As I understand it, this is an attempt to give us the basic machinery, within which we can flex. As Margo said, something that we all agree is paramount may demand our attention. In terms of the structure of our work programme, is that not a reasonable proposal?
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Annabel Goldie only · show everyone- John Swinney SNP 44
- Margo MacDonald SNP 14
- George Lyon LD 11
- Allan Wilson Lab 10
- Annabel Goldie Con 9
- Duncan McNeil Lab 8
- Fergus Ewing SNP 5
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 5
- David Davidson Con 4
- Elaine Murray Lab 3
- Elaine Thomson Lab 3
- Nick Johnston Con 2
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Simon Watkins Committee Clerk 1
Annabel Goldie’s contributions
9 contributionsI seek to broaden the discussion a little. I am very much in sympathy with what Marilyn says. My dilemma, when considering this issue, is that it is like being presented with a plate of my favourite cakes—I simply do not know which one to go for.
With no difficulty.
As a committee, we are anxious about the two audiences that are relevant to us: those who have an interest in lifelong learning and those who have an interest in enterprise. We need to reassure them that, in three to four months, we have been a good advertisement for what we are here to do. This is my dilemma: when I look at the list of potential topics, I realise that there are two possible approaches. We could go for something that seems fairly neat and containable, but which is more reactionary than innovatory. On the other hand, some of the topics are chunky and, as Marilyn indicated, give the committee scope for some really good, solid work.My question—and I welcome the views of other members on it—is that, if we are to give a good advertisement for the Parliament and this committee by producing something that is genuinely positive, constructive and useful to the audience to whom we should relate, should we not be careful about our selection of topic, bearing those broad criteria in mind?
Yes, I want to expand on that. I am looking with great interest—and, I have to say, great personal selfishness—at topic 9 on our list of potential subjects for inquiry, which concerns our small and medium enterprises and rating revaluation. We know that there is a real and on-going agony in the small-business community, which could be aggravated by the impost of revaluation. SMEs make up a huge sector of Scotland's economic activity, and if we are to look at that sector, we should consider it fairly neatly and effectively in the short term. I would be interested in Fergus's views on that. A lot of the information that we need is already available, but we must co-ordinate it. That offers the prospect of taking on something that is manageable, worthwhile to a significant part of our business community and will, I hope, allow us to come up with some sensible recommendations. I would plump for that issue as my first choice.
I have eaten the cakes, Allan.
To be slightly polemical, I think that item 4 is the most important subject. I did not choose it first because I think that it needs a lot more time than the period between now and Christmas. That is why I expressed a preference for item 9, on SMEs and rating revaluation. As a second topic—and one that will take a chunky period of time—4 is my choice.
That is the difficulty. Fergus is correct: we need either to act now or forget about it. The imperative is to examine the small business sector and to offer constructive advice now. If we cannot do that, the issue almost slips off the agenda.
It is considering the broad issue, George.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Sep 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Wednesday 15 September 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 4
- Work Programme Procedure · 121
- Other Business Committee business · 49
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.