Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 15 September 1999 Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Procedure 121 contributions · 14 speakers

Speakers

Showing John Swinney only · show everyone

John Swinney’s contributions

44 contributions
John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

The main item of business today is the committee's work programme up to Christmas, although we can look a bit further ahead if members wish. There are two relevant papers: the first is a methodology paper that sets out how we can go about our business and the type of inquiries that we can pursue; the second has been drawn up following our informal discussions with the minister a fortnight ago. We may wish to consider some of the minister's suggestions, which may be relevant to the work of his department and of the Executive. At the conclusion of this part of the discussion, I hope that we can agree on the type of work that we will undertake between now and Christmas. I also hope that we can agree on the remit of any inquiries that we will undertake during that period, and that we can give guidance to the clerks on the type of witnesses that we want to invite to the committee in the course of those inquiries.Before we go through the two papers in detail—I expect that it will be a fairly long discussion—do members want to raise any points about the papers or the process that I have set out?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

It would be helpful if we could look through the methodology paper and decide whether we want to do, for example, two medium-sized inquiries or one large inquiry and one smaller inquiry. We may want to do one major piece of work leading to a report, and have three or four meetings at which we take evidence so that the views of particular organisations appear on the public record. A number of organisations have expressed a desire to make representations to the committee, and we have to decide how to absorb that input.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Can we address the work programme and the suggested sequence of meetings on page three of the methodology paper. I want to make one comment and then we can talk about the rest of the paper. I am keen to ensure that we deliver on our commitment to undertake consultation in the Highlands and Islands before the turn of the year. It would be regrettable if we were unable to do that.Having said that, with the remaining scheduled Wednesday meetings, we probably have enough time to do one other inquiry. We would have the opportunity to meet nine groups or individuals to take evidence. We could have a detailed dialogue, which would give us a reasonable evidence base, in addition to any written submissions that would be available to committee members to read at any time. We could then reach our conclusions about the area of work before the turn of the year.Once we see how that pattern of activity is working out, there may be the opportunity to have a couple of 45-minute meetings on non-related topics, when we can invite organisations to meet us and give a 30-minute presentation on their areas of interest. A degree of balance is required. It is difficult to give a definitive answer to George's question without knowing the subject of the inquiry that we will embark upon. The paper refers to a number of subject areas for which we could spend a lot of time evidence gathering if we wanted to do the job properly, which obviously is what we want to do.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Let us look at the methodology paper, which gives us a feel for how we can operate. Then we can go on to the detailed discussions and come to some conclusions.Before we slot in the inquiry that we wish to have, one matter that I would like to have the committee's agreement on is the suggested work programme listed on page three, which proposes fortnightly meetings, the Highlands presentation and the objective of coming to some conclusion on the inquiry before the turn of the year.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

The committee controls its own work programme. What we have put together is one proposal that would see us completing an inquiry by the turn of the year. If the committee wants to conclude the first inquiry by Easter, it is within its control to do that.I would like to talk some more about the paper before we have a detailed dialogue about the issues that are involved. A number of issues must be borne in mind, some of which we have already touched on. It is my view, based on what the minister said to us, that it is unlikely that we will have to allocate any time to consider legislation. Inquiry time is therefore at our discretion and disposal. Most of the activity in the minister's departmental area will probably relate to Executive action. There may therefore be no legislation in either year 1 or year 2, but the Executive can advise us about that.The conveners group has made it clear that a certain amount of material will be referred to the committee from other sources. Some of that may be in the form of European directives referred to us by the European Committee, and public representations referred to us by the Public Petitions Committee. The convener of the Public Petitions Committee has made it clear that he wants other committees, so far as they are able, to give swift and prompt consideration to the petitions that are brought before the Parliament, and we want to respect that wish.Our primary work load, over the next year, will be non-legislative and we will be able to pursue inquiries at our discretion. We have scheduled a meeting on a Wednesday morning once a fortnight. The clerks have had some trouble slotting everything together to arrange that, fitting in with members' other commitments, so we do not have a great deal of room for manoeuvre to schedule additional hearings. I do not want to schedule hearings that will automatically disenfranchise members who cannot take part because of clashes, so we must be aware of those constraints. I have commented on whether we should conduct large or small inquiries; the committee must decide that. In our work so far, in the private session to hear representations from various organisations and the in the public hearing with the minister a fortnight ago, we covered a very wide canvas. I was anxious to ensure that we touched on each of the policy areas for which the minister is responsible. That leaves us with the essential frustration that we may not have drilled in as much detail as we would have liked in areas of interest. Our inquiries must therefore become much more focused and specific, with the objective of delivering some clear policy guidance to the Parliament, to ministers and to the wider public.The other point about innovation arises from some comments that Annabel Goldie made at our first meeting. We must engage in dialogue with the wider community and take part in site visits to companies that may want to make representations to us. That will be an essential part of how we go about our business.One point that struck me at the outset of our discussions at the first meeting was that there is a danger that we may look at the whole policy area as comprising an enterprise work load in one compartment and a lifelong learning work load in another. The purpose of the formation of the enterprise and lifelong learning department is to challenge that compartmentalisation, to acknowledge the relationship between enterprise policy and lifelong learning and to work on those linkages. I am anxious to inquire into subjects that enable us to pursue those links in our discussions. We must avoid duplication on matters on which the Executive has triggered an inquiry. For example, the Executive is pursuing an inquiry on student finance, so there is no requirement for us to duplicate that. The Government is also reviewing the tourism sector, so again that is best left to the Government—there may be a role for us at a later stage in considering the formulation of the tourism strategy. The House of Commons Scottish Affairs Select Committee has also examined some issues recently; we may want to note some of its findings in our deliberations.We should select topics on which we can add value to the policy-making process in the Scottish Parliament.Page 3 of the first paper, on the methodology of the work programme, outlines the structure of the work load that we can undertake, with the objective of completing one inquiry by the turn of the year. The committee can decide whether that is a satisfactory work load. We will now have a discussion on the methodology.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

