,320 42.6%
  2. United Kingdom471 15.2%
  3. France376 12.1%
  4. England342 11%
  5. Germany113 3.6%
  6. Canada79 2.6%
  7. United States73 2.4%
  8. Australia68 2.2%
  9. Poland43 1.4%
  10. Wales33 1.1%
  11. 35 other countries179 5.8%

Comments

521 comments, oldest first
521 comments · showing 101–150
  1. David doohan 27 Mar 2015
    I and my wife have spent many happy times travelling around the loch and the surrounding area. The wind farm at Farr was the result of an appaulling decision as have been the case with other approvals in this iconic and beautiful part of the Highlands. This vandalism MUST STOP.
  2. Ernie Smart 27 Mar 2015
    If we carry on as we are doing Scotland will be infested with wind turbines. We will have no trees and a whacking debt.
  3. Judith Costello 27 Mar 2015
    The while country doesn't have to be covered in wind turbines! Leave some places turbine free!
  4. Michael James Cooper 27 Mar 2015
    id like to see this kept the way it is
  5. Victoria Berryman 27 Mar 2015
    I have wonderful memories of visiting Loch Ness. If the wind farm goes ahead, I certainly won't ever return! It is too painful to witness the destruction of your chief tourist attraction
    - wide open natural (undeveloped) areas! Scotland used to be the place to go to escape urban pressures. As every new turbine goes, so this becomes less true.
  6. martyn sharpe 27 Mar 2015
    How long does this madness go on before someone sees sense!! Is there any wonder politicians are held in such low esteem when they continue to destroy the landscape just to look green...
  7. Diana Goodbourn 28 Mar 2015
    We hope that Loch Ness and the Great Glen are very good sites and I hope they will survive.
  8. Anna Sargent 28 Mar 2015
    Do not do irreversible damage to this unique place.
  9. Maureen Case 28 Mar 2015
    I have serious doubts that the present planning situation is doing anything to protect this world famous and special area. I fear that the area will be ruined for both visitors and locals.
  10. Bernard Case 28 Mar 2015
    To protect the remaining unspoilt Highland Region with Loch Ness and the Great Glen at its heart, a moratorium on all future turbine schemes is essential whilst an assessment on the impact is made.
  11. Ian Dailey 28 Mar 2015
    I find this situation alarming and it is clear to me that the SNP are clearly no friend to the environment nor to the people of Scotland and those of us who live abroad.
  12. vicky dallenger 29 Mar 2015
    Loch Ness is an iconic part of Scottish heritage!!
  13. Kevin Williams 29 Mar 2015
    I cannot beleive the Scottish Parliament and Government are considering letting up to 500 wind turbines to be sited on land around Loch Ness, The Great Glen, Beinn Mhor ( nearTomich and Loch Affric). Did the Government not announce in June a new planning policy bannig wind farms in national parks and national scenic areas. If any of these wind turbines arer allowed to be constructed in Scot
  14. Deborah Massey 29 Mar 2015
    Don't sell your beauty Scotland, it is priceless !!
  15. Mariusz Biski 29 Mar 2015
    It looks as if wind industry was trying to continue to excercise its power on the Scots. There is, however, too much evidence concerning adverse effects on environment and human health. As this plague has already reached Loch Ness, it may just as well reach your backyard, the way it reached mine, one of those days. Consequences are cataclysmic. Don't you ever let them put up those monsters there! Your children will never forgive you!
  16. Ruth Adams 29 Mar 2015
    This is a popular area for tourism. More than 15 years ago this was the first place to hat I stayed on holiday. The scenery was so breathtaking that it drew me back year after year until I could not longer leave such beauty and moved up to live in Sutherland in 2011. Since then there has been such an increase in applications for windfalls in areas of outstanding beauty. The question to be asked is will the area draw in tourists still when these farms blight the skyline throughout the Great Glen and beyond. Companies may offer the local communities community funding but how much more money will be lost to local businesses by tourists no longer coming to the area as it's too ugly to visit any more?
