I echo that comment. In its conclusion, the BBC reiterates the reasons why it did not attend, but the fact that it has submitted written evidence, which is quite helpful in providing a context for what we heard the other week from the union representatives, slightly undermines the reasons that it set out for not appearing. I think that the BBC has entirely needlessly got itself on a bit of a spike here.
The explanations for non-appearance seem to be a combination of, “We’ve already appeared before the committee on this issue,” and, “It would be inappropriate to carry out industrial relations negotiations in a public forum such as a parliamentary committee.” However, the BBC has undermined its second argument with its written submission and, as for the first argument, the question whether its appearance is appropriate is surely a judgment for the committee. It is of course up to the BBC what it chooses to say or not to say when it comes before us; after all, we have had plenty of witnesses who have indicated that there is territory that, for whatever reason, they do not feel able to go into. We can only imagine how the BBC would cover this if another witness were involved, and I think that we should impress that point on it.
I echo the comment that I made to you privately, convener, about the timeframe within which the letter was received and reiterate the apology for that discourtesy, although I suggest that it is perhaps a little synthetic of Joan McAlpine to complain about those particular inconsistencies.As Liz Smith says, there are wider concerns about the scrutiny process. It was not helpful that, on the back of the decision by Kirk Ramsay to resign, you found yourself on a programme with a story that was changing by the hour. That put the committee in a difficult position, as you were represented as the convener of the committee rather than a spokesman for your party. I have no real concerns about the ability of the committee to undertake its role to date. We have had healthy and robust discussions on a range of issues and have had the opportunity to express our differences of opinion where appropriate.On the issue that arose around the cabinet secretary’s behaviour in relation to the chair of Stow College, there is a commonly held view that the cabinet secretary’s behaviour towards some of the leading figures in the college sector goes beyond what is healthy and needs to be looked at, not simply in relation to the reform programme and regionalisation, which command wider support than Mr Russell sometimes seeks to portray. When a cabinet secretary demands the resignation of a college chair, that throws up serious questions about his judgment and the relationship that he has with the sector. Therefore, I think that it is worthy of specific review by the committee.
It is dangerous to suggest that this is politically motivated. I cannot speak for others, but I am certain that if a Labour or Liberal Democrat minister had called into his office a chair of a college and demanded his resignation, there would be calls from each of the SNP members of this committee for some form of inquiry if not into that specific incident then into the relationship between ministers and the sector. I do not believe that this is politically motivated and think that there are sufficient concerns to address.It should surprise no one that a series of college principals has not popped up on the airwaves in recent days to denounce the cabinet secretary. However, at least a couple of the other chairs have expressed concern about the education secretary’s management style, and a number of trade unions at specific colleges have expressed grave concern. That is sufficient to suggest that some form of inquiry is justified.As I said, the problem might have been triggered by the reforms and regionalisation, but it goes wider than that. Some members were made aware of concerns in the primary and secondary sector about the implementation of curriculum for excellence, in particular, which speak to the concerns that have emerged from the college sector.I dispute the suggestion that the initiative is politically motivated. There is justification for an inquiry into the cabinet secretary’s relationship with the college sector. I do not think that such work would sit comfortably with a wider investigation into regionalisation, but if that is where it needs to sit we will find a way of accommodating it.
We invited the EIS to give evidence and to answer questions on the budget. Had that meeting taken place after the events in relation to Kirk Ramsay, I think that we might have been inclined to pursue a line of inquiry in that regard, and I suspect that we would have got a different response. The argument that there is no case to answer because Larry Flanagan did not mention the issue when he gave evidence on the budget does not stack up.Enough has happened in the context of the events relating to the chair of Stow College and issues that a number of members have picked up anecdotally. I accept what Clare Adamson said about there being no common consent, but I think that enough of us have heard similar stories from across the college sector and other parts of the education landscape to suggest that we are entirely justified in asking that work be done by the committee.
My preference is to have something that would stand apart from our work on college regionalisation. There would be a requirement to do that sooner rather than later, notwithstanding the work to which we are already committed in relation to the inquiry. That might be before the Christmas recess or immediately after it, but that would be the timeframe.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.