We can debate whether to conclude in December, as that date was chosen arbitrarily.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

We will come back to that.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

We must get to the heart of the issue that Duncan raises. How can a situation be transformed in such a short time, when at one stage it appeared that prospects were extremely poor? Why has this company had the confidence to give a commitment that a number of other companies might have been able to give?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

There are two avenues. First, committee members could do it. Duncan, for example, could contact the clerks and raise with them the issue that he has raised here. We could also decide to write to the parties involved—the local enterprise company or the minister—to obtain quick information for the committee, which could be circulated.Secondly, we could build time into the structure of our meeting programme. We could, for example, spend the first two hours of each meeting dealing with our main line of inquiry, but keep an hour free to investigate topical issues that we think are relevant. Members could raise subjects that we might want to consider in slightly more depth. We could have a meeting at which representatives of the company, Scottish Enterprise or the local enterprise company involved appear and are questioned for half an hour. We would not be reaching conclusions, but providing an opportunity for material to reach the public domain in a more formal way and examining issues through questioning in committee. That would be a useful way of responding to some of the issues that get lost because we are concentrating on other matters.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

We can build it into the work programme. I can ask the clerks to inquire into this case and to make their findings available to members.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

That takes us on to the subject inquiries that we may want to conduct, but I take Elaine's point.Further to Allan's comments, it might be helpful at this stage to agree on a process. If a member feels, like Duncan, that they have a specific issue to raise, they should be free to mention it to the clerks. The clerks, depending on their work load—I am anxious not to place enormous additional burdens on them, as they are very busy already—could pursue those issues on behalf of members, after discussing with me how much work needs to be done and so on. Their findings can be made available to members on a continuous basis. At committee meetings we can then discuss what inquiries we want to make to follow up some of that material. Does that meet with broad agreement?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

If we wanted to allocate an hour of our time every fortnight for a topical inquiry in which witnesses would appear before us, giving short notice would make it difficult for many of the people whom we want to see. On the other hand, there are many people who want to appear before the committee.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I was halfway through summing up our discussion of the work programme. Members' comments have been helpful. I take it that we are broadly agreed that we will complete one major inquiry before Christmas.The one issue that we still have to settle concerns our meeting in the Highlands. When we planned our informal seminar in August, we felt that it was inappropriate to summon to Edinburgh Highlands and Islands Enterprise and other organisations representing the Highlands. I envisage at this stage a one-day exercise in information gathering. For the sake of convenience, it would be sensible for that to take place in Inverness—although it would not bother me if Highlands and Islands Enterprise and other organisations wanted to meet somewhere else. The aim of the exercise would be to familiarise the committee with the issues that the body of opinion in the Highlands and Islands would want us to consider as part of our on-going work.The issue of visits outwith Edinburgh has been discussed by the conveners committee and the Presiding Officer, and a process for securing agreement to such visits has to be gone through. I am anxious for us to reach agreement on this now for two reasons. First, as Elaine said, people's diaries are very congested and I want to give as much notice as possible. Secondly, we must jump through several hoops before we can establish that the visit is valid and legitimate. Because the minister's remit covers policy on the Highlands and Islands, it seems to me to be legitimate for us to want to have that area's perspective. Although this is something for the committee to decide, I would prefer the meeting to take the form of a public hearing.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Where are we now—Lochgilphead?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I have an open mind on that and will take guidance from the committee on it. Fergus, I can feel a plug for Inverness coming on.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Thanks for that. Are there any other points on the methodology?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

