Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01537 · Session 4

Proposed Energy Park at Cockenzie

Closed Submitted 9 Oct 2014 Environment & Energy
Signatures
1
2,571 online signatures with a country
Comments
212
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to abandon the proposal for the development of an Energy Park at Cockenzie, and ensure that any future proposals are subject to full public consultation and do not extend beyond the existing footprint of the former power station.

What the petitioner did first

Letters to Iain Gray, East Lothian MSP: Iain Gray MSP contacted and raised community concerns with Cabinet Secretary For Finance, Employment and Substainable Growth, John Swinney MSP
Letters to all ELC East Lothian Ward councillors bordering the proposed development: contacted by letter expressing deep community concerns” Out of 12 only 4 replied
Petition to East Lothian Council: rejected because “what is being sought is not within the power of East Lothian Council. The proposals are in the hands of Scottish Enterprise, Scottish Power and others”;
Meeting with Scottish Enterprise: unsuccessful as SE continue to drive forward with planned development regardless of community concerns expressed. SE also told us no discussions had taken place with Scottish Power, yet it is reported that all land belongs to Scottish Power;
Meeting with Inch Cape: informative but ultimately unsuccessful;
Meeting with Iain Gray MSP: Iain Gray, MSP sympathises with communities and their concern and opposes development, but powerless to stop it;
Community meetings: Community meetings have been held since July 2014 with numbers growing from 25 at first meeting to over 800 members of the community at most recent meeting in September and more than 4000 local signatures on petition supporting our community concerns;
Attendance at ELC Planning Committee meeting on Inch Cape (September 2014): CRA spoke to ask for a 2 month deferment of judgement on the battlesite development on local countryside land to enable CRA to seek a meeting with Scottish Power to establish why land currently unused on existing energy footprint at Cockenzie could not accommodate Inch Cape. Request unsuccessful;
Efforts to secure meeting with Scottish Power: SP Generation Director finally responding by email but refusing to meet whilst consideration to commercial approaches and options for the site being considered. Scottish Network planned to meet but cancelled meeting because "Scottish Generation dealing with matter". A meeting with SP has since been scheduled for late October 2014;
Contact with office of David Martin MEP to discuss proposals;
Public consultations: Vision gathering sessions held by Coastal Regeneration Alliance to enable the community to put forward their vision of the areas in question;
Press Releases issued weekly to local & national newspapers with support from press for the community;
Analysing petition signatures to demonstrate local feeling to community councils & secure Community Councils support for community action;
Contact & support from organisations linked to Battle Of Prestonpans;
Contact & advice from Greenpeace, Marine Conservation Society and Marinet of the dramatic effects of coastal dredging of the proposed deep water site and effects of local East Lothian beaches and also proposed Underground Coal Gasification drilling near our coastline;
Poems, songs & video presentations created to demonstrate extent of community concern and the positive & peaceful actions taken to voice this concern into public domain;
Pop-up stalls held weekly in local communities to provide information, petition and letter signing opportunities for those who are concerned and without online access;
Bumper stickers & #keepourcoast T-shirts produced & widely available locally;
Leaflets produced & delivered to premises immediately bordering proposed site initially, and now wider East Lothian county.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 9 Dec 2014
    1 mention
  2. 3 Mar 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 28 Apr 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 23 Jun 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,571 online signatures
  1. Scotland2,116 82.3%
  2. United Kingdom319 12.4%
  3. England80 3.1%
  4. New Zealand10 0.4%
  5. United States9 0.4%
  6. Australia8 0.3%
  7. Canada5 0.2%
  8. Northern Ireland4 0.2%
  9. Wales4 0.2%
  10. Ireland3 0.1%
  11. 9 other countries13 0.5%

