Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01510 · Session 4

Emergency Service and Non Emergency Service Call Centres

Closed Submitted 25 Jan 2014 Justice
Signatures
0
1,704 online signatures with a country
Comments
232
Considered
15 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to undertake a committee inquiry into the closure of Police, Fire, and Non-Emergency Service Centres north of Dundee. In particular, the major concerns raised have been the loss of public knoweldge; public safety; officers being off the street and overwhelmed in managing the increased workload this would create.

What the petitioner did first

Written to and encouraged others to write to their local MP.
I am aware that employees at Aberdeen Service Centre have also written to their MPs and indeed the Chief of Police Scotland, asking them to and reconsider the closures. They have yet to receicve responses.
I have also emailed the Scottish Police Authority Complaints Department and am still waiting for a response.
As yet I have not had a response from my local MSP.
Alongside this petition I will acquire the contact details of the relevant Minister to which these organisations are accountable, and appeal to them for a review of the descision.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 22 Apr 2014
    1 mention
  2. 3 Jun 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 24 Jun 2014
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  4. 4 Nov 2014
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 3 Feb 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 21 Apr 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 22 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  8. 29 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  9. 5 Jan 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  10. 23 Feb 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  11. 27 Sep 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  12. 24 Jan 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  13. 2 May 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  14. 5 Sep 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  15. 19 Dec 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    3 mentions

Signatures by country

1,704 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,508 88.5%
  2. United Kingdom179 10.5%
  3. Wales5 0.3%
  4. England4 0.2%
  5. Australia2 0.1%
  6. Mexico1 0.1%
  7. Taiwan1 0.1%
  8. Isle of Man1 0.1%
  9. United States1 0.1%
  10. Kuwait1 0.1%
  11. 1 other countries1 0.1%

