Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Wind Farm Developments (PE1095)

Tuesday 12 January 2010 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 47 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

47 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The next petition is PE1095, from Sybil Simpson, whom I welcome to this afternoon's meeting. She has petitioned the Parliament for a considerable period of time, and we have received a voluminous amount of information and correspondence. I am pleased that we have the chance to have a shared discussion this afternoon.The petition has been lodged on behalf of the save your regional parks campaign, and it asks the Scottish Parliament to urge the Government to provide greater protection for the national and regional parks of Scotland from industrialisation, including wind farms and their associated quarries, roads, cable trenches and sub-stations.I welcome Kenneth Gibson MSP to this afternoon's session. He has been a supporter of the petition for a long time. We also have with us Nigel Willis, who is the chair of the save your regional parks campaign, Robert Maund, and, from the Scottish Government, Graeme Purves, assistant chief planner, and Jamie Hume, deputy director of renewable energy.We therefore have at the table a number of individuals with experience and knowledge on these issues. I know that committee members wish to ask a lot of questions, and I invite Anne McLaughlin to begin.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

We know that Kenneth Gibson has proposed a member's bill, and we thought that it might be interesting to kick off by asking him where that stands. My fellow committee members said that I ought to ask you to be brief, Kenneth, but I thought that that was a bit unfair, so you take your time.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The caveat to that is, "Don't always believe what a politician says."

Kenneth Gibson SNP Cunninghame North
link

Thank you, Ms McLaughlin, for that warm welcome. It is hard to believe that it is almost two years since I last came to the committee to speak on this issue.The responses to the consultation on the bill proposal came in last year; all members should have a copy of the summary of them. Around 91 responses were received, which represents a very high proportion of the total number—150—of consultation documents that were circulated in hard copy and by e-mail.The overwhelming response is that there should be protection for Scotland's three regional parks, which take up around 0.5 per cent of Scotland's land area. It is clear that the vast majority of respondents do not believe that the Scottish Government is providing enough protection. The committee is concerned that there have been evasive responses from the Government during the past two years. Everyone involved wants some decisions to be made on the issue.One concern is that applications continue to be submitted, certainly with regard to Clyde Muirshiel regional park. There are fears among many local people, including those who are present today, that the regional parks will be chipped away piece by piece. There are no statutory rights attached to regional parks in Scotland, and there is therefore very little protection against industrial development. We should recall the words of the First Minister, who on 23 May 2007 stated:"There is enormous potential for further wind power development in Scotland, but we must also be mindful that natural beauty in our environment is a scarce resource."—Official Report, 23 May 2007; c 72.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you. We will gather some information quickly, as a fair amount of material has been sent to us. I invite the Scottish Government officials to make a brief contribution on the maps that have been provided to committee members. I feel as if I am trying to do geography standard grade—I need some help here.

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

We provided the maps as part of a supplementary briefing paper that we prepared just before Christmas. As has been mentioned, the petition has been before the committee for some time. We have now provided six responses to the committee on the petition, and we are anxious not to swamp you with yet more paper.We have tried to provide a fairly brief further supplementary paper that gives some background on the origins of regional parks and brings the committee up to date with planning policy in relation to regional and national parks. The committee may be aware that we are undergoing a process of transition. We are consolidating the existing body of Scottish planning policy, which was previously contained in around 17 documents, into a single SPP that we expect to publish very shortly. We do not yet have the date for that, but it will be published quite soon. We wanted to provide the committee with a picture of how planning policy is likely to develop.Our supplementary paper also seeks to bring the committee up to date with wind farm casework, both nationally and particularly in Clyde Muirshiel regional park, which has been one of the main focuses of concern of the petitioners. The first map in the paper presents a Scottish picture of wind farm proposals. They are colour coded. Those proposals that are still in scoping are in purple, current applications are coloured orange and those that are already installed or approved are shown as red. The map also shows significant environmental designations. We thought that that would provide the committee with a useful context for understanding the range of environmental constraints that require to be taken into account in considering policy on wind farm development and individual wind farm proposals.The second map focuses on Clyde Muirshiel regional park, which has been a primary focus of concern for the petitioners. There have been a number of applications and proposals for wind farm development within the regional park. The map shows the boundary of the regional park in purple and it illustrates that a substantial part of the northern area of the park—shaded in green—is covered by a European designation. It is a special protection area, which has been designated to protect important wild bird habitat. A significant part of the northern area of the park is also protected by the Glasgow city green belt, and that is shown as the hatched area.The map illustrates a range of proposed and approved wind farm developments within the park. Three have already been approved: at Ardrossan, which is at the southern edge of the park, at Wardlaw wood and at the Kelburn estate. There are further live proposals at Kaim Hill, Wings Law and Waterhead Moor further north. I hope that that provides a helpful summary of what the map is attempting to illustrate.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thanks for that. It might be harder for those in the public gallery to judge, but members have the map in front of them and that summary has given us a clearer sense of what we are dealing with.I now invite Sybil Simpson to contribute on some of the issues of concern. We have already had the petition in front of us on a number of occasions, so I ask you to focus on the current situation, given the most recent developments elsewhere in Scotland.

