Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

NHS 24

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Health and Community Care

Thursday 3 February 2005 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 9 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

9 contributions
Iain Smith LD North East Fife
link
To ask the Scottish Executive how it is reviewing the performance of NHS 24. (S2O-5189)

Andy Kerr Lab The Minister for Health and Community Care · East Kilbride
link
The Health Department receives weekly performance reports from NHS 24 and tracks the trends in the organisation. Meetings to review performance are held regularly with senior staff from NHS 24. Our aim is to ensure that patients and the public receive the service that they expect and that the taxpayer gets value for money.

Iain Smith LD North East Fife
link
I am sure that the minister will join me in paying tribute to the staff of NHS 24 for the work that they do, which can range from dealing with potentially serious medical conditions to dealing with, for instance, a hamster bite or a request for an emergency supply of condoms. A number of cases have been cited in which concerns have arisen about whether the appropriate advice has been given to patients and, on occasions, about whether doctors have been called by NHS 24 to go out to patients when that has been required. What happens in NHS 24 to ensure that its procedures are monitored regularly, so that such problems do not arise? What impact has there been on general practice and accident and emergency services and has there been any monitoring of that impact?

Andy Kerr Lab The Minister for Health and Community Care · East Kilbride
link
The member recognises the contribution of NHS 24 staff, which was particularly relevant over what was a difficult festive period for them, especially given when the public holidays fell. NHS 24's resource was stretched at that time, but the planning that it put in before the Christmas break ensured that the service was delivered effectively. I understand that, on occasions, the call waiting times extended beyond what I would say was normally acceptable. Nonetheless, that was the case on only a few occasions. From Christmas eve to 5 January, NHS 24 took 89,700 calls, which was a substantial achievement.

NHS 24 is not an emergency service—it is not about emergencies or 999 calls and the first message that the caller gets contains that information. The service receives a wide variety of types of call. One of the refreshing things about the service that NHS 24 provides is that anything that gets round the systems of working can be effectively investigated by listening to the calls and going through the protocols. That can help patients to understand why certain decisions were made on certain occasions.

We can always improve our services, particularly with regard to the use of support organisations over the festive period. The links between organisations were under some strain—I recognise the member's point about how we should properly treat the various services. Lessons have been learned and I hope to report to the Parliament further on the changes that we wish to make to the system to ensure that it becomes even better, while recognising that an organisation that handles 1,250,000 calls but received just 89 complaints is not doing badly.

Alasdair Morgan SNP South of Scotland
link
I echo what the minister says about the staff of NHS 24. However, does he acknowledge that there have been cases in which constituents have either not been able to get through to NHS 24 at the first time of trying or been asked to phone back? Does he agree that the targets for both those occurrences should be zero? Otherwise, more pressure is put on the 999 services.

Andy Kerr Lab The Minister for Health and Community Care · East Kilbride
link
Many of those issues will be dealt with in the reports that I will receive as part of our considered analysis of what occurred over the Christmas and new year period. The sheer volume of calls put strain on the system. Nonetheless, I would say that the service performed extremely well overall. I am happy to take on individual cases.

The issue is about properly resourcing NHS 24 to ensure that targets are met. The current target is for 90 per cent of calls to be responded to within 30 seconds of people hearing the message that they receive when they call the line. That is a substantial target, which is not yet being achieved on every occasion. We need to ensure that the targets are correct. There are strict limits with regard to calling back. I am aware of some individual failures with call-back over the Christmas and new year period. We will learn from those.

With the transfer of out-of-hours services, this has been the first time that NHS 24 has had to deal with almost every call to do with health in Scotland. I repeat that, although there might have been individual service failures, which is completely unacceptable to the individual callers concerned, NHS 24 provided an extremely efficient service over what was a very testing period.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link
An "efficient service" was not my experience over that period. The minister rightly indicated that NHS 24 is not an emergency service. Why, then, is the first question that patients are asked when they ring up, "Is this an emergency?" Patients are told that emergencies are to be dealt with first, but is that not the wrong message for NHS 24 to send out?

Andy Kerr Lab The Minister for Health and Community Care · East Kilbride
link
Mike Rumbles's experience is not the same as my experience from the calls that I have made. The message says that the service is not an emergency service—the call handler is, of course, simply seeking to reassure himself or herself on the nature of the call. It is not a matter of saying that a call will get to the top of the queue, but the call handler will—correctly—place an emergency call in the hands of the 999 service. I am happy to discuss the matter privately with the member, but my experience is not the same as his.

George Reid The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Question 7 has been withdrawn.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 February 2005 Debate · 1
  2. Economy Debate · 183
  3. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  4. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  5. Ferry Services First Minister’s Questions · 19
  6. Terrorism (House Arrests) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  7. Shipbuilding First Minister’s Questions · 12
  8. European Structural Funds Questions · 5
  9. Agricultural Diversification Questions · 10
  10. Royal Highland Showground Questions · 5
  11. Flood Prevention Questions · 4
  12. Fly-tipping Questions · 4
  13. Power Generation (Environment) Questions · 7
  14. Water and Sewage Questions · 4
  15. PFI/PPP (Costs to NHS Boards) Questions · 4
  16. Private Health Care Referrals Questions · 8
  17. Centralised Hospital Services (Assessment) Questions · 6
  18. Cancer in Children (Pollution) Questions · 4
  19. Smoking Questions · 6
  20. NHS 24 Questions · 9
  21. Psychiatric Care (Children and Young People) Questions · 4
  22. Community Transport Questions · 4
  23. Housing Questions · 6
  24. Community Planning (Rural Services) Questions · 5
  25. Scottish Water (Cowie Planning Application) Questions · 4
  26. Area Infrastructure Investment Plan Questions · 5
  27. Maritime Heritage Questions · 11
  28. Global Economy Questions · 4
  29. Laurencekirk Railway Station Questions · 9
  30. Enterprise Grant Awards Statement · 16
  31. Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2005 (SSI 2005/19) Debate · 82
  32. Inquiries Bill Bill debate · 7
  33. Business Motion Business motions · 6
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 34
  35. Local Benefits Services Debate · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.