Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 27 November 2012 Education and Culture Committee About 10:00 Procedure 89 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Stewart Maxwell only · show everyone

Stewart Maxwell’s contributions

36 contributions
Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Item 3 is to discuss our future work programme. The clerks have prepared a paper showing the current work programme as agreed. Members now have the opportunity to discuss that paper and any other areas that they wish to suggest.I will begin the discussion by referring members to annex A of the work programme paper, which is a response from BBC Scotland to the evidence that was presented to the committee on 30 October by the trade unions. As members will be aware, we requested on more than one occasion that BBC management come to give oral evidence to the committee, but they declined to do so and have instead submitted a written rebuttal of the unions’ evidence, if I can put it in that fashion. Do members have any comments on this area?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am sorry, but I did that prior to the start of the meeting. For the Official Report, I say that the BBC sent a response to us saying that it was not willing to come to the committee on this issue but meant no disrespect to the committee. I will just give the exact wording so that we are clear on it and so that members are aware of what has happened. The statement said:“We would respectfully decline the invitation to attend an evidence session with the Education and Culture Committee for the reasons set out within the conclusions to the paper submitted earlier this week. This, in no sense, is intended to be or should be regarded as disrespect towards the Parliament.”I am sorry, Colin, but I just wanted to ensure that everybody was aware of what was said.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

It was raised briefly earlier in the session as something that we should keep an eye on. As you know, there have been a couple of cases, particularly as far as this committee is concerned, in which people who had been approached to be witnesses declined to come forward. However, the issue seems to have receded since then and, as far as I am aware, this is the only case in recent times.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

That is helpful. Just for clarity, I point out that I sought guidance on whether we could make a stronger request or indeed require the people in question to attend. However, that is outwith the Parliament’s powers. I certainly cannot force the BBC to attend the committee—we just do not have the authority—and we are therefore left with the current situation in which the BBC has declined to attend and has instead provided a written submission.The question for the committee is, as we are about to discuss, what we do about that. We have a number of options: we can do nothing and leave things as they are; we can write back to the BBC with various questions and points that the committee might want to raise; we can write and publish a report; and we can seek a debate in the chamber before or after the publication of that report. I seek guidance and comments from committee members on those options.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I certainly agree. I think that the BBC’s evidence is unhelpful and has indeed undermined its own argument. In any case, as members will be aware and will agree, the committee would not discuss or debate private negotiations between a trade union and management on wages, conditions or redundancy packages and I do not accept that that is a valid argument for not attending the committee. Indeed, I think that that is what Liam McArthur has just indicated.What do members wish to do with this?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am happy to do that, although we have asked the BBC to give evidence twice recently.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

It would not have to be compelled—it would appear.I am happy to do what is suggested. One option is to write, and we have already written. Helpfully, the clerk has just handed me the most recent letter that I sent to the then director general on 2 November—the postholder has changed since then. How do members feel about writing in the way that Liz Smith suggested?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

We can write to either the chairman or the director general and copy the letter to the other person. If the committee is minded to write, we will work out who to write to and copy in the other individual.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Of course. The letter would be circulated for members’ agreement before it was submitted in my name, on the committee’s behalf.What do members feel about the evidence that has been received? Do we want to begin to write our report?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Nothing prevents us from doing both things. If we start to draft the report, it will not be available for publication immediately, as we will have to consider it. At the same time, we could write in the way that Liz Smith proposed. If the BBC reverses its decision and comes to give evidence, that will help the committee in producing its report. If it refuses for a third time, we can finish our report. Do members agree to proceed on that basis?Members indicated agreement.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Another issue that has emerged in the past two weeks relates to college regionalisation and reform. The committee will be aware that I received a letter from the four Opposition members on the committee, which was circulated along with my response last week. I circulated that letter to members immediately because it was in the public domain and so that members could see it.Before receiving that letter, I received correspondence from Mr Findlay, which said:“Dear Convener,Given the weekend coverage of the call by the Cabinet Secretary, Mike Russell for the Chair of Stow College to resign, I would urge you, as Chair of the Education and Culture committee to recall the Cabinet Secretary to the committee to give evidence on this episode as part of our sessions on the colleges and the regionalisation agenda.”My response to Mr Findlay said:“It would be my intention to call the Cabinet Secretary to appear before the committee on the issue of college reform and I think we may have already agreed to do that when we discussed the work programme recently. I am sure there are a number of witnesses we would want to hear from on the regionalisation issue.”

