Petition · PE01537 · Session 4
Proposed Energy Park at Cockenzie
Signatures
1
Comments
212
Considered
4 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to abandon the proposal for the development of an Energy Park at Cockenzie, and ensure that any future proposals are subject to full public consultation and do not extend beyond the existing footprint of the former power station.
What the petitioner did first
Letters to Iain Gray, East Lothian MSP: Iain Gray MSP contacted and raised community concerns with Cabinet Secretary For Finance, Employment and Substainable Growth, John Swinney MSP
Letters to all ELC East Lothian Ward councillors bordering the proposed development: contacted by letter expressing deep community concerns” Out of 12 only 4 replied
Petition to East Lothian Council: rejected because “what is being sought is not within the power of East Lothian Council. The proposals are in the hands of Scottish Enterprise, Scottish Power and others”;
Meeting with Scottish Enterprise: unsuccessful as SE continue to drive forward with planned development regardless of community concerns expressed. SE also told us no discussions had taken place with Scottish Power, yet it is reported that all land belongs to Scottish Power;
Meeting with Inch Cape: informative but ultimately unsuccessful;
Meeting with Iain Gray MSP: Iain Gray, MSP sympathises with communities and their concern and opposes development, but powerless to stop it;
Community meetings: Community meetings have been held since July 2014 with numbers growing from 25 at first meeting to over 800 members of the community at most recent meeting in September and more than 4000 local signatures on petition supporting our community concerns;
Attendance at ELC Planning Committee meeting on Inch Cape (September 2014): CRA spoke to ask for a 2 month deferment of judgement on the battlesite development on local countryside land to enable CRA to seek a meeting with Scottish Power to establish why land currently unused on existing energy footprint at Cockenzie could not accommodate Inch Cape. Request unsuccessful;
Efforts to secure meeting with Scottish Power: SP Generation Director finally responding by email but refusing to meet whilst consideration to commercial approaches and options for the site being considered. Scottish Network planned to meet but cancelled meeting because "Scottish Generation dealing with matter". A meeting with SP has since been scheduled for late October 2014;
Contact with office of David Martin MEP to discuss proposals;
Public consultations: Vision gathering sessions held by Coastal Regeneration Alliance to enable the community to put forward their vision of the areas in question;
Press Releases issued weekly to local & national newspapers with support from press for the community;
Analysing petition signatures to demonstrate local feeling to community councils & secure Community Councils support for community action;
Contact & support from organisations linked to Battle Of Prestonpans;
Contact & advice from Greenpeace, Marine Conservation Society and Marinet of the dramatic effects of coastal dredging of the proposed deep water site and effects of local East Lothian beaches and also proposed Underground Coal Gasification drilling near our coastline;
Poems, songs & video presentations created to demonstrate extent of community concern and the positive & peaceful actions taken to voice this concern into public domain;
Pop-up stalls held weekly in local communities to provide information, petition and letter signing opportunities for those who are concerned and without online access;
Bumper stickers & #keepourcoast T-shirts produced & widely available locally;
Leaflets produced & delivered to premises immediately bordering proposed site initially, and now wider East Lothian county.
