Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Nature Conservation (Scotland) Act 2004 (Snares) (PE1124)

Tuesday 12 January 2010 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 78 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

78 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Good afternoon, everyone, and a good new year. Welcome to the first meeting in 2010 of the Public Petitions Committee. We have not received any direct apologies from members who are unable to attend this afternoon's meeting. I remind everyone in the room that all mobile phones and other electronic devices should be switched off in case they interfere with the broadcasting system.Item 1 is consideration of current petitions. For our first current petition I welcome Roseanna Cunningham MSP, the Minister for Environment. Here with Roseanna are John Gray and Hugh Dignon of the species management team—a very grand title. This is the minister's first opportunity to appear before this committee, so I welcome her. A number of ministers have appeared before the committee in the past and the discussions that we have had with them have always been constructive.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Absolutely. None was snared. Do not worry—we are much more humane than that. If the minister wants to make any opening remarks, we are happy to hear them; otherwise, we will go straight to questions. We have had PE1124 before us a number of times and we know that there has been a broader debate on the issue in the chamber. Members have a series of questions. We have had information from the minister and the rural directorate about a review of the snaring policy. What is that review based on and how do you gather the numbers of target or non-target species that are caught?

link

We are not conducting a formal review of snaring, although we do a constant monitoring exercise. We discuss snaring on a regular basis in a variety of ways. Obviously, there are discussions on snaring in relation to the wildlife and natural environment bill that is coming. We are laying orders soon, on 20 January. The partnership against wildlife crime Scotland has a sub-committee that is heavily involved in issues that relate to snaring. Issues around snaring are kept under such review almost constantly. I do not see that ever changing.Our approach has been to seek improvements in snaring standards. I know that some members of the committee might wish the approach to be changed. Because we are looking at it from the point of view of making constant improvements in standards, we do constant monitoring.As I can see from the various pieces of correspondence, there has been some to-ing and fro-ing about the statistical evidence on a number of aspects of snaring. Because snaring is a legitimate legal activity, we are not carrying out a specific monitoring of returns—which some members might wish to happen. We are trying to improve standards, but we are not constantly monitoring returns, which I think has been expected—or it has been thought that that might be happening. That, I suspect, has created some of the confusion that has emerged in the to-ing and fro-ing of correspondence.Some forms of snaring are illegal, and they can be picked up through criminal law and prosecutions, as is the case with a number of wildlife crimes. It is not always easy to get sufficient evidence, so cases do not always proceed to prosecution. Through the partnership against wildlife crime, we monitor all wildlife crime, not just crimes in connection with illegal snaring, as the same issues tend to arise.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

You mention progress. What examples of progress do you have in relation to snaring?

link

We are in constant dialogue with the countryside managers who are most involved in snaring. A number of practices that are illegal in Scotland are still legal in other parts of Europe. We have made real changes in that respect. There are further real changes coming up, with the orders that we will lay on 20 January and the proposals that are likely to be contained in the wildlife and natural environment bill that will be introduced in the spring. It is a case of constant monitoring and dialogue.Committee members might be interested in a project at Langholm moor, in the south-west. That joint demonstration project, which involves Buccleuch Estates, RSPB Scotland, Scottish Natural Heritage and other organisations, is examining different methods of snaring and ways to integrate snaring and wildlife management, particularly in connection with birds of prey. The people who are running the project would be only too happy if any members of the Parliament wished to arrange a visit to Langholm moor, and would afford every opportunity for that. Such projects are done on a regular basis.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

You will be aware that the previous Administration in 2006-07 carried out a consultation on the future of snaring, which produced responses in a ratio of 2:1 in favour of an outright ban on snares. Independent opinion polling shows public support in favour of an outright ban at between 75 and 79 per cent. Furthermore, 75 per cent of vets support a ban on snaring. Is the Scottish Government not prepared to accept the will of the Scottish public, and to actually listen to them and do what they want?After nearly two years we still do not even have regulations. What will be in the forthcoming statutory instruments? How will they reduce the high toll on non-target species such as badgers, otters, deer, livestock, domestic pets and the Scottish wildcat, which get caught in these indiscriminate traps?

