Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01510 · Session 4

Emergency Service and Non Emergency Service Call Centres

Closed Submitted 25 Jan 2014 Justice
Signatures
0
1,704 online signatures with a country
Comments
232
Considered
15 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to undertake a committee inquiry into the closure of Police, Fire, and Non-Emergency Service Centres north of Dundee. In particular, the major concerns raised have been the loss of public knoweldge; public safety; officers being off the street and overwhelmed in managing the increased workload this would create.

What the petitioner did first

Written to and encouraged others to write to their local MP.
I am aware that employees at Aberdeen Service Centre have also written to their MPs and indeed the Chief of Police Scotland, asking them to and reconsider the closures. They have yet to receicve responses.
I have also emailed the Scottish Police Authority Complaints Department and am still waiting for a response.
As yet I have not had a response from my local MSP.
Alongside this petition I will acquire the contact details of the relevant Minister to which these organisations are accountable, and appeal to them for a review of the descision.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 22 Apr 2014
    1 mention
  2. 3 Jun 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 24 Jun 2014
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  4. 4 Nov 2014
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 3 Feb 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 21 Apr 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 22 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  8. 29 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  9. 5 Jan 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  10. 23 Feb 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  11. 27 Sep 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  12. 24 Jan 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  13. 2 May 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  14. 5 Sep 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  15. 19 Dec 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    3 mentions

Signatures by country

1,704 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,508 88.5%
  2. United Kingdom179 10.5%
  3. Wales5 0.3%
  4. England4 0.2%
  5. Australia2 0.1%
  6. Spain1 0.1%
  7. Mexico1 0.1%
  8. Taiwan1 0.1%
  9. Isle of Man1 0.1%
  10. United States1 0.1%
  11. 1 other countries1 0.1%

