Was that a warning, madam convener?
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Linda Fabiani only · show everyone- Fiona Hyslop SNP 74
- Linda Fabiani SNP 49
- Jeremy Purvis LD 37
- Karen Whitefield Lab 35
- Ken Macintosh Lab 21
- Pauline McNeill Lab 20
- Rob Gibson SNP 9
- Greig Chalmers Scottish Executive 4
- Aileen Campbell SNP 4
- Liz Smith Con 3
- Christina McKelvie SNP 3
- Mark Batho Scottish Executive 1
Linda Fabiani’s contributions
49 contributionsOkay, I will rush through it. I am glad to be able to give the committee an idea of my first thoughts about our culture agenda, and I thank the committee for its invitation.I am discovering daily that the culture part of my brief is enormous. It covers support for the arts; film, the creative industries and broadcasting; local culture and festivals; the national museums, libraries, galleries and the archives; the national performing companies; built heritage, the historic environment and architecture; and Scots and Gaelic. As the committee will understand, after a few weeks in the job I have been able to meet and discuss issues with only a few of the people that I wish to meet—I will do a lot more of that over the summer—but I welcome the chance to tell the committee about my first reflections and initial plans. No doubt we will have plenty of time to speak again, and I hope to be able to come to the committee's away day towards the end of August. As I develop and implement the programme, I will ensure that I keep the committee well informed of what we are doing.In the discussions that I have had so far in the culture sector, I sense a thirst for action and that people are looking for practical progress. Our agenda is about letting Scotland's creativity flourish to achieve all that it can for artists and creators and, indeed, for the nation. Art brings a sense of well-being to people.I feel strongly about art for art's—and indeed the artist's—sake. That needs said and there is no need to be defensive about it. To support artists, I intend to develop a new grants scheme to help individual practitioners. I also want to explore ways in which we can widen the types of finance available, for example with more loans and, potentially, venture capital. We want to simplify the ways in which creative businesses get support. I have had a chance to talk to Richard Holloway about our thinking, and I intend to meet the joint board of the Scottish Arts Council and Scottish Screen tomorrow evening. That team, headed by Richard, has an exciting agenda for creative Scotland, and I want that work to continue. That leads me to legislation, which will be of interest to the committee. The previous Administration published a draft culture bill late last year, and I have been considering the responses to the consultation on that. I have not quite formulated my plans for the bill, or finished discussing the issues with relevant people, but my general approach would be to propose legislation only when it is clearly necessary, and not to legislate for the sake of it. If we introduce a bill on culture this year, it is likely to be quite short—perhaps only a few sections—and focused on one or two issues. When we have decided our view on that, I will ensure that the committee is kept well informed, so that it can plan its work.Over the longer term, once we have completed a review of heritage protection, I may introduce a bill on heritage. As I said, however, I want to discuss my first thoughts with those with an interest. I will pick up on that over the recess. It will take a while, given the range of interested people, and I expect that I will have much more to say to the committee in the autumn, when I will be more than happy to return.
The set-up of the Cabinet and the Government is cross cutting: the flow of ideas about what we are trying to achieve should cut across all the portfolios. As you know, culture has been placed with Europe and external affairs, within the office of the First Minister. I am pleased that culture is in my portfolio, along with Europe and external affairs, because of the internationalism of culture. The benefits that we can derive from our culture—in terms of both heritage and the arts—and from sharing experiences nationally and internationally is huge. I am delighted that the portfolio is in the office of the First Minister. It is a mark of just how important the SNP believes culture to be to the well-being of our nation.
I can say with absolute confidence that I would not allow that to happen. I can also say with absolute confidence that the fact that the First Minister has taken culture into his own office and ensured that it is given the importance and legitimacy that it deserves is a mark of the importance that he places on the cultural agenda.
The Government is being run in a very inclusive way. I have regular meetings with the First Minister, and there are regular ministerial meetings. Obviously, you would not expect me to go into great detail about that, but I assure the committee that culture is an extremely important part of the First Minister's portfolio. It is taken as seriously as everything else that we do in government.