Letters to all ELC East Lothian Ward councillors bordering the proposed development: contacted by letter expressing deep community concerns” Out of 12 only 4 replied
Petition to East Lothian Council: rejected because “what is being sought is not within the power of East Lothian Council. The proposals are in the hands of Scottish Enterprise, Scottish Power and others”;
Meeting with Scottish Enterprise: unsuccessful as SE continue to drive forward with planned development regardless of community concerns expressed. SE also told us no discussions had taken place with Scottish Power, yet it is reported that all land belongs to Scottish Power;
Meeting with Inch Cape: informative but ultimately unsuccessful;
Meeting with Iain Gray MSP: Iain Gray, MSP sympathises with communities and their concern and opposes development, but powerless to stop it;
Community meetings: Community meetings have been held since July 2014 with numbers growing from 25 at first meeting to over 800 members of the community at most recent meeting in September and more than 4000 local signatures on petition supporting our community concerns;
Attendance at ELC Planning Committee meeting on Inch Cape (September 2014): CRA spoke to ask for a 2 month deferment of judgement on the battlesite development on local countryside land to enable CRA to seek a meeting with Scottish Power to establish why land currently unused on existing energy footprint at Cockenzie could not accommodate Inch Cape. Request unsuccessful;
Efforts to secure meeting with Scottish Power: SP Generation Director finally responding by email but refusing to meet whilst consideration to commercial approaches and options for the site being considered. Scottish Network planned to meet but cancelled meeting because "Scottish Generation dealing with matter". A meeting with SP has since been scheduled for late October 2014;
Contact with office of David Martin MEP to discuss proposals;
Public consultations: Vision gathering sessions held by Coastal Regeneration Alliance to enable the community to put forward their vision of the areas in question;
Press Releases issued weekly to local & national newspapers with support from press for the community;
Analysing petition signatures to demonstrate local feeling to community councils & secure Community Councils support for community action;
Contact & support from organisations linked to Battle Of Prestonpans;
Contact & advice from Greenpeace, Marine Conservation Society and Marinet of the dramatic effects of coastal dredging of the proposed deep water site and effects of local East Lothian beaches and also proposed Underground Coal Gasification drilling near our coastline;
Poems, songs & video presentations created to demonstrate extent of community concern and the positive & peaceful actions taken to voice this concern into public domain;
Pop-up stalls held weekly in local communities to provide information, petition and letter signing opportunities for those who are concerned and without online access;
Bumper stickers & #keepourcoast T-shirts produced & widely available locally;
Leaflets produced & delivered to premises immediately bordering proposed site initially, and now wider East Lothian county.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
9 Dec 20141 mention
-
3 Mar 20151 mention
-
28 Apr 20151 mention
-
23 Jun 20151 mention
Signatures by country
2,571 online signaturesComments
212 comments, oldest first212 comments · showing 101–150
-
Lorna White 16 Oct 2014A shocking proposal to turn the Garden County into an industrial bombsite. Tearing communities apart
-
Garry Schulte 16 Oct 2014Once again it looks as though the Council are trying to sneak through another ill conceived short sighted plan, riding rough shod over the people who have been living and working in this area for generations.
-
Maj-Britt K Stevenson 16 Oct 2014It is incomprehensible that such an energy park should get the permission to be built immediately next to where people live.Most people in the villages had looked forward to the end of the power station not for it to be replaced by an industrial energy park.
-
Shauna Hendy 16 Oct 2014this would be detrimental to Tourism , Wildlife and the way of life for local folk.
-
Brad cassidy 17 Oct 2014O no
-
Arran Paul Johnston 17 Oct 2014The communities around Prestonpans, Cockenzie and Port Seton have worked hard over the past decade and more to create a strong and positive identity and an energetic vision for their future. All this work would be trampled into the ground by these grossly inconsiderate proposals which utterly ignore both the community's wishes and the importance of this part of East Lothian's coast. They threaten livelihoods, a nationally important battlefield, valued green spaces and community assets, and disregard the nature, aspirations, and inter-connectedness of these communities.
-
Dave Beards 17 Oct 2014The historic battlefield site has great potential to be developed for tourism, and is one of few green spaces left in the area.
-
Caroline Ross 17 Oct 2014I have lived with the power station for 45 years and do not want anything else in its place
-
Derek Stewart 17 Oct 2014This site is part of British History
- and is unique ... To build upon it would be cultural vandalism
- a selfish act that benefits only a few. -
Colin hattersley 17 Oct 2014Historic sites like this should be protected for future generations rather than sacrificed for short term profit
-
Catherine Baillie 17 Oct 2014Signed
-
charlene 18 Oct 2014dont no
-
Jean Grundison 18 Oct 2014Why Cockenzie & Port Seton? This is a wee quiet fishing village
- let's leave it that way!!! -
Alan Magnus-Bennett 18 Oct 2014It is important to the local community hereabouts to preserve the greenfield site in question for the benefit of all. The fact that it is a historical battle site of importance to the specific history of Scotland is all the more important. There is a brown site nearby under orders for demolition. It makes more sense to use this area for any further development associated with the proposed energy park.
-
Bill Fenton 19 Oct 2014For over 20 years I have proposed the demolition of Cockenzie Power Station and proposed a massive all the year round Tourist and Commercial Park Development which would include a cruise liner terminal, My predictions are to employ long term many thousands of local people and not only revitalise this magnificent coastline but launch Tourism in East Lothian to new heights and stimulate the whole Scottish Tourism Industry. A sure fire winner. Scottish Enterprise take note, we need you to invest our money in such a project!
