I think that it is quite an insulting way to treat us. The BBC is rebutting the trade unionists in a way that allows it to control how it is examined by the committee.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Joan McAlpine only · show everyone- Stewart Maxwell SNP 36
- Liz Smith Con 11
- Neil Findlay Lab 9
- Joan McAlpine SNP 8
- George Adam SNP 7
- Colin Beattie SNP 6
- Liam McArthur LD 6
- Neil Bibby Lab 4
- Clare Adamson SNP 2
Joan McAlpine’s contributions
8 contributionsI endorse what Liz Smith suggested. Is the highest authority the BBC trust’s chairman, Lord Patten, if he is responsible for governance?
When did you receive that correspondence?
I was very disappointed that Twitter knew about the letter before the committee did.
First, I think that the fact that the letter appeared on Twitter and in the press before it was made available to the committee convener shows that it is a politically motivated initiative.On the criticisms of the convener, I think that the convener has always conducted himself impeccably. Not everything that we say should be interpreted as the view of the committee. The deputy convener often says things that I disagree with, but as a committee member I do not think that when he talks about various aspects of education he is speaking for me. On the scrutiny provided by the committee, I think that our budget report, when it is published, will show that the committee is a very effective vehicle for scrutiny. Given that our work programme includes looking at college regionalisation, I think that the scrutiny of that issue will be as robust as anything that we have done. There will be an opportunity to look at the issue then.
Representatives of all the trade unions gave evidence during the budget process. As I recall, the Educational Institute of Scotland’s spokesman for the further and higher education sectors was pretty critical of the Government. He did not appear to be intimidated: he criticised the Government’s approach but he said nothing about bullying and intimidation. None of our witnesses has said anything about bullying and intimidation, either in our budget meetings or in meetings last year, when we heard from several college principals. I do not know where the concerns are coming from, given that in all the critical evidence that we heard, bullying was not mentioned.
I want to respond to that point on the record. The cabinet secretary has had two debates on colleges in which it was possible to scrutinise him. He is also answering questions; I believe that, for education portfolio questions this week, every single question is on college reform, and I understand that topical question time last week ran over because there were questions about college reform and the Presiding Officer allowed many supplementary questions. No one can doubt that the cabinet secretary has been put under considerable scrutiny, and we will have an opportunity to scrutinise him again when the committee covers college regionalisation.
I back the Labour Party’s original proposal. We will have an opportunity to question the cabinet secretary during our discussions on college regionalisation as part of bill scrutiny.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Nov 2012 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 6
- 10:00 Skills Development Scotland Evidence session · 152
- 10:00 Work Programme Procedure · 89
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.