Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01537 · Session 4

Proposed Energy Park at Cockenzie

Closed Submitted 9 Oct 2014 Environment & Energy
Signatures
1
2,571 online signatures with a country
Comments
212
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to abandon the proposal for the development of an Energy Park at Cockenzie, and ensure that any future proposals are subject to full public consultation and do not extend beyond the existing footprint of the former power station.

What the petitioner did first

Letters to Iain Gray, East Lothian MSP: Iain Gray MSP contacted and raised community concerns with Cabinet Secretary For Finance, Employment and Substainable Growth, John Swinney MSP
Letters to all ELC East Lothian Ward councillors bordering the proposed development: contacted by letter expressing deep community concerns” Out of 12 only 4 replied
Petition to East Lothian Council: rejected because “what is being sought is not within the power of East Lothian Council. The proposals are in the hands of Scottish Enterprise, Scottish Power and others”;
Meeting with Scottish Enterprise: unsuccessful as SE continue to drive forward with planned development regardless of community concerns expressed. SE also told us no discussions had taken place with Scottish Power, yet it is reported that all land belongs to Scottish Power;
Meeting with Inch Cape: informative but ultimately unsuccessful;
Meeting with Iain Gray MSP: Iain Gray, MSP sympathises with communities and their concern and opposes development, but powerless to stop it;
Community meetings: Community meetings have been held since July 2014 with numbers growing from 25 at first meeting to over 800 members of the community at most recent meeting in September and more than 4000 local signatures on petition supporting our community concerns;
Attendance at ELC Planning Committee meeting on Inch Cape (September 2014): CRA spoke to ask for a 2 month deferment of judgement on the battlesite development on local countryside land to enable CRA to seek a meeting with Scottish Power to establish why land currently unused on existing energy footprint at Cockenzie could not accommodate Inch Cape. Request unsuccessful;
Efforts to secure meeting with Scottish Power: SP Generation Director finally responding by email but refusing to meet whilst consideration to commercial approaches and options for the site being considered. Scottish Network planned to meet but cancelled meeting because "Scottish Generation dealing with matter". A meeting with SP has since been scheduled for late October 2014;
Contact with office of David Martin MEP to discuss proposals;
Public consultations: Vision gathering sessions held by Coastal Regeneration Alliance to enable the community to put forward their vision of the areas in question;
Press Releases issued weekly to local & national newspapers with support from press for the community;
Analysing petition signatures to demonstrate local feeling to community councils & secure Community Councils support for community action;
Contact & support from organisations linked to Battle Of Prestonpans;
Contact & advice from Greenpeace, Marine Conservation Society and Marinet of the dramatic effects of coastal dredging of the proposed deep water site and effects of local East Lothian beaches and also proposed Underground Coal Gasification drilling near our coastline;
Poems, songs & video presentations created to demonstrate extent of community concern and the positive & peaceful actions taken to voice this concern into public domain;
Pop-up stalls held weekly in local communities to provide information, petition and letter signing opportunities for those who are concerned and without online access;
Bumper stickers & #keepourcoast T-shirts produced & widely available locally;
Leaflets produced & delivered to premises immediately bordering proposed site initially, and now wider East Lothian county.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 9 Dec 2014
    1 mention
  2. 3 Mar 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 28 Apr 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 23 Jun 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,571 online signatures
  1. Scotland2,116 82.3%
  2. United Kingdom319 12.4%
  3. England80 3.1%
  4. New Zealand10 0.4%
  5. United States9 0.4%
  6. Australia8 0.3%
  7. Canada5 0.2%
  8. Northern Ireland4 0.2%
  9. Wales4 0.2%
  10. Germany3 0.1%
  11. 9 other countries13 0.5%