link

With respect, some of that presentation of the situation was an exaggeration of what is actually happening. I fully accept the point on the response to the consultation, but the Administration has in, looking at things in balance, taken the view that snaring remains essential for countryside management. Economically, countryside management is extraordinarily important in Scotland, not just for income generation but for employment, so we need to consider that.Given the management that farmers and game managers require to undertake to protect livestock, crops and wild game, the view of those who manage the country—and, indeed, the view of this Government—is that some snaring must be allowed to continue. All the controls that we are beginning to put in place should ensure that the conduct of that snaring is at as high a standard as possible, but nothing will ever be ideal. We will never be in a position in which we will not need to manage the countryside. Everyone expects and understands that there are times when some animals need to be killed—few of us take the view that that need never happen—so the question is on the best way to manage it. In effect, we have considered snaring as one of the least bad options. Shooting is not always practical or safe and it is not always the right thing to do. If we were to say that no animal must ever be killed in the country, we would have a big problem with management.We have decided to go down the road of regulation and order-making powers. I was asked specifically about what is in the orders, but I am not sure whether the convener wants me to move on to that now or to deal just with the more general points at this stage. I have information on what is in the orders, obviously.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

It might be interesting to find out what the key provisions are. However, in response to the minister's comments, let me just say that we know that major landowners and land managers such as RSPB, the Forestry Commission, Scottish Natural Heritage, the John Muir Trust, the Scottish Wildlife Trust and all 32 local authorities manage land without the use of snaring. Therefore, in my view, the minister's claim that snaring is a necessary part of land management is simply untenable.

link

The activity that takes place on many of those estates is not the same as that which takes place on farming and shooting estates. The truth is that the farming and shooting estates are where a lot of the economic activity in the countryside happens. I remind members of what I said about the Langholm project, in which the RSPB is actively working with other organisations to produce concrete and positive outcomes. It is not fair to say that one set of organisations has completely turned away from snaring and another set of organisations is completely turned on to it. The issue is about management.Different proposals are likely to be introduced in the bill, compared with the orders. The original intention was that the bill would introduce two measures: the creation of an accreditation system for those who wish to set snares—that will also include a requirement to use identity tags to identify who has set a snare—and the creation of a new offence of tampering with legally set snares. The ID tag provisions will be included in the primary legislation. That will allow us to police what is happening far more effectively. The ID tags will state the intended target species, so they will also provide a mechanism for better information gathering. The bill will require users of snares to undertake a qualification course and to produce a valid training certificate when requested to do so. It will be an offence to set a snare without having completed such a training course.However, we have been given legal advice that we should not proceed with the original proposal to create a new offence of tampering with a snare because two existing criminal offences cover precisely the same activity. Therefore, that proposal will be dropped. Let me just check where we are with the orders.The order that will be laid on 20 January will introduce proposals for fitting effective stops on snares to prevent the noose from closing too far, which is one of the issues that have been raised with us. Other measures include the checking of snares every 24 hours, a prohibition on the setting of snares near features that could cause unnecessary suffering—which will be dealt with as part of the training—and the ID tag, which I have already mentioned. Some measures will be introduced by the order that will be laid on 20 January, whereas others are being held back for the bill. One measure that we had expected to include in the order has been held back on legal advice and will be included in the bill instead. It was considered that primary legislation rather than regulation would be needed to bring it in.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Good afternoon, minister. In response to one of the convener's questions, you mentioned that the Government is not conducting a formal review. Why has there been some confusion about that? The committee was under the clear impression that a review was under way.

link

I am not clear why there was such confusion, unless it was simply to do with different uses of the word "review". As I said, there is a constant review process as part of our work on drafting the orders, looking at the bill and so on. The confusion may just have been between a formal review and the constant process of informal review. I am sorry, but I am not sure how it arose.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Thank you for that possible explanation.I have a few specific questions. Does the Government have any information on the numbers of animals that were trapped in legal snares and in illegal snares over the past 12 months?

link

We have figures that the national wildlife crime unit has provided, which show that 47 incidents involving snaring were reported in Scotland between April 2007 and October 2009. That period is longer than 12 months.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

From whom did you say those figures had come?

link

They came from the national wildlife crime unit.I can give a breakdown. Of those 47 cases, 18 involved illegally set snares and six involved snares that had been set legally. The national wildlife crime unit was unable to identify whether the remaining 23 incidents involved illegal or legal snares as the information that had been provided did not allow an assessment to be made about legality.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

So the ratio of cases involving illegal snares to those involving legal snares is about 3:1. In how many cases did the snare catch an animal that it was designed to catch?

link

I have no information on that from the figures from the national wildlife crime unit. Such information will not have been available. Hugh Dignon might have further information.

