To ask the Scottish Executive how it is promoting agricultural diversification. (S2O-5237)
Official Report · Chamber
Agricultural Diversification
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Environment and Rural Development
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 5
- Scott Barrie Lab 2
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 1
- Alex Fergusson Con 1
- Eleanor Scott Green 1
The record
10 contributionsSupport for agricultural diversification is one of the key themes of "A Forward Strategy for Scottish Agriculture", which I published in 2001. The Scottish Executive provides financial support to farmers and their families who want to diversify through two principal grant schemes: the agricultural business development scheme and the farm business development scheme. The schemes were launched in 2001 and have a combined budget of more than £60 million over six years. They offer support for diversification into alternative agriculture—for example, energy crops, soft fruit and worm farming—or non-agricultural activities such as tourism, retail or sports and leisure.
A third element of diversification is the processing and marketing grant schemes that we operate, which support diversification by providing assistance to farmers to develop innovative products, to add value, to co-operate to exploit new markets and to shorten the supply chain by linking producers and processors. The grants will deliver £22 million of assistance between 2001 and 2006.
A third element of diversification is the processing and marketing grant schemes that we operate, which support diversification by providing assistance to farmers to develop innovative products, to add value, to co-operate to exploit new markets and to shorten the supply chain by linking producers and processors. The grants will deliver £22 million of assistance between 2001 and 2006.
I thank the minister for that comprehensive answer. Given the difficulties in our agriculture sector, can the minister indicate whether all the moneys that are allocated to the farm business development scheme have been taken up? What additional publicity could there be in the sector to assist agricultural diversification to take place?
There is no doubt that the implementation of common agricultural policy reform has created an element of uncertainty in the sector and that there has been a concomitant reduction in the uptake of, and inquiries into, both of the schemes to which I referred. The Environment and Rural Affairs Department has tried to engender new interest by distributing a leaflet. Some 20,000 leaflets have been sent out with farmers' integrated administration and control system packs, and the project staff who work in agricultural areas have held surgeries to promote the schemes. We also ran a campaign through the young farmers organisations and other stakeholder organisations. Scott Barrie is right to raise this issue, as we have been concerned about it. We are taking every possible step to encourage people to take up the two schemes.
What assessment has the department made of how successful the money that has been disbursed so far has been in achieving lasting and successful diversification? What plans does the department have to put in place research to establish that?
Of course, the crucial issue is the long-term outcomes of the schemes. We are obliged to assess each element of European funding, particularly as one of the schemes is co-funded. The scheme in the rest of Scotland is a Scottish Executive funded scheme. We are reasonably satisfied that we are achieving our long-term aims. However, as Alasdair Morgan will be well aware, it is all very well to use the glib term "diversification". The issue is to find schemes that can be applied in specific areas that have specific characteristics, which is why we offer a broad range of options. The scheme can be agricultural or non-agricultural; within agriculture we support a broad range of activities. We are reviewing the schemes, which we are obliged to do, and we keep under review whether we are getting long-term benefit.
One thing that is certain is that farmers will have far greater freedom to diversify away from traditional livestock farming under the single farm payment support structure. Many current livestock farmers may, for example, choose to diversify into deer farming to satisfy the ever-increasing market for venison. Does the minister agree that it is grossly unfair that any farmer who chooses to do so will receive full single farm payment as long as he has entitlement, whereas current deer farmers who have been farming without support for some years will receive no support?
No, I do not agree. We had to make a very difficult decision. There is no doubt at all that in financial terms Scottish agriculture is still in a relatively fragile state if we do without subsidy. The aim and object of the agriculture strategy is to try to increase the proportion of that very small section of the industry—it is perhaps less than 20 per cent at the very top. The difficult decision was about whether we should change the whole financial basis, as has been done elsewhere, or introduce major reform but provide some certainty about the financial support. My judgment was that it was better, given the state of Scottish agriculture, to give farmers the certainty of financial support, while at the same time encouraging them through the agriculture strategy to implement measures that will make them less subsidy dependent.
I am sure that the minister will agree that a popular and successful form of diversification has been tree planting under the forestry grant scheme. However, that is under threat from the current draft European Union rural development regulations, which propose a reduction of support to 40 per cent of costs and propose that it will last for 10 rather than 20 years. What will the Scottish Executive do to ensure that the current level of support for farm and croft forestry is maintained?
Two elements are involved in addressing that problem. One is to try to get greater integration between agriculture and forestry; such integration is more common in mainland Europe. Compared to other European countries at our latitude we have below-average forestation. The second element is to consider more closely the opportunities that are afforded by energy crops and, in respect of forestry, short-rotation coppice. I will link Eleanor Scott's direct question on agriculture and forestry development to the opportunities that open up with energy crops. The Executive, in considering how it pursues its strategy, is well placed to ensure that we continue to give support to ensure greater integration of those two aspects.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Feb 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 February 2005 Debate · 1
- Economy Debate · 183
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Ferry Services First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Terrorism (House Arrests) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Shipbuilding First Minister’s Questions · 12
- European Structural Funds Questions · 5
- Agricultural Diversification Questions · 10
- Royal Highland Showground Questions · 5
- Flood Prevention Questions · 4
- Fly-tipping Questions · 4
- Power Generation (Environment) Questions · 7
- Water and Sewage Questions · 4
- PFI/PPP (Costs to NHS Boards) Questions · 4
- Private Health Care Referrals Questions · 8
- Centralised Hospital Services (Assessment) Questions · 6
- Cancer in Children (Pollution) Questions · 4
- Smoking Questions · 6
- NHS 24 Questions · 9
- Psychiatric Care (Children and Young People) Questions · 4
- Community Transport Questions · 4
- Housing Questions · 6