We now come to item 3. There are three current petitions and we will take the first two together: PE1098, by Lynn Merrifield on behalf of Kingseat community council, and PE1223, by Ron Beaty. The petitions are on school bus safety. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions.
Stewart Stevenson has a long-standing constituency interest in the petition. I am not sure whether Mr Stevenson is able to attend today, but I highlight the good work that he has done on it.
A number of overlapping issues are raised in the petitions. For clarity, we agreed that we would take evidence on the progress of the section 30(2) order, which, as members will know, relates to the transfer of powers from Westminster to the Scottish Government. However, a letter on the subject has been received from the Minister for Transport and Veterans, so it may be wise to postpone an evidence session. It is clear that progress has been made and Keith Brown has put some policy out on the issue. It is good to hear that there is excellent progress.
On PE1098, the committee may wish to write to the Minister for Transport and Veterans to request a more detailed timescale for the devolution of powers to the Scottish ministers in order that the progress of the process can be monitored.
On PE1223, the committee may wish to write to Transport Scotland to seek further information on the work that it is undertaking with local authorities on signage and lighting and whether it still intends to assist with evaluations of some of the pilot schemes with a view to developing them nationally.
I apologise to the committee if that is a bit complicated, but there are a couple of overlapping issues.
I also flag up the very helpful reply that we received from the Welsh Assembly. It has done some really good work on the issue, as it has on other issues that we are concerned with, such as organ transplantation.
I throw the matter over to the committee for its views on the next steps.
On PE1098, in view of the announcement in Keith Brown’s letter, I agree that we might wish to postpone the evidence session and monitor what is happening with the transfer.
On PE1223, section 12 of the note from the clerk, PPC/S4/14/8/3, makes it quite clear that it is intended that the
“powers relating to signage and lighting, which are the main issues detailed in petition PE1223, will remain reserved.”
I may not be here on earth in four years’ time. We seem to be banging our heads against a brick wall when it comes to getting those things moved. I will not mention September—although I have just done so. I simply do not understand why these things take so long, but I am glad that we have moved at least one of the petitions along a bit.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
Can we deal with one petition at a time? It has been suggested that we postpone our evidence session on the section 30(2) order. Are committee members happy that we do that in light of Keith Brown’s letter?
Convener, I am not quite sure whether we are going to let the evidence session with the minister slide, as you have just indicated. I know that you are coming to the second point. It would be useful if we asked the minister or the Scottish Government to give us a timetable for when the Scottish Government expects the powers to be devolved, but we should still indicate that we reserve the right to invite the minister along to give evidence at some future date, if we deem that necessary. As I said, we should not let the minister slide.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
I emphasise that my view is that we should just postpone the matter. If we discover that we need a further evidence session in light of further information, I am sure that the committee will want to have that. I agree with John Wilson that we need to keep that option open.
I just do not understand what goes through the minds of people in the Westminster Government when they say, “Yes, it’s okay. These powers can be granted to Wales, but we’ll take an aeon to decide whether they should be transferred to Scotland.”
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
I noticed in the letter from the Welsh Assembly minister that some powers on technical specifications were held back. Westminster has not allowed a certain level of powers to go, although it has allowed others to go. We need to keep a careful eye on that.
I will confirm what we are doing. We are temporarily suspending the evidence session with the Minister for Transport and Veterans. In relation to PE1098, we will write to him to request a more detailed timescale for the devolution of powers, and in relation to PE1223, we will write to Transport Scotland to seek further information on the work that it is undertaking with local authorities on signage and lighting and whether it still intends to assist with evaluations of some of the pilot schemes with a view to developing them nationally.
Presumably we still have powers. The Welsh say that they are installing closed circuit television cameras, and they can do exactly the same as we can. Are there certain things that we can do that we have not yet done?
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
We need to clarify with the Scottish Government that there are certain actions that it wishes to carry out but for which it does not yet have the powers—the so-called section 30(2) orders—and if there are areas in which they do have the powers, how quickly those actions will be pursued. I have spoken to Keith Brown on this issue and he is certainly very keen to get powers over seat belts, because he feels that they are crucial.
On PE1223, I note from the recommendation that we will ask whether Transport Scotland
“still intends to assist with the evaluations of some of the pilot schemes.”
I would want to put that in stronger terms and say that Transport Scotland should ensure that the evaluations of the pilot schemes are concluded and that its report on the evidence is published as soon as possible so that we can take the petition forward. We need the evaluations to be carried out and published to strengthen the argument that Mr Beaty has been pursuing for almost eight years now about having the appropriate signage on school buses.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
I have one final comment, convener. This is one of the very few occasions that Mr Beaty has not been present at a committee meeting at which we have considered his petition, and I trust that he is keeping well and that there are other reasons why he has not been able to attend today.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
I certainly note John Wilson’s point. Mr Beaty has been extremely dedicated to his petition and has taken a great interest in our proceedings for a number of years now.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.