  17. William Fraser 30 Mar 2015
    We already suffer from approval of far too many applications for construction of wind farms in areas quite unsuited to this type of obtrusive industrial development. We are fortunate in Scotland to have some of the finest remaining wild land in Europe
    - wild land that millions of others are happy to travel far and pay handsomely to see and experience. It is part of our heritage as Scots. Loch Ness and the Great Glen are prime examples of this. We have a duty to recognise their uniqueness and worth, and to safeguard them for future generations. For decades, many of our residents have derived their livelihood from catering for those who travel to witness the scenic grandeur we have to offer. This is likely to become an increasingly significant factor in Scotland's economic future. Accumulating actual output data for existing wind farms shows that their potential contribution to our requirement for renewable energy has been vastly over-hyped by those who stand to profit from their construction. Wind farms with projected efficiencies of 30% and over are being shown to struggle to reach even 20%. In the UK, they tend to produce most electricity at times when nobody needs it. We are all footing the bill for misguided subsidies that are inducing a flood of totally inappropriate applications for wind farm construction. Most are made by those whose sole interest is easy profit in the short term. They don't "do" long-term thinking. Someone else is going to have to do the long-term thinking required to safeguard our heritage. I therefore urge you to 1) Afford protection to the Loch Ness and Great Glen by designating it as a National Scenic Area 2) Recommend that a priority application is made to UNESCO for designation of the Loch Ness area and the Great Glen as a World Heritage Site 3) Take appropriate steps to discourage all wind farm developments in this area, and support the restoration of all sites therein damaged by wind turbines.
    William Fraser BSc, MIMechE, CEng
  18. Steve Lamb 30 Mar 2015
    This is an area of outstanding natural beauty. Please leave it that way.
  19. kathy bluefield 30 Mar 2015
    Scotland has the last few wilderness areas and areas of outstanding natural beauty to be enjoyed not only by residents in the area but it is also a major attraction for tourism. Millions of pounds are spent by tourists and lots of businesses would not survive without the money which this generates.
    Please leave this area free of ugly inefficient wind turbines.
  20. James McComas 30 Mar 2015
    These developments represent short term gain for a few thanks to government subsidies against long term marring of the countryside for everyone
    - a very short sighted policy
  21. Brian Jagger 31 Mar 2015
    Windfarms are not the solution to our energy needs, they are inefficient and damaging to the visual environment. This proposal will bring questionable economic benefits at the cost of lost revenue from tourism to an iconic area of Scotland.
  22. Kathryn Squire 31 Mar 2015
    The increasing industrialisation of Loch Ness and the surrounding landscape is unacceptable. Local communities have objected to applications for windfarms in the area in their thousands
    - and yet, the Scottish Government continue their drive for 100% renewable energy at the expense of the environment. How contradictory is this? I fully support the priority application to UNESCO for World Heritage protection.
  23. Sorcha Ni Aoidhe 31 Mar 2015
    Yes these are sites of International importance, icons and like the rest of the countries that are be desecrated by the wind industry it is time for the people to take a stand. This is not working...
  24. Robert grove 31 Mar 2015
    This country depends predominantly on tourism and this government seems hellbent on destroying what people come here to see....it's great natural beauty. It has to stop now. Wind turbines are a monstrosity and a huge blot on our landscape. There are alternatives but greed blinds the politicians as it always has done! Save this beautiful country NOW while we still can!
  25. mel randall 31 Mar 2015
    enough is too much, would they be building these turbines without subsidies I dont think so
  26. Eric Dickison 31 Mar 2015
    Scotland relies on tourists.
    I should know, I run a guesthouse.
    Tourists come here to see Scotland's natural beauty.
    NOT WIND TURBINES.
  27. Karen Roden 31 Mar 2015
    We have been visiting Scotland as a family holiday for 15 years and each year it has been getting worse, and it has now got that we think this will be our last year. There is NO justification for what these massive wind turbines and their attendant pylons, miles of access roads, sub stations etc are doing to Scotland's once stunning landscape. The Scottish Government should hang its head in shame.
  28. Harry Amey 1 Apr 2015
    A minority profit financially from a short term subsidy dependent business at the expense of the majority. A method of producing electricity that is inefficient, expensive, ecologically unsound and so intermittent that it will never be capable of replacing base power be that coal, gas or nuclear. All this whilst the health risks to residents are ignored. Shame on those in power who choose to continue with this disgraceful wind power fraud.
  29. Karen Wharton 1 Apr 2015
    Wind turbines are intrusive, furthermore there are many doubts over their efficiency. Once damaged, Loch Ness can NEVER be recovered. I urge that this be designated a UNESCO world heritage site.
  30. Butré Jean-Louis 1 Apr 2015
    Wind farms imperil wildlife and destroy natural habitats which have hitherto escaped the destructive powers of earth-moving equipment, concreting operations and other highly invasive human activities.
    The negative effects of industrial wind turbines on people, landscapes, tourism, property values, wildlife, and the economy are widely understood and accepted. They are significantly altering Europe's natural and cultural heritage by their harmful effect on landscapes .
    In France Mont Saint Michel have been saved from wind turbine's desater by UNESCO after years of battle
    Now Vezelay, Saint Savin,La Saline Royale, and all the most beautifull landscapes of France are under attack by the same promoters.
    Please stop ruining beautiful lands . Please save Loch Ness
  31. John Curtis 1 Apr 2015
    This endless, mindless, wanton destruction of beautiful Scotland must be stopped.