Comments

212 comments, oldest first
212 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Elizabeth Balfour 11 Oct 2014
    I feel that this whole plan has not been open an transparent an the residents of East Lothian being forced to unite and fight to save the East Coast. All these communities have had a history with the coast, do we now forget it.
  2. language Mcneill 11 Oct 2014
    Don't want this
  3. M Gordon 11 Oct 2014
    I agree with comments relating particularly to the development of extra ground for industry. This area is bang in the middle of residential villages which have worked hard to maintain their identities
    - particularly through fishing, mining and historical interests
    - as more and more housing development has developed over the last 20 years on more and more of their green spaces. I believe that part of the proposed site was previously earmarked for a new health centre. While that did not materialise, we need the site to be developed in such a way that it could benefit all the local people
    - for increased resources or for recreation. Most certainly, options such as this proposal, which would have such a devastating effect on the nature of our surroundings, must have full and thorough investigations only in consultation with the public concerned.
  4. Denise Keen 11 Oct 2014
    This proposed development would rip the hearts out of our communities and have a disastrous effect on our coast line and environment,
  5. Lesley Baillie 11 Oct 2014
    Had to sign this petition against the Energy Park. This will kill Cocknezie and Port Seton as people will want to move, there will be no passing trade and an eye sore to boot.
  6. Anne Elizabeth Baillie 11 Oct 2014
    I was brought up in Prestonpans and have always been so proud of our coastline, please don't destroy it. It gives so much pleasure to so many.......
  7. Mary Cotter 11 Oct 2014
    Please preserve our coastline and our communities.
  8. steven renton 12 Oct 2014
    The proposal bt Scottish Enterprise for this site is a disgrace in its current form. It will destroy and divide three communities, pollute the area environmentally and sociably and strip East Lothian of its tourist status!
  9. Ed Bethune 12 Oct 2014
    The notion that there has been adequate consultation regarding the proposed Energy 'Park' is preposterous, and those in Scottish Enterprise and ELC who would argue otherwise clearly have no respect for the communities involved. The consultation route which was embarked upon by the aforementioned organisations was merely a box ticking exercise with minimal advertising. Communities should not have to dig for information in the way that we have had to in this instance
    - the great irony is that the community themselves have initiated the vast majority of any consultation. Surely this is the wrong way round?
  10. Noelle 12 Oct 2014
    We don't want or need the largest energy park in Europe on our door step. It would totally ruin the coast and the skyline of Edinburgh which has world heritage status. The Forth would be polluted and all the good done to clean the environment over the past few decades put at risk. JOHN Muir walkway, oysters in the forth, nature reserves etc. It would be a massive carbunkle in the beautiful East lothian tourist area close to the capital. Very detrimental to tourism. The chimneys can be seen from the centre of Edinburgh including the Royal Mile and the castle. Do we really think this proposed industrial scar would promote Scottish tourism
    - a massive ugly industrial site on the skyline?
  11. Chris Greive 12 Oct 2014
    I use this part of the coast for walks with the family, it's open access coastal spaces that are close to Edinburgh (east) & would be spoilt by plans to ruin history sites & the fact this proposed 'Energy Park' would be bigger than the town itself.
  12. Jeannine Mjoseth 12 Oct 2014
    Clean water and a clean environment are the most important things the Parliament can protect. Without these, nothing else is possible or worth doing.
  13. Cameron Jay 12 Oct 2014
    Not long in the area and I was actually looking forward to the removal of the old CFPS. I genuinely thought a project would be implemented to give the site a relevant and viable use for the local communities and forth, North Sea coast. A marina, yaught haven, coastal recreation and tourism site would be an amazing draw to people from all over the world to this ancient and historical part of Scotland.
  14. Louise Whitson 12 Oct 2014
    Do not destroy our beautiful coastline
  15. Rita Murray 12 Oct 2014
    Against this proposal
  16. Sheila Laing 13 Oct 2014
    Port Seton is a working harbour and this would negatively impact on this small but crucial local industry. The adverse impact on surrounding historical sites is important. Our beautiful coastline would be decimated. Leisure opportunities on the sea for community groups like Boatie Blest would be reduced.
  17. Douglas Farquhar 13 Oct 2014
    Leave our landscape for everyone to enjoy
  18. Carl John Barber 13 Oct 2014
    I will not see two towns and a large community torn apart and their environment and history ruined and lost forever.
  19. Paul smith 13 Oct 2014
    Don't won't our beautiful coastline destroyed by an industrial estate take it elsewhere !
  20. Sharon Malcolm 13 Oct 2014
    This will have a devasting effect to our expanding communities and to our marine life . Not forgetting our amazing east lothian coast . An industrial monstrosity to a massive scale bang in between two communities with no radius (mileage) for any failures i.e gas explosions etc Where is the humane side to all this ??? Many huge scale industrail sites are not built right in between a community area especially with one mile between two towns.
  21. Ross Armstrong 13 Oct 2014
    Please don't replace one monstrosity with another!!
  22. Nichola Cochrane 13 Oct 2014
    Against this proposal
  23. Mr and Mrs Brown 13 Oct 2014
    The green space is an important legacy to leave for our children. Many, many memories have been created and it's a shame that greed looks to erode them.
  24. Harry Robertson 13 Oct 2014
    The communities of Port Seton, Cockenzie, Prestonpans and Tranent will be destroyed if this development is allowed to proceed. This must not be allowed to happen.
  25. Laura Brash 13 Oct 2014
    Signed with passion.
  26. Mr Charles O'Neill 13 Oct 2014
    Dont want this monster so near to house Torness better site for it
  27. Clare Morgan 13 Oct 2014
