Good morning. I thank you for allowing me to come here today to give evidence on my petition. As you are no doubt aware, I am a former employee of the Bucksburn service centre in Aberdeen. However, that is only a small part of the reason why I lodged the petition.
During the few months since I created the petition, I have spoken with reporters, MSPs, employees of the Aberdeen police and fire call centres, serving police and fire officers, the Scottish Police Authority complaints department, Michelle Brady of police Unison for Aberdeen, and members of the public across the north and north-east of Scotland. I would like to address the concerns that were most common in my investigations. Those were: the lack of service provision north of Dundee, at the expense of public safety; the loss of local knowledge and expertise, and misunderstandings between southern and northern dialects; the impact that the closures will have on serving officers; and the lack of public consultation.
I intend to do my best to represent those collective concerns and to put forth a set of reasonable and fair requests to the committee, which will, I hope, lead to a positive outcome on the issues.
I begin with a quote from Dr Ian Oliver, who is a former Grampian Police chief constable. He not only supports the notion that the cuts will result in a lack of local provision, but directly addresses the issue of the autonomous nature of Scotland’s northern regions and therefore the importance of their local services. He states:
“Local knowledge has a bearing on the deployment of the number and type of officers to an incident. Unless there is a very sophisticated central computer with all of the previous information stored in it then these fears will certainly materialise. Not only is the personal knowledge of controllers essential, it could be vital in terms of their ability to remember previous criminal activity in the area, or what issues have an effect on local conduct and who is likely to be associated with an incident. An additional police responsibility in Aberdeen is that of the North Sea where over 70,000 personnel work. The potential for disasters such as Piper Alpha, or terrorist related incidents ... is significant. Local knowledge of the companies operating in the North Sea and close liaison with them has always been important. It is unlikely that a central system will have the degree of sophistication necessary to address these issues as well as local centres.”
I remind the committee of the unfortunate number of incidents involving helicopters ditching in the North Sea in recent years, and of the fact that the relationship that Dr Oliver outlines has led to swift and succinct action in response to those tragedies.
When it was put to Dr Oliver that the Government had offered its assurances that there would be no diminution in service, he responded by saying:
“Well they would say that wouldn’t they. Apparently this move is more to do with saving money than it is with increasing overall efficiency.”
In acknowledgement of the level of expertise of the work that is undertaken by Aberdeen force service control centre, the centre has been externally accredited and its control room has been heralded as one of the most modern in the United Kingdom, with huge future-proofing capacity. The centre undertakes the security and safe keeping of the royals on their visits to the north.
Having experienced working at the Bucksburn-based force service centre, I can confirm the enormous workload that is undertaken there. Having stated my concerns about the closure of the FSC and the enormous task that serving officers would take on, given the added burden of its paperwork and additional hours, I spoke with several officers on the beat. All the personnel with whom I liaised reflected those concerns and stated that they already feel that they are stretched thin in balancing paperwork with time on the streets; the latter being the reason why they joined the force in the first place.
With regard to the fire control room closures, I recently had the opportunity to speak with Aberdeen’s fire control room crew manager, Darren Gibb, who shares concerns that are similar to those of Dr Oliver. He states that the Aberdeen control room is responsible for safe maintenance of the oil capital of Scotland, the largest heliport in Scotland and a large amount of human traffic pertaining to the likes of Aberdeen airport and the local football stadium, and that it has the same capacity as the Dundee and Inverness centres combined.
It would be fair to assert that Aberdeen fire and police control rooms and service centres are well versed in management of emergency procedures and specific locations, such as the St Fergus gas plant and Peterhead power station, which may be vulnerable to a terrorist attack or a large-scale disaster.
In speaking about the control rooms being centralised with up-to-date proficient technology, Mr Gibb points out that Strathclyde, for example, is a built-up area, whereas the surrounding areas of Aberdeen and especially Inverness are increasingly rural and sparsely populated. Mr Gibb fears that a proposed system that appears to rely heavily on up-to-the-mark technology will not suffice when dealing with postcodes, and that it will lead to loss of life in attempting to assist the public.
He states that, in rural areas of northern Scotland, one postcode can cover up to 50 square miles. That becomes increasingly problematic when dealing with, for example, a road traffic incident where the victim or victims are unaware of their surroundings and/or the operator is unfamiliar with those surroundings. There is also the possibility that the technology will crash and that the call handlers will have to operate manually while the system is being fixed. Both Mr Gibb and I have witnessed that happening in our roles at the call centres.
There is evidence of such incidents having taken place when Ireland took the decision to centralise its ambulance control rooms. In 2013 a member of the Irish Parliament, Tom Fleming, raised concerns and asked the health minister to reconsider the centralisation of the control room after
“a series of incidents where issues with mistaken addresses and communication difficulties occurred.”
On one such occasion of mistaken location, when an ambulance took more than 30 minutes to reach its destination, an infant lost its life.
Examples such as that confirm the concerns that I previously outlined, which come from all sections of the community, thereby refuting the assertion of “misplaced public concern” as quoted in the minutes that were taken at the C3—command and control centre—meeting at which Assistant Chief Constable Mike McCormick presented on 30 January this year.
It was stated at that meeting that there would be no public consultation because it was generally felt, in particular by one senior officer, that the issues pertaining to the proposal would be above the understanding of the person on the street. I believe that the public have a right to be given an opportunity with regard to the decision making, because it is the public for whom the service is being provided, and the collateral directly affects them.
One final point that I take from the minutes of the C3 meeting relates to one of the areas that are marked for further work: consideration of the opportunities to operate in partnership with other blue-light services. To me, that sounded like an opportunity for real information and knowledge sharing and an opportunity to maintain the services, and a percentage of the existing staff, in both Aberdeen and Inverness.
I hope that the committee will consider taking further actions, based on the information that is laid out in this statement. First, it could ask Police Scotland to outline its reasoning for the decision and how the conclusions to the report, which went to the Scottish Police Authority, were arrived at; and it could inquire as to why no public consultation was undertaken on the proposals, and whether the decision will be revisited to allow the public input to the proposals.
Secondly, the committee could write to the Scottish Police Federation and the Fire Brigades Union Scotland to ascertain exactly what impact the closures will have on fire and police officers.
Thirdly, the committee could request that the First Minister, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, the chair of the Scottish Police Authority and the chief constable of Police Scotland undertake to visit each site that is proposed for closure and speak directly with the staff to find out their views and concerns.
Fourthly, the committee could consider writing to the police and fire Unison representatives, asking for their views, and fifthly, the committee could provide evidence that government, fire and police agencies are looking carefully into the service that is provided in the north and north-east of Scotland.
Finally, the committee could revisit the proposal that was laid out for a coalition call centre, which would enable a fluent exchange of important knowledge between blue-light services, retain the knowledge of local staff as well as a percentage of the jobs, and allow the retention of both fire and police call centres in Aberdeen and Inverness, which would hopefully result in some restoration of public confidence.