Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01510 · Session 4

Emergency Service and Non Emergency Service Call Centres

Closed Submitted 25 Jan 2014 Justice
Signatures
0
1,704 online signatures with a country
Comments
232
Considered
15 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to undertake a committee inquiry into the closure of Police, Fire, and Non-Emergency Service Centres north of Dundee. In particular, the major concerns raised have been the loss of public knoweldge; public safety; officers being off the street and overwhelmed in managing the increased workload this would create.

What the petitioner did first

Written to and encouraged others to write to their local MP.
I am aware that employees at Aberdeen Service Centre have also written to their MPs and indeed the Chief of Police Scotland, asking them to and reconsider the closures. They have yet to receicve responses.
I have also emailed the Scottish Police Authority Complaints Department and am still waiting for a response.
As yet I have not had a response from my local MSP.
Alongside this petition I will acquire the contact details of the relevant Minister to which these organisations are accountable, and appeal to them for a review of the descision.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 22 Apr 2014
    1 mention
  2. 3 Jun 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 24 Jun 2014
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  4. 4 Nov 2014
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 3 Feb 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 21 Apr 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 22 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  8. 29 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  9. 5 Jan 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  10. 23 Feb 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  11. 27 Sep 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  12. 24 Jan 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  13. 2 May 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  14. 5 Sep 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  15. 19 Dec 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    3 mentions

Signatures by country

1,704 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,508 88.5%
  2. United Kingdom179 10.5%
  3. Wales5 0.3%
  4. England4 0.2%
  5. Australia2 0.1%
  6. Taiwan1 0.1%
  7. Isle of Man1 0.1%
  8. United States1 0.1%
  9. Kuwait1 0.1%
  10. Spain1 0.1%
  11. 1 other countries1 0.1%

