The target has not yet been met.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Fiona Hyslop SNP 74
- Linda Fabiani SNP 49
- Jeremy Purvis LD 37
- Karen Whitefield Lab 35
- Ken Macintosh Lab 21
- Pauline McNeill Lab 20
- Rob Gibson SNP 9
- Greig Chalmers Scottish Executive 4
- Aileen Campbell SNP 4
- Liz Smith Con 3
- Christina McKelvie SNP 3
- Mark Batho Scottish Executive 1
The record
263 contributions · showing 201–263It was to be met by August.
No, it is for next year. Sixty per cent of pupils in P1 are in classes that are way above 25.
Is the figure 40 per cent or 60 per cent? Earlier, you said that it was 40 per cent.
Forty per cent of P1 pupils are in classes bigger than 25, so 60 per cent are in classes of 25.Members have asked me to appear before the committee within five weeks of our coming to power. The Minister for Education and Young People in the previous Administration made his first visit to the Parliament at the invitation of the Education Committee in October 2003. He appeared before the committee not to set out the programme for government, the Executive's proposals, how it intended to implement its policies or what discussions had taken place with local authorities, but to talk about the budget process. I welcome the early opportunity that I have been given to speak to the committee, but I cannot give members the roll-out dates for particular measures until I have had the necessary discussions with local authorities.Five weeks in, we have managed to inject 300 new teachers and 250 new probationers into the system. We have also injected £40 million into the capital programme, to start the process of ensuring that there is investment in the space that will be needed to accommodate smaller class sizes. I understand that members are impatient to have targets, details and so on, but it might be helpful for them to wait until discussions with all 32 local authorities have taken place, so that we can give them a better indication of the pace and scale of implementation. I intend to see year-on-year progress, which is achievable. Local authorities are enthusiastic about making a difference in early years education. However, I ask members to bear with me. Five weeks in, I have managed to give the committee a lot of information. Under previous Governments, that was not expected of ministers for at least another six months.
link
We at least had a legislative programme set out, which we have not had from your Administration.
I think that you will find that that did not take place until the autumn.
I remind all members that, at the committee, they should address their comments through the chair.
link
Sorry, convener, I just got a wee bit frustrated at that.
It applies not only to members of the committee but to everyone sitting round the table.
Indeed.
I have a question about additional support for learning. The Scottish National Party manifesto made two welcome commitments. One was for a £10 million fund to help in training teachers and the other was a promise to"review the operation and implementation of mainstreaming of children with additional support needs".One of the issues that the committee will discuss is whether it needs to embark on a programme of post-legislative scrutiny. There is obviously no point in our duplicating the Executive's work on that, so what are the Executive's thoughts on it?
That is an interesting point. We have now reached the stage at which the policy and principle of mainstreaming are embedded in school education in Scotland. Our thinking behind having a review is that this is an opportune time to find out how mainstreaming is working. For many children, there is a great benefit, but each child is different and each child's experience of mainstreaming is different. There are also concerns about resourcing. There were previously concerns about whether there would be an internal rationing system for additional support for learning resources based on what level of support plan a child had.We intend to review the implementation and operation of mainstreaming—not to change the policy but to find out how it is working in practice and what is needed. We definitely need to liaise with the committee on that, because a committee inquiry might well be able to inform our work. I know that some academic research has been carried out into the implementation of mainstreaming. That is a useful source from which we both can start, but you are right that there is no point in duplication. The situation is similar with looked-after children: a strategy is being produced, and the issue is whether the committee would replicate a consultation that is taking place anyway.Post-legislative scrutiny is an effective vehicle. Because the legislation is the driver for much of the policy and delivery in additional support for learning, one way of conducting a review is to examine how well the legislation is working. The issue is whether it is too early after the implementation of the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004 to do that meaningfully. I will need to consult officials on that and on when it would best be done. Perhaps my officials could liaise with the clerks and the convener so that, before the committee's away day, we can give you an impression of what the best time for that would be. There is obviously no point in the committee doing post-legislative scrutiny if we are carrying it out, but the committee has quite a good geographical spread and range of interests and experience, so its perspective might be helpful, particularly bearing in mind the work that the previous committee did on the 2004 act. Post-legislative scrutiny might not sound very sexy or exciting, but it would probably allow you to get into the meat of what is happening—the nut and bolts of it—more than a general inquiry would. I hope that that is helpful.
