In the paper on methodology, five further Wednesday morning meetings are scheduled before the end of the year. From your experience of how long inquiries at Westminster usually last, will five meetings give us the chance to undertake a big inquiry, or should we be thinking about doing a couple of small ones? We need to consider the experience south of the border to enable us to decide.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing George Lyon only · show everyone- John Swinney SNP 44
- Margo MacDonald SNP 14
- George Lyon LD 11
- Allan Wilson Lab 10
- Annabel Goldie Con 9
- Duncan McNeil Lab 8
- Fergus Ewing SNP 5
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 5
- David Davidson Con 4
- Elaine Murray Lab 3
- Elaine Thomson Lab 3
- Nick Johnston Con 2
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Simon Watkins Committee Clerk 1
George Lyon’s contributions
11 contributionsI have no problems with the work programme, but it narrows down the subject matter of the inquiry that we can undertake. If we want to have a conclusion on an issue by December, it cannot be a wide-ranging inquiry.
Before we move on, what Fergus said about the Highlands and Islands is very important. Do you have in mind a date when we could meet there? I also want to stress that the Highlands and Islands are not just Inverness. We need to bear that in mind when deciding where to hold the meeting.
We need to give a strong signal to rural Scotland that the Parliament will reach out and engage with it.
It is important that we do not get stuck in the mindset that we can meet only in Glasgow, Edinburgh or Inverness.
I agree with Marilyn. We must give a clear signal that we want to take a balanced approach to both of this committee's responsibilities. Workplace training is causing great concern in my part of the world. I spent Monday with Argyll Training, an organisation that has expressed great concern over some of the schemes and the way in which they are working.On the business side, the biggest drivers, in terms of the levers that the Scottish Executive can use to influence the Scottish economy, are the economic development agencies, which are responsible for £0.5 billion of spending. If we, as a committee, are to get a fundamental knowledge of what is happening out there and how the Executive can influence economic performance in Scotland, that is the area that we must address as a priority. I appreciate that that is a big subject for us to tackle, but we must treat item 4 on our list—"Co-ordination and Performance of Economic Development Services"—as a priority.Our understanding of how those organisations work, and of the effect that they have on the Scottish economy, is central to our ability to address the longer-term issue of the performance of the Scottish economy and how the Scottish Executive can affect that performance. I appreciate that that is a big subject and that we may have to weigh up which issue to tackle first, but that is my choice.
To return to Margo's point, we set priorities and then the work load has to be shifted around. Although we would like to deliver some sort of definitive statement around Christmas to demonstrate that the committee has done some work, we should not let that get in the way of our priorities. A strong preference for item 4—and the concept of linking the enterprise network to workplace training—has been expressed. We should start the inquiry as soon as we can.
The links exist. We are going into a big inquiry, but it is the kind of thing that we should be doing.
My understanding is that the Local Government Committee is debating local government funding, including rating. That is the relevant place to debate those matters.
There will need to be discussions with colleagues on the Local Government Committee. There is no point in our work overlapping.
It is very important that we should tackle the remit as a series of separate blocks, as the inquiry will cover a huge area. We could end up with a report that means nothing, and just skim the surface, as we tended to do in some of our initial discussions. The linkages within the remit are clear, but we will have to break the work load down so that we can get to grips with the issues that underlie the structures and come to meaningful conclusions. That may mean that the work programme goes over into next year and that there are a series of breaks in which we come to interim conclusions. I would be very disappointed if we ended up with a bland conclusion. That would mean that we had not got into the nitty-gritty of the issues. The committee must understand what it is talking about, understand where the levers are and how they work, and reach sensible conclusions.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Sep 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Wednesday 15 September 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 4
- Work Programme Procedure · 121
- Other Business Committee business · 49
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.