Petition · PE01564 · Session 4
Save Loch Ness and the Great Glen
Signatures
1
Comments
521
Considered
3 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take steps to designate the Loch Ness and Great Glen as a National Scenic Area; to recommend a priority application is made to UNESCO for the area to be afforded World Heritage protection; and to take appropriate steps to discourage further wind turbine developments and support the restoration of sites damaged by wind turbines.
What the petitioner did first
1. Letters of comment and opposition on an individual basis by Friends of the Great Glen on planning applications in the Great Glen through the Highland Council planning system, for example on Beinn Mhor, Invermoriston, Bhlaraidh, Stronelairg, and the extension to the Millenium Wind Farm. These applications have been recommended for approval, despite considerable public objections, for example over 1200 in the case of Beinn Mhor.
2. Correspondence with local MSP on wind farm developments in the Great Glen.
3. A complaint was lodged with the Highland Council on the visual impact of the Millenium Wind Farm and this was later referred to the planning process (the planning application is still active).
4. Letter to the SNH Chair asking for more active defence of wild land and internationally acclaimed landscape sites in the Great Glen and specifically Stronelairg.
2. Correspondence with local MSP on wind farm developments in the Great Glen.
3. A complaint was lodged with the Highland Council on the visual impact of the Millenium Wind Farm and this was later referred to the planning process (the planning application is still active).
4. Letter to the SNH Chair asking for more active defence of wild land and internationally acclaimed landscape sites in the Great Glen and specifically Stronelairg.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
26 May 20151 mention
-
22 Sep 20151 mention
-
14 Sep 20171 mention
Signatures by country
3,097 online signaturesComments
521 comments, oldest first521 comments · showing 51–100
-
James Brewster 23 Mar 2015There are far greener ways to generate electricity than blight our landscapes with turbines. A new wave of highland clearances and a life changing impact on all residence of the proposed scheme's surrounding area.
-
Catherine Nolan 23 Mar 2015What are you thinking? How can you even consider spoiling such a unique and world renowned location with wind turbines. They are so ugly!
-
steve darling 23 Mar 2015Please set a precedent and stop this tsunami of wind turbines now. We have enough, we want NO MORE HERE. The potential impact on scottish tourism and environment will be devastating. Please make it significantly harder and less financially attractive for these carbuncles to be dumped on the beautiful highlands, before we can no longer call it BONNIE SCOTLAND
-
Brian Gregson 23 Mar 2015When will people learn that windfarms are neither green nor sustainable and that the only reason they are being built at all is to attract government subsidies.
-
Ian mure 23 Mar 2015If this proliferation of windfarms continues the cost to the population at large through the levy on household invoice will soon become intolerable. Add in the cost of lost tourist trade to the local economy and you create an impact from which the economy will not recover from for a very long time. Tourism has had a very large beneficial impact within the Loch Ness area which should not be economically challenged otherwise the cost of social care could rise substantially.
-
wilma whelton 23 Mar 2015Tourists who come to see our landscape will be disappointed when they see it has been industrialised. I grew up in Lanarkshire where the landscape was blighted with the residue of coal mining
- "bings" of waste. In 25 years when the subsidies no longer apply will the Highlands be littered with lumps of decaying concrete and steel? -
Simon John Kirkpatrick 23 Mar 2015I was born a Scot and visit several times a year, this desecration of one of Europe's last great wildernesses is criminal and must cease.
-
Kim Polley 23 Mar 2015Please don't destroy this piece of heaven for our children and grandchildren. We regularly fly over 21 hours, like many other Australians, to the Scottish Highlands to solely experience this special area. Its natural and built heritage as well as unique flora and fauna are precious and must not be compromised.
-
Fiona Brown 23 Mar 2015I am so so ashamed to have been one of a population who has allowed our wonderful beautiful country to become so desecrated
- I feel so helpless, and apart from signing petitions I don't know what else to do to stop a few powerful, money-grabbing people from abusing their power and over-riding the wishes of so many dedicated people who love this country. -
Lizzie Stewart 23 Mar 2015Compare the long term impact on Tourism income in Scotland to the wind turbine income
- why is this even being considered ? -
Ian Richards 23 Mar 2015Wind farms have a place in any well considered energy mix. What we face now is the industrialisation of our greatest natural asset, Scotland's unique landscape. The prostitution of our heritage by profiteering landowners and windfarm operators is shameful.
-
angelika smith 23 Mar 2015There is not one redeeming feature when it comes to wind turbines! They are a health hazard, they spoil the countryside, they kill birds and bats and they don't even generate enough electricity to make them economical viable. Nor do they save any CO2! It is a scam where only developers and landowners benefit from the subsidies!