Sybil Simpson Save Your Regional Park Campaign
link

It is important to reiterate that we are strong supporters of renewable energy. We are certainly not an anti-wind farm group. We are strong advocates of putting wind farms in appropriate sites. This is not a party-political issue, but it should be viewed by Government as a national issue. There are national parks, but regional parks contribute to national targets and policy, too, on the health front and so on.We represent thousands of supporters as well as 13 community councils whose areas surround Clyde Muirshiel regional park. We do not wish to give the committee the wrong message—it seems as if we are focused only on Clyde Muirshiel, but we are not; we are equally passionate about all the parks of Scotland. However, Clyde Muirshiel is the first park that has been attacked—and quite vigorously—by developers.Why is it that, for generations, man and Government have not valued our natural environment as a very important national asset? Government should put a price tag on such natural assets and they should be as precious as a gold reserve. A healthy natural environment is an ecological life-support system. Our natural environment provides loads of goods and services. Believe it or not, all of us have taken them for granted. However, they are vital to human life, to the quality of life, to the climate and to people's livelihoods as well as their recreation. In fact, they provide a green service to us all.Now that we are more aware of green issues, I feel that we should, as a nation, consider national and regional parks as a vital plank in the future wellbeing of our nation. With appropriate policies and good structures, the parks could and should deliver a green way of life for many of us. As well as providing services, much of our green environment is traditionally viewed as providing free benefits to society, which we take for granted and assume will always be there for us. That includes wildlife habitats, biodiversity, water purification, carbon storage and scenic landscapes.Lacking a formal market, our parks are traditionally absent from society's balance sheet. Their critical contributions are often overlooked by public, corporate and Government decision making. However, it is important to me that we protect them. Because they are undervalued, they are increasingly susceptible to development pressure and conversion to urban use. It is easy for people to make such development decisions just to get developers out of their hair.Is it not time that our Government listened to the wishes of its people and took a firm stand against developers in the parks? We know that thousands of people are concerned about the issue. Community councils reflect the wishes of people from all walks of life and from all political parties in that regard. That is why we feel that the issue of developments in parks should be a national issue.The decline and loss of our national parks cause significant harm to our nation's economy as well. Because our parks are being forced to absorb major change by Government vis-à-vis wind farms, they will continue to be undervalued. Clyde Muirshiel regional park is beginning to be undervalued, because we can already see the wind farms coming up. In fact, the map on the table before us is not correct, and I will ask Robert Maund to explain the ways in which it is incorrect. An awful lot more is happening in the park than appears on the map.The sad thing for us is that developers and reporters in public inquiries are trying to tell us that the Glasgow and Clyde valley structure plan and the Ayrshire structure plan do not really matter and that wind farms will not affect in any way the wonderful wildness of our parks. I feel that the developers and the reporters underestimate the general public and the thousands who live in and use the parks, because we see, for example, the south side of Clyde Muirshiel park being eroded year by year.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I know that this is a round-table discussion, but it is your petition, so I thought that it was appropriate to hear from you about the concerns that you still have, particularly given that the petition has been in our system for a few years.We have heard about the proposed bill, which was outlined by Kenneth Gibson, and we have heard from Sybil Simpson about the petition and the locations concerned. I invite comments and observations from committee members and from those who have been invited along as specialists or people with an interest in the areas concerned. I am happy to hear your views. Who wants to kick off?