Hugh Dignon Scottish Government Rural Directorate
link

There is no systematic information available on the number of non-target species that are caught in snares, although a number of research projects have been carried out over the years, in which the percentage has varied. In some surveys, it has been as high as 50 or 60 per cent, but other surveys reflect a concentration on improving the fieldcraft of the person who was responsible for setting the snares.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Should a more systematic approach be adopted if we are to have pertinent information on the basis of which Governments can decide the correct policies to follow? The information that is available seems to be extremely vague and hazy.

link

At the moment, suspicious incidents are reported—those are the figures that we get from the national wildlife crime unit. It can decide whether those incidents involve snares that are legal or illegal, but in some cases it cannot make an assessment.Because snaring is, essentially, a legal activity, detailed information has not been gathered over the years. Detailed returns such as Bill Butler is talking about have not been gathered. There is a culture of gathering information, which goes back to the 19th century and what were called vermin books. Keepers would report to their bosses about what had been caught in any given period. What no Government has ever done is to turn that into a legal requirement to report to the police or to a Government body. In theory, it would be possible to do that, although the burden would be extremely heavy if we were to go down that road.The alternative would be to conduct on a number of farms and estates a research survey on information gathering. Such surveys cost tens of thousands of pounds, so we would need to consider whether that was appropriate. The difficulty is that we are starting with an activity that is, in effect, legal, so our approach is to professionalise that activity. ID tagging, together with the professionalisation, will go quite a long way towards raising standards. The worst examples of snaring tend to be part and parcel of activity that is already illegal, such as poaching. That is a bigger wildlife crime issue.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

You mentioned that orders are to be laid on 20 January.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I accept that that is the current plan, because you have just said it. Whenever the orders are laid, will they prevent instances such as are mentioned in a document that the committee has received from the petitioners—you may have seen it—in which apparently legal snares are likely to operate illegally in circumstances beyond the operator's control, for example when the trapped animal struggles, making the wire kinked and twisted? Can any order ever prevent that?

link

I do not know whether we will ever have a perfect scenario. Our view is that snaring is one of the least bad options. I do not want to sit here and say to the committee that a non-target animal will never be caught in a snare or that there will never be difficulties. What we are trying to do is to tackle the difficulties and remove them from the process. We have not seen the papers to which you are referring, so I do not want to talk about the specifics of such incidents.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

If you will take it from me, minister, it is one of the concerns raised by the petitioners.

link

I understand. The concerns exist even among a wide group of countryside managers. People are trying to establish a position in which the snares do the precise job that they are required to do, and no more. We are not at that perfect state yet, and we are trying to introduce various measures that will allow us increasingly to rely on the accuracy of the snares in terms of the animals caught, and the ability of the snare to release non-target animals or not to hold them in such a way that they will be in danger.We continue to address the kinds of snare, ID tagging and the requirement for a professional qualification. All those measures attempt to tackle concerns and issues that people raise—legitimately—about a major animal welfare issue.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Members want to ask about several issues. Does anybody still want to ask about the current subject? Is John Wilson's question about a different matter?

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

My question is about the recent responses.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We will keep to that at the moment.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

You have referred a couple of times to the training and qualifications that individuals who set snares will need. What discussions have taken place with countryside managers and conservation organisations about the costs of introducing such qualifications for operators of snares?

link

The cost has not been paramount in our minds. Our view is that the qualitative necessity overrides any cost issue. I am not conscious of representations from organisations that are concerned about the costs—Interruption—but I am obviously about to be given some information. The lack of representations might be because the cost is only £40 per person. The concern has not been raised directly with ministers and neither of my officials indicates that it has been a big issue that organisations have raised.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Thank you for your response and for giving the cost that is expected to be associated with the measures. The sum of £40 does not seem huge for the training and qualifications for setting snares. The aim is just to have the accuracy of that figure.You mentioned the records that gamekeepers in particular used to keep about the snares that they set, the target animals and the animals that those snares caught. If we are to have a qualification for setting snares, we should build on that to ensure that snare operators detail the species that are being targeted. Without causing undue distress to snare operators, we should encourage them to be honest about the species that snares catch unintentionally, so that we have an accurate figure about how successful and useful setting snares is for countryside management.We have heard a couple of times that setting snares is one of the best ways of controlling some species, but I am concerned about how, if we continue to set snares but not to collect accurate information and figures about their unintended consequences, we will monitor the effectiveness of setting snares and stop the continued snaring of species that have been reintroduced into Scotland.

