Petition · PE01564 · Session 4
Save Loch Ness and the Great Glen
Signatures
1
Comments
521
Considered
3 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take steps to designate the Loch Ness and Great Glen as a National Scenic Area; to recommend a priority application is made to UNESCO for the area to be afforded World Heritage protection; and to take appropriate steps to discourage further wind turbine developments and support the restoration of sites damaged by wind turbines.
What the petitioner did first
1. Letters of comment and opposition on an individual basis by Friends of the Great Glen on planning applications in the Great Glen through the Highland Council planning system, for example on Beinn Mhor, Invermoriston, Bhlaraidh, Stronelairg, and the extension to the Millenium Wind Farm. These applications have been recommended for approval, despite considerable public objections, for example over 1200 in the case of Beinn Mhor.
2. Correspondence with local MSP on wind farm developments in the Great Glen.
3. A complaint was lodged with the Highland Council on the visual impact of the Millenium Wind Farm and this was later referred to the planning process (the planning application is still active).
4. Letter to the SNH Chair asking for more active defence of wild land and internationally acclaimed landscape sites in the Great Glen and specifically Stronelairg.
2. Correspondence with local MSP on wind farm developments in the Great Glen.
3. A complaint was lodged with the Highland Council on the visual impact of the Millenium Wind Farm and this was later referred to the planning process (the planning application is still active).
4. Letter to the SNH Chair asking for more active defence of wild land and internationally acclaimed landscape sites in the Great Glen and specifically Stronelairg.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
26 May 20151 mention
-
22 Sep 20151 mention
-
14 Sep 20171 mention
Signatures by country
3,097 online signaturesComments
521 comments, oldest first521 comments · showing 301–350
-
Louise Clapham 7 Apr 2015More and more of our wild and beautiful places are being industrialised to the detriment of wildlife and people who love those wild places. This area is iconic, time to stop the industrialisation.
-
Duncan Tannahill 7 Apr 2015Yet again an iconic area of Scotland is being threatened with industrial vandalism to produce very high cost power. When will the government in Edinburgh ever learn and bring in legislation to protect our countryside in a fit and proper way?
-
Angus Thomson 7 Apr 2015This is a ridiculous scheme in a terribly sited situation.
-
Ted Venn 7 Apr 2015Wind farms are already destroying the natural beauty of the countryside, negatively affecting other businesses and threatening Scotland's tourist industry, and at the same time only survive on subsidies whilst working intermittently and generating about 30% of their maximum capacity.
-
KLEIN Denis from FRANCE 7 Apr 2015Scotland is known for her wild nature, amazing landscapes...how can we imagine the loch ness with wind turbines ...It'll be a disaster .
Denis KLEIN -
Eric Macdonald 7 Apr 2015I think that this will destroy what is a beautiful part of Scotland,that I know very well.I may live in Aberdeenshire now but I belong to Invergordon and proud of it.
-
Yvonne McWhirr 7 Apr 2015There's a place for renewable energy and wind power, but the last few years have seen unprecedented developments that are now becoming a serious blight on our beautiful landscape. Iconic views such as Loch Ness, where I grew up, must be protected from such industrialisation. Beside which, when you look at the facts with wind turbines, they may be renewable, but their green credentials lack in so many other ways. I fear the SNP will disregard public opinion in order to achieve targets and convenient soundbites. Playing politics. Not governing our country.
-
Antony Eldridge 7 Apr 2015I bought a house in this area for the views and the general wildness of the environment. Please stop this industrialisation and communicate a clear message that the Scottish Highlands have been damaged enough.
-
Rachel Burgess 7 Apr 2015I think everyone is agreed that renewables are a good idea but if they destroy what they have set out to preserve then they are a false economy. We all NEED wild places to escape to in this fast and furious world
- what are we leaving for our children and grand children if we turn these glorious places in to industrial landscapes? -
Michel CAMUS 7 Apr 2015Worse than DAESCH in Mossoul !