Nigel Willis Save Your Regional Park Campaign
link

Could Mr Maund explain this map, which unfortunately is very incomplete?

Robert Maund Scottish Campaign for National Parks
link

Sybil Simpson initiated the petition because it was clear to us that Government guidance on the location of wind farms was not working, although that does not mean to say that it was not well intentioned. Clyde Muirshiel regional park is the best example of that. It is 118 square miles and 35 square miles at its heart is a site of special scientific interest and a special protection area. However, it has been the subject of an ad hoc, unplanned, developer-led assault by the wind energy industry. To appreciate the scale of that assault, it is necessary to look at the map.Your briefing note refers to eight applications in or partly within the park. In practice, there are 13 schemes. The ones that are missing are applications for 22 turbines on Corlic' Hill in Inverclyde; 10 at Inverkip in Inverclyde; 20 on Ferret of Keith Moor in Inverclyde; 16 at Skelmorlie in North Ayrshire; 13 at Hunterston in North Ayrshire; six on Millour hill in North Ayrshire, which is referred to in the key but not shown on the map; and three at Glenlora in Renfrewshire.There have now been four approvals—one by ministers and three by North Ayrshire Council—two withdrawals and five refusals. There are three outstanding refusals. Two are being appealed and the other is likely to follow. That would bring the number of public local inquiries in one area to six.If Government guidance was clear and was working, a lot of time, effort and resources could be saved. Developers have been unresponsive to the site of special scientific interest and the special protection area and the fact that the whole park is an area of great landscape value and an International Union for Conservation of Nature category 5 protected area in exactly the same way that all the national parks throughout the United Kingdom are.The three local authorities that are responsible for the park—Inverclyde Council, North Ayrshire Council and Renfrewshire Council—clearly do not wish to see further turbines in the park. Their local plans and structure plans clearly reflect that, but they are being pressured, through the appeals process, to allow some.Government guidance said that regional designations should be protected, but not as strongly as national designations. In reality, there is no way that the impact of a 400ft structure can be ameliorated. Park users' countryside experience is destroyed.The park is a vital resource for conservation and landscape, health and wellbeing, education, recreation and leisure and tourism and the economy. More than 1.25 million people are recorded as using the park every year. Given all those who just walk out into the countryside and who are not recorded as using the park, we could probably say that 1.5 million to 2 million people use the park every year. The park is in grave danger of being destroyed because there is equivocation and a lack of clarity in the guidance, which is not working.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I am conscious of how difficult this issue is because there are competing pressures. Robert Maund and Sybil Simpson have raised concerns. I wonder about the role that Scottish Government officials can play. I know that there are many pressures, given the different commitments that have been made by both the previous Government and the present Government. How do you try to accommodate the concern that there could be an endless amount of development in a regional park that does not respect why the park is treasured by the local public?

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

I acknowledge that there has been quite a lot of development interest in Clyde Muirshiel. Mr Maund referred to a number of proposals that are not shown on the map. The reason why several of them are not shown on the map is that they have either been withdrawn or been refused permission, which means that they are not live proposals. Some of them are shown on another map that is among the material that has been submitted to you by the petitioners.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I understand that, and it is helpful to have that clarification. However, in terms of the principal issue—

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

You are right that planning policy is trying to do two things. It is trying to provide a supportive network for the development of our renewable energy capacity—given the ambitious climate change targets that we have given ourselves, that is necessary—but it is also trying to protect the environment. I do not accept that the planning system undervalues our environment. It attaches great importance to protecting our environmental assets. I argue that the policy framework that is in place is robust and is entirely in tune with the sentiments that were expressed by the First Minister in May 2007.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I know that some piece of research—whose name I cannot recall—has shown that, given that Scotland has around 23 per cent of European wind energy resource, more than enough energy for Scotland's needs can be produced in Scotland without impacting on any area of special environmental designation. It strikes me that having six public local inquiries is a ridiculous waste of public money, apart from anything else. You have helpfully set out how the planning system is being reformed and I understand that work is under way in that regard. I note that you say that it is important to balance the need to reduce carbon emissions with the impact of developments on the environment. However, I do not think that the balance is right at the moment. In what way will the balance be changed to ensure that what is happening in this park does not happen in other places? I represent Midlothian, which covers a part of the Pentland Hills regional park, and I understand the importance of such areas. I am seeking reassurance that the planning system is changing in such a way that we can deliver carbon emission reductions while not having ridiculous situations of the sort that appears to have developed in Clyde Muirshiel regional park.

