Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Scottish Prison Population (Catholics) (PE1073)

Tuesday 12 January 2010 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 35 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

35 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I seek members' indulgence. Although the next petition on our agenda should be PE1302, on Larbert rail noise and vibration, I know that a member who has an interest in PE1073 needs to leave shortly, therefore I ask members to agree that we consider PE1073 before Colin Sloper's PE1302.

Members indicated agreement.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We will not spend a lot of time on PE1073. I welcome the Scottish Parliament information centre's Graham Ross, who has previously spoken to us about the petition. PE1073, which has been in the system for a considerable time, urges the Parliament to investigate and establish the reasons for the apparently disproportionate number of Roman Catholics in Scottish prisons.At our meeting in November 2009, we asked for further deliberation on whether research could be carried out into the issues that the petition raises. On 26 November, SPICe sent a scoping paper to a number of academics, who were asked to comment on the questions that the committee raised. We have received responses from some academics, including a joint response from Joseph Bradley of the University of Stirling and Susan Wiltshire of the University of Leeds.We have some options to consider, but I will first invite Nigel Don to make some observations, as I am conscious that he must be somewhere else shortly.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I thank the convener and other committee members for indulging my programme, which, people will understand, was not created by me.I hope that I have the right end of the stick on this, but I am concerned about the proposed research methodology. That is not because I wish to tell researchers how to investigate the subject, but because I am concerned about what we are trying to research. I want to take this opportunity to point out that science very rarely proves anything. Scientific method is about doing your level best to disprove something. When you fail over a large number of attempts to disprove something, you tend to believe that your hypothesis is true.If we were to research whether people in Scotland thought that they had been discriminated against in any context, I am absolutely sure that we would manage to find examples, but that would not tell us very much. In this case, as I understand it, the research would try to find out whether discrimination in the criminal justice system might account for what we agree is the disproportionate number of Catholics within our prison community. If I have that right, what we should be doing is testing the hypothesis that there is no discrimination. We should ask our researchers to look at the information on those who, as it were, present to the front door of the criminal justice system—by which I mean those who are perceived to have undertaken some kind of criminal activity—to see whether that population correlates with those who finish up in, if I may use such a phrase, the backyard of the criminal justice system, by which I mean our prisons. We need to ask our researchers to look at all the data that they can find to see whether that proportion of prisoners reflects the proportion of those in our society who tend to indulge in criminal activity, which is what I think the minister and others have suggested. If we do that, we will see whether there is any discrimination.I am concerned that we get the science the right way round. If all the data that the researchers can put together are as incomplete and uncertain as I fear they are, the researchers will have to ask themselves what assumptions they will have to make to demonstrate that the hypothesis is still intact. Looking at those assumptions will tell us whether the hypothesis is intact. If the assumptions that they have to make with regard to the statistics are so improbable that we do not believe them, that will demonstrate that there may be some discrimination. If, on the other hand, the researchers can rationalise the input and the output of the system one way or another, that will tend to suggest that the system is okay.I add that I am not in any sense naive about the likelihood of there being discrimination in our society in different places and that I am not attempting to suggest that there is not an historical tendency. I am not at this stage trying to pass any comment at all on the criminal justice system, because I am sure that those who work in it are very professional, but I am concerned that we get our science the right way round.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Are there any other comments on how to progress the petition?

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Nigel Don is right: we need to ensure that we set the correct parameters for the research. Although the petition refers to the proportion of a particular religious group whose members are in the prison system, the committee, or at least some of its members, have argued that the focus should be widened to consider the number of members of other religious groups who are in prison. I have a point about broadening the research. The difficulty is that we have to go back to how many people are charged, what their religious affiliation is and how many of them end up in court, and then whittle it down to how many of them end up in the prison system. It is necessary to broaden the research in that way.We can definitely say, in terms of the statistical evidence, that X number of Catholics, Y number of Muslims and Z number of Sikhs are in prison, but we cannot look at how they find themselves there and how the criminal justice system deals with each group. That would, unfortunately, almost imply that religious discrimination was taking place in wider society in dealing with particular religious groups. We could end up saying that particular religious groups are more inclined to commit crimes that lead to them being imprisoned. If that were the case, there would be a much wider issue about how we view religious groups in Scotland.If we are going to do this properly, the research has to be widened to gather information on the initial charges, the initial court appearances and the decisions by various court officials on how to deal with the individuals, because we could end up with research that says that a member of a particular religious group is more likely to commit a criminal offence and end up serving a custodial sentence as a result of that offence than are members of other religious groups. It could get to the stage that we are almost profiling based on religious grounds, and we could end up identifying particular groups and saying, "They are more likely to end up in prison, so let us deal with them—fast-track the system and imprison more of them, because that will hopefully deter them from committing crime in the first place."