Is the £10 million fund dependent on the review.
No. That is separate.
I meant "dependent on the spending review".
Well, yes it is in the sense that we are looking at the current budgets to determine where we want to embed the funding. I would like it to be embedded in policy and baseline expenditure because continuing professional development in general is an issue that we want to progress. Where additional support needs are concerned, it is essential that teachers have a regular opportunity to receive expert advice on how to deal with certain conditions. If we say to them that mainstreaming is the policy that must be pursued, they will need support in doing that. Some of that support must be additional staffing. That is one of the issues that we will have to wrestle with, as the committee would have to if it had an inquiry. Training is another element of that support. Perhaps such training should be done nationally rather than each local authority having to reinvent the wheel for training on how to help children with autism or dyslexia, for example. We might start with those subjects, but perhaps we could extend it.There is a CPD fund for additional support for learning and we must work out how we can marry our plans with that. The new fund is separate from and not dependent on the review. Again, we will have to work with local authorities on the implementation of the fund.We must ensure that children in mainstream schools who have additional support needs get the support that they need. When I go to schools, I ask how the mainstreaming policy is developing and the headteacher usually tells me that it is going well and that all the children have a better understanding of people with differences and disabilities. That immediate answer reflects the response of the majority of the children who do not have additional support needs, which is an interesting perspective, but it shows that mainstreaming is working. However, we must show that it works for the individual child who needs additional support by giving them not only the life opportunities that they deserve and need but the education that they need when they need it, because each child is different.
Higher education has been part of your work so far. Are you aware of the work that Universities Scotland is doing? Have you had discussions with that organisation in the context of the upcoming budget process, which you touched on in your statement? Have you accepted the principle that, as part of Universities Scotland's bid for the spending review period, there should be more funded places for undergraduate and postgraduate degrees in Scotland?
Part of the preparation for the spending review was to request Universities Scotland to present more detailed proposals on what it needs. It welcomed the invitation to provide more detail. We are still in the process of receiving that, so I cannot say that I have seen the detail. Part of the process is looking at the student places that we have.I am interested in a particular issue regarding postgraduate students. There has been an expansion in the number of postgraduate students, particularly from overseas, but there has been a reduction in the number of Scots who take up postgraduate places. We need to address that issue because if we want to develop the economy, we must ensure that we have the higher skill base of people with postgraduate degrees as well as first degrees.
What evidence can you cite for a fall in the number of Scotland-domiciled postgraduate students? The statistics that the Executive published in May show that there has been an increase in the number of such students.
I do not have the statistics to hand—you may have them—but they show that, although there has been an expansion in the overall number of postgraduate students, there has been a change in the proportions of those who are international and those who are domestic. My understanding is that the number of domestic students studying at postgraduate level has reduced.
It is certainly the case that the numbers of non-European, European Union and non-EU European postgraduates have gone up, but it is not the case that the number of Scotland-domiciled postgraduate students has fallen. The number of non-European students has increased at a higher rate, but that does equate to saying that the number of Scottish postgraduate students is falling. Between 1999 and 2005-06, the numbers went up by more than 2,000. I do not know whether Mr MacLean or Mr Batho has information on that.
I have not got any detail on the figures at the moment, but we can look into them.
I am quoting from the Scottish Executive statistics publication of 16 May 2007 entitled "Students in Higher Education at Scottish Institutions 2005-06". I am disappointed that you do not have that to hand, but we can leave that point.
Different sets of figures come at different times. About four different sets of university figures come out and the ones that I looked at would not have come out in May; they would probably have been the January or February figures and there was concern about them then. The variation might be to do with the difference between the number of people who are offered postgraduate positions and the number who accept. I think that the concern is that although the number of international students coming to Scotland has certainly grown, which is good, we must ensure that we protect the percentage of postgraduate students who are Scots.
So you would be looking to alter the proportions of places for Scotland-domiciled and international postgraduate students.
It is important that we continue to have high levels of Scots going on to postgraduate study. Concerns have been expressed to me about the levels. I have seen the figures in previous statistics—possibly in an earlier publication than the one to which you referred. If we genuinely want to have an economically vibrant country, it is essential that we maintain the levels of not just first degrees but second degrees and postgraduate research.The issue that you have raised is an illustration of the detail that we need from Universities Scotland. We need to know whether we have the balance that we need or whether that needs to change. You asked about the bids for the spending review. The detail that you are asking for is exactly what we need Universities Scotland to tell us—the balance that it wants, for example. Rather than my saying that I want more postgraduate students, I need to consider the data and Universities Scotland's arguments on the balance.