-
Richard McLean 19 Oct 2014I'm all for renewable energy and redevelopment but there must be sites more appropriate than the site in question. I feel it'll have a detrimental effect on the surrounding villages and towns.
-
adam paterson 19 Oct 2014Just goes to show again. That the government don't care about the people of Scotland. As long as they don't live there....who cares! Shove your energy park
-
Helen Anne Foster 19 Oct 2014It is inconceivable that Scottish Enterprise and East Lothian Council should bulldoze ahead with plans for a large scale industrial zone separating Cockenzie and Prestonpans and close to local residents' homes with no consultation or regard to the people who live there. There is a sense of 'hidden' future plans including channelling of energy from Dunbar wind farm if it goes ahead. Also plans uncovered to extract coal gas from under the Forth by unproven methods. One can only assume this was planned when seeking approval for the gas fired power station. It didn't make sense to us at the time that the gas was going to be piped in from Russia.
- More lies and hidden agendas. How about being up front and getting the local community on board as opposed to up in arms? -
Margaret Johnston 19 Oct 2014These plans would separate the three close communities of Port Seton, Cockenzie and Preston Pans, and threaten a lot of jobs in the area.
-
Evelyn Schulte 19 Oct 2014Far too much of our green space has disappeared over the years we can not let this go on. This an area steeped in history with spectacular views that will be spoiled with this development. Please don't let this happen.
-
Shona Bain 19 Oct 2014shouldn't tamper with natural tides, directing water makes you susceptible to flooding.
Efforts should be being made to enhance the coastal road route at the old site and the history of the area. -
Alan Carter 20 Oct 2014These proposals will destroy the local community, heritage and amenity of this area. There is very little information on what might be included in the energy park other than Wind Turbine Construction. Potentially dangerous coal gas extraction may follow to power the gas fired Power Station which has already been approved and will create a restricted industrial zone within a residential area. These plans are being pushed ahead against the interests and wishes of the local community.
-
Peter Fairbrother 20 Oct 2014Let's do more to promote beautiful East lothian as an tourist destination. Let's say YES to protecting the enviroment, promoting our rich cultural heritage, and NO to these energy park proposals.
-
Helen Hindmoor 20 Oct 2014Please could someone advise how to sign the petition on this site?! Can't work it out, thanks
-
Moderator 21 Oct 2014Helen Hindmoor
- sorry to hear that you are having difficulty signing the petition. After you have filled out the name, email and town/city boxes and selected your country from the drop-down menu, you have to complete what is called a "captcha challenge". This is an additional security and anti-spam measure
- you should see a box with text or numbers in, type the text or numbers you see in the box with "Type the text" in and click "Sign This" underneath that. Your signature should then be recorded. If you are still having difficulty then please email the clerking team at petitions@scottish.parliament.uk and one of the team will manually add your signature for you. -
Bill Fenton 21 Oct 2014For over 20 years now I have proposed that Cockenzie Power Station should be replaced with a huge "all the year round" leisure and commercial park covering the whole of the now defunct Scottish Power Site. This would utilize not only the existing marina and harbour facilities, but critically provide a cruise ship terminal as well. Links into Edinburgh would be via rail on the line which already exists and touring visitors provided with free passes to use. All the high voltage interconnectors and pylons would be removed from the area and the natural beauty of this coastline restored. A Tourist Growth Scheme to make East Lothian and Scotland proud. Several thousand long term jobs would be provided and add support to the planned Blindwells New Town complete with its own train station. Strikes me that Scottish Enterprise should be proposing such a Tourism Growth Proposal as opposed to a industrial site with a very doubtful long term future aside from the obvious negative impact on the existing long suffering communities of Port Seton and Prestonpans. Offshore windfarm manufacturing growth should be directed to the existing underused site in Fife to ensure full viability there.
Bill Fenton -
Liam Morrison 21 Oct 2014Re signing the petition. The wording states 'text', the information can also include 'numbers', input the numbers and it should work
-
Michael Langton 21 Oct 2014Listen to the locals re their environment!
-
Helen Hindmoor 21 Oct 2014Thank you. Worked it out now! You need to click on petitions in the top left of the screen to then get the form up.