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

It strikes me that a detailed, sophisticated approach is needed. If we concentrate just on the Catholic community, we may come up with a skewed result. We need to identify the factors that are most likely to affect the likelihood that someone will be involved in criminal activity and confrontation with the law. For example, a disproportionate number of young men who have been in care land up in prison—it is well known that a direct link has been established in that case. It might be a good idea for us to look at whether a disproportionate number of young people who have been in care happen to be Catholic. If so, we would expect a disproportionate number of that subset of young people, compared with the general population, to be in prison.I am sure that the church has a definition, but how do we define who is a Catholic? Is it someone who is a practising member of the Catholic Church, someone who comes from a Catholic family, someone who comes from a Catholic area or someone who supports a football team that was Catholic historically? What are our definitions of who is a Catholic? People may have different attitudes to the issue. We must be very careful about definitions before starting.I am concerned about the lack of a control group. I agree entirely with John Wilson that we should take the overall number of people who are charged as a base group, so that we can compare it with what comes out of the other end of the legal system. If 50 per cent of the people who are charged are Catholic, we would expect 50 per cent of the same group to land up in prison—that would be reasonably proportionate and fair. However, if only 20 per cent of the people who are charged are Catholic, by any definition, but 40 per cent of those who land up in jail are Catholic, that would clearly be disproportionate.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Essentially, we are trying to work out the research option. The issues that members have raised can be explored through that.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Is it possible for us to request more detailed descriptions of how a research project might look?

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I invite Graham Ross to respond, as he has been in dialogue with academics on the issue. I am not an expert on sociological assessment, but the petitioner has raised an issue and we have tried to address it. We have identified more effective research as one way of doing that. It is for those who carry out statistical analyses, rather than for me, to arrive at definitions, which are difficult.

Graham Ross Scottish Parliament Research, Information and Reporting Group
link

From the inception of the petition, we have focused on the specific issue that it raises: the number of Roman Catholics who are in prison in Scotland. The raw numbers stack up—a disproportionate number of Roman Catholics are in prison in Scotland, compared with the overall population.I take on board the points that Nigel Don, John Wilson and Robin Harper have made, which could form part of a research proposal that we put to the Conveners Group. As Robin Harper said, we could explore further exactly what that research might entail. As members' opinions form and people think about different things, the scope of the research becomes wider. Our concern is that it will become too wide and miss the specific issue that the petition raises: the number of Roman Catholics in prison.The academics who responded to our scoping paper commented on the point about including the Muslim population as well. They said that that should be a separate area of research in addressing the issues in the petition, because the Catholic minority in prison is a specific white minority group and little is known about how they end up in custody. A lot is known about the link between social and economic deprivation and offending behaviour across all groups—that is well established—but, if the committee wants to explore further the factors that affect specific religious groups, the project might widen. We can go back to the academics and say that we need more information and need to know exactly what the scope must be to get to the nub of the problem, not only for the Roman Catholic population but for other minorities that end up in prison. However, it is a decision for the committee to make.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We must try to move the petition forward.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I have come to the committee only in recent months, but the matter does not strike me as necessarily a major issue. I probably have more concerns about the number of people in Scottish prisons who are dyslexic. I would be concerned if the committee took the petition any further.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

What would the consequences be for the research if further research into the current social and economic state of Scotland showed clearly that, as would be possible, a disproportionate number of Catholics were in the lower-income groups and groups suffering from multiple deprivation?

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We are in between a number of things. Members have raised two or three important points, so we should try to find greater clarity on the matter. We wanted to bring back the petition. We are trying to respond to the issues that the petition raises. We have had it for a long time, and we agreed in previous discussions that we would like to do some research. We have identified academic researchers who have identified a number of approaches that they could take, and we are focusing on that today. Do we want to get further information and come back to the petition or not?

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I am inclined to agree with Rhona Brankin about the relative importance—although I hesitate to say "importance"—of the numbers of people whom the petition refers to and the numbers of dyslexic people in prison. I will be guided by the clerks: should we go ahead with any further research?

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

That is the decision that we make as committee members. The poor clerk is having an apoplexy at that question. I am trying to be consistent with the position that we took: we received the petition and identified issues around it; a number of members raised concerns about other religious minorities in prison; we identified ways to broaden our consideration; and the researchers tried to identify ways to do that research.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I apologise to you and other committee members, because I had to step out of the meeting for a minute or two and missed the beginning of this item.We should not present a research proposal to the Conveners Group immediately. However, from what I was able to pick up from what John Wilson and Robin Harper said, I think that we should further explore the scope of the research so that, if possible, it is focused in a way that avoids it being skewed. We need a research proposal that is much more focused on the concerns that the petition raises in the first instance.That might seem a long and roundabout way of arriving at the same point, but I am not convinced that, if we made a proposal to the Conveners Group, it would stand the test of scrutiny at the moment.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