I will give you more detail about that when I return to the committee. I am on a learning curve—I am very open about that—and I have many people to meet and to listen to. I want to understand the portfolio of culture and all the different forms of culture. I will give you some examples of cross-cutting. Our built heritage is very much part of our culture and identity as a nation and ties in with other portfolios across the spectrum. I mentioned earlier that I have responsibility for festivals; such events tie in with the tourism portfolio, which ties in with the economy. There are also the creative industries. A major part of the Scottish economy lies within the culture brief, so obviously I would be cross cutting that with, for example, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth. That is how we are working across the board. Any proposals and initiatives that I bring to the committee will have been run past the Cabinet and will be announced when appropriate.
I have yet to meet formally those involved in either the Gaelic language sector or the Scots language sector. I want to discuss those matters in detail, because language is so much part of our culture and identity as a nation. I know about the Macpherson report and how it was produced. We are open to suggestions from individual parliamentarians, committees or cross-party groups. In the previous session there was a strong cross-party group on the Scots language, although I am unaware of whether it has been reconstituted. If the group would like us to consider commissioning an expert report on Scots, I would be more than happy to look at its submission.
I will be honest and say that I have not had time to think the matter through properly. The convener mentioned the cross-cutting elements of culture, a huge part of which is education. That point is also reflected in the committee's remit. Recently I visited the Glasgow Gaelic school for the first time. I was fascinated, not just by the mainstream learning from primary right through to secondary level that takes place at the school and in which the language is embedded as a source of identity and culture, but by the way in which music, dance and storytelling was placed within the curriculum. It is important that culture becomes part of normal educational practice, so that it does not have to be referred to as culture, but becomes part of day-to-day education and what we do.The previous Administration formed some good initiatives to take culture into schools—for example, the school music initiative about which the convener asked at question time a couple of weeks ago. I am currently looking into those matters. At the moment 13 pathfinder projects are under way in schools. I do not know the detail of those projects and want to visit some of the schools involved to see what is happening. I am not sure whether any of the projects relate to language.
I know that some time ago there was a Scots language project in some schools in South Lanarkshire. Matthew Fitt, the Scots writer, went into schools to help children to write stories and poetry in Scots. I would be very happy to look at such initiatives, because they give children a sense of confidence, as well as a sense of identity.
Are you going to form a band?
I have had an outline briefing on the scheme to which you refer. As far as I remember, it was not a year-on-year commitment that was announced, but I stand to be corrected on that. Perhaps Greig Chalmers can enlighten us.
It is often the case that intentions are not translated into commitments or action. I will check out the position and find out exactly what was said and done at the time.I share your views on the need to support contemporary music as one of the creative industries. I am having discussions with members of the Scottish Arts Council, who will be on the new board of creative Scotland, about how we can formulate a loan and grants scheme to help artists. I imagine that emerging artists in the contemporary music field are just the kind of people we would consider helping in that way. There is a general view that such assistance should be provided.Scotland has a great culture of festivals, which feed into the economy. Any proposals should always be talked over with the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth. The creative industries in Scotland are huge and I sometimes feel that they are not given the consideration that they deserve, given their importance to our economy. I am talking about music, film and all the other elements of those industries.I am keeping an eye on developments at Westminster, where the live music forum, which is chaired by Feargal Sharkey, is examining how initiatives can be used to boost the contemporary music industry. There has been discussion of how that could be done on a United Kingdom basis, which would obviously affect Scotland. I am monitoring the situation, but any progress is on hold until we find out about the portfolios that the new Prime Minister puts in place. I am aware of the importance of contemporary music, I want to support it and I am looking at all the options.
I certainly would. I will check out the music futures fund and write to the committee if that is acceptable.
I take Aileen Campbell's point. Who are the four committee members who are on the cross-party group? I am fascinated.