-
Joan Holt 23 Mar 2015YOU CANNOT DESTROY TOMICH OR THE GLEN AFFRIC THIS IS DISGRACEFUL. ONCE GONE
ITS GONE FOREVER.THE MOST UNSPOILT PRESERVED BEAUTY AND YOU WANT TO DESTROY IT UNBELIEVABLE IGNORANCE. -
Susan Chisholm 23 Mar 2015As a frequent visitor to the Highland Region with family in the area I am very against further such development. Wind turbines apart from being of dubious value from and energy production point of view are detrimental to this most beautiful landscape and have been shown to damage wild life and in particular bird life. This area also relies on overseas visitors and tourists to boost the economy, how can it make sense to damage the very thing people want to come and see and enjoy.
-
matt smith 23 Mar 2015Wind turbines have their place and can actually enhance some landscapes. They are a useful part of the generation mix. However, I believe that wild areas that tourists come to appreciate are adversely impacted and thus so is the visitor experience. The cost and impact of build, especially if habitat such as peat bog is destroyed, has to be part of the equation, along with opportunity costs of reduced natural beauty.
-
Eric Gilroy 23 Mar 2015The desecration of wild land must cease, these infernal turbines are barely producing 40% of their rated output.
-
Mike Rogers 23 Mar 2015Windfarms are inefficient.
-
Mairi Fraser 23 Mar 2015Loch Ness and the Great Glen should and needs to be a protected area now and for future generations.
-
Pamela Soper 24 Mar 2015It is crucial to preserve parts of Scotland, that will enable local people and industries to build on what is already a substantial tourist industry. Governments must look at alternative "green" energy sources that do not have such a direct impact on the landscape. Windpower is not as "Green" as we all are led to believe, and most certainly does not bring the wealth to the lcoal communities that is sometimes promised.
-
Mark Pilbeam 24 Mar 2015there are places and times for wind farms but not at the expense of wild life, countryside, local people, visitors and beautiful panoramas that will be forever lost !
-
Peter Smith 24 Mar 2015Enough is enough. Stop the industrialization of our hills and glens.
-
Mark Hodgson 24 Mar 2015From south of the border, and as an Anglo-Scot who loves Scotland, the policy of the Scottish Government in basing its revenue-stream on the income from North Sea Oil whilst blighting the irreplaceable beauty of its incomparable countryside with useless and expensive wind turbines in the name of reducing carbon emissions, seems to combine stupidity and hypocrisy in equal measure.
-
Graham Hannah 24 Mar 2015I am absolutely passionate about preventing the proliferation of industrial windfarms in wild places in Scotland. Wild land where no sign of man can be seen or heard is a very special resource. Quiet places where people can go and recharge the batteries of their soul.
-
Brian A Bell 24 Mar 2015Let this government prove we live in a democratic society by holding a referendum on SNP energy policy. With Longannet closing down and windmills which provide a pitiful and insignificant quantity of power it can only be a matter of time before we suffer blackouts.
-
Lynda Hodgson 24 Mar 2015Picture the scene: an early 19th century Highland crofting family driven from their home and livelihood by the greed of a rapacious landowner blanketing the landscape with sheep.
Fast forward to the 21st century. Highland residents' lives blighted by the greed of rapacious landowners shrouding the landscape with wind turbines.
A stark parallel.
But worse! Not only lives destroyed, but also the destruction of the environment. Look to your history and weep. -
sorcha ni aoidhe 24 Mar 2015Please SAVE
-
Andrew Walker 24 Mar 2015Industrial scale wind farms are the all too visible manifestation of a failed energy policy. Firstly, the public has been sold the idea that wind farms are crucial in the fight against climate change: this is not true because the amounts of CO2 saved are utterly insignificant in comparison with global emissions. Secondly, the planned closure of current coal and nuclear generation will mean that Scotland will need to import electricity from the rest of the UK in order to meet demand at times of low renewables generation, as predicted by the Scottish Government's own Expert Commission on Energy Regulation (July 2014). Thirdly, Scotland's tourism industry will be progressively eroded as residents and visitors vote with their feet and go elsewhere, appalled at the desecration of Scotland's beautiful landscapes. Fourthly, the environmental consequences include the loss of peatland, and the death of rare birds and bats.
-
Irene Smith 24 Mar 2015The existing planning system is biased towards the Scottish Government's policy of sustainable renewable energy
- in effect, the opinions and wishes of those who submit their objections to wind farms are effectively being ignored, while greedy and unscrupulous developers and land owners happily trouser the huge grants available, paid indirectly by the population through inflated electricity bills. It seems like the Highland Clearances once more, with greedy landowners, riding roughshod over the needs and wishes of the people. This situation is quite shocking in a so- called democratic society, -
Audrey Litterick 24 Mar 2015I cannot believe what the Scottish Government is allowing to happen! Loch Ness is one of our most loved, most famous and greatest assets. People come to look at it because it and its surroundings are beautiful. The area is fast being destroyed and once the people stop coming to visit, they will not return. I and others like me have already abandoned parts of the Southern Uplands for holidays because they are an industrialised mess of turbines. Do not further destroy our highlands in the name of renewable energy generation (I won't start on the environmental sense, or lack of it of that). For heavens sake, no more turbines around Loch Ness
- PLEASE. -
Andrew Hamilton 24 Mar 2015Scotland is going to import more and more electricity because of wind farms. Our Government needs to start doing their jobs and ensure we have a proper power supply.