link

That question is fair. The ID tags will be tied to target species—that is one initiative that will help. We need to remember that, if we went for detailed and constant monitoring, that would have a cost, too. People would have to record the information when they were out on the hills for eight, nine, 10, 11 or 12 hours in all weathers, because of the work that they do. Such monitoring raises practical issues.If we chose to, we could spend money on a research project. Much record keeping will still be done relatively informally. The vermin books that I spoke about were not formal—they were estate books and were part of estate management. Much of that record keeping still goes on. Monitoring and control are constant, because if the number of foxes or whatever increases suddenly and is a problem that must be managed, management will want to be aware of that. If the number of foxes that are caught in snares suddenly rises, management will want to know what is going on. Part and parcel of management is keeping such monitoring going.From the estate manager's point of view, it is of no great use to get non-target animals. They want to achieve real quality by getting target animals, because it is those that are the problem in the management of estates.The Food and Environment Research Agency in York is doing a research project on snaring. Strictly speaking, it is doing the work for the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, but we, too, await the outcome. The issues that we are addressing in Scotland are live for the whole United Kingdom. That is part and parcel of keeping the matter at the forefront of our thoughts. We are constantly looking at any research that has been done elsewhere. We are keeping all that constantly in our minds.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I was interested to read that all but five of the European member states have banned the use of animal snares. Has the Scottish Government looked at other countries to find out when they banned snaring, why they did it and what the consequences were for effective countryside management? If not, will the Government consider finding out how other countries manage their countryside economies?

link

Yes, of course we look at what other examples there are of snaring policy in other countries. However, it is not as easy as you might imagine to get detailed information about what takes place in other countries. For example, there is a belief that France has far stricter snare rules than we have, but that is not the case. When we look closely at what it does, although it designates community trappers—individuals who are responsible to the local mayor or notary for the trapping—it still allows the kinds of traps and snares that are illegal in this country.At one level, France does things slightly differently, with the community trapper, but at another level they use snares that we do not allow because we believe that they are inappropriate from an animal welfare point of view. That shows why it is sometimes difficult to look at the headline figure from a country and say, "Okay—they have done that. We can now do it as well." When we look behind the figures and the headlines, the position does not always turn out to be quite what the public relations say it is.We have found it difficult to get the detailed information that we require to make a fair cross-border assessment. Even within the UK, there are variations, and tracking down the differences is not always as easy as you might think. I guess that I am just issuing a word of caution about assuming that, because there is a headline that says, "We have done this" or, "We have a stricter set of that", we can accept it. It might turn out not to be accurate; the reality might not justify the headline in the way that you might imagine.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Countries such as Ireland, France and Spain and, of course, the whole of the United Kingdom still have animal snaring, but I understand that other European member states have banned it. It would be interesting to look at the difference and find out what the reaction to the ban was at the time, and what the reaction is some years on, from people who work in the countryside.

link

That would be reasonable if we could assess that kind of thing easily, but we cannot. The other thing that you need to keep in mind is that the nature of our countryside economy might not be the same as that of other countries. We would have to look at that as well. The impact of a ban will depend entirely on the nature of the countryside economy in any one country. To be facetious about it, if Luxembourg bans snaring, a comparison with it will be of no use from our perspective. When you compare what happens in one country with what happens in another, it is not only the policy on snaring that you have to compare but the potential impact on those countries' rural economies, how each country's rural economy is made up and where the money, jobs and so on come from. If you do that, you will find that there will be great differences in the impact on certain countries.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I understand what you are saying, but it would be interesting to see whether there was a body of work that compared like with like, in so far as that is possible. It would be good to know what the impact has been on countries that have completely banned snaring. Such research might back up the petitioner's argument, or it might back up the Government's argument.

link

There is no cross-border European study of that nature. I am not sure how easily we could set one up. We could try to perform an informal study but, for the reasons that I have outlined, that has not proven to be easy to do.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I cannot help but venture the opinion that all of the facts and figures on Europe's rural economies are readily available to anyone who cares to ask for a summary of them from the countries concerned. I want to ask about the monitoring that the minister mentioned earlier. An essential part of that is performed by wildlife crime officers. Is the minister aware of the pressures that are exerted on those officers in many communities? Is the Government considering offering them extra support? Will there be any comfort for them in the forthcoming legislation?