Would you be open to coming back to the committee to give your response to what Universities Scotland publishes on that? The committee might find it interesting to see what your response is to the details that it provides. As you know, Universities Scotland published its previous bid for the spending review.
That is certainly an issue in the preparation for the budget. Indeed, you would expect me, like previous ministers, to come to the committee to discuss the budget proposals. That is probably the most appropriate occasion on which to discuss that issue.
That would be helpful.A specific point that has been raised in the past is the application of fees for non-Scotland-domiciled students—I do not know whether another member wants to ask about that as well. You are on the record as saying that the application of the fees for English students is "anti-English". In the past, you have said that "English students would be treated the same as students from any other country, including Scots",under an SNP Government and that "We are the only party that has made a stance on this."Do you intend to change the approach for the application of fees to English-domiciled students?
It was regrettable that the previous Government introduced variable top-up fees for students from England, Wales and Northern Ireland. There was a fee hike, which in effect brought in an additional fee cost to English students. My comments, which you quoted, were right. I thought that it was wrong at the time, which is why we voted against it. Interestingly, the SNP was the only party to stand up for English students when it came to the vote in Parliament just about a year ago.
Is it still wrong?
Yes, I think that it is still wrong. When will we right that wrong? In an independent Scotland, an SNP Government would treat English, Welsh and Northern Irish students exactly the same as students from France and Germany, first because it is desirable and secondly because we would have to under EU legislation. The question is whether we would want to lift that fee now, which is probably the question that you are coming to.
Yes.
I think that it is one of a number of issues in the queue for delivery. When I was asked at the time whether I would change it, I said that it is something that we would want to change but that the issue is the priority that we would give it compared with other issues. Should we change fees for English students that were introduced by the previous Government? The mistake was made previously, but can we right all the mistakes that were made previously? Probably not and, given a choice between part-time Scottish students receiving finances from the spending review and rectifying the problem in question caused by the previous Government, I think that part-time Scottish students—many of whom are from deprived areas—are probably more deserving of investment from the Government in a shopping list of order of priorities.So the answer is yes, I would want to right that wrong, but I do not know whether I can do that now, so let us have a look at the comprehensive spending review. However, I think that the previous Executive took the wrong decision. It was meant to prevent medical students from flooding over the border from England to Scotland and to preserve the number of medical places for Scots. However, we have probably lost more Scottish students as a result of the debacle of the UK's modernising medical careers structure than we ever prevented the loss of with the hike in fees.
Why did you say that you would have to wait until Scotland was independent before you made that change? You have the powers to do it.
No, we do not have to wait; we could do it now. All that I am saying is that other spending priorities sit ahead of that one. If we spent all our money and used all our resources undoing all the mistakes of the previous Government, that would leave us less room to manoeuvre to make progress in the areas that we have to make progress in. For example, I would want to address funding for part-time students first. It is not that we cannot make the change; it is just that we are choosing at this stage not to undo all the things that the previous Executive did. In an independent country, students from England, Wales and Northern Ireland would be treated in exactly the same way as students from other countries in the EU, and that is perhaps a simpler way of addressing it.
So, when you decided that the scheme was discriminatory and anti-English, that you were the only party making a stand against it, and that you would scrap the fees when you got to power, what you meant to say was that those students would be put in a queue.
We said that we wanted to get rid of the fees, and I have said that we want to get rid of them. It is simply a matter of prioritising spending. We cannot spend all our time unpicking everything that the previous Government did. Frankly, we are making significant progress on abolishing the graduate endowment fee, for which I believe we have your support. Is not abolishing the graduate endowment fee for Scots—remember that students from England, Wales and Northern Ireland do not pay the graduate endowment fee—a higher priority than reducing the fee levels for English students that were introduced by the previous Government? Probably.Politics is about priorities, and we set out our stall when we voted against the introduction of top-up fees. We did not think that it should have happened. However, we need to drive forward our agenda, which is making a significant impact on relieving Scottish students of debt. The fact that students who are currently sitting their finals, students who are at university and students who are about to go to university will not have to pay the £2,000 graduate endowment fee is a major step forward. That is one of the things on which we want to make progress. The scheme was established by the previous Government and it is one of our priorities for change, but not everything can be a priority. Such are the choices in politics.