  32. Mark Pawelek 1 Apr 2015
    Wind farms are not an economically viable solution for Scotland's energy needs. They provide unreliable, intermittent electricity. They damage the natural environment and take up vast spatial areas. There are far better alternatives.
  33. Mr. Andreas Marciniak 1 Apr 2015
    " It's always about the almighty Dollar $$$$$$$$$$$$..The fact is ! There is no safe distance for wind Turbines, NOT GREEN, NOT CHEAP, NOT RELIABLE, and come with a very BAD side EFFECT on people and the ENVIRONMENT. there is Nothing GREEN about WIND TURBINES . SAY NO TO WIND TURBINES.
  34. Eddie Freeman 1 Apr 2015
    Sacrificing our natural heritage for multi-national company profits. They don't care, we have to.
  35. David Baird 1 Apr 2015
    Complete and utter madness. Why is the Scottish Government letting this happen?
  36. Chris Park 1 Apr 2015
    I have no words.
  37. Lorna Potter 1 Apr 2015
    I've found a place I can call home, where I feel safe, where I feel my children are safe. Glen Convinth is only a few miles from Loch Ness and was a proposed site for a huge wind farm. Turbines are NOT the only green energy, money would be better spent on Solar Panels on Council Properties and Homes, not only would this help the environment but it would help families suffering from fuel poverty. Hydro Dams, we've got plenty of water and I know there's lots of people flock to Aigas each year to take pictures.
  38. Mhari Drozdowska 1 Apr 2015
    Out of date, not economical! Disgusting, depressing horrible giants, bad for environment, and health!! Completely destroy natural beauty. Think it is absolutely ridicules to even consider putting any windmills near Loch Ness, which is massively well known!! It's silly to put wind farms up any where!!
  39. Maureen Wallace 1 Apr 2015
    It's not just the visual impact of hundreds of turbines it's not fully understood the impact that construction of the turbines, the access routes and supply to the national grid make on the land. Due to the climate land does not recover for years you only need to look at any fire damage to the hillsides to see how long it takes. Turbines in their construction are not GREEN.
  40. Louise Evans 1 Apr 2015
    Please stop the destruction of our outstanding landscape and prescious environment!!
  41. Andrew Shiells 1 Apr 2015
    This plan is a disgrace. You would think the SNP by it's very name would protect Scotland, it's heritage and countryside. Not a bit of it. they're not in any way "green"
    - apart from behind their ears!
  42. Hector M Rogers 1 Apr 2015
    The planet has been warming and cooling with ever changing climates throughout its existence (Green Planet C U P 1982) and will continue to do so whatever we humans do. There are other forms of less visually intrusive and more efficient renewable and green energy to which the resources currently directed to wind should be re-allocated e.g. wave, tidal and hydro and pusued energetically. There is also, so I understand, a widely available mineral (Thorium?) which is capable of producing non-toxic nuclear energy which is NOT suitable for weapons
    - hooray! This too shoud be investigated urgently.
    Scotland's wild country and eco-systems is its 'Golden Egg' which should not be prostituted for political or economic ideals.
  43. J A Raper 1 Apr 2015
    If you wish to prosper don't destroy your assets
  44. John Scott 1 Apr 2015
    It's a source of embarassment to me whenever I have friends from abroad whom I take up north for a few days to enjoy the beautiful Scottish scenery. What must they think about us when they see us wantonly vandalising our unique landscape in the name of money. Because that's what it's really about. Shame on our politicians and industrial leaders who have let this happen!
  45. Fiona Gibbons 1 Apr 2015
    What are they thinking of?
  46. Catherine Bayne 1 Apr 2015
    Industrial Wind developments are a manifestation of UN Agenda21 wealth transfer which are unsustainable without subsidies and have no place in a sane energy system.

    Industrial Wind Turbines are environmentally, socially and economically destructive and are monuments to greed and gullibility.
  47. Demagny Joel 1 Apr 2015
    L'éolien industriel est une arnaque
    L'écologie de l'éolien est une arnaque

    Industrial wind power is a scam
    The ecology of the wind is a scam
  48. Hilary Burdett 1 Apr 2015
    This absolute desicration of such a beautiful area & must be stopped now
  49. Jane Fraser 1 Apr 2015
    With strong family ties in this area of Scotland the on-going plans for more and more wind turbines are very alarming.
    I am a strong supporter of renewable energy but these turbines simply aren't fit for purpose. The technology is expensive and ineffective
    - our reliance on fossil fuels is not reduced in any way by the proliferation of turbines and the landscape (& the tourist industry) is seriously harmed by this creeping industrialisation.
  50. Roger Stroud 1 Apr 2015
    When is this madness going to stop? RIP Scottish scenery.It's not green
    - just GREED.