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

The email from Mr Findlay came at 5 pm on 12 November and I responded at 10 to 8 the same evening. The letter was dated 14 November, which was a Wednesday, but I did not receive it on that day. Members will be aware that the letter was with the press on Wednesday at lunch time, when I was made aware of it through comments by journalists on Twitter. It subsequently appeared in the press on the Thursday. Neither I nor the clerks had received it by the afternoon of 15 November, but then I—luckily—bumped into Liam McArthur and I asked him for a copy of it. The media relations officer for the committee was being asked for comment and a response to the letter from me, as the convener. The letter was in the public domain with journalists on the Wednesday lunch time, and I eventually received it some 25 or 26 hours later, on the Thursday afternoon.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

It is unfortunate that, for whatever reason, the letter appeared in the press and in social media forums before it was received by the committee, either by the clerks or by me. That is unfortunate, but it is by the by. That happened last week. We now have, in effect, two bits of correspondence on the same matter. I ask members to comment on those issues, given that they now have all the information that I have.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Thank you. Do other members have comments?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am happy to respond to that. I expressed my view on the information as it was available at the time. Clearly, it is always the case—that is why I have put this item on the agenda—that the committee decides these things. I expressed my view, not the view of the committee. I thought, and still think, that the position that I expressed at the time was based on the evidence that was available.As I said to Mr McArthur in the earlier discussion to which he alluded, it is unfortunate that it was portrayed that I had some sort of power to block the committee’s decision. I do not have such a power and I did not say that I have such a power—of course, the issue is for the committee to decide—and I accept that that is unfortunate. I certainly do not want members to feel that I was trying to speak on their behalf or override their rights to discuss these matters or decide the committee’s work programme. That is why I immediately requested that a discussion of the work programme should be on the first available committee agenda.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I will answer that specific point, but let me first ask whether any other members want to speak.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

For everyone’s benefit—I know that you are probably not going to reveal anything—I should say that the budget report is still confidential, as it has not yet been published and is still with the Finance Committee. Before we go on, I just want to ensure that no one discusses any details of our budget report.11:45

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am sure that you did not, Mr Adam, but I just wanted to make sure.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

