I thank the committee for its forbearance in allowing me to address this petition once again.
The core of the petition is the request
“to abandon the proposal for the development of an Energy Park”
on that site. That proposal from Scottish Enterprise has now been withdrawn, so I can understand it if the committee feels that there is an opportunity to close the petition. However, I have discussed the issue with the petitioners and I make a plea for the petition to be continued, at least in the meantime.
The petition comes in two parts. The first is about the previous proposal for an energy park, but the second part says:
“and ensure that any future proposals are subject to full public consultation and do not extend beyond the existing footprint of the former power station.”
Indeed, colleagues may remember that, in its initial evidence, the Coastal Regeneration Alliance presented a master plan for the area that reflected the aspirations of the local community. It was quite a sophisticated plan that had been put together after a great deal of work that the CRA did locally with the community to try to draw out what local people would like to see on the site.
It is the case that the Cockenzie site remains a strategic site, so the tension between possible future developments and the aspirations of local people remains. The petitioners are concerned to ensure that that aspect of the petition is not lost and that some way is found to examine how they can have some confidence that future proposals will not be handled in the way that the energy park proposal was, which caused so much concern locally.
There are some general principles here about how the current planning and economic development processes can, on occasion, sideline local communities, particularly when a large strategic site such as this one is in question. I suggest to the committee that it continue the petition and perhaps even consider referring it to an appropriate committee, such as the Infrastructure and Capital Investment Committee, to look at how this proposal and indeed other proposals can be brought forward alongside and with the support of local communities rather than without their collaboration and participation.