PE1241, by William Buntain, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Government to conduct an impartial and independent review of its contract with Kilmarnock Prison Services Ltd on the design, construction, financing and management of HM Prison Kilmarnock. Members have dealt with the petition previously, and I know that Margaret Mitchell, in particular, has expressed support for it, so I invite her to make some brief comments.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
HM Prison Kilmarnock Contract (Independent Review) (PE1241)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 9
- Margaret Mitchell Con 5
- Bill Butler Lab 3
- John Wilson SNP 1
- Fergus Cochrane 1
The record
19 contributionsIt has been a long day for the committee, so I will be brief.Even though there has been a fair amount of correspondence with the Scottish Prison Service and other interested parties, there remain certain unresolved issues, including in relation to conflict of interests, on which there is no audit trail and a lack of transparency in accounting.The disciplinary process is very much a live issue. I believe that what happened following an incident that took place this week at Kilmarnock sheriff court is analogous to the situation in the prison. After the union and Reliance had agreed on a course of action in relation to a custody and restraint incident—they had agreed that a debrief would be the best way forward—the SPS decided to suspend the member of staff in question, which means that their certificate is withheld and that they cannot work. It is a little disingenuous of the SPS to say that it does not determine employment matters when suspension of a certificate results in the employee losing their employment for a specified period. That issue is still unresolved, as are various physical training issues.The financial penalties system should be looked at, given that we are 10 years into a 25-year contract. Key performance indicators that looked quite good 10 years ago might not be as robust as we thought they were. That certainly seems to be the view of the workforce at the prison. Rather than adding to performance and making the prison safer, they are detracting from it and affecting morale. The health and safety issue that arises from staff not being able to use PAVA spray is unresolved, too. It is worth pointing out that the normal process of contract management has still not resolved that issue.For all those reasons, I hope that the committee will consider recommending the independent review that is supported by the Prison Officers Association Scotland, the Prison Service Union and the petitioner, and that it will look at the petitioner's other suggestion, that the Public Audit Committee should investigate the £2.1 million in financial penalties that has been withdrawn from Kilmarnock prison. Incidents such as the finding of a mobile phone attract penalty points; five penalty points could mean the withdrawal of £2,000. The Public Audit Committee would be able to establish an audit trail and provide some transparency and accountability as regards where that money has ended up. Those are the two points that I hope that the committee will consider taking action on.
Do committee members have any other observations? We have been broadly supportive of exploring the issues that the petitioner has raised and the points made by Margaret Mitchell. Can we take those together and perhaps also consider some of the issues that have been raised relating to the performance system, which Margaret touched on, the ways in which staff members are affected by the perverse criteria that are applied when contraband material is found, and so on?
I suggest that we write to the SPS about the response that we have received from Mike Ewart to Margaret Mitchell's question. His letter states that the SPS does not receive any financial gain. The question was whether"SPS have received monies as a result of the penalties system".Mike Ewart's response is that"SPS have received no income from KPSL please refer to the response above ‘financial penalties'."There seems to be no clarification as far as I can see of the issue that I believe Margaret Mitchell mentioned about the £1.5 million clawback—the moneys that have been withheld from Kilmarnock prison. Can we seek clarification from Mike Ewart? If the SPS does not receive any moneys as part of the financial penalties system, where is that money going? There seems to be a contradiction: a financial penalties system is in place, but the chief executive of the Scottish Prison Service says that the SPS does not receive any moneys as part of that system. Who receives the penalties or fines that are imposed on the operators of the prison and where does the money go?
We want to keep the petition open. I know that the petitioner has been patient all afternoon. We want to continue to pursue these matters; I hope that that will help.
On the issue that John Wilson mentioned, the money was withdrawn from the sum that would otherwise be given to Kilmarnock prison. The point is that we do not know where it goes. That is why it has been suggested that the Public Audit Committee could examine the issue to establish where the money has gone. We do not know whether it goes to the SPS indirectly or to some other organisation or budget, but it would be good to nail the conflict of interest issue by establishing the audit trail.
It might be refreshing if, when we ask the SPS a specific question, we get a specific answer and not obfuscation.
Do you want me to put that in the letter?
Yes.
Good.
That is why I said it.
Fergus Cochrane will need to check the dictionary, because he is looking puzzled at that one. Well done, Bill. I thank Margaret Mitchell for her time. We will keep the petition open and pursue the issues.
I would like to be clear about whether the committee will go back to the SPS and ask for that information.
Fergus Cochrane would like to comment.
I will have a chat with the clerks to the Public Audit Committee about any scope that that committee has to consider aspects of the petition, given that the Public Petitions Committee is not referring it.
Will that be resolved before the other aspects are looked at, such as the disciplinary issues, training and health and safety, which are the core of why an independent review is being sought?
Yes. We will pursue the matters. You have a worried look. What are you worried about?
Will the committee come back to look at the whole issue once it has been in contact with the SPS?
Yes.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 Jan 2010 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 12 January 2010 Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 78
- Current Petitions Petitions · 47
- Current Petitions Petitions · 35
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 19
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.