Another choice that you made was when you took a clear stance on the increase in fees for medical students, which you voted against when you were in opposition. Is that another policy that you have decided not to change?
The fees for medical students were the same as the other fees that were introduced. However, when the previous Government introduced an across-the-board increase in variable top-up fees for English students, it decided to increase the fees for medical students even further. It wanted to do so in order to deter English medical students from taking up places in Scottish universities. That was blatantly discriminatory, and it was a duff policy because it did not achieve what it was meant to achieve. In fact, one university principal said that the number of English medical students who were deterred from taking up places in Scotland would have fitted in a bus. The British Medical Association did not think that it was a good idea, Universities Scotland did not think that it was a good idea, and we did not think that it was a good idea. We voted against it because we thought that it was wrong.I always argued that the hike in fees for English medical students was the wrong solution to a real problem. The real problem that we had with junior doctors in Scotland was the career choices that they made later, not the number of applicants for university places. If we want to ensure that more Scots medical students stay in Scotland, we ought to address their career progression. I do not think that that will be an issue for this committee, but it is an issue for the Health and Sport Committee. We must ensure that we support junior doctors and encourage them to stay in Scotland.The increase in fees for medical students was a flawed policy. However, is it a priority for us to change that policy? Frankly, I think that there are other things on our list of priorities—not least nursery education, the reduction of class sizes and the abolition of the graduate endowment fee. My answer is the same as my answer to your previous question. In politics, we have to set priorities, and that issue is not a priority just now. It was not a helpful policy when it was introduced, which is why we voted against it.
Have you costed what the change would be just to reduce the medical student fees? I understand that you have made a connection between the two issues, but there is a distinction between the application of fees to English, Welsh and Northern Irish students studying in Scotland, which is discriminatory, and the increase in the fees that English, Welsh and Northern Irish medical students have to pay.
It is £1,500 more.
How many students does that apply to?
Convener, your invitation was for me to come and outline what the Government wants to do and what our priorities are. We could spend a lot of time in discussing the problems of the previous Government's decision to introduce top-up fees for English students. However, I do not intend to make any movement on that because we have other priorities, which I have set out. I appeal to your judgment as to how we should proceed. We could spend a lot of time discussing the previous Government, but perhaps we should spend more time discussing our plans and the proposals that I have presented to the committee this morning.
Absolutely. However, Mr Purvis has the right to ask his questions, even though you are under no obligation to answer them.
There is a danger of repetition.
That is fine, convener.
Time is marching on. The minister has been very indulgent, so I ask Mr Purvis to ask one final question—other members wish to ask questions, too.
It has been helpful, cabinet secretary, that you have said that you are not going to move on the two areas that I asked about.You have spoken about relieving student debt, although you used different language in your manifesto, which spoke about removing the burden of debt repayments. In your recent statement to Parliament and, I think, today, you spoke about relieving the burden. When will you make clear proposals? You have said that more than 300,000 individuals in Scotland will benefit, but when will you come back to Parliament with proposals to benefit the 300,000 Scotland-domiciled and resident graduates for whom you have made a commitment to assume debt repayments?
To assume debt repayments means to remove debt repayments from graduates who have that burden of debt. In effect, we will be relieving them of the responsibility, because we will be standing in their shoes. You can use the word "remove" or the word "relieve"; to me, it is one and the same thing.The measures will be part of the spending review. The difficulty is that much of our work will depend on our discussions of the spending review and on negotiations with the Treasury. That will take time, but I will certainly come back to the committee when I have information on progress. We are making progress on grants and loans, and we have made an early impact on the graduate endowment fee. We had to do that for people who are starting university this year or who have been sitting their finals; people have to know what is likely to happen—depending on Parliament's approval. Where necessary, we have moved quickly to maximise our impact this academic year.
The time for this point has probably passed. Jeremy Purvis was talking about postgraduates, and a person has to graduate before they can become a postgraduate. Will removing the barriers to higher education be part of a Government strategy to get more Scotland-domiciled students into postgraduate education?