-
heather maxine barclay 25 Mar 2015Bring back democracy
-
GLYNNE GIANELLI 25 Mar 2015Loch Ness is Scotland. It must not be desecrated.
-
jo chapman campbell 25 Mar 2015this madness of destruction must be stopped
- we are ruining the planet, not saving it. -
STYLIANI AILAMAKI 25 Mar 2015I support your fight against the huge turbines in nature with high interesting.It is happening the same in Crete in Greece where the virgin and unspoilt environment gives a huge income through the tourism .
-
Andrew Redden 25 Mar 2015I live in an area with a lot of wind Turbines. They are ugly, noisy and obtrusive spoiling the views in all directions. They do not benefit local employment. The only financial benefit is to the local landowner. One nuclear power staion could probably replace every existing and planned turbine. Prepare to be overuled by the government unless hundreds and hundreds of thousands sign the petition. Sign now.
-
Roy Milne 25 Mar 2015Loch Ness and the Great Glen are vital to our tourist industry on which so many people depend. Huge arrays of windmills will do nothing to attract tourists but will almost certainly do plenty to repel them. How can our Scottish Government be so thoughtless and obstinate, not to mention stupid?
-
Ragnar Reutz Haakenstad 26 Mar 2015This is madness!! Visit Loch Ness many years ago and it is just one thing to say about windturbines around Loch Ness. We fight against windturbines in Norway, too!
-
Fiona MacAllister 26 Mar 2015One of the most stunning area of scenery, i work in a hotel highly dependant on the Tourism industry.
-
margery watson 26 Mar 2015Every time I cross the border I feel as thought there should be a sign saying welcome to Scotland home of the windfarms!!!!!!!
-
John Robertson 26 Mar 2015This desecration of our beautiful countryside has to stop. Generations yet to come will blame us for allowing the SNP to destroy our heritage and we need to do all we can to bring them to their senses.
-
Claire Armstrong 26 Mar 2015Tourism is a main income for Scotland. Destroying all the Countryside, our views, & our enjoyment with 22 tons of concrete under each turbine plus the road scars littered all over the hills now is uneconomic & makes all Authorities involved Unfit for Purpose. So as a minimum ensure TOTAL protection for the entire Loch Ness areas from these horrendous & massive contraptions!! :-(
-
Iain Fincham 26 Mar 2015Why do these companies insist on destroying our landscapes with these revolving monstrosities ???
-
Anthony Ernest Wilson 26 Mar 2015Loch Ness and the Great Glen are an extremely important tourist site and the landscape around it should not be blighted by Windfarms.If the building of windfarms continue there soon will be nowhere in Scotland that will be free of the sight of windfarms. It will have a great adverse effect on tourism which is important to the local economy .It will also have health effects for people living near them.
-
K Gallagher 26 Mar 2015Tourists don't come to the Great Glen to see wind turbines, and residents are demonstrably none too keen to build or inhabit homes anywhere near them. Too many of our wild and beautiful places are already littered with these white elephants, so beloved of businesses for the massive public subsidies and faux green credentials they offer. I'm sick of wasteful, symbolic, public spending simply enriching corporate investors in lieu of a coherent energy policy. Turbines are all too visible reminders of scientifically illiterate politicians' pretence at saving the planet. Politicians who take wind developers' sales pitch at face value and make no attempt to determine the truth of the claims that they decarbonise energy production, or make significant contributions to local economies. Likewise they ignore any health detriment attributable to turbines. Holyrood or Westminster, 'left' or 'right', they're all in lust with marketization and eager to indulge tax dodging corporates. They're happy to construct their own alterative reality bubble, where evidence based policy doesn't get a look in, when people's votes can be more easily won with misdirection, panic spreading rhetoric, and irrelevant, unworkable, or counterproductive 'solutions'. And a supine media offers nothing much in the way of critique. Enough, already.
-
John Radford 26 Mar 2015Enough is enough , no more wind turbines required in Scotland
-
Alison Petrie 26 Mar 2015Please stop these turbines! We are battling at least 5 developments here! It's exhausting and makes trust difficult! Stop
-
Andrew Finnimore 26 Mar 2015Windfarm proposals in the Scottish Highlands are threatening to ruin one of the most beautiful areas of wild country in Western Europe.
-
Elizabeth darby 26 Mar 2015Enough is enough. We are surrounded by turbines here. No more needed..There are 1000 more in Planning process. Say NO to any more.
-
Ian Cotterill 26 Mar 2015We are in danger of losing Scotland's wild land and the economic benefits and employment that we get from tourism. The decimation of our wonderful wild land must be stopped before it's too late.
-
Miriam Raftery 27 Mar 2015Wind turbines are horrible
- they have despoiled many areas here with visual blight, noise, flashing lights and infrasound
- don't despoil this famous and beautiful wild place I always wanted to go to Scotland but would scratch if off my list if they build these.