link

We are proactively pursuing work on the issue of wildlife crime. Obviously, it is a bigger issue, of which illegal snaring is a part. I have already had discussions with the Cabinet Secretary for Justice because the prosecution of wildlife crime is part of the normal Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service set-up. We have concerns about how seriously wildlife crime is taken. One of those concerns involves the differences between police forces. Some forces are good at clearly designating wildlife crime officers, while others are not. We are actively trying to tackle that in various ways, including through our work with the partnership for action against wildlife crime. I will meet the Solicitor General tomorrow to discuss that subject.Obviously, all police forces try to investigate reported crime and prevent crime, but there is a range of priorities for their limited resources. Nonetheless, some police forces manage to deal with the issue that we are discussing better than others do. Many of us will have spoken to Alan Stewart, who has been a wildlife crime officer with Tayside Police for a long time—in some parts of Scotland, there is a history of proactivity, although in other parts there is not. The designation of wildlife crime officers is a matter for the chief constable within any given police area. If there are police authorities that are not proactively designating wildlife crime officers, I invite MSPs to lobby appropriately. That would help us enormously.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

You make a strong case for the retention of snaring, which I find surprising. I cannot possibly agree with many of your statements. I was also quite amused when you said that the snare could be adapted or set for a particular target species—that you could identify the snare with the species that you were trying to catch.

Hugh Dignon Scottish Government Rural Directorate
link

It is to do with the stop. We are specifying that the snare must have a stop on it to prevent the noose from closing too tightly. That stop will be set at different diameters for fox and rabbit snares. It will say whether the snare is set for foxes or rabbits—

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I understand that, but you must appreciate that the predator or wild animal that is roaming about in the forest does not read and cannot identify whether the snare is for him. I cannot see that what you describe will benefit wildlife at all. There will be nothing on the snare to prevent its snaring a domestic animal or a non-target species—it is not always the targeted predator that goes in the snare. You are suggesting that the answer to the problem is for the snare to have an identity tag on it. Yes, there should be an identity tag to identify whoever has set the snare, but to suggest that a snare can be identified for a particular species is quite—

link

The snare can be set to stop at the appropriate point for an identified species. To be fair, I did not say that we would achieve a perfect world on this—I do not think that that is possible and I doubt whether it would ever be possible.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I am not suggesting that we should even attempt to get a perfect system. I have met many keepers and have spoken to them at length about snaring. Some of them are quite supportive of snaring; others would sooner not have anything to do with it. So, you have a mixed bag there. However, no matter which snare is set, you cannot guarantee that it will catch only the target species.I have several questions, which I should perhaps lump together. Can you guarantee that only targeted predators will be caught in snares? I do not think that you can.

link

No, and I have not pretended that we can guarantee that. We are trying to make it possible to release non-target species unharmed—that is the point. The point of the stop is to ensure that, if a non-target species is caught by the snare, it will not be harmed by the snare and it will be possible to release it.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

But any animal—targeted or otherwise—that is in a snare for any length of time will be traumatised and cannot be released unharmed. It will certainly be harmed if it goes in the snare.Why can a snare not be regarded as cruel? It causes suffering to the caught animal and a long and painful death. Most people would agree that any animal that is caught or restrained in a snare for any length of time will be traumatised. On the basis of the best evidence that is available to us and to you, and in the light of the responses that we have heard, there is no justification for continuing to snare wild animals. Why not just ban snares completely?

link

I said at the outset why we do not think that an outright ban is appropriate. I point out that any research that anybody might ask to be carried out would involve the use of snares. For example, scientists on research projects have to use snares to capture animals, which obviously will not be dead. Snaring has uses beyond vermin control, but the basic point is that the control of these target animals is a fundamental aspect of rural management.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

There are means of controlling such animals without using snares.

link

Well, there is shooting, which is as likely to throw up the same kinds of problems that we have with snaring. Unless you can guarantee—and no one can—that anyone on the hills who uses a gun for vermin control can be 100 per cent accurate, you are just as likely to have the same longer-term problems.As I said at the outset, there is no perfect solution to this problem. Vermin control will still have to be carried out even if snaring is banned, because otherwise it will be impossible to manage the rural economy. However, every other method of vermin control comes with its own issues and is just as likely to raise the same kinds of animal welfare issues that we have been discussing in relation to snaring. Sadly, this is not an ideal world.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I quite agree that this is not an ideal world, but I have more confidence in the skill and ability of gamekeepers who use rifles or guns. There will, of course, be the odd incident in which an animal is wounded, but I am sure that the keepers would continue with its culling before it died from those wounds.