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

Over the past year, we have conducted a consolidation exercise with regard to Scottish planning policy. The issue, therefore, is not about creating new policy—when the new SPP is published, planning policy will remain substantially the same as it was. However, we have taken the opportunity to clarify matters and have specifically addressed the issue of regional parks. Those parks have been designated because of their recreational value to urban populations, and the policy states clearly that planning authorities should take account of the reason for that designation in making decisions that affect those parks. That is a clear signal to planning authorities—and developers—that the recreational value of the parks is important and should be protected in planning decisions.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Are you saying that it is okay for there to have been six PLIs and for there to have been a cumulative impact on an area as a result of such a number of applications?

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

Cumulative impact is a key consideration for planning authorities. The fact that a number of developments have already taken place makes that an even more important consideration when any other proposals for development in the park are considered.

Sybil Simpson Save Your Regional Park Campaign
link

I have heard that argument being made by the local authorities many times at the PLI, and I have seen the advocate for the developers shatter it by saying that SPP 6, on renewable energy, does not protect regional parks. What you have just said saddens me considerably, because what you are really saying is that your new planning policy will not specifically say that regional parks are equal to national parks.

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

It certainly does not say that, because regional parks and national parks are different and are defined very differently in the legislation. They have a different status: regional parks have a regional status, whereas national parks have a national status. Regional parks are not equivalent to national parks; they are not, for example, junior or cadet national parks—they are defined much more narrowly than national parks. Regional parks have recreational value, whereas national parks are natural and cultural resources of national importance, so they are different in character.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We will need to come back to those points. I missed out John Wilson—sorry about that.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I want to understand why so many wind farm developments have been proposed for Clyde Muirshiel regional park. We need to concentrate on the situation there rather than on the Scotland-wide situation. I am reminded of last week's statement on the Beauly to Denny transmission line, when I think the minister said that about 85 per cent of the renewable energy in Scotland would come down that line. If that is the case, why do we need the plethora of wind farms for which applications have been made in areas such as Clyde Muirshiel regional park?For me, the issue is where the market is for that renewable energy. Is it in Scotland or—just to be controversial—given that the area that we are talking about is conveniently close to the Irish Sea, is it in Northern Ireland or Ireland? I need to get responses from the Scottish Government officials on that. Given the number of wind farm developments that are in the pipeline for Scotland, we need to be clear about what the market is for that renewable energy. The issue is not just about the recreational value of some of our countryside assets; it is about the wildlife, too. There is a hen harrier population in Clyde Muirshiel regional park that is fairly unique to the area. If we go ahead with some of the proposed developments, they will have an impact not only on recreational use of the park but on some of the wildlife in it.We need to find out what the Government is trying to achieve through the number of wind farm developments that have been proposed and how developers are getting away with such proposals. If we can meet our targets on renewable energy, where will all the additional energy that is to be produced be used? Is it simply the case that developers are picking an easy target in regional parks? Are they making applications to build wind farms in such locations because they know that the Scottish Government has renewables targets and they think that they can circumvent some of the planning policies and, in doing so, generate energy that we can sell elsewhere?