I see Pauline McNeill, Ken Macintosh, Aileen Campbell and Jeremy Purvis raising their hands.I began by saying how keen I am to engage with committees. We think it is important that the Government and the Parliament, through its committees, agree on as much as possible and discuss things openly. I am also happy to take soundings from cross-party groups. I would be more than happy to come along to your cross-party group, not to stand there and say what I think, but to listen to what is said. If you think that something particularly relevant will be discussed at a meeting, I would be happy to come along and listen or to meet up with the band or a delegation from the group.
I am considering that and taking soundings. So far, I have met only Richard Holloway from the creative Scotland interim board. Tonight I will meet the joint board of Scottish Screen and the Scottish Arts Council. Under the proposed culture bill, those two bodies will be disbanded and a new agency, creative Scotland, will emerge, which I hope will revitalise the arts and culture in Scotland.I strongly believe that we should legislate only when necessary. I am going through the bill at the moment and taking advice, in the legal sense as much as on the consultation responses, in which people are saying what they would like and what they think is necessary. I am looking forward to tonight's meeting because many of the people who will be there can give a lot of input as they have great experience in the field. I am reluctant to say how I envisage that the bill will progress until I have spoken to all the people who can give that important input.Did you mention local authorities?
First, I am going to give you a row, because I got a row from Richard Holloway for talking about the merger of Scottish Screen and the Scottish Arts Council. It is not a merger. A brand new body will come into being to revitalise the arts in Scotland, so consider yourself told. I did, and I will not use the word "merger" again.Obviously, local authorities play a huge role in culture and the arts in Scotland. We have all seen great examples of that. I am open to discussions with people in the know about whether we need to put that in legislation and whether things can be done through community planning partnerships. I mentioned the pathfinder projects that are under way. I want to visit some of those during the summer and take soundings from people who are involved to find out how the projects are coming together. I do not believe that we necessarily need legislation on what local authorities have to do in culture, because I believe that they should be considering that themselves.
Again, that is being discussed at the moment. In the previous session of Parliament it was agreed that an interim creative Scotland would come into being. All these things are being discussed just now. I am still looking at the consultation on the proposed culture bill, which will inform the thinking on what creative Scotland is there to achieve and where it is to be located. Until I have spoken to the people who have been directly involved—which I will begin to do tonight—I am loth to say more. I hope that, when I come to the committee's away day in late August, I will have had a lot of those meetings. I will speak to those who can inform me and I will come back to the committee with more defined plans about how we wish to proceed.
The previous Minister for Tourism, Culture and Sport, Patricia Ferguson, with the agreement of the Parliament, effectively brought the national companies into the Executive, because of the many issues—mainly governance issues—that arose. I had a chat with Patricia Ferguson about that. She felt that those arrangements had worked well. Since then, I have talked the situation through with some of the civil servants who are directly involved with the national companies. It seems that the arrangements have been a big success. However, that is a different thing from Government deciding what the national companies should do with respect to their output. One element of what the national companies do lies in schools and the education sphere. For example, Scottish Opera has had a wonderful in-schools opera programme. There is a role for the national companies there. I do not believe that there is a prescriptive role for Government when it comes to creative output and what the companies do. Our role should be at arm's length. We cannot stifle the arts and creativity and what people want to achieve. I would find that impossible, and it would be a bad move to impose any strictures on the ability of companies to produce what they want.
The location of creative Scotland is open for discussion while I meet all the players involved and we work through the plans. I cannot, therefore, give you an idea about that.The National Theatre is committed to staying in Easterhouse.
Is there something particular that you wish to ask about?
Of course we would like more of the licence fee that is raised in Scotland to stay in Scotland. According to the figures, there is a disproportionate distribution, to the disbenefit of Scotland. We will work towards rectifying that. It is a reserved matter, so, with our colleagues in Westminster, we will consider the possibilities and have discussions with the appropriate people.