It is a separate matter. I do not want to have an extended discussion on an issue that is not central to the work programme. This item is about the work programme, and our discussion should stick to that subject.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am sorry but, as I said earlier, I do not want to get into this matter. This is a discussion about the work programme. In the interview, I was responding to a question about my view on the issue. That is my view on it. Can we stick to the matter in hand, which is the work programme?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Does Liam McArthur want to respond to that? I do not want to curtail debate on the issue; I want to give members as much opportunity as they want to make points. I am quite happy for you to come back in, if you want to do so.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I will sum up the proposals that are before us, but I first ask whether members have any other comments.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Everybody has had their say.There has been correspondence between Mr Findlay and me. It was not in the public domain, which is why I did not circulate it, but everybody now has a copy. I hope that everybody heard me the first time but, for Colin Beattie’s benefit, I will read it again. It states:“Given the weekend coverage of the call by the Cabinet Secretary, Mike Russell for the Chair of Stow College to resign. I would urge you, as Chair of the Education and Culture committee to recall the Cabinet Secretary to the committee to give evidence on this episode as part of our sessions on the colleges and the regionalisation agenda.”It is clear that we have a difference of opinion on the work programme. On the work programme more widely, we have already agreed to do a number of things. We still have to deal with the Donaldson review of teacher education. We have asked members to suggest possible witnesses; some members have responded, for which I am grateful. We also have the post-16 education reform bill, which I believe will be published this week and will come to us in the new year. Those are the main items. I will not go through all the others—the paper sets them out. We have our current inquiry into the decision-making process in removing children from the parental home, as well as some petitions, secondary legislation and other matters. That is the current work programme.In effect, we have two proposals on the same issue. One, which was originally made by the Labour Party, is that we ask the cabinet secretary to“give evidence on this episode as part of our sessions on the colleges and the regionalisation agenda.”We then had a subsequent letter and the further comments today. I am paraphrasing but, in effect, the second suggestion is that we have a separate inquiry on the issue. I think that Liz Smith talked about a “scrutiny process”. That is what has been suggested.We have a number of options. To sum up, we can do one or the other, or we can do neither, or we can do something else. How do members wish to proceed? I leave the issue in your hands. I ask members to say what they would prefer to do and when they would prefer to do it.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Just for clarity, what is your suggested timescale?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I was just double checking. I do not want to overstep my authority, but my expectation is that we will agree to look at the bill as soon as possible and that stage 1 will begin in January. However, we have not seen the bill yet, so we cannot say that for certain.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Thank you. Just for clarity, and to be fair, the original email from Mr Findlay talked about taking evidence during our sessions on the colleges and regionalisation agenda. We had not set a timescale for them, although I think that we were probably anticipating that they would be at some point later in 2013. I have to say that, under the circumstances, I do not think that it would be reasonable to wait until then, and I presume that that would not be acceptable to Labour Party members, either. I accept that things have moved on from the original discussion.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

That is what I am saying; I accept that. It is obvious that there is not going to be agreement round the table about the two proposals that were submitted—one by Neil Findlay on behalf of the Labour Party, and then the letter to which he was joint signatory. That is not surprising.If I interpret the situation correctly, we have two proposals. One is to have a separate inquiry, as proposed by the Opposition members, and the other is roughly outlined by what Colin Beattie said, backed up by Clare Adamson, which is to look at the matter as per the Labour Party’s original suggestion. I hope that members agree that the matter could not be put back as far as was originally envisaged. I think that it was George Adam who originally said that it could be considered with the bill at stage 1. Is that correct?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Those are the two positions. I would prefer that we did not vote on this, but if it is what members prefer, we can have a vote. It looks like four members support the position that was originally outlined by Liam McArthur. The other position is supported by the four Scottish National Party members. All these matters can be discussed and questions can be asked, as per Colin Beattie’s suggestion about supporting the Labour Party proposal to take consider the episode during evidence on the colleges and regionalisation agenda.

That would take place as part of our scrutiny of the bill, starting in January. Are members content with that? I know that it is not the unanimous position, but it is the majority position in the committee at the moment.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

We do not have to have a vote. Will we have a vote?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Is everyone clear about the two proposals? I describe them as the letter from the Opposition members and the original Labour Party proposal. I know that that is not exactly right but it is just for clarity, so that people know what we are talking about. Who is in favour of the proposal that has been submitted by the four Opposition members in the form of the letter?ForBibby, Neil (West Scotland) (Lab)Findlay, Neil (Lothian) (Lab)McArthur, Liam (Orkney Islands) (LD)Smith, Liz (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con)

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Who is in favour of the original Labour Party proposal—albeit that it would take place in the context of the post-16 education reform bill?ForAdam, George (Paisley) (SNP)Adamson, Clare (Central Scotland) (SNP)Beattie, Colin (Midlothian North and Musselburgh) (SNP)Maxwell, Stewart (West Scotland) (SNP)McAlpine, Joan (South Scotland) (SNP)

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Four members supported the call for an immediate inquiry and five members supported the proposal that the evidence be taken as part of the bill on post-16 education and training. Members have no other points about the work programme, so I close the meeting.Meeting closed at 12:08.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 6
  2. 10:00 Skills Development Scotland Evidence session · 152
  3. 10:00 Work Programme Procedure · 89

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.