Are you committed to delivering what was in the SNP manifesto? Can we treat what is in the manifesto as the platform for your agenda?
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Jeremy Purvis only · show everyone- Fiona Hyslop SNP 74
- Linda Fabiani SNP 49
- Jeremy Purvis LD 37
- Karen Whitefield Lab 35
- Ken Macintosh Lab 21
- Pauline McNeill Lab 20
- Rob Gibson SNP 9
- Greig Chalmers Scottish Executive 4
- Aileen Campbell SNP 4
- Liz Smith Con 3
- Christina McKelvie SNP 3
- Mark Batho Scottish Executive 1
Jeremy Purvis’s contributions
37 contributionsYes, there is. You mentioned that broadcasting is part of your wide brief. Your manifesto states:"We want BBC Scotland to retain more of the licence fee raised in Scotland."How do you intend to bring that about?
Are you referring to colleagues in the United Kingdom Government? You said "our colleagues in Westminster".
I wondered whether the Scottish Government intends to ask the BBC trust to reconfigure part of the expenditure so that Scotland retains more of the licence fee that is raised in Scotland. That is what is proposed in your manifesto.
Your manifesto also says:"As a very minimum we will demand the creation of a Scottish news service."What are your plans to deliver that?
I just wanted to clarify for the committee the type of discussions that will take place. The language in the manifesto is clear: it says that you will "demand" the creation of a Scottish news service. The situation now appears to be that you will open up discussions.
I am simply asking what the Government's intention is with regard to how it wishes to take forward the retention of more of the licence fee that is raised in Scotland and the creation of a Scottish news service. I am interested to know how you will bring about the situations that you want to bring about. It is quite fair to ask about that.
You have also made a commitment to merge the Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland into Historic Scotland. How will that be brought about? What is the intention behind reducing the duplication between the two bodies?
That is helpful. Just to be clear, am I correct in understanding that it is not necessarily the case that you will merge the Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland and Historic Scotland?
Yet.
Christina McKelvie asked about the winter festival and St Andrew's day. There is a commitment to make St Andrew's day a full national holiday. How would that be different from what the legislation provides for at the moment? Would you seek to change the legislation, presumably on a UK-basis, to make St Andrew's day a full national holiday?
I might follow that up with your colleagues.I might have misheard you when you answered my questions about broadcasting, the commitment to retain more of the licence fee in Scotland and a Scottish news service. I heard you say that you will have discussions with colleagues at Westminster about lobbying the UK Government.
I am just seeking clarification. You did not say that SNP MPs would lobby the UK Government on behalf of the Scottish Government to work towards those things.
I have to say that I am not clear about the answer to Mr Macintosh's question, but that might well be my fault. Is it correct to say that local authorities' PPP bids will be able to be serviced through part of the Scottish Government's overall school building fund as well as through the Scottish futures trust and support from prudential borrowing?
There is a huge difference between what you think local authorities might want to do and what Government policy will be, which is the introduction of a new programme to fund PPP schemes that local authorities might wish to develop. In other words, the Scottish Government would provide funding to service new PPP schemes if a local authority preferred to take that route. Is that correct?
It will therefore be possible under this Government for councils to put forward new PPP schemes.
Well, the committee will have an opportunity to look back over your previous comments, but it is helpful to know that new PPP projects will be possible under this Government.
I listened carefully to what you said about flexibility and the fact that the Government will not be setting targets in education. That might be the case, but I notice that your manifesto says:"We will also set a target to expand the number of children in Gaelic medium education within our first term."It seems as if, in some areas, you want to set targets. You have said clearly—and parents across Scotland have understood clearly—that you will reduce class sizes in primaries 1, 2 and 3 to 18 pupils or fewer. Your manifesto says: "Headteachers will have the power to decide on the most appropriate class sizes in later years, within national guidelines."In answer to a parliamentary question that I asked on 22 June, you said that headteachers will have flexibility in primaries 1, 2 and 3 as well. That is different from what your manifesto says clearly.