The UK Government and SNP colleagues at Westminster. They have an SNP agenda—that is how political parties work. Discussions are happening and, as MPs do, the SNP MPs will lobby the Government at Westminster. We wish to have good relationships with our colleagues in the Government in Westminster. We will discuss matters with the appropriate ministers at the appropriate times.
We will discuss those issues at the appropriate time with the appropriate people.
That, too, will be open for discussion. We set out in our manifesto the measures that we think are the best for Scotland. Every political party does that. We will try to take action on those measures by discussing with the appropriate people how we can move forward. The most recent Office of Communications report on network television production in Scotland showed that the number of Scotland-produced programmes is reducing. As a first step, we have to reverse that trend. I will meet the BBC, Scottish Media Group, Ofcom and others in that regard.I believe that Scotland has the talent to provide much more for the network. We should all be working towards that for the benefit of everyone. We will have discussions—about, for example, the Scottish Six—with the appropriate people.
Do you want to have a party-political discussion here, or do you want to talk about the way forward for culture in Scotland?
Any Government that wishes to bring about its manifesto pledges and plans will have discussions with the appropriate people. That is what this Government intends to do.
You know that a general thrust of our Government is to reduce the duplication of functions where at all possible. I am currently considering that issue, but I have also decided to be open minded about whether the Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland would find its natural home in Historic Scotland or whether it might sit better in another body. I have not yet had time to discuss these matters with the Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland. I want to speak to it, ensure that I understand exactly what it does and take its views into account before I consider the other heritage agencies and decide on the best way forward.
I will be looking for the most streamlined way in which to deliver that part of my portfolio. The possibility of merging those two organisations will be considered seriously. However, I am open to the suggestions of those people who have experience of these matters and work in the area already, and I believe that there might be a better way of streamlining the portfolio.
I am extremely happy to confirm that. It is part of the cross-cutting work that we are talking about. Discussions will take place over the summer recess, but I cannot give you a specific timescale.
I know about your general questions, convener: you were the convener of a committee of which I was a member.
That is a very general question.
It is hard to know where to start with an answer.
It is an interesting question. The previous Government considered the matter and thought that giving people a cultural entitlement might be the way to do it. That is valid, but I am not convinced that that is the best way forward.Some of the language we use can be off-putting. For example, we ask someone what they do in the arts or culture and they say, "Nothing," yet it turns out that they have been doing things that are cultural all their lives. Most things that people do have an element of culture in them.Liz Smith talked about bringing the curriculum for excellence into schools. That is crucial, and everybody has a big part to play in it. Local authorities also have a big part to play in it. Some of the pathfinder projects that were given approval by local authorities were targeted at groups that they felt did not have access to the arts. It will be interesting to see the results of those projects and whether they have provided access that was never available before.The national companies do a lot of travelling. Travelling theatre companies are really important in providing access to the arts. Drama in community halls and the national companies going into schools are different elements of that.It also comes down to the fact that one person's idea of art is another person's idea of poison—there is such a wide range of culture. There is no easy answer to your question, and I do not think that anybody will come up with an answer to it. We intend to mainstream culture; that is the most important thing.
What I said is that I do not believe that a legislative cultural entitlement is the way forward. There are two different types of entitlement: a legislative entitlement, which comes from the Government down, and an entitlement that people have within their local authority areas through their community planning partnerships. The latter is something that can happen without legislation. That is why I want to look carefully at the results of the pathfinder projects and take advice from those who ran them and those who took part in them.The other people I want to meet over the summer are the cultural co-ordinators who were employed directly to ensure that there was access to culture in local areas. They were appointed without legislation. I want to find out about their experience, too.I am aware that I am currently unable to give you any absolutely firm plans of what I intend to do, and I know how frustrating that might be, but I ask the committee to bear in mind the fact that I have been in the portfolio for only a short time. I do not want to make any firm commitments to do this or that without a real understanding of the breadth of the portfolio and what we want to do. That said, I will build on the previous Administration's successes. If something is good, there is no point throwing out the baby with the bath water but, obviously, every fresh Government will have its own approach. There will be things that we do not agree with and that we will want to alter. I hope that when I come to the committee's away day or to a meeting early in the autumn, I can be much more specific about my plans.