Comments

232 comments, oldest first
232 comments · showing 101–150
  1. Brenda Brown 18 Feb 2014
    Absolutely essential that these centres remain local to the area .Full knowledge of the area is paramount in an emergency situation. Aberdeen, as the "Oil Capital of Europe" & 3rd largest city in Scotland should have full access to immediate city-based emergency centres. Ludicrous, dangerous & life-threatening to think otherwise.
  2. Joyce C Farquhar 18 Feb 2014
    Being Governed by the Central Belt is no different from being Governed by London. Scotland stills needs to be regional. STOP DESTROYING OUR EMERGENCY SERVICES. I can see a new postcode appearing, instead of AB it will be EH
  3. David Smith 18 Feb 2014
    Another example of doing this without any trials of the new so called control rooms and other centers actually working and showing what they can and can't do. They are positioned well out of the areas they are supposed to be serving and this will cause more delay in respo nding to everything because instead of one communication to get one thing done it will involve several layers to get the message to where it is meant to be going...
  4. Margaret Cruickshank 18 Feb 2014
    The older I get the more exasperated I become by all government activities, most of which are ill conceived and badly prepared, and the affect on you and I ( Joe Public) barely considered,
    I wonder why I am considering giving up my right to vote, I am beginning to wonder if people in power really listen to us at all.
    For years I have believed that government has been hellbent on centralising all services,trouble is most of it hasn't benifited the vast majority of us.
    As far as I am concerned moving our emergency calling centre from Aberdeen to Dundee, will end up in happenings that all of us will live to regret these actions.
  5. Derek 18 Feb 2014
    This is only the start. Policing in the north of Scotland is slowly but steadily being destroyed.
  6. Ruth Leslie 18 Feb 2014
    I would like to know when Aberdeen became a second class city. According to the things the government do to us it appears that this is indeed the case.
  7. Rhona Ramsay 18 Feb 2014
    As a citizen of the Grampian Region, and a former Service Centre Advisor, I find the idea of 101 calls being answered in Motherwell absolutely appalling. Aberdeen's Service Centre is the flagship model for the whole of Scotland, being rhe only accredited centre. How the standards will be improved by losing the knowledge and expertise of the staff who work both in the Service Centre andcthe contol room is beyond me. Just a ridiculous exercise, with no gain other than to the local economies of the central belt...surprise surprise!
  8. charlotte leys 18 Feb 2014
    The closure of Aberdeen leaves one feeling unsafe and vulnerable. Just what are we paying our taxes for?
  9. Helen Stuart 18 Feb 2014
    they there has been consultation, i would like to hear from anyone who has been consulted!!!
  10. Gary Williams 18 Feb 2014
    The Scottish Government harp on about Westminster bias in their dealings with the UK govt. as far as I can see this is bias but in Scotland with the southern regions being the winners. The cynic in me says that it is an attempt to buy support in those areas retaining their contact centres. The realist in me says that the SNP are risking their core vote by attempting to harvest the west coast vote. This will backfire spectacularly. Surely they should be looking after their core supporters first. That has certainly been the history of non SNP governments. Rethinking all my voting intentions as a result of this.
  11. Thomas Whyte 18 Feb 2014
    Typical of Scottish government,they say its up to the police to make the decisions on how they decide where and where not to close.Don't they realise that it is our money they are spending and they should at least look at the most cost effective way of dealing with this matter.Typical of SNP.keep everything in the central belt
  12. C Reid 18 Feb 2014
    Sad times and bad decision if no local call centres cover Aberdeen and the North East. Scotland covers more than the Central Belt!
  13. Steve 18 Feb 2014
    The start of cuts and moving everything to the Central belt. This is a step backwards
  14. Robert McKinney 18 Feb 2014
    Another wrong step by the SNP! The must really want to lose the referendum and 2015 election!
  15. jill Cruickshank 18 Feb 2014
    Aberdeen is supposed to be the oil capital of Europe. A vibrant , proud, multicultural city and it won't be able to care properly for its vulnerable because of some naive, conceited politician who can see no further than Dundee. Dundee for gods sake!!!!!!!
  16. Eric Rae 18 Feb 2014
    The decision to close the Aberdeen centre is a classic case of asset-stripping and typical of the way the North-east of Scotland has been treated by the Scottish Government since devolution, and will be even worse should we get an independent Scottish Government
  17. Moyra Joss 18 Feb 2014
    Ridiculous that Dundee chosen for 3rd emergency call centre
  18. Evelyn Robertson 18 Feb 2014
    From what is happening to the call centres in the Aberdeen area it appears we have exchanged one centralised government for another. This area is being ignored by the Scottish government but they are quick to demand money engendered in this area. We have been underfunded by governments of all parties both for local council and NHS
    - time the people of this area let our voices be heard
    - we are fed-up being ignored. I hope your petition is successful, it deserves to be
    - remind the powers that be that there are some or the population live north of Dundee
    - a fact they seem to have forgotten
    - OFTEN!!!!!!
  19. Eric Robertson 18 Feb 2014
    Central Belt bias has never been more obvious and the closure of our call centres is symptomatic of the mind set of this Government. All monies are allocated with the central belt well-being their main concern. Why would you close a up and running modern call centre and have to spend a large amount updating Dundee
    - and why did the cost of upgrading Dundee suddenly drop by £3 million ?
    - to make the move sound less stupid? The SNP politicians might like to consider that the people of this area are unlikely to forget the considerable amount of snubs they have inflicted on us.
  20. Sandra willox 18 Feb 2014
    Police answering calls NEED local knowledge
  21. Brian Cumming 19 Feb 2014
    We all know cuts are necessay, but Grampian Police have a wealth if knowledge and experience in a unique are(Oil, Royal Protection) and a large population. No- one in Dundee will find the Back o' Bennachie in an emergency sitting in Dundee
  22. Kathryn Hunter 19 Feb 2014
    If you limit the call centres, be prepared for somethig massive to happen that you can't deal with, with your limited resources, because you need everyone you have! By limiting the areas of call centres you are putting yourself at a disadvantage, do Dundonians speak Doric? No. Will they understand people from the coast and the country? I highly doubt it!
  23. Linda Gatt 19 Feb 2014
    Operators need to understand what we are saying south of Dundee may struggle to understand our dialect. Plus they need local knowledge
  24. Margot 19 Feb 2014
    For me, as an incomer to this area, for me the main issue is that it has taken me more than 10 years to understand the various county accents in this area.
    I don't doubt that the actual dispatching can be done anywhere with our lovely technology, but when the technology fails, or more so, when trying to understand quickly a panicked Doric accent over the phone, is why we need these services to be retained locally in every area, not just Aberdeenshire.
  25. Jim McPherson 19 Feb 2014
    If the system is not broken, why try to fix it ?.
    This is purely about cost cutting.
    If, God forbid, someone dies because of these changes, who will be held to account ?.
  26. Edna Booth 19 Feb 2014
    It is an absolute disgrace that these services are being cut and all the local knowledge lost. This is a prime example of the Scottish Gov. and its continued central belt bias.
  27. Alastair Ritchie 19 Feb 2014
    It would be a disaster if local knowledge was lost with the proposed closure of the control rooms.for a small cost saving.puting lives at risk.
  28. Jim Watson 19 Feb 2014
    I feel very strong, that our Police and Fire control rooms are not based in Aberdeen, I read today 19-2-14 that Police calls will be handled in, Glasgow, Motherwell which is approx. 25 miles south of Glasgow in the district of Cunninghame, which is approx. 175 miles south of Aberdeen, you tell me how experienced the staff will be to understand all calls from Aberdeen and Aberdeenshire and Banff, and relay the correct locations for the local officers to respond correctly in all situations without mistakes being made, which could mean the difference between life and death situations, we all know that when emergency or non emergency calls are phoned in by people under extreme pressure of an emergency call or not can get slightly unsure of surrounding's or locations, this is where local call handlers, most certainly come into their own, that is why this latest, idea by Police Scotland ( central belt logic, and administration is not in the best public safety of the North East of Scotland, as tax payers we are not getting value for our money locally.
  29. Angela Auld 20 Feb 2014
    I do not agree with the decision to close the emergency & 101 call centre from Aberdeen. Local knowledge will be lost and I am concerned over the closure. Our nearest centre will be in Dundee. The Aberdeen Centre should be retained in Aberdeen.
  30. BRIAN SMITH 20 Feb 2014
    This is crazy what is Aberdeen, a small Village North of Dundee ?
  31. Cheryl Collins 20 Feb 2014
    Aberdeen has a modern upto date call centre for the Fire service and it's being scrapped does this mean tax payers moeny will be thrown at the new (central belt) centres to bring them up to date when this is already in place in Aberdeen another example of wasting tax payers money and nothing existing in the north of Scotland
    - we need centres that will have local knowledge and understanding of local dialect
  32. Margie Mellis 20 Feb 2014
    This is a shortsighted move which totally disregards the importance of local knowledge and expertise in ensuring a quick and appropriate response.
  33. Mary Donald 20 Feb 2014
    A major fire in Beach Sea Front this morning and I feel that we should not close our emergencies services centres that is the Fire, Police and Ambulance services we do really need them open.
  34. meg mcgregor 20 Feb 2014
    I do not think we should loose our control centre
    my husband was in a serious road collision in January if the emergency services had not been so quick I would not have him now. I thank everyone who helped. our serves deserve better mr salmond should remember where he started it seems that Aberdeenshire does not come into anything apart from the oil.our emergency men and women do a good job and work very hard to look after us but if they do not get the proper support.then what can they do .
  35. Andrea Mennie 20 Feb 2014
    Total disgrace if this goes ahead.
    Our community needs to be 'looked' after by their own.
  36. Kim Kydd 20 Feb 2014
    Sign to save.
  37. Michael Riddle 20 Feb 2014
    I am disgusted by the Scottish governments continued removal of resources under the banner of improvement. We are not stupid, it won't matter how often you try any tell us how much better the new systems work- we can see that they are failing at ground level!
  38. Raymond Smart 20 Feb 2014
    Leave the Police and Fire Service control roome in Aberdeen and do not move them to the cenrtal belt area
  39. Sian Lyon 20 Feb 2014
    Disgrace..local knowledge is key....
  40. Leslie Duncan 20 Feb 2014
    Since most of the SNP's arguements are about London running everything from Central London and how it diminishes Scotlands interests, how can they now carry out a series of cuts that centralise Operations and withdraw funds to areas they have maximum support
    - otherwise their supporters would be voicing concerns for their areas, or are they prepared to sacrifice some of their principles for a 'Holy Grail'?
  41. suzanne sinclair 20 Feb 2014
    shame on the Scottish government. Once again you give the people of Scotland the clear message that only the central belt matters.
  42. Kathryn Rough 20 Feb 2014
    Scotland does exist above Glasgow,Edinburgh and Dundee
  43. James 20 Feb 2014
    Emergency call centres that are divorced from major cities such as Aberdeen lead to a loss of skill and knowledge of local call handlers. No amount of mitigation measures can make up for this. I have experienced first hand the problems associated with diverting ambulance 999 calls from Aberdeen to Inverness. On two seperate occasions calling for an ambulance the operator failed to recognise my location. A problem which would have unlikely have happened if dealt with by a local call centre.
  44. Selina 20 Feb 2014
    I was in a situation where I needed the emergency services back in 2012. A man who sounded like he was from Glasgow couldn't understand my accent. It took a good few attempts until he got my address and then whilst waiting I wasn't sure if they were coming or not because of this problem. This wasn't good when there was a big emergency and I'm just glad I wasn't in a worst state or this could have been life threatening.

