Are we discussing both papers together and then coming to a conclusion on both the methodology and the potential subjects for inquiry?
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Allan Wilson only · show everyone- John Swinney SNP 44
- Margo MacDonald SNP 14
- George Lyon LD 11
- Allan Wilson Lab 10
- Annabel Goldie Con 9
- Duncan McNeil Lab 8
- Fergus Ewing SNP 5
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 5
- David Davidson Con 4
- Elaine Murray Lab 3
- Elaine Thomson Lab 3
- Nick Johnston Con 2
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Simon Watkins Committee Clerk 1
Allan Wilson’s contributions
10 contributionsThe paper is laid out effectively, to help us come to a decision on methodology. You have mentioned the major factors that will influence our decision. I accept that balance between the enterprise and the lifelong learning aspects of our role is important. If we find a subject that combines both, so much the better. I agree that it would be pointless to replicate the work of House of Commons select committees, Cubie and work that has been done on inward and outward investment. I hope that by the conclusion of our deliberations we will have made a difference, so it is important that we get our strategy right at the outset.The proposed work programme for us between now and mid-December seems satisfactory. Whether to have an additional meeting in the October recess was discussed at the European Committee. I would not rule out having a meeting in the second week of the October recess, if our work load makes that necessary.With the proviso of a possible additional meeting, should circumstances necessitate it, the work programme is fine.
Is that a form of rapid response in reverse? Are we proposing that we examine the rapidity of the Executive's response not only to large-scale industrial closures, but to major investment and job-creating projects?
What sort of time scale are you suggesting? Would we need to give a minimum of a week's notice for an item to be included on the agenda?
I am in favour of taking the committee to venues outwith the Edinburgh-Glasgow-Inverness triangle. There are two islands in my constituency that would be suitable, and the isle of Arran combines the highlands and the islands in one place. However, in the first instance, I favour the Inverness option for holding a public inquiry, as that is more easily accessible. Thinking back to when I was involved in other organisations, I suggest that competitive tendering would be a good idea. A lot of organisations are anxious to meet us and they might be prepared to make a contribution to the cost of our going to see them. That would minimise the cost to the taxpayer. There are a number of options, as Duncan said.
I agree entirely with what Duncan and George have said. It is important to get the balance right, as we said in our discussion on methodology. There are 14 important topics for inquiry, discussion and review. If they are 14 cakes, two of them are cream-cakes.
My apologies to fellow members. Point 4 deals with the co-ordination and performance of economic development services. I agree with George; the questions that are posed under that heading are crucial to the Scottish economy. Are there too many agencies delivering economic development in Scotland? Do they overlap? In the context of our saying that we should have meaningful discussions, I think that that is the point that stands out. As Duncan and Marilyn said, point 4 is linked to FE expansion and finance and to workplace training, which should be combined under a single heading. Workplace training could be examined in an inquiry into the enterprise network, but it is probably better kept as a secondary priority. I say all that with no disrespect to the relative merits of small businesses and rating revaluation, which, as Fergus suggested, could be dealt with as a single item using the convener's model of a rapid response for the committee's work programme.
There is a specific reference to rating revaluation in the list of potential subjects. I have corresponded with the convener about some of the other matters we have discussed, such as the Scottish Qualifications Authority and whether the Education, Culture and Sport Committee should take lead responsibility for the development of higher still. A similar question arises in relation to rating revaluation, in so far as it strays into the remit of the Local Government Committee. It could be argued that that committee should be the lead committee on rating revaluation. I would like that to be clarified by the two committees before we start to examine the matter. We should not look at it separately from discussions with the Convener of the Local Government Committee. The same applies to the Education, Culture and Sport Committee and higher still.
It is hardly academic to the business community to whom rates are paid. That statement ought to be corrected for the record.
The latter suggestion is probably the appropriate one at this juncture.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Sep 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Wednesday 15 September 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 4
- Work Programme Procedure · 121
- Other Business Committee business · 49
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.