-
Willie Forbes 7 Apr 2015It is shameful that this destruction and massive industrialisation of our God given, world class scenery should be allowed in our beautiful land. The Loch Ness area is paying a heavy price for being outwith an arbitrarily designated area called a national park. Anything goes as far as development in our area is concerned.Our politicians have sold our birthright in the delusion that we are saving our environment. WAKE UP SCOTLAND, ONSHORE WINDFARMS ARE A MASSIVE CON! These ugly turbines are not saving our environment, they are destroying it! They are grossly inefficient. I have watched the turbines at the Farr Windfarm stand still for the entire months of January and February in 2010
- thereby producing NO electricity whatsoever for that entire period. The only beneficiaries are the already very wealthy absentee landlords and remote multinational corporations. These companies are even paid tens of millions of pounds to NOT produce electricity. How completely stupid. And who is paying the massive subsidies to these landowners and corporations
- you and me through our inflated electricity bills. The poor widow on the 14th floor, the single parent struggling to make ends meet, the family breadwinner on a minimum wage and zero hours contract
- all are contributing towards the increased wealth of these fat cat landowners and corporations. Only a nation of fools would allow such valuable, world-class scenery to be destroyed in this way
- and that is what we have become. But no more
- this deception, this destruction has to stop. When I look up to the hills I once loved I no longer feel pride, I feel shame. And it is a legacy of destruction of our precious landscape that we are passing on to future generations who will one day ask why the previous generation acted so carelessly, greedily and irresponsibly with our irreplaceable landscape. -
Christine Wallace 7 Apr 2015Sincerely hope something will result from action as we will otherwise lose our wild spaces.
-
Leslie Starks 7 Apr 2015Ugly on a massive scale, kills avian life, makes wildlife and people sick, impotent energy. Wind turbines are the international insignia of greed, political corruption and propaganda
-
Rosamund Devonshire 7 Apr 2015The point is:
This ecological lie shouldn't be going on anywhere in the world -
Valerie SVG 7 Apr 2015Loch Ness is beautiful as it is. Let's not spoil it with Wind Turbines.
-
Rachel Witt 7 Apr 2015i have visited the area on many occasions and also have family living in the area. I just cannot believe that these turbines would be allowed to blight such beautiful historic scenery.
-
Ken Crocket 7 Apr 2015it's not too late to save the Scottish landscape here.
-
John Richmond 7 Apr 2015I'm not going back to south west Spain because there are so many wind turbines there.
-
Chris Ward 7 Apr 2015The systematic deranged vandalisation of Scotland's greatest asset
- it's scenery
- with this wind farm obsession, must cease. -
Michel Gaudry 7 Apr 2015stop the stupid Policy for energy developed Under the pressure of
"green party" ... -
Violet, Tandragee 7 Apr 2015Please stop destroying your beautiful country with these unhealthy, uneconomical, unwanted turbines.
-
Phyllis cooper 7 Apr 2015This is a beautiful and important area, and should be left alone. The birds and wildlife would suffer.
-
Robert Gehr 7 Apr 2015As a descendant of clan Gregor I feel a connection to Scotland, even though I live in the United States and sadly have never visited your great country.
I am related to the great Robert MacGregor and must submit this 'signed' document in the hope of preserving the wild lands for current and future generations.
It is what Robert would have done...
Good luck! -
Catherine Williams 7 Apr 2015Please don't damage natural habitats and beauty
-
Steve Dickison. 8 Apr 2015Wind energy has already been proven to be an enormously costly failure. Why continue the destruction of the Scottish wilderness for no purpose other than to make a few people outrageously wealthy. This nonsense needs to stop now!
-
John Fitzgerald 8 Apr 2015It's time the ruling bodies got some sense of what they will lose if this continues. Don't think of "now" think of the future
-
Graham Milton 8 Apr 2015Don't allow destruction of our beautiful lsndscape.
-
Roslyn Turp 8 Apr 2015Too much of our beautiful landscape is already blighted by such monstrosities. If we cannot protect our iconic Loch Ness I will despair.
-
Shona Mackie 8 Apr 2015This is a beautiful area with low power demand, why not generate more power closer to the big cities where it's needed? A lot of them are close to the coast where we know that wind power generation is more effective. Or an even better idea, why don't we all just start using less?
-
Adrian Lewis 8 Apr 2015The wind industry exists only because of the largely unwitting subsidy from the public, who have been brainwashed into believing in climate catastrophe, for which there is no evidence. Despite rising CO2, there has been no global warming for over 18 years, global sea ice is the same as 30 years ago, and sea level is rising at about 1.7mm per yr, just as it has for the last century. Man-made global warming is a scam.
-
Andrew Thomson 8 Apr 2015Why oh why despoil such a lovely place? My USA friends cannot believe it, especially as many wind farms in the US are now derelict and no-one takes responsibility for removing them. Utter folly.