People might or might not agree with that approach. I do not think that it is pedantic to quote from the manifesto that you now seek to implement. It stated clearly:"Headteachers will have the power to decide on the most appropriate class sizes in later years, within national guidelines."That is not in the context of primaries 1, 2 and 3.On the subject of outcome agreements, moving towards having class sizes of 18 pupils or fewer would involve considerable on-going revenue costs for local authorities, given the proposed expansion in the number of teachers and indeed, the possible requirement to extend schools. Local authorities might decide that they are quite happy, on an educational ground, with a class size of 25, and you will not set a target or have any restrictions on keeping class sizes at 25. You said that you have faith in directors of education to make applications. What happens if local authority education directors look at what would be required in their area to provide class sizes of 18 and find that they cannot meet the demand? Will it be at that stage that you define deprivation, which is the area for which you will release funds?
I think that you said that you wish to see substantial year-on-year progress. It is fair for Parliament to ask how you define substantial progress because you have not done that so far. It is correct for Parliament to ask for that definition because although reducing 5 per cent of P1 class sizes to 18 might be substantial progress, you might say that 20 per cent is. We simply do not know how you define success for this policy. We will come back to the matter. Parents will realise that from the Official Report of this meeting and make up their own minds.Convener, could I move on to ask about higher education?
That is helpful. In light of the illustration that the cabinet secretary has just given, what should the percentage be next year?
Higher education has been part of your work so far. Are you aware of the work that Universities Scotland is doing? Have you had discussions with that organisation in the context of the upcoming budget process, which you touched on in your statement? Have you accepted the principle that, as part of Universities Scotland's bid for the spending review period, there should be more funded places for undergraduate and postgraduate degrees in Scotland?
What evidence can you cite for a fall in the number of Scotland-domiciled postgraduate students? The statistics that the Executive published in May show that there has been an increase in the number of such students.
It is certainly the case that the numbers of non-European, European Union and non-EU European postgraduates have gone up, but it is not the case that the number of Scotland-domiciled postgraduate students has fallen. The number of non-European students has increased at a higher rate, but that does equate to saying that the number of Scottish postgraduate students is falling. Between 1999 and 2005-06, the numbers went up by more than 2,000. I do not know whether Mr MacLean or Mr Batho has information on that.
I am quoting from the Scottish Executive statistics publication of 16 May 2007 entitled "Students in Higher Education at Scottish Institutions 2005-06". I am disappointed that you do not have that to hand, but we can leave that point.
So you would be looking to alter the proportions of places for Scotland-domiciled and international postgraduate students.
Would you be open to coming back to the committee to give your response to what Universities Scotland publishes on that? The committee might find it interesting to see what your response is to the details that it provides. As you know, Universities Scotland published its previous bid for the spending review.
That would be helpful.A specific point that has been raised in the past is the application of fees for non-Scotland-domiciled students—I do not know whether another member wants to ask about that as well. You are on the record as saying that the application of the fees for English students is "anti-English". In the past, you have said that "English students would be treated the same as students from any other country, including Scots",under an SNP Government and that "We are the only party that has made a stance on this."Do you intend to change the approach for the application of fees to English-domiciled students?
Is it still wrong?
Yes.
Why did you say that you would have to wait until Scotland was independent before you made that change? You have the powers to do it.
So, when you decided that the scheme was discriminatory and anti-English, that you were the only party making a stand against it, and that you would scrap the fees when you got to power, what you meant to say was that those students would be put in a queue.
Another choice that you made was when you took a clear stance on the increase in fees for medical students, which you voted against when you were in opposition. Is that another policy that you have decided not to change?
Have you costed what the change would be just to reduce the medical student fees? I understand that you have made a connection between the two issues, but there is a distinction between the application of fees to English, Welsh and Northern Irish students studying in Scotland, which is discriminatory, and the increase in the fees that English, Welsh and Northern Irish medical students have to pay.
How many students does that apply to?
That is fine, convener.
It has been helpful, cabinet secretary, that you have said that you are not going to move on the two areas that I asked about.You have spoken about relieving student debt, although you used different language in your manifesto, which spoke about removing the burden of debt repayments. In your recent statement to Parliament and, I think, today, you spoke about relieving the burden. When will you make clear proposals? You have said that more than 300,000 individuals in Scotland will benefit, but when will you come back to Parliament with proposals to benefit the 300,000 Scotland-domiciled and resident graduates for whom you have made a commitment to assume debt repayments?
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Jun 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 27 June 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- Work Programme Procedure · 263
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.