Comments

232 comments, oldest first
232 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Andrew Burnett 16 Feb 2014
    It is utter stupidity and criminal negligence to even think of closing Aberdeen. Dundee would be hopelessly inadequate to cover the needs and dialects of our area and the North.
  2. Rhona Strachan 16 Feb 2014
    we need centres north of Dundee
  3. Derek Milligan 16 Feb 2014
    The call centres of the emergency services should be based locally
  4. Mrs Clare Joyce Doig 16 Feb 2014
    Aberdeenshire emergencies should surely be dealt with in Aberdeen? Local knowledge is very important when dealing with distressed people in situations where lives are in danger.
  5. TL Anderson 16 Feb 2014
    Local knowledge is so important to the ongoing success of our services. Safety needs to be prioritised over cost cutting.
  6. Charles McPherson 16 Feb 2014
    Local knowledge and understanding accents is of vital importance in emergency situations
  7. Raymond Burgess 16 Feb 2014
    Scotland exists outside the central belt. Please don't make the mistakes that Westminster has and centralise everything.
  8. Heather Burgess 16 Feb 2014
    Please support our emergency services.
  9. Dawn 16 Feb 2014
    Working in a wide area of the Northeast I come across many different dialects. I struggle to always make them out & am from the North East. Also loss of local knowledge will be critical when trying to guide emergency services to the right areas & may cost lives... Cannot believe that highly proficient service is being pulled out of such a large area.Can only qoute central belt bias once again.
  10. Jenny Strachan 17 Feb 2014
    I think it is a disgrace that Aberdeen and local areas are to lose their Police Fire and other Non emergancy services.Scotland doesnt stop at Edinburgh and Glasgow and we have the same problems as everyone else,also as someone pointed out how is someone in Glasgow going to know where to send a fire engine when they cant even pronounce the Scottish names,are we to wait till our houses burn down while waiting for them to figure out where we are,shame on you for closing these services!!!!!!!
  11. Gaynor 17 Feb 2014
    Disgrace to close
  12. Rachel Little 17 Feb 2014
    The emergency service in Aberdeen do a fantastic job and unfortunately it maybe too late before many of the general public realise this. I truly hope we can save our Aberdeen service.
  13. Gundula Sharman 17 Feb 2014
    can't be rocket science to work out that local help is better for the local community.
  14. janis cardno 17 Feb 2014
    very concerned about this this should not be happening it needs to be kept if this goes ahead it will be a disaster waiting to happen Mike&Janis Cardno
  15. Sue Stockton 17 Feb 2014
    This is all a cost cutting exercise and nothing about making an already highly efficient service better. It is only a matter of time before these emergency arrives are brought to their knees and the public are put in danger.
  16. A Fyfe 17 Feb 2014
    Ridiculous to close the Aberdeen centre and the Inverness one for that matter. Just stupid !
  17. Judith Barker 17 Feb 2014
    Yet another stupid idea to make me think that an Independent Scotland is a farce ..
  18. Fiona Simpson 17 Feb 2014
    Emergency Centres must remain in the areas they serve as extensive experience and detailed knowledge of the area in which an individual Centre operates is essential to provide a fast, efficient and effective response.
  19. Keith macMillan 17 Feb 2014
    Cost cutting at the expense of another public service we cannot do without. I cannot see the sense of trying to control essential services from the central belt.
  20. Craig McGrattan 17 Feb 2014
    Absolute disgrace
  21. Kirsty Whyte 17 Feb 2014
    We need this service to continue.
  22. Phil Murray 17 Feb 2014
    Local expertise and knowledge cannot be lost. All work to review position gas been carried out with clear bias against NE of Scotland.
  23. Bill Archibald 17 Feb 2014
    Aberdeen and surrounding area is served by a call centre recognised as being very successful. Why close it and pay money to upgrade elsewhere that will not deliver that quality of service?
  24. Kenneth Mackie 17 Feb 2014
    Just what we expect from SNP government, only interested in central belt. We need controllers who understand the local dialect.
  25. Alexander Souter 17 Feb 2014
    Once again common sense has failed to prevail. Take an existing functioning control room disband it and move it to Dundee. Just another example of devolving power to the Central belt. DUNDEE THE FURTHEST north control in Scotland. We have Police in Glasgow that believe that the train runs north to Shetland !
  26. Mhairi Jarvie 17 Feb 2014
    It's vital to public safety to keep these control rooms local!!
  27. Ian Thomson 17 Feb 2014
    Keep the local knowledge local retain Aberdeen save money but not upgrading Dundee
  28. Jon Smith 17 Feb 2014
    SNP will do anything to increase their voter base in the Central belt.
  29. Doris webster 17 Feb 2014
    Closure is ridiculous !!
  30. Donald Boyd 17 Feb 2014
    Very poor decision which has not been thought through
  31. Bill Cowie 17 Feb 2014
    Does an operator in Dundee know where Crichie, Foggie, Fishie or Broch are, to name but a few.
  32. William Cormack 17 Feb 2014
    Another cost cutting measure which will cost us a
    fortune
  33. Alexander Watson 17 Feb 2014
    The SNP claim rule from Westminster. The SNP already do not care about the north and north east. It is all about Central Belt. When ast did they do something positive about Aberdeen and beyond. I thought the First minister had his roots here. He has been bought over!!!
  34. Claire Ann Cushnie 17 Feb 2014
    You cant cut back on such a valuable and badly needed service in the North of Scotland.
  35. Kevin Heatly 17 Feb 2014
    Why get rid of the original service centre and the only one which is actually accredited. They perform to the highest standard and continually produce the goods. Kenny McCaskill said they were what other centres should aim to be what has changed, shame on you mcCaskill- two faced say something mean another who could possibly trust you
  36. Gordon Simpson 17 Feb 2014
    Aberdeen
    - Scotland's third largest city with no Police or Fire control centre, absolutely ridiculous.
  37. Charles Donald 17 Feb 2014
    With the Royalty in Deeside, Oil Industry serviced from Aberdeen and local Airport a Control Room in Aberdeen is a must.
  38. Rona Boyd 17 Feb 2014
    To lose Police Control Room staff (sadly) experienced in many offshore major incidents as well as having vital local knowledge for dealing with onshore emergencies is both short sighted & wrong. But as long as the Central Belt is covered!!
  39. Francis Watson 17 Feb 2014
    Short changed again
  40. Tom McLennan 17 Feb 2014
    This would leave the North of Scotland out on a limb!
  41. Rona Insch 17 Feb 2014
    We need to retain local knowledge.
  42. Ian Menzies 17 Feb 2014
    It's all about local knowledge, and that isn't possible
    from a remote area.
  43. Derek Pickthall 17 Feb 2014
    If you remove local contact you are removing local and district knowledge which are essential with local issues, whether crime or minor incidents. I think this is a very poor decision and as usual is finance driven as always and not for the good of the community that is served by the present dedicated teams.
  44. Dave Milne 18 Feb 2014
    How can a devolved government justify centralisation of services without undermining its reason for being?
  45. Hazel Thompson 18 Feb 2014
    Having worked in a Police Control room for 24 years believe me you do need local knowledge, not only about the local characters but the area
    - it does save lives,
  46. James Mackay Beattie 18 Feb 2014
    Already I have had a report of an ambulance call where the person making the call was asked "Where is Union Street?"
    "Aberdeen".
    "OH, Aberdeen"
    Local knowledge is essential.
  47. Heather Schofield 18 Feb 2014
    why do you want to spend more money on doing up dundee when we have an adequate one here in Aberdeen . And Once again it is just wasting money that could be used for other much needed projects.
  48. Ian McAllister 18 Feb 2014
    Absolutely ridiculous idea to relocate this service away from Aberdeen. Pay attention people, this is the type of political thing which will be common place in an independant scotland. Better off with Westminster! While they are equally stupid, at least they dont differentiate between the north of scotland and the central belt
  49. Mrs Sutherland 18 Feb 2014
    Instead of cost cutting measures in Aberdeen, why not cut the roles of some of the pen pushers in the central belt! We need these services!
  50. George Paterson 18 Feb 2014
    Another ill- conceived and unjustified attack on our emergency services.