This committee discussed the importance of properly looking at issues from the Highlands and Islands perspective. We deliberately did not invite organisations from that area to come to our seminar in August because we intended to visit the Highlands and Islands to talk to them. A number of organisations there have perspectives that relate to our remit—the University of the Highlands and Islands, for example, has an interesting perspective on the approach to the learning environment and would have a great deal to say to us. Highlands and Islands Enterprise has taken pains to express that it is a different organisation from Scottish Enterprise and there might be lessons that one enterprise company can learn from the other.The purpose of the exercise is to familiarise the committee with the issues in the Highlands and Islands that are relevant to our remit. It is not a detailed inquiry; it is a one-day study visit to one place with a programme that—to take on board Elaine's point—allows us to use public transport.The purpose of the visit is to ensure that the proper attention is given to a perspective to which committees in Westminster were not always able to give their full attention. We have the lead responsibility for Highlands and Islands policy in the Parliament.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I seek agreement from the committee that we make approaches to the conveners committee and the Parliamentary Bureau to make that visit at a convenient time—ideally in the second week of the October recess—and that we arrange meetings with the organisations that have made representations to us. Is that agreed? It is agreed.The next paper before us is on potential subjects for inquiry. In compiling it, the clerks and I considered all the issues that have been raised by members of the committee, by external organisations, by other members of Parliament and by the minister in his discussions with the committee. I do not plan to go through each point in great detail as they are fairly self-explanatory. On Executive rapid response, we have had representations from, for example, shop stewards at Kvaerner about the situation during the summer—although the situation has improved since then. We have had representations from Clackmannanshire Council and the members of the Parliament—Nick Johnston, George Reid and Richard Simpson—who have been involved in the difficult economic circumstances in the area during the summer. We have put those issues in the context of economic dislocation, through either the loss of individual plants or the concentration of difficulties in an area. Ten years ago, when I gathered my experience of the economic development sphere, area economic development strategies were in vogue for dealing with such problems. Those strategies have become unfashionable now, but I wonder whether there might be some merit in them.On the fourth point in the paper, Nick Johnston has suggested that the co-ordination and performance of economic development services in Scotland should be considered in terms of the effectiveness of the local enterprise companies structure.The committee has discussed tourism, which is the fifth point. The minister is leading a consultation exercise on tourism strategy. There is a question about whether now is the appropriate time for this committee to become involved, given the recent select committee report from the House of Commons and given that a tourism strategy paper is due to be published at the turn of the year. We might want to become involved at that point.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I shall conclude my comments on the paper and we shall return to some specific issues. We have had comments on the rates burden on individual companies, which comes under item 9 on our list of potential subjects for inquiry. Material on that subject has been given to us by the Federation of Small Businesses. The Confederation of British Industry has made other representations to us about economic statistics.My final point relates to item 14 on the list: e-commerce. There is a reference there to the work of the House of Commons Select Committee on Trade and Industry in this field. I have twice tried to meet Martin O'Neill, the chairman of that committee, but on both occasions, for various reasons, I had to cancel the meetings. I want to have a chat with him to get up to speed with the work of his committee so that we can close off any issues that we may be duplicating.With those comments, I open the discussion. I ask members to try to focus on the subject matter that we should examine in the period until Christmas—the broader inquiries and the more specific hearings that we could have on individual subjects. There might also be speculation about what we might want to knock into the work load for the start of the period from January. I welcome contributions. I also welcome David Davidson, who has just joined us.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

So, you have 14 favourite cakes? Laughter.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

That is a few fewer than I have.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

My view is that the committee should do exactly what you have said, Annabel. I think that all members would sign up to the test of whether something is productive and constructive, and whether it helps policy making and gives a signal to the wider community that this committee can suggest ideas that can make a positive difference. It is a question of what subject area we can use to express that point. That is the nub of it. Do you want to make some suggestions, Annabel?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

That has to be this morning's last cake analogy. We will have to take a break at 11:15 for some pastries.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Thank you, that would be helpful.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I am anxious to keep us focused on the agenda and subject areas. We can return to other points later.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