Jamie Hume Scottish Government Business, Enterprise and Energy Directorate
link

I am happy to respond to some of those points.First, I will deal with the point about the market for renewable energy. The largest stimulus for renewable energy developments is the renewables obligation certificate system, which works on a United Kingdom level to make onshore wind commercially viable. Scotland is already a net exporter of energy, and it is a clearly stated Government ambition for it to remain so. Last year's inquiry by the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee showed that there is wide cross-party support for the notion that Scotland's extremely high level of resource in onshore and offshore wind and wave and tidal energy carries with it highly significant economic opportunities. A policy that works to encourage and facilitate the development of those opportunities has potential benefit for Scottish firms, job creation and so on. That is the broad direction.John Wilson alluded to the idea that, as we approach our own domestic targets for renewable energy, there should perhaps be a corresponding tail-off in support for renewables. Is that the case? The answer to that is no. Those targets are perceived less as a ceiling and more as a floor for our ambition, because there is a significant international market for renewable energy, not just in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland but in the rest of the UK. For instance, proposals are going ahead for grid interconnectors down the east and west coasts to enable more of that power to be exported, while the idea of a North Sea supergrid is gradually gaining momentum and has strong support at Government and European level. It strikes me that there are a few sets of issues here. There is the developer mentality: what is driving the applications and how many more of them might there be in future? There is the clear question of what resource is required, and there are the PLIs, how much of our collective resource gets sucked into administering the applications, and the Government role in managing that.The case history is interesting. I run the section 36 consents team—applications under section 36 are for anything of 50MW or more. There are the schemes at Ladymoor, which has been withdrawn, and Corlick Hill, which was refused. Of other applications that have been submitted, it is widely understood that there is a high level of opposition to the Waterhead Moor scheme at the local community level and from statutory consultees. It is classed as an application although in fact for three or four years it has been more of an intent to submit an application. The environmental statement has still not come through, which reflects the difficulty of progressing the application from a developer perspective, the opposition that the application has already met, and the case history. Other cases, such as the Lewis wind farm, have shown that the current system does what it says on the tin in terms of protecting designated areas and accommodating the views of the statutory consultees.As recently as just a few years ago, the consenting system was quite slow and bureaucratic. A lot of effort has gone into speeding it up and getting quicker decisions for developers and greater clarity on proposals at an early stage, so that we avoid, for instance, unrealistic proposals getting all the way through to public inquiry.It is a slow process, but there are definite signs of progress. On the one hand, we are providing a joined-up and coherent system among the Scottish Government, SNH, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, and local authorities and so on, which offers surety and speed of decision—we now have a nine-month turnaround target for developers. On the other hand, there is an obligation for everyone to play the game and not to submit unrealistic applications or applications that will bog down everyone's resource in costly and time-consuming inquiries.Based on the case history of section 36 applications and proposals such as Waterhead Moor that have been sitting more or less stagnant in the system for a few years, it is recognised that further large-scale developments such as Waterhead Moor are unlikely to be worth the resource that developers will need to put into them to make progress. Obviously, local planning issues and sub-50MW proposals are a separate discussion but, as far as section 36 goes, we feel that the process is working well. The case history of section 36 applications over the past few years shows that no schemes of that size have come through. We feel that the notion "renewables but not at any cost" is being pretty much borne out as events unfold.

Kenneth Gibson SNP Cunninghame North
link

We seem to have heard contradictory statements from Mr Hume and Mr Purves. Mr Purves talked about consolidation in applications for Clyde Muirshiel regional park, whereas Mr Hume seemed to say, in response to John Wilson's questions, that there would never be a limit on renewables developments.Last week, there was an announcement about 4.8GW of offshore wind in the Scottish sector to 2020. There are proposals for carbon capture and storage plants at Longannet and Hunterston, and there is the possibility of a new gas turbine at Cockenzie and hydroelectric power in the Great Glen. Today there were two announcements about wind farms in Rothes and Caithness. North Ayrshire Council, which covers part of the regional park, has already made it clear that it can meet its renewable energy obligations without having to go into Muirshiel park.Most of the people who are opposed to those unwanted developments, including all the local community councils, bar none, want to know when enough is going to be enough. Despite what you have said, I do not think that there has been an unequivocal statement that we will not permit developments beyond a certain amount. Developers seem to have an amber light, if not a green light, to continue to put in applications. As Robert Maund said, that wastes everyone's time: the developers might or might not be successful at tremendous financial cost to themselves, and the protesters do not want to spend their whole lives having to fight application after application.Question 4 in my consultation asked:"Do you think the Scottish Government is doing enough to maintain and protect Scotland's regional parks? If not, what are your recommendations?"No one really said that the Government is doing enough to protect the regional parks; there is no confidence that the Government is doing the right thing. Regional parks are different from national parks, and people accept that there is a difference, but the adopted aims for regional parks are more or less the same relative to national parks. They want to do similar things: enhance the landscape and the natural and cultural heritage of the area, widen opportunities for local communities and beyond, protect the asset, and make the recreational amenity attractive and popular in those special areas.Most of us who are against further developments in regional parks are saying that, 100 years from now when we are all long dead and gone, we want the people who come after us to be able to enjoy the asset as it is now, not two thirds, three quarters or half of it. That is why we are opposed to the relentless chipping away of 50MW here and 25MW there that is effectively ruining that asset.On the economics of the situation, back in February 2008 when the petition first came to the committee, the Scottish tourism economic activity monitor researched visitors' attitudes to the regional parks and showed that up to 27 per cent said that they would not return to the park if more turbines were erected. That would have a significant economic impact on the tourism industry in that part of Scotland. I therefore suggest that it is time for the Scottish Government to be much less ambivalent and much more direct about saying what its position is, and that that position should be that no more wind farm developments should be agreed for regional parks.