    Although this has been an industrial area for many years, many families paid the price for this with illness in their loved ones like the coalminers. The energy park would further increase the industrial landscape which would again reduce the health and wellbeing of the large residential area that is here now. We only ask that we maintain the quality of life we have. We keep our historical areas and environment and wildlife. The community would like to be supplied with 'the facts' that make this industrial site 'a dream' for us. How many jobs? How many jobs will go to the local community? How will this affect the coastline
    - tidal
    - wildlife? If this goes ahead i have no doubt the affect will be dramatic and will last forever.
  28. Clare-Ann McShane 13 Oct 2014
    The area should be celebrated not decimated!! The coast on East Lothian is incredible and beautiful.
  29. Angela Thomson 13 Oct 2014
    I grew up in prestonpans and lived in cockenzie 4 a few years., I love that coastline the wild life the people walking there dogs sayn hello and always friendly. It beggars belief 2me that you would try and destroy not just 2 communities but all the surrounding communities . Eastlothian has already served our time , we don't want our beautiful bit of land destroyed.its wrong on every level .make it into somthin we can be proud of I'm sure this can be achieved
  30. Linda Archibald 14 Oct 2014
    Please reconsider this plan as it will do nothing for the well being of the local communities. I am not against progress and would be happy for another power station but not anything on the proposed scale. IT HAS NO PLACE IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA
  31. Laurie Brett 14 Oct 2014
    Port Seton, as a commercial fishing port is a scenic tourist site. The smaller Cockenzie harbour is also attractive to visit. Tourism is an important part of our community, which should be developed not discouraged.
  32. Mrs. Marion Dickson 14 Oct 2014
    Our fish business is at the Old Harbour, Cockenzie. Where exactly do we stand?
  33. Frances Lamarra 14 Oct 2014
    This area is ideal for development of leisure activities and associated businesses. Please do not disrespect a beautiful area and the vibrant community.
  34. Allan Campbell 14 Oct 2014
    We love Cockenzie and it's harbour , visiting as tourists several times each year . The proposed development has no respect for local environment .
  35. Craig Smith 14 Oct 2014
    Can't believe the negative response when there are no concrete plans in place. This group are robbing our children of a better future with a jobs boom that we will never get any other way.
  36. Stuart Fleming-Cain 14 Oct 2014
    To lose the blight that is the power station and have it replaced by an Energy Park would be criminal. Cockenzie and Port Seton are on the coastal trail and this should be invested in the local community, tourism and future generations. Do not lose this vital coastal view to commercialism.
  37. Claire Nossiter 14 Oct 2014
    Listen to the people who live in area. Listen to your consituants. Or in return when you want the people to listen to you it might go on deaf ears...councillors!!!
  38. Pamela cormack 14 Oct 2014
    The way that this has been handled by the local council and Scottish enterprise so far has been disgusting. We are educated people who have for years taken an interest in our local community. To be treated as though we don't matter is soul destroying. We will lose thousands of ponds on the values of our homes if this goes ahead. Why not allow another industry such as hospitality to generate jobs as well as tourism in this area? Please do not destroy our lovely coastline with this monstrosity. We should be allowed choices about what goes into our local communities. If this goes ahead I for one will lose all faith in this government and question deeply whether it is the right government for our families future. Please listen to us
  39. Frances Lamarra 14 Oct 2014
    There is also a thriving and growing artist community in the area. Please help to encourage the diversity and enthusiasm of the local people.
  40. Pat Berry 14 Oct 2014
    Why is our beautiful coastline and views across the forth being spoiled for ever. It's a sin.
  41. John Cockerell 14 Oct 2014
    This monstrosity will destroy the Heritage and the character of one of the most visited coastlines in the uk !
  42. Rosemary Parkyn 14 Oct 2014
    The proposal for a major industrial development in the middle of 2 residential areas is totally inappropriate. Prestonpans has been developed as a residential expansion corridor for Edinburgh. As part of this my estate has 500 houses plus flats immediately adjoining the proposed site. Within its planning consents it had 5 play parks specifically because this was designed as for families and it has a high percentage of children. In addition I choose my property location specifically to avoid proximity to heavy traffic roads due to asthma and cardiovascular issues but due to the constraints of movement of turbines etc it is proposed to divert the main road adjacent to the estate. Scottish Enterprise proposals would have a major impact on the residential environment and the whole nature of the coastal towns of Prestonpans,Cockenzie and Port Seton and divide the communities. If the situation was reversed this would be considered as retrospective planning and consent would automatically be rejected.
  43. Maureen Matthews 15 Oct 2014
    Stop this madness now. We demand Public Consultation NOW.
  44. Shazney-t 15 Oct 2014
    something that the whole community could use should be built on the land .
  45. Sandra Eeles 15 Oct 2014
    We need something to enhance our area. I personally will expect compensation for my property if this goes ahead.
  46. Yvonne Reekie 15 Oct 2014
    do not want the proposed wind farm to go ahead
  47. Rosemary Crockett 16 Oct 2014
    I fail to see the benefits of this to the near or wider community. A marina and Holiday flats for rent or purchase would fit in with area plus a site for housing the Prestonpans Tapestry. Wind farms? What about solar panels on all new houses and council houses. New houses on the doorstep of an industrial eyesore? Finally there needs to be more openness about this.
  48. Thea Campbell 16 Oct 2014
    Cockenzie as a village will suffer the loss of most of its green space if this proposal goes ahead. This will be to the detriment of those who live there and also those who visit.
  49. Shirley Bailey 16 Oct 2014
    So, all of East Lothian's Golf Coast along that route should be disbanded along with all the work that was done on promoting the John Muir Way. Bye-bye tourists! I think the idea of a Tate Northern would be more in keeping with the tourist theme of the county.
  50. John Graham 16 Oct 2014
    We do not want a cut off between Cockenzie and Prestonpans WE must keep the road open