This Government is determined to tackle the issue of debt. The fear of debt has the biggest impact on people who are perhaps the least likely to want to go to university.Debt is one burden but other issues will have to be addressed, too—for example, we have to consider people with families and the age profile of people who want to go to university. I am very keen that people with the ability to learn are given the opportunity to go to university. There has been a reduction in participation levels at university from 51 per cent to 47 per cent; that has been a dramatic change after decades in which the trend was in the other direction.We have to consider debt, widening access and giving opportunities, and we have to ensure that young people in schools can make the right decisions. Some young people might want to go into vocational education, and there has to be parity of esteem between that and university education. We have to ensure that young people's career choices and life choices are appropriate to them, and that young people are not held back by poverty or by not having a family background of relatives going to university. Also, some people who automatically choose to go to university might benefit from doing something else. They should have the choice of vocational education.In order to widen access, not only universities but schools should be changing things. Schools should be encouraging goals and ambitions and should be providing proper information about career opportunities earlier on, so that young people can make the life choices that are best suited to them.
On that point, you will be aware that North Lanarkshire Council has been developing 21st century comprehensives—the model is vocational excellence as well as academic excellence in schools. Will additional funding be available to local authorities such as North Lanarkshire Council to pilot a vocational skills strategy? How will you ensure that we have a proper vocational qualification framework in Scotland so that we do not just talk about parity of esteem between the academic and the vocational but make it a reality?
We have announced that we want to introduce a skills strategy that goes from the early years right through. We will have to look at the vocational skills strategy that you are talking about at a local level and we will have to agree with local authorities the sort of things that we expect to see.In relation to colleges, again much will depend on the local area. Facilities in local schools might be more fitting, but there is an issue about ensuring that young people have an opportunity to go off site, away from more formal education, to experience the adult world. We therefore have to make sure that our colleges, many of which are already doing great work with young people, are geared up to offer that opportunity.Employers are going to be the big challenge for us. How can we engage employers and get them to provide facilities and experiences to young people that will give them some status? That is particularly relevant to young men who need such opportunities—for example, working with an older role model in a way that might not necessarily happen in a school setting, where it might not be appropriate. I am very interested to see what the North Lanarkshire schools are doing, but we have to marry all that work with employers and colleges.You are absolutely right about the qualification framework. We have a great opportunity, which is why I am enthusiastic about meeting the European Commissioner for Education, Training, Culture and Youth tomorrow. The Scottish credit and qualifications framework, which is internationally recognised, could work harder for us. It is informing some of the work that is being done in Europe on the development of a European qualification framework.It is essential for vocational qualifications to have parity of esteem with academic qualifications. We have to do more work on that, and it will be interesting to see how the schools for work roll-out is supported in different areas. If the committee has views on how the schools for work programme is operating or whether it can be developed or enhanced, I would welcome hearing those.
I am sure that North Lanarkshire schools would welcome a visit. The partnership is not just with the schools but with local colleges, which deliver vocational education in the schools. The young people are able to go out into the community—each primary and high school is in partnership and has a contract with a local company. There is constant learning and development of skills that meet the needs of local employers. There is much to recommend in the model that is being used in North Lanarkshire. I am sure that the council would be happy to have you.
Thank you.
As an addendum, the UHI Millennium Institute has majored in marrying vocational education with higher education. Have you considered how university status for the UHI Millennium Institute can be fast tracked? Can we expect that to happen in the near future? It is important because parity of esteem for vocational courses relies on the UHI having a permanent set-up and on its being a model for other parts of rural Scotland.
You raise an important question that I will discuss with officials. I intend to visit Inverness and to hold discussions with the relevant bodies. You will understand that it would be premature for me to make any decisions today and announce them to the committee, but we need to develop that work and decide how to go forward and achieve parity of esteem and recognition for vocational education.The credit and qualifications framework is very important because a huge percentage of higher education is delivered in colleges, so we have to address the relationship between colleges and universities and the status of the UHI Millennium Institute. However, it would be premature for me to make any statement to the committee before I have had discussions with the relevant officials.
That concludes our questions, minister. Thank you very much for your attendance at the committee. You are likely to receive a formal invitation to our committee away day and I hope that you and your deputies will be able to accept that when it arrives.
Thank you.
I remind committee members that our away day will take place on 27 and 28 August at Keavil House hotel, which is just outside Dunfermline. It is an appropriate location for the committee's away day; some of you might not know that the building was a children's home before it was turned into a hotel. The clerks have made a good choice of location.
Meeting closed at 11:51.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Jun 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 27 June 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- Work Programme Procedure · 263
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.