Jamie Hume Scottish Government Business, Enterprise and Energy Directorate
link

Convener, may I clarify something?

Jamie Hume Scottish Government Business, Enterprise and Energy Directorate
link

I referred to the ambition to continue to support the renewables industry in general on a Scotland-wide basis. Whatever Graeme Purves was saying about the park, I do not see—

Kenneth Gibson SNP Cunninghame North
link

He said that there would be a limit in the park without specifying what that limit would be. You were talking about Scotland. What is the limit? The situation appears to be contradictory because you are looking for a way for Scotland to expand its renewables potential exponentially, but it cannot continue to do that unless more or less every area in which wind farms and other such developments are possible is developed. I do not believe that many of us want to see that; I certainly do not.

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

I was talking about the cumulative impact in a particular area.

Kenneth Gibson SNP Cunninghame North
link

Yes, you were, but you did not say what, in your or the Scottish Government's view, that limit would be. When will enough be enough? That is the point about the cumulative impact. Why does there need to be any impact? In the two years or more since the petition was first submitted, we have already had umpteen offshore and onshore wind developments, not to mention all the other renewables developments.

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

Ms Simpson made the point that they are large, prominent structures, so they will inevitably have some sort of visual impact. It is a question of whether the impact on the environment is considered to be acceptable. They cannot be hidden behind a bush; they are big structures so there will be an impact if they are built.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Robin Harper wants to say something but it is on a different topic. Rhona Brankin wants to ask something about this issue.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Yes. With the best will in the world, Mr Gibson, you are talking about a policy issue. Far be it from me to protect civil servants, but I think that you might do better to address your policy comments to the minister in your own party.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I am still not clear whether SPP 6 covers regional parks.

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

The policy framework in SPP 6 certainly covers regional parks, but it does not mention them specifically. We have remedied that in the consolidated SPP that we are introducing, which talks about regional parks. In essence, it indicates that planning authorities should protect the parks' recreational value.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Will that make a difference in the part that we are talking about?

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

It will certainly make the issue clearer, but the policy framework remains substantially the same.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

There is a wee flurry of members wanting to ask questions, but I promised Robin Harper that he could speak. I will let Nigel Willis in first and then Robin Harper.

Nigel Willis Save Your Regional Park Campaign
link

The proof of the pudding is in the eating. Only last year, after a PLI, the Kelburn wind farm was allowed through by the Government. One main plank of the argument in favour of it was that the designation of the landscape in that part of the park had been changed to moorland with wind farms—that was one of the main reasons given for the minister's decision after the PLI. It is complete nonsense to say that there is any protection in either SPP 6 or the new system; it is still completely open to interpretation in any way you like. Probably, the new one has less protection than the old one, because a series of big documents has been reduced into one small one.

Graeme Purves Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment
link

We would argue that the guidance is much more focused and therefore much clearer.