-
Ray Morrison 8 Apr 2015When it is gone, it is gone, what will our future generations think of us?
-
Bill Budge 8 Apr 2015It really is time we take a stand against the crass stupdity of installing these structures in our beautiful country which is tantamount to vandalism.
Under the auspices of so called 'green energy" all that is occurring only because of massive subsidies.
Enough is enough .. no more wind farms -
Matthew Smith 8 Apr 2015Wind Turbines have their place in a mixed generation portfolio, and can even enliven some areas. However, the Highlands are famed for their natural beauty and attract tourists from around the world because of this. We risk adversely affecting the economy. I believe hydro and tidal offer better 'base load' energy generation prospects.
-
Sandra Little 8 Apr 2015The citizens of Ocotillo, California, had no chance to stop the corrupt bureaucrats with their ridiculous wind farm plans. Sure enough, the unique and beautiful desert fell victim to this project! Big profit hungry corporations hide behind their "Green Power" mantra, licking their fingers cunningly as they receive subsidies. It's criminal how pristine landscapes, its vegetation and animals are getting destroyed in the name of "clean" energy! Fight for Loch Ness and the Great Glen, good people of Scotland! I sincerely hope you'll be able to save your national treasure from this madness!
-
Linda Ross 8 Apr 2015Wind farms on this scale are no longer environmental ly friendly.
Leave the Loch Ness area alone. -
Wolf Doleys 8 Apr 2015Real monsters instead of Nessie? Incredible barbarism!
-
Susan E Dudley 8 Apr 2015Do not destroy this beautiful landscape any further with the folly that is industrial wind. It will turn out to be the biggest scam of the 21st century.
-
Jonathan Howell 8 Apr 2015If allowed to happen this will be destruction and pollution of a precious landscape on a monumental scale. There are far more efficient and controllable forms of electricity generation. This is the will of Scottish leaders and not of Westminster. Is Scotland prepared to suffer anything at any price to enable their leaders to prise Scotland away from the United Kingdom?
-
Vivienne Kelly-Keane 8 Apr 2015If you proceed with this you will go down in history as having destroyed your country for lousy money because wind turbines have been proven over and over again as being ineffectual, subsidy-grabbing monuments to greed and stupidity.
Your country is your soul and you are willing to sell it forever to carpetbaggers.
Shame on you! -
Susan Jenkins, Nanny 8 Apr 2015This is very wrong for environmental reasons.no fracking no windmills.
-
robert m roberts 8 Apr 2015do not ruin beautiful views because you can!
-
Ruth Reynolds (nee Cameron) 8 Apr 2015This is a part of the world where many of us have roots. We planned on coming back to tour. Won't bring our tourist dollars to an industrial wind wasteland. We know it does not really save carbon since the power is not generated as needed and those profiting from the taxpayers are doing so only for money.
-
Calum Mackinnon 9 Apr 2015Is No place sacred enough to say No to turbines,
Leave Loch Ness alone n find somewhere else mor suitable...... -
Allan Macdougall 9 Apr 2015This is not about 'saving the planet' or 'reducing CO2 emissions'
- it IS about bloated, madcap subsidies paid to those who least deserve to receive them.
If all factors are taken into account, such as peat disturbance and the need to keep fossil fuels burning in power stations on tickover to cover for windless (or over-windy) days, then a carbon audit would reveal that more CO2 is emitted than saved during the turbine's 25 year life. This is the most outrageous form of destruction and vandalism I have ever seen committed on Scottish soil. It needs to stop
- right now. -
Miss Victoria Howell 9 Apr 2015When it's gone it's gone!
-
B Griffiths 9 Apr 2015yet another part of the country that will be ruined if they go ahead with this. Is no-where safe from this madness?
-
Stuart Murdoch 9 Apr 2015I'm all for developing green energy but these monstrosities have proven to be inefficient, short-lived and expensive and, in the meantime, they're ruining our landscape, causing health issues, devaluing properties and ruining our tourism industry.This march across our country must be stopped.
-
john bamkin 9 Apr 2015Wind farms will not provide the solution to our energy needs. What they will do is provide huge profits for the manufacturers and line the pockets of landowners with no respect for the environment.
-
Captain Alex Gibbons 9 Apr 2015Its disgusting to read that many of our Beautiful British Iconic landscapes and coastlines are going to ruined by these eye sores . Please think again before they are gone forever.