The second item on the agenda is the development of the committee's work programme. I am delighted to welcome to the committee Linda Fabiani, the Minister for Europe, External Affairs and Culture. I am grateful to the minister for making time in her busy schedule to accommodate the wishes of the committee. She is joined by Greig Chalmers, who heads the Scottish Executive's culture and Gaelic division. I understand that the minister has a very brief statement to make.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Karen Whitefield only · show everyone- Fiona Hyslop SNP 74
- Linda Fabiani SNP 49
- Jeremy Purvis LD 37
- Karen Whitefield Lab 35
- Ken Macintosh Lab 21
- Pauline McNeill Lab 20
- Rob Gibson SNP 9
- Greig Chalmers Scottish Executive 4
- Aileen Campbell SNP 4
- Liz Smith Con 3
- Christina McKelvie SNP 3
- Mark Batho Scottish Executive 1
Karen Whitefield’s contributions
35 contributionsIt was indeed a warning.
Thank you for your comments and that outline of your initial thinking, minister. Where does culture figure in the Government's agenda? Does the Scottish National Party Administration rank culture as one of its priorities?
That is a helpful continuation—the previous Administration felt that culture should be a cross-cutting issue. It has been suggested, however, that not having somebody sitting at the Cabinet table with direct day-to-day responsibility for culture might mean that cultural matters could be forgotten, that we will not deliver that cross-cutting agenda and that culture will not feature in all aspects of the current Administration's work.
I appreciate that you would want that to happen, but if you are not sitting at the table, how can you ensure that it happens?
What cross-cutting initiatives will the Executive announce in relation to culture?
That would be helpful.
I have a general question about access.
How does the Government intend to increase access to the arts and culture in Scotland?
Very general.
You may be specific about how you will do it. I do not need a general answer.
As you say, minister, the previous Administration wanted to go ahead with plans for a cultural entitlement. You say that you have reservations about that, and your reservations are legitimate, but if a cultural entitlement is not the right way forward, what is your alternative?
I accept absolutely that we need to get the best model, but perhaps we need to ensure that all local authorities live up to the standard that Labour-led North Lanarkshire Council has set in delivering the youth music initiative, which it has embraced, rather than do anything to its detriment.
I thank you for your attendance—I know that you have to go to other meetings. This session gave us an interesting taste of what your portfolio is about. I am sure that we will have much dialogue with you over the coming months.
I look forward to seeing you at the committee's away day.
I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the witnesses to change over.
I am delighted to welcome the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning, Fiona Hyslop. She is joined by Liz Lewis, director of the schools directorate, Colin MacLean, director of the children, young people and social care directorate, and Mark Batho, director of the lifelong learning directorate.I am grateful to you for accepting at short notice the committee's invitation to join us. I hope that that invitation demonstrates our great interest in the matters for which you are responsible. I understand that you wish to make a short statement.
Thank you for that extensive introduction. There is much that members will want to get their teeth into and ask questions on.
Did the minister say that various options would be open to local authorities and that they could choose to use prudential borrowing, the PPP route or the Scottish futures trust?
That shows exactly why I asked my question. If you believe that the Scottish futures trust will squeeze out PPP, why are you giving local authorities the option of PPP? If there are sound economic reasons why PPP is a bad investment for local authorities, surely you as a prudent Government would be wiser to say that councils can use traditional funding methods or the Scottish futures trust, but not PPP.
The last time that I checked, Falkirk Council had built no schools in the past four years, whereas North Lanarkshire Council has built 12 new primary schools in my constituency alone.
I have a couple of questions on the announcement that you made last week on class sizes. What is the timescale for ensuring that every child in P1 to P3 is taught in a class of 20?
I appreciate and welcome your desire for year-on-year progress, but if you do not set an overall target for when you would like the policy to be implemented, directors of education in local authorities will use that fact not to implement it. I am not saying that you should set a date in stone; I am saying that there needs to be some timescale.
I certainly have plenty of faith in local authorities.
My authority is one of the best in Scotland on education. The record of North Lanarkshire Council speaks for itself, and I wish there were more councils like it.Will there be any flexibility for headteachers to choose not to have a class size of 18, if they believe that a class size of 20 or 21 is more appropriate?
A number of schools in deprived areas in my constituency already have class sizes of 18 or 19. The headteachers of those schools tell me that having smaller class sizes does not do much to drive up standards. Indeed, over the past few days, following my appointment to the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee, a number of them have approached me to say that they would much rather have as an additional classroom assistant an early years worker in their primary 1, 2 and 3 classes.Headteachers have also raised concerns about the socialisation of children in much smaller classes. Judith Gillespie made a point about that on the radio last week, when she said that there was academic evidence of some children in smaller classes being highly excluded from social groups. When there are one or two dominant personalities in small classes, most of the children focus on those personalities, with the result that some children are left with no friends and do not develop the necessary socialisation skills.
Is the figure 40 per cent or 60 per cent? Earlier, you said that it was 40 per cent.
I remind all members that, at the committee, they should address their comments through the chair.
It applies not only to members of the committee but to everyone sitting round the table.
Absolutely. However, Mr Purvis has the right to ask his questions, even though you are under no obligation to answer them.
Time is marching on. The minister has been very indulgent, so I ask Mr Purvis to ask one final question—other members wish to ask questions, too.
On that point, you will be aware that North Lanarkshire Council has been developing 21st century comprehensives—the model is vocational excellence as well as academic excellence in schools. Will additional funding be available to local authorities such as North Lanarkshire Council to pilot a vocational skills strategy? How will you ensure that we have a proper vocational qualification framework in Scotland so that we do not just talk about parity of esteem between the academic and the vocational but make it a reality?
I am sure that North Lanarkshire schools would welcome a visit. The partnership is not just with the schools but with local colleges, which deliver vocational education in the schools. The young people are able to go out into the community—each primary and high school is in partnership and has a contract with a local company. There is constant learning and development of skills that meet the needs of local employers. There is much to recommend in the model that is being used in North Lanarkshire. I am sure that the council would be happy to have you.
That concludes our questions, minister. Thank you very much for your attendance at the committee. You are likely to receive a formal invitation to our committee away day and I hope that you and your deputies will be able to accept that when it arrives.
I remind committee members that our away day will take place on 27 and 28 August at Keavil House hotel, which is just outside Dunfermline. It is an appropriate location for the committee's away day; some of you might not know that the building was a children's home before it was turned into a hotel. The clerks have made a good choice of location.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Jun 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 27 June 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- Work Programme Procedure · 263
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.