Nigel Willis Save Your Regional Park Campaign
link

I would like to hear Mr Maund's comment on that, because he has greater experience than I have.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I have several observations and questions. I was rather worried about the condensation of the SPPs, as some significant things have been left out on other occasions. I would like an assurance from the Executive, or at least an opinion, that the modifications that are being made will get the ducks in a row better and that the system is trying to adapt to cope with the huge pressures that are inevitable from the development of renewables.I cannot resist the temptation to make a couple of contextual references. Protecting the environment is in essence about biodiversity. It is not about the shape of the hills, as we cannot alter that, but we can destroy biodiversity. Over the past 1,000 years, deforestation and sheep farming have done more to destroy biodiversity in Scotland than any other single activity. Any destruction—shall we say—that is wrought by the renewables industry will pale into insignificance compared with that.It is of course not only electricity from wind that is projected to come down the new Beauly to Denny line. I hope that a huge amount of electricity will be contributed by the development of tidal and wave energy in the north of Scotland. We must bear it in mind that we have up to 40 per cent of the European Union's potential for wind, wave and tidal development. It will be difficult for the European Union, let alone the UK, to reach any target under any Copenhagen-style agreement that is reached in future if we do not commit ourselves to developing that potential as far as we can without the kind of damage to our environment that would be unsupportable.Of course, you cannot make omelettes without breaking eggs, and most of the damage that people complain about relates to the visual impact of the power lines. It is incontrovertible that the nature of the regional parks will be changed if there are too many power lines and windmills on the horizon. I am sympathetic to people's reactions to wind farms on that basis, and I think that it should be at least advised that consideration should be given to the likely impact of wind farm developments in regional parks. Nevertheless, it is not just inevitable but our duty to ensure that there is some development of wind farms over the whole of Scotland.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I am conscious of the time, as we have several other items that we must get through today. One of our members also has to leave for another committee meeting shortly. Are there any other pressing issues that people want to raise? A number of those who have been involved with the petition want to speak but, with due respect, it may be helpful to hear some final comments from Sybil Simpson, given that she is the key petitioner.

Sybil Simpson Save Your Regional Park Campaign
link

Common sense must prevail, and I wonder whether anyone has a vision of what Scotland will look like when the renewables policy is fully in place. We will still have to sustain a tourism industry, but that is beside the point. As someone who has worked in education for 40 years in the Strathclyde region, and Glasgow in particular, I have witnessed at first hand serious health concerns because of obesity in children and parents. You say that there is a different description of regional parks. My understanding of regional parks is that they were established so that people who were trapped—not by snares, but by cities—could get out into the green areas to improve their health and do all sorts of recreational things. I remind the committee that one of the most successful RSPB centres, with many different protected species, is in Clyde Muirshiel park.It is all very well to say that the local authorities will protect the areas that they want to protect, such as the parks. They are working their butts off to do that, but when there is a public inquiry we will have reporters and advocates from wind farm companies knocking holes in SPP 6. I hate to think it, but I have no doubt that they will knock holes in the new planning regulations as well in order to get their own way and that the ultimate decisions on the big wind farms will lie with the Government. The local authorities will protect the regional parks as much as they can, but when it comes to the big wind farms they have no chance.The development at Kelburn was allowed because we have six turbines at Wardlaw wood. Because the Kelburn development was allowed, the development at Millour hill has been allowed and the proposal for Kaim Hill, which has been turned down by North Ayrshire Council, will no doubt go to a public inquiry. Then, because of the developments at Kelburn, Millour hill and Wardlaw wood, the Government will say, "Och, that's just another addition to the cumulative effect," and that will be the south part of the park written off. I rest my case.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you. Today will not resolve those fundamental issues. A range of discussions needs to take place; the purpose of this afternoon's discussion was to pull some of the issues together. Others, such as Scottish Renewables, have communicated to me their views on the matter and the written submissions are all in committee members' papers for them to read. Kenny Gibson is to pursue a member's bill on the subject, and I hope that the discussion will encourage the dialogue that he needs to have with ministerial colleagues to concentrate their minds on the difficult issues.I am conscious that the Scottish Government representatives may have been constrained by the nature of some of the questions because, as officials, they do not make the final decisions, but they have helpfully given a reasonable account of the Government's perspective. We will have an opportunity to bring back our further thoughts on the issue at a subsequent committee meeting, at which time we will determine whether this committee can assist with the issue or whether other avenues should be explored to address the concerns that the petition raises.I thank the witnesses for their time. I suggest that committee members remain where they are seated in order to save us time.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 12 January 2010 Petitions · 1
  2. Current Petitions Petitions · 78
  3. Current Petitions Petitions · 47
  4. Current Petitions Petitions · 35
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  14. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.