When the committee first considered the petition, I talked about other minority groups, because the proportion of prisoners from other minority groups is far higher than the proportion of the Catholic population that is in prison. High proportions of prisoners in Scottish prisons are from particular religious groups, but my major concern is that the proportion of Muslims who are incarcerated in Scottish prisons seems to be higher than normal—if it is possible to have a normal proportion—or higher than expected in a society where we know the percentages, because that proportion is higher than the proportion of Muslims in Scotland's population. I do not have the paperwork that I quoted when we originally discussed the petition, but I believe that the proportion of prisoners who are from the Muslim community is almost 50 per cent greater than the proportion of those who are from the Catholic population.I have concerns about how we scope research. We could concentrate on one religious grouping, as the petition suggests, but, in subsequent responses to the committee, the petitioner accepted that we needed to widen research to cover people from other religious groupings who are in prison. Although he raised the issue of the Catholic population in Scottish prisons, he failed to understand the proportions of other religious groupings who are in Scottish prisons.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I ask Robin Harper to be brief, because I want to conclude this item soon.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

It has struck me for a long time that we need to entertain the possibility that, if there is discrimination against Catholics, it is historical and social. The least likely place to find discrimination against Catholics might be in our courts. If a problem exists, it lies elsewhere.

Graham Ross Scottish Parliament Research, Information and Reporting Group
link

Briefly, convener—

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We need the wisdom of Solomon.

Graham Ross Scottish Parliament Research, Information and Reporting Group
link

You are asking the wrong person.If we consider all the points that members have made, we could go round the houses. I have worked on the criminal justice system and Bill Butler has been involved in the Justice Committee, and we know that the subject is huge. The scope for research could be so wide that we lose the focus on the petition. Rather than our continually providing scoping papers and sending them to academics left, right and centre, I suggest that it might be worth while for the committee to hold a one-off evidence session to bring in the academics who responded to the paper that we produced in November, along with other academics, to discuss the scope of any research and the best way forward to examine the problems that the petition describes, and possibly some wider problems. That would give the committee the chance to hear from academics from other quarters, as well as from those who responded, and might allow the committee to decide whether to commission external research. The one thing that I will say is that, if academics are invited to give evidence, they will say that research is needed. However, it might be better to ask the academics who are involved about all the issues that have been raised.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We will not have answers until we ask questions of the individuals who work on such policy. None of us has the specialist knowledge to interrogate all the stuff. We can identify directions of travel, but we would hope that academics would provide much of the detail.Are members comfortable with following Graham Ross's suggestion rather than seeking the Conveners Group's support to commission a full research paper?

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Yes, because we are in no position to approach the Conveners Group, to be frank. We can all agree on that. I am not against talking to academics, provided that they realise that we might simply say, "You're wrong," or, "We disagree." As long as they are sanguine about that, I am sanguine about approaching them.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Although I welcome the suggestion that we invite academics and people with experience of the court and prison system, if we are going to have a round-table discussion on the petition, we should widen it out and invite representatives of the Scottish court system. That would send other agencies the message that we are looking at the issue and would allow them to tell us how they gather data—or should that be left for another day?

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

First, I would rather not widen things out like that, because we would be doing so without having asked academics whether we can scope the issue in a focused and productive way.Secondly, I am sure that round-table discussions can be wonderful, but I would rather have a formal question-and-answer session with two or three academic witnesses. That would allow us to take a more focused approach, whereas round-table discussions can, despite the best intentions of the convener and members, be rather unfocused.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I am conscious of the time, but I would like to take a more fundamental look at what we should do with this petition. I realise that it has gone some distance with the committee, but we need to spend a bit more time discussing it. I certainly do not think that we should make any decisions on it today.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

That is different to Bill Butler's proposal.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

One compromise is that we go ahead with what I and other members have suggested but that, before we do so, we have a private informal session for members to chat about the issues that have arisen today.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I will try to pull this together. I suggest that we discuss privately the issues that have been raised on the petition and determine from that whether to have the question-and-answer session that John Wilson and other members have proposed. Do members feel that that is the best way to proceed? Members have raised a number of substantial issues, and we might not reach complete agreement on how to proceed. The two options would at least allow us to move forward.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I really want to avoid going to a division over this, so perhaps your suggestion represents the best way forward. I accept it, though with the proviso that we bring back the petition at the first available opportunity; indeed, we should accelerate it in the process.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I am happy to accept that. I realise that this discussion has taken a lot longer than we expected, but I appreciate members' comments and I thank Graham Ross for his time.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 12 January 2010 Petitions · 1
  2. Current Petitions Petitions · 78
  3. Current Petitions Petitions · 47
  4. Current Petitions Petitions · 35
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  14. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.