Convener, can you update us on whether the matter has been discussed by the Conveners Group in relation to not just the BBC but witnesses at parliamentary committees in general?
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Liz Smith only · show everyone- Stewart Maxwell SNP 36
- Liz Smith Con 11
- Neil Findlay Lab 9
- Joan McAlpine SNP 8
- George Adam SNP 7
- Colin Beattie SNP 6
- Liam McArthur LD 6
- Neil Bibby Lab 4
- Clare Adamson SNP 2
Liz Smith’s contributions
11 contributionsThe committee’s general and I think pretty unanimous feeling is that this does not help the scrutiny process of the Parliament and the committee system in particular. As a result, I suggest that we raise the general issue.
Do Westminster committees have powers to bring people before them?
I recommend that you as convener—on the committee’s behalf, obviously, as the feeling is unanimous—directly appeal to the highest authority in the BBC; indicate our disappointment; suggest that, whatever our views on the matter might be, in the lead-up to the referendum debate it does not help good scrutiny of, as someone has pointed out, a public institution if it will not appear before the committee; and make strong representation that the decision be reversed.11:30
If we were in another Parliament, it would be compelled to appear—
As we develop our work programme, there is an issue about the scrutiny process in general. There are various issues in the Parliament at the moment about what constitutes effective scrutiny and its publication. Joan McAlpine has also raised an important point. It is absolutely right and proper that there should be the correct timescale.Generally speaking, I think that there is an issue about the scrutiny process in any committee of the Parliament, not just this one. I had cause to look at various bits of the standing orders recently, and I understand that we must ensure that the convener of any committee represents the views of their committee. Therefore, any statement that is made on our behalf must be agreed to. That has not been the case over the past two weeks, and not just within this committee. We must be careful, when we develop our work programme, that the correct witnesses are brought to the committee, that the cabinet secretary has a specific role that is very clearly laid out and that the convener has a specific role. We must also be careful in how we approach not only the study of an issue but the decision making in reaching our conclusions. That is something that we need to tighten up on.
Convener, thank you for clarifying that point. Given that your comments were made prior to other evidence appearing about difficulties with the numbers and various data that we were provided with, might you have changed your mind since then?
Forgive me, convener, but that is a separate issue. We can speak as spokesmen for our parties, but that is not the same as speaking for the committee.
I want to put on the public record again that I think that the issue is scrutiny; it is not to do with personalities. There is a fundamental issue about scrutiny of a cabinet secretary and how he or she operates in the sectors. I am not commenting one way or the other, but we have a significant concern of which we need to be mindful, so I very much agree with Liam McArthur’s points.
I am fine with that.
I support what Liam McArthur and the two Neils said.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Nov 2012 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 6
- 10:00 Skills Development Scotland Evidence session · 152
- 10:00 Work Programme Procedure · 89
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.