    Don't let this happen!
  45. Johnny 20 Feb 2014
    As usual the north of scotland gets treated as if we not important...
  46. Amanda McConnachie 20 Feb 2014
    I reported something important the other day and had to be specific about the area. The call centre staff knew exactly the area and street I was speaking about. Taking the call centres outwith the area could caused problems and maybe even delays on more important matters as the staff at centralised centre wouldn't be familiar with the area. This could also become very frustrating. It would also be wrong not to mention the obvious job losses caused by this centralisation. Bad decision all round!
  47. Sharon Bradford 21 Feb 2014
    The loss of local knowledge will undoubtedly have catastrophic consequences. It is completely ludicrous to even contemplate centralising such vital services. This I must admit may well be a deal breaker for me when it comes to the independence referendum later in the year, because at the end if the day, who wants a government who clearly holds so little regard for our basic safety and welfare
  48. Edna Kirton 21 Feb 2014
    Once again the North East is losing out! Local knowledge is invaluable in an emergency. Save our control rooms!!
  49. Eddy Hall 21 Feb 2014
    If the SNP needs our vote they need to start listening to the public about Centralisation..Thats a NO NO !
  50. John Reddin 21 Feb 2014
    I find this little short of disgraceful, that Joe public has not been consulted or allowed debate on this. Aberdeen is the Oil capital of Europe with award winning services, now to be serviced in a continued effort to centralise all power to the central belt, House is little short of a bureaucratic's whip, stripping all of local law enforcement down to a strathclyde run organisation used at the whim of the politicians that helped usurp local commands to push through MacAskill's policies of centralisation of power.