Comments

212 comments, oldest first
212 comments · showing 151–200
  1. Kenneth Donald 26 Oct 2014
    Nothing against renewable energy but not to the detriment of local communities in any way.
  2. Suzanna Marchant 26 Oct 2014
    24-hour operation is just wrong for the locals
  3. Gillian McLean 26 Oct 2014
    I am very much pro-renewables but this proposal is madness and in completely the wrong place.
  4. Diane McLeod 26 Oct 2014
    proposed plan should be within existing Cockenzie Power Station footprint.
  5. Matthew Nicholas 26 Oct 2014
    We need a much smaller proposal within the existing site footprint which doesn't destroy the 3 Harbours community and open land and threaten our coastline and beaches.
  6. Fiona lind 26 Oct 2014
    The coastline should be preserved and the views of the local community taken into account.
  7. Keith Kirby 26 Oct 2014
    Please do not build this facility in Cockenzie, thank you.
  8. Ann Paterson 26 Oct 2014
    The Energy Park plans will have a devastating effect on the local area and will effect property prices, local trade and the environment. The relocation of the coast road is unacceptable and the land should remain accessible to the public.
  9. Margaret Lynch 26 Oct 2014
    It is very important for this area to give great consideration to your proposals. This is an opportunity to improve the coastal area for East Loathian and particularly for Port Seton and Cockenzie. Richard Demarco's suggestion seems very exciting. The Tate of the North!! Scrape the Energy Park and think BIG
  10. Robert marr 26 Oct 2014
    To much heavy traffic , not happy about the closing of the coast road.
  11. Kevin Eeles 26 Oct 2014
    Closing the link road between the communities would be a disgrace. Stop this madness
  12. Sylvia Bennett 27 Oct 2014
    There is so much of our countryside being destroyed by ugly housing and wind farms to build on this coastline would be a travisty
  13. Marion Robertson 27 Oct 2014
    The overall benefits to the communities haven't been taken in to consideration at all. Only the benefits to the developers. The waste to this coastline is an absolute disgrace.
  14. Florence archibald 27 Oct 2014
    I agree that this energy Park proposed for Cockenzie and surrounding area should be abandoned.
    The power station has blighted the area of Cockenzie for 50 years and we deserve to have our Garden County to mean that. This proposal is horrendous.
  15. frank hamilton 27 Oct 2014
    this development is massive and will affect a huge area and numbers of people. smaller developments would be far more in keeping and be in keeping with the area.
  16. kevin rodgers 27 Oct 2014
    please keep our green hills green and do mess up our lovely village
  17. linda Sneddon 27 Oct 2014
    East Lothian is under threat from development. It won't be long until it becomes indistinguishable as a county, and merely a suburb of Edinburgh. It's time to stop and consider what we are losing
    - BEFORE its gone.
  18. Steve and Cathy Rowe 28 Oct 2014
    A marina and tourist craft scheme would be much better suited to this location. The protection of the wildlife, and the wider amenity, along with the benifits to the local communities would be much better suited to this coastline. Thank you.
  19. Gavin Lawson 29 Oct 2014
    The John Muir Way is a national treasure located in East Lothian, it must be valued and protected.
  20. george paterson 29 Oct 2014
    As an architect I have a reasonable appreciation of how planning applications are made and granted. I for one do not care about how much planning gain a developer wishes to contribute to the area! We are very happy with the satus quo. No change thanks.
  21. Michael Duff 29 Oct 2014
    out businesses are under threat also if the link road between prestonpans and port seton is closed, no passing trade can affect us all
  22. Dorathea Hiscocks 29 Oct 2014
    When I came to Cockenzie 20 years ago they named
    it "God's Little green acre". If the Energy Park is completed this most certainly will not be true.
  23. Karen Taylor 29 Oct 2014
    dredging would have a negative effect on the fishing industry
  24. Mrs G M A York 29 Oct 2014
    The public must be fully consulted over this proposal
  25. Michael keenan 30 Oct 2014
    These password are very very difficult to read and discourage people from online signing
  26. Michael Keenan 30 Oct 2014
    It has taken many years to make this area very popular both for residents and visitors, and this outrageous destructive scheme will nullify all that immediately. Can't see Seton Sands Park remaining so popular