Comments

232 comments, oldest first
232 comments · showing 151–200
  1. Mark Cushnie 21 Feb 2014
    Stop eroding local services
    - not everyone wants to be governed by Police Glasgow.
  2. Ronald Macdonald 21 Feb 2014
    It not good not having locals put out of work when they know the areas. This can put life's at risk. Bad call on this one.
  3. graeme 21 Feb 2014
    police moral is at an all time low as it is, closing call centres in the north east is a bad move.
  4. A Forbes 21 Feb 2014
    Central belt bias yet again
  5. Ian Ross 21 Feb 2014
    You can't close down Aberdeen call centre the staff know all Aberdeen and shire area . We have a great police force and support staff in this area . Closing this down gives crooks the idea that they will have a easy life lets close down the central belt see how they like it
  6. L Beattie 21 Feb 2014
    It's a step too far. We need the local knowledge, not delays because emergency services has been sent to the wrong town. I feel you should be opening another emergency call centre north of Aberdeen & not closing Aberdeen at all.
  7. Margaret Short 21 Feb 2014
    I live in a rural community and my fears are that lack of local knowledge will cause delays in reaching the local community and this decision would without doubt put public safety at risk
  8. Mrs Mary Annal 21 Feb 2014
    Aberdeen needs their own services run from Aberdeen, only our own emergency people know the locations in their own town. A lot of lives could potentially be lost if services were moved.
  9. Gordon Mciver 21 Feb 2014
    Why are all the fire control rooms being kept are only 60 miles leaving some places in the North over 200mls away from 1 of these centres
  10. Brian 21 Feb 2014
    Yet another West Coast bias decision that will seriously effect the well being of the Oil capital of Europe and the main bill payer of Scotland.Not a very good decision based on the hopes of yes vote for independence in this part of Scotland.Wakey Wakey SNP,stand up for the North East of Scotland for a change !
  11. John Hay 22 Feb 2014
    Another huge backward step again. Pounds over safety once more, disgusting!
  12. J Duncan 22 Feb 2014
    Having been a Control Room Sergeant in Aberdeen I know the value of having a locally staffed and locally positioned Control Room. Its more than about taking a call Its knowing the area and knowing what resources you have
    - not just from a computer screen. The North East is now becoming the forgotten area of Policing due to Central Belt influence. Colleagues still in the Police in the North East are doing an excellent job in trying times.
  13. Jean Stevenson 22 Feb 2014
    I believe that this centralising of everything is the root cause of the present lack of community presence in our towns and villages. I know the supermarkets have blamed but they didn't close local schools, post offices, hospitals, police stations. Now any town is just a place to live, certainly not a community and centralising our call centres leaves us ever more remote. It is time those in charge of Police Scotland realised that Scotland is not a city and can not be run like London.
  14. Doreen Fraser 22 Feb 2014
    All the money is being spent in the Central Belt whereas Aberdeen does not get its fair share and it is supposed to be the Oil Capital
    - it does NOT make much sense. More money needs to be spent in the Aberdeen area to support our local industry and people who stay here.
  15. jacqui ross 22 Feb 2014
    we need our own serive run from aberdeen with large area they cover they know all the small community's and the quickest ways of getting to them there service is hard pushed as it is y make more cuts its about saving lives not money
  16. tracey rait 22 Feb 2014
    Do not move our 999 services we need it here concern it will b so bad for our area x worry about what could happen
  17. Jennie Taylor 22 Feb 2014
    In support of all families impacted by this move, both employees & those in the community.
  18. Neil Spinks 23 Feb 2014
    Even with the promised state of the art technology...how can anyone in central belt locate a remote rural location to report road blockage...the caller may be calling from home and need assistance to identify the locus. Glasgow do not even know that Huntly is near to Aberdeen and not Inverness.
  19. G,Burkhill 23 Feb 2014
    Amalgamate both Fire and Ambulance control rooms into the new Mounthooly Fire Station complex in Aberdeen. From all I've read in the local newspapers, this control room is up-to-date as far as technology is concerned. Surely it would be more sensible to train (or re-train) operators to take both Fire and Ambulance emergency calls. Not only would this save millions of pounds of taxpayers money, but there would seem to be little need to move these vital control rooms to either Dundee or Glasgow.
  20. J. Lynne Batik 23 Feb 2014
    We need call centres with local knowledge, or lives will be unnecessarily lost -- please do not close these centres, we depend on them.
  21. George Ross 23 Feb 2014
    Inverurie has been known as Inveraray
  22. Stella 24 Feb 2014
    Save these service centres
  23. James Gallagher 24 Feb 2014
    I firmly believe that emergency call centres should stay local and that police front desks open times should remain as is.What is proposed is more centre belt control.
  24. kenneth downie 24 Feb 2014
    It is crazy phoning someone in an emergency that has no knowledge of the area
  25. steph 24 Feb 2014
    you can't put a price on the professionalism & knowledge of the service centres in local areas
    - this needs a complete re-think!
  26. Peter Reid 24 Feb 2014
    Another hugely damaging cut that could ultimately cut lives!
  27. adam mcneill 24 Feb 2014
    Lets keep it as it is with people that know the place and can work out where you are. I have had a situation where I didn't know the arrest name but told the way I had gone and the person on the phone knew where I was.
  28. Gary Swinscoe, Scotland 24 Feb 2014
    This decision seems to show a central-belt bias.
  29. Suzanne falconer 24 Feb 2014
    For all those that do such a good job running an essential service that should stay local
  30. Leanne Morrison 24 Feb 2014
    Keep service centres local!
  31. John Timmins 25 Feb 2014
    Dublin Fire Brigade . . Supporting Your Petition
  32. Eileen Dallas 25 Feb 2014
    Please leave our local emergency services where they are. They are doing a great job. We need them!
  33. Aileen Mitchell 25 Feb 2014
    How would Piper Alpha been dealt with without local knowledge and services
  34. Laura Stephen 25 Feb 2014
    Keep the centres open!
  35. Steven Peterson 26 Feb 2014
    The loss of local knowledge could have fatal consequences given the repetitive use of some places names. The mis-direction of emergency services within rural areas could be disasterous.
  36. Steve Mackay 26 Feb 2014
    17 years of loyal supervisory service to legacy Grampian Police and now Police Scotland, sorry Police Glasgow, for what? To be thrown on the scrapheap by Kenny McAskill all so he make savings & adhere to the SNP's centralised agenda. Well they've got what they wanted. Heaven help the Grampian region. The Aberdeen Service Centre is one of the top performing Service Centre's in the whole country. Fact. It is the only Service Centre in Scotland to achieve an accreditation from the CCA. None of this appears to matter though. 300 people out of jobs means nothing to Alex Salmond, but it's 300 people & 300 familes & a lot of votes.
  37. Elizabeth Fuller 26 Feb 2014
    For a service like this local knowledge is crucial.
  38. Callum Stevenson 28 Feb 2014
    For a service like this local knowledge is cruicial
  39. Brenda Challoner 2 Mar 2014
    When I read the terms and conditions I wondered if there was anything relevant that I could say without breaking all the terms, BUT LOCAL KNOWLEDGE IS CRUCIAL, no-one in the central belt has a clue about anything that happens north of Perth, or even that we exist as humans.
  40. Mrs Linda Cullen 3 Mar 2014
    It is essential that these services are kept locally for the people to have local knowledge and to ensure the public safety of the public. Trying to save a wee bit of money can cost lives. Which is more important?
  41. Lesley Ross 4 Mar 2014
    We need local police now more than ever.
    Rediculous decision to close local centres.
  42. Mrs Cran 4 Mar 2014
    A large city such as Aberdeen should have local services. It will cost lives. Oil capital? Joke more like!
  43. Lynn Bruce 4 Mar 2014
    Certain services just NEED to be localised! It's common sense and more importantly LIVES that are potentially put at risk. It is essential the public can be assured of safety!
  44. victoria christie 4 Mar 2014
    i dont have a clue what our goverment is coming too! are they not concerned on us the public,s saftey, wellbeing, and protection surley knot! it is absolutly disgracfull what they are trying to do.
  45. S Grassick 4 Mar 2014
    Local knowledge is essential for the area
  46. Beth Carmichael 4 Mar 2014
    Local knowledge and dialect knowledge is critical. Precious seconds and minutes can be lost with someone not understanding these.
  47. Andrew Smart 4 Mar 2014
    Another example of Scottish Government gone mad. And they expect us to be independent with them?!? No chance.
  48. Vivian Davidson 4 Mar 2014
    An absolute disgrace
  49. Paula Burns 4 Mar 2014
    We need local knowledge to assist in the Saving of lives. What's more important a life or £'s? I know what my answer to that is.
  50. Catherine Dixon 4 Mar 2014
    Local knowledge is so important in a rural area where I live half of the places are off the main roads.