I like your idea Bill Fenton, a much more positive use of the space for the local community & Edinburgh. Hopefully something like this would provide growth, jobs and another reason for people to visit East Lothian. My only question would be, is the forth deep enough at this side for cruise liners? I heard somewhere that this might be an issue. -
Y Addison 21 Oct 2014I find it incredibly difficult to understand the logic behind the proposals to create an energy park right in the heart of small communities. I do understand the need to meet the demand for energy, however there must be alternative sites which could be considered for such a development which are a more reasonable distance from residential areas. Whilst those alternative sites may mean building on open spaces this surely has to be a more feasible option. I appreciate also that the creation of jobs is important but would say that the impact of this development on the quality of lives of those living in and around Cockenzie has to take precedent over the few hundred jobs which may or may not benefit local people. The tourism related ventures which are being suggested by many would surely bring more sustainable, long term job opportunities to the area. I would ask each individual involved in the planning process to step back momentarily from what they are being asked to consider and ask themselves how they would feel if this energy park was being built in their community.
-
I Whalen 23 Oct 2014THIS MUST NOT HAPPEN!
-
Christine Ireland 23 Oct 2014Against
-
Ian Graham 23 Oct 2014Please keep the green hills for future enjoyment
-
Angela Snedden 23 Oct 2014This should not happen! Yes, it is not the same without the power station there. But I would rather it be left that way, than see an energy park in its place!
-
Alan Cooke 23 Oct 2014The Power station is an important visual navigation aid to sailors in the Firth of Forth
-
Simon Gall 23 Oct 2014The decommissioning of the existing Power Station is real opportunity to return the coastline to it's near original state and invest in sustainable, locally supported developments particularly tourism. Crazy, crazy proposal!
-
Raymond turner 23 Oct 2014Wind farms. Should be at least 1mile from Coast . Iconic land mark the power station.
-
Martin Hayes 23 Oct 2014This should not happen
-
Wilna Knox 23 Oct 2014Why would anyone want to destroy our landscape? And why won't anyone listen when other, more suitable options are suggest for the community.
-
Cassie Gibb 23 Oct 2014The Coast will look horific and will bring house prices down. With an already decreasing poverty i fear that this could decrease. Also for environmental veiw it does not look to be that friendly to wild life or surrounding areas.
-
Linda Marshall 24 Oct 2014I would love the area to be kept as lovely as it is and I remember as a child coming on holiday down here from the big city and it was so lovely and clean and green so I hope this does not go ahead.
-
Ruth Donaldson 24 Oct 2014I think the secrecy of this whole project has annoyed most people especially those who bought houses on the understanding that there was to be a marina on the power station site
-
Grant Watson 24 Oct 2014Not against the re-development of the site but agree that it should be restricted to the existing site boundary. The relocation of the coast road however is totally unacceptable.
-
Charlie Hunter 24 Oct 2014Any plans should be accessible to the public and stay in line with the EU Green Policy promoting renewable energy to lower the carbon Footprint and preserve the land.
-
Bill Fenton 24 Oct 2014Further to my recent postings. It is well worth reading on line about the existing Energy Park at Methil which I can actually see from my house across the Forth.
I would particularly recommend reading about the visit of the Scottish Enterprise Minister in 2011 when opening a new road to the site and lauding the massive future of the park for the future offshore windfarm manufacturing base. This development site is actually owned by Scottish Enterprise who have invested considerable sums of our money in jointly developing it with Fife Council over the past few years. The existing docks on the site allied to the industrial development already there appear perfect for the job at hand. Why on earth then are Scottish Enterprise proposing another Energy Park at Cockenzie when Methil is only about 25% utilized. -
David Morrison 24 Oct 2014I am disgusted that residents are not able to vote directly on this matter. It is their homes and their lives which are affected after all.
-
Claire Pemberton 24 Oct 2014This area is the start to a beautiful coastline which needs to be enhanced not destroyed. What will visitors to Scotland arriving at Edinburgh think of this eyesore never mind the poor residents who will have to live with it. It's our children's future at stake , think carefully
-
Nichola Clyde 25 Oct 2014East Lothian is the 'garden of Scotland'
- let's keep it that way! -
Scott clunie 25 Oct 2014As a father of four young children this is NOT what i want for our future generations!
-
Duncan Paterson 25 Oct 2014Please do not destroy our coastline, this proposal is disgusting