  27. Marlyn Minto 30 Oct 2014
    Given Longniddry residents are resisting the housing development on agricultural land beside Longniddry station why not switch that to the power station site at Cockenzie and add in leisure and sports facilities. This would surely appeal to both villages
  28. kathleen bain 31 Oct 2014
    destruction of historical site, NO
    light, traffic noise pollution
  29. Valerie Forbes 31 Oct 2014
    The development of this site along the lines proposed would be disastrous for this area that is so important historically and ecologically. It would nullify the hard work that has gone into attracting residents and visitors to the area.
  30. Christine Nolan 31 Oct 2014
    I cannot believe they could ruin our beautiful coast with the monstrosity planned. It would be a crime to spoil our lovely coast for people, animals and birds. I'll do all I can to help stop it.
  31. Liz Beckley 31 Oct 2014
    Common sense tells us that the views of the local communities MUST be taken into consideration and acted upon.
  32. Fi Stewart 1 Nov 2014
    Everyone needs to sign this petition and support keepourcoast.com before our environment and lifestyles are irrevocably changed for the worst
  33. john wheelan 2 Nov 2014
    The residents of this area should have the final say in this very important project. these are our lives and livelyhoods at stake
  34. Margaret Nisbet 2 Nov 2014
    This proposal could have a detrimental effect on the wildlife (e.g. waders and geese) and also on the local communities and tourist industry.
  35. Robert ritchie 2 Nov 2014
    No to park
  36. David Ha,LINTON Fleming 3 Nov 2014
    Are you mad ? There are other préxisting established industrial sites elsewhere so why spoil the East Lothian County by building That here ! Let's vote the people out who support this in our beautiful county !
  37. Moira Fleming 3 Nov 2014
    Can you believe those East Lothian politicians giving this the go ahead Lets find out who voted for it and let's vote them out ! Save our beautiful county
  38. Sara Riccio 3 Nov 2014
    A strong NO! Destroying local wildlife and scenery.
  39. RUTH BOWES 3 Nov 2014
    Of all the places in Scotland with an industrial heritage do you think Cockenzie would be top of the list ? Lets put those politicians who voted for it out of office
  40. William Wallace 3 Nov 2014
    I can't understand why you want to put a marina in an area which will split community's and make cockenzie a ghost town. House prices will fall and people have tried to improve their life's and you will take this away from ordinary hard working people in the community's
  41. Dr Patricia Macdonald 3 Nov 2014
    Please abandon this proposal and restore the coast at this point to greenspace by the sea for the benefit of local communities and visitors to East Lothian. More jobs will be lost than gained by such a development in East Lothian as it is today. There were good reasons for the location of the power station on this site, but there is now no reason for its replacement, or for its footprint to be expanded, by another polluting and amenity-destroying industrial facility.
  42. corrine jackson 3 Nov 2014
    No
  43. MRS CADEAN BADRICK 4 Nov 2014
    For me and my family we prefer something more like educational for kids in the future.
  44. Julia Dianne Hewitt 4 Nov 2014
    signed
  45. Dr Allan W Brown 4 Nov 2014
    There is already an 'energy park' at Leven, Fife, so it is difficult to understand why there needs to be another one located in the Forth. If the basis is for promoting and developing sustainable energy then why this has to be linked to the destruction of an area of the coast, as well as important greenspace, is perverse.
  46. Gavin Halcrow 4 Nov 2014
    I am opposed to the proposed industrial development on a scale exceeding the existing power station in such close proximity to residential areas.
  47. Renate Millar 4 Nov 2014
    no
  48. William Ness 4 Nov 2014
    If the site is going to be used for anything, make sure that it does not damage the surrounding historic sites or local beautiful coastline. Create something that is of benefit to the local & wider community
    - perhaps something that is educational or multi-use.
  49. Audrey Allan 4 Nov 2014
    Cannot believe that we get rid of the coal fired power station and now these plans are being considered. Unbelievable but not surprising.
  50. Sophie Tulloch 4 Nov 2014
    the consultation period appeared to be non existent and plans so far advanced by the time they came to the community's attention that it smacked of duplicitiousness on those backing the project.