link

I am bound to say that I have received no representations from gamekeepers along those lines and I look forward to their presenting those views. I admit that I do not take part in these kinds of country sports, but I find it difficult to see how shooting would work with some of the species that are targeted by snaring. You have high vegetation and small animals—it is not as simple or as straightforward as it might sound when you first say it.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

Given the difficulty of detecting wildlife crime, I assume that, if snaring were to be banned, a group of people would still carry on with what would be an illegal pursuit and animals would still suffer as a result.

link

A lot of illegal snaring takes place as part and parcel of a larger illegal enterprise, which includes activities such as poaching and badger baiting. The fact is that, as we still have problems in tackling such crime, illegal snaring will still take place. Banning legal snaring activity will not necessarily do away with much of the illegal snaring that, as I say, is part and parcel of this wider criminal activity, and that raises issues that we have already discussed about the prosecution of wildlife crime.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

The Parliament has already agreed that snares should be checked once every 24 hours. Given some of the comments that have been made, and rather than having wildlife managers going around the countryside shooting at foxes or other species deemed to be vermin or thought to be damaging the environment, I was wondering, just out of curiosity, whether alternatives such as using nets or cages have been considered.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

If snaring is seen as inhumane, we need to find other ways. A large proportion of public opinion is opposed to snaring, but there are other methods that we could use, if we ensured that their management was monitored properly.

link

There are some. The Langholm project has invited the committee to come and look at what it is doing. Part and parcel of that is the project's investigation of different kinds of trapping. I have been reminded that there is a big difference between urban and rural foxes. Rural foxes are a bit cannier and are not likely to enter the kind of cage trap that you are envisaging; you must bear that difficulty in mind. An urban fox is accustomed to the ways of humans; rural foxes are not and are likely to be much less inclined to be caught. I urge members to look at some of the traps that the Langholm project is examining, as well as snares.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

This has been a helpful discussion. There will be different views on the effectiveness or otherwise of snaring and so on, but one key issue on which the Public Petitions Committee has worked over the past few years is the engagement that petitioners can have with the process of discussion, participation and partnership. We have received some positive responses from Government ministers, who have indicated that they will try to work with petitioners, where they can.Two issues popped up at the end of the discussion. First, if snares are applied, what will be done to ensure that that is done as humanely as possible or managed as effectively as possible, to minimise risks? Has thought been given to involving the petitioners in some of the training processes about which people have expressed concerns, especially in relation to how snares are set or used? Secondly, you referred to an organisation called the partnership for action against welfare crime—

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The partnership for action against welfare crime could also be interesting—we are not snaring any of those yet, but it is a thought. Is there any chance that the petitioners could engage in discussion about the membership of the partnership?

link

The partnership for action against wildlife crime involves a large number of people—the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals and the petitioners are involved. I have also met the petitioners to discuss the wildlife and natural environment bill. It is not the case that there has been no involvement—there has, but there has been no meeting of minds. That is the issue, not lack of involvement.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

You mentioned DEFRA research. What is the timescale for that?

link

I do not know the timescale for the York project. We will try to establish that.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

It would be helpful if you could get back to the clerk about that.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

You talked about moving towards a system of accreditation. Do you agree that it is important that people representing animal welfare organisations are involved in any such system? You also talked about the importance of shooting to the Scottish economy. Can you provide us with figures for the economic importance of wildlife tourism, excluding shooting and stalking, in Scotland?

link

I do not have both sets of figures in front of me, but the two are not mutually exclusive. One is not at the expense of the other—both are vitally important to the economy of rural Scotland, and we want both to grow and thrive. I question how many tourists come to Scotland to see foxes and rabbits because they are the principal pests in countryside management.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I was not suggesting that people were doing that, minister.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We have had a good discussion on some of the issues. There are strongly held views on the issues that the petitioners raise, and the minister needs to address some of them. We will continue the petition and will have a chance to discuss it in subsequent meetings.I thank the minister for her contribution. We will bring the petition back to the committee to deliberate further on some of the points that it raises.There is a wee bit of logistical shifting around to do for the next item because it is a round-table discussion, so I leave the committee in the capable hands of the clerks while we do that.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 12 January 2010 Petitions · 1
  2. Current Petitions Petitions · 78
  3. Current Petitions Petitions · 47
  4. Current Petitions Petitions · 35
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  14. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.