They will have their cakes, biscuits and political ornamentation.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

We have had a good expression of views. Marilyn's contribution was helpful in addressing the point that we have reached on this issue. There is a general view that we should take a good look at local economic development services. However, if we do that it is inevitable—as we reach the boundaries of that review—that we will touch on the issues raised by Marilyn. Those are important issues about the relationship with workplace training and how the different elements of funding fit together. I have looked closely at the FAST-TRAC proposals and a lot of material has been passed to me by Roger Mullin, who is part of the Inter-ed company, and other contacts in Fife. That material has been made available to the committee. I have been fascinated by the innovation involved and level of agreement on the issue. However, I do not share Marilyn's optimism that that model has been extended throughout the country.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I qualify what I said. Whether such good practice will actually be extended is a big issue. In effect, three issues have attracted members: the economic development services; workplace training and a coherent education and training strategy; and issues relating to rating revaluation. We could not do the economic development services review without touching on the issues raised by Marilyn, and we certainly cannot do it before Christmas. I put into the pot the suggestion that we draw those points together and conduct an inquiry into the delivery at a local level of local economic development and further education and training services in Scotland. That could be a longer inquiry, taking us beyond the turn of the year—we could not do it justice in three evidence-taking sessions. The clerks could look at when it would be credible to conduct all the necessary inquiries and come to conclusions. In the interim, we could do the exercise on rating revaluation that was suggested by a couple of members.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Are you quite comfortable with my proposal about drawing those two areas together?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

The clerks have flagged up the issue of the potential overlap with the work of the Local Government Committee. I would certainly be breaching the agreements reached in the conveners group if I did not check with the Convener of the Local Government Committee. That is a piece of housekeeping that I will deal with immediately and I will confirm at our next meeting what discussions have taken place. We will need to wait two weeks for clarification, but I will try to make some progress.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I knew that the European Committee had been considering this question, but I did not know how closely. That is helpful to know. I will speak to Hugh Henry about the views of this committee. We do not want to overlap with the work of other committees.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I want, first, to discuss the issue with the Convener of the Local Government Committee, to get some guidance on where it is on the subject. We will also consider the on-going preparation that will be needed for an inquiry.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Are there any other comments on the work programme, before I move on?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

We have had a good discussion. We are largely agreed that we will undertake a substantial inquiry into the delivery of local economic development services and into the organisations that carry out that work. Additionally, as part of that inquiry, we will examine how workplace training is delivered and supported as a key part of the economic development strategy.I will draw up a detailed remit, send it to members, ideally by e-mail—or e-commerce, if you prefer—and seek comments and agreement on it from members. I will want the remit to be formally approved as the first item on the agenda of our meeting in two weeks' time but, in consultation with the clerks, I would like individual agreement to the contents of the remit—and any comments or suggested alterations—in the next 48 hours. That will help us to define how we carry out the exercise. If the methodology for agreeing the remit is acceptable, I will now take views from members on what people who wish to make representations to us we should see first.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Yes. Effectively, the remit will be a merger of items 4, 7 and 8. I am anxious that we define a remit that structures exactly what we are examining and what our end product will be. That cannot be done by committee; we will need to go away and put the remit on paper and then get it to you so that it can be agreed in due course.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

George has made a fair point. We are certainly no longer talking about completing an inquiry by Christmas—it will not all be over by Christmas.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Perhaps by the next one, yes. Our programme will run well into next year and I am reluctant to fix a definitive end point. We must consider the volume of material that we will be surveying and the type of organisations and individuals that we want to see, and we must begin to schedule that work. The suggestion about interim conclusions in certain areas is helpful and may signpost some of the work that we carry out.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I do not want to give any agreement to taking steps on that, although the committee recognises that it is a serious issue, until I have had a chance to discuss it with the Convener of the Local Government Committee. To say anything before then would get us into a fankle. It will be an agenda item for the next committee meeting for me to report back on that and decide where to go next.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

There will be great enthusiasm in the communities that operate economic development schemes in further education colleges and workplace training centres. They will be delighted that the committee has made their subject a priority.The plethora of organisations involved in our exercise a month ago was bewildering, so we must approach this area carefully and in a constructive way to find a method of delivering services more effectively to give the public better value. Do members want to suggest any organisations that we should contact, or should I discuss the matter with the clerks and report back in due course?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Thank you. That draws the discussion on the work programme to a close.

  1. Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Wednesday 15 September 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 4
  2. Work Programme Procedure · 121
  3. Other Business Committee business · 49

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.