That takes us to another manifesto commitment, which Mr Purvis has not mentioned.
Indeed.We intend to put in place plans for a winter festival. That is not to say that I will come up with plans for a festival that will last for the entire winter. I want to build on what there already is from St Andrew's day to Burns day—from the end of November to the end of January. A winter festival in Scotland will tie in with everything else that already happens. Part of the plan is, of course, to promote St Andrew's day. I have looked at what the previous Administration did about celebrating that day. The process was started, but the celebrations could be better. We could do more, and we will build towards having better celebrations. I am considering the matter.
There are members who feel strongly about the youth music initiative. I have considered it, and one thing that I have picked up is that people have different experiences in different local authority areas. The convener would never forgive me if I did not mention North Lanarkshire Council, as she is the MSP for a constituency in the area that that council covers. In my experience as a regional MSP, I have been bowled over by the music initiative in North Lanarkshire schools, which is fabulous. Those schools have grabbed the initiative and run with it. There seems to be open access for all. However, I have heard reports, some of which are anecdotal—I will look into them—that accessibility is not as great as it should be in some areas. If, for example, letters are written home to parents, will all children have equal opportunities to learn to play musical instruments? We could discuss that matter. Are there other ways of encouraging access? There seems to be an accessibility issue in some places, which we are considering. Where the initiative works, it is great, but we should try to ensure that there is access for all.There are other music initiatives. Members may have read about Richard Holloway going to Venezuela to see the orchestras that have been set up there for children in deprived areas, and bringing that initiative back to Scotland. There will be a pilot programme in Raploch in Stirling. That will give young people access to music and enable them to tap into it. I want to consider all such initiatives before I consider expanding the youth music initiative into secondary schools.
The fèis movement has been hugely successful. Thank you for raising the point about the arts being embedded locally, which I discussed with Richard Holloway and hope to discuss tonight with the people who will be on the board of creative Scotland. Ken Macintosh asked how creative Scotland will be structured and where it will be located. That is up for discussion. We have to get the best model to feed into all the areas in which we are trying to make progress.
I do not think that its success is necessarily party political; I am sure that I could find an example of a bad Labour-run council.
I think that that work is on-going.
That information was part of the briefing I received. I seem to remember that it was one of the things that triggered my concern about the patchiness of accessibility. We will look out the figures for you. I cannot remember the detail in them, but there were percentages for different projects.
We are developing plans for St Andrew's day as a national holiday. I think that John Swinney's secretariat is heading up that initiative; there are many details to consider and people to speak to. My involvement is more to do with the celebrations around St Andrew's day, which would be tied in with hogmanay, Burns day and the promotion of the winter festival.
I do not think I said that.
I think I said that we will, obviously, have intra-party discussions: the SNP Government and MSPs obviously have discussions with SNP MPs and MEPs about things that are party policy. That will carry on.The Scottish Government will discuss many matters with the UK Government. That is one reason why we must have the joint ministerial committees, which have been in abeyance for years, up and running again, starting with the plenary committee, with the subject ones following. That will allow the Scottish Government to discuss in a formal forum matters that it believes are for the benefit of Scotland, instead of always having to rely on informal methods.
It is the 30th.
That is one of my portfolio responsibilities. Part of my portfolio remit is to promote Scotland nationally and internationally through our wonderful Scottish heritage, culture and identity. As I said earlier, some plans are in place for celebrating St Andrew's day, but I want to expand them. I believe that the celebration should have an international flavour, because that would promote Scotland overseas and we could receive benefits that would help make Scotland vibrant, which is what we want.
I hope so.
Thank you, convener.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Jun 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 27 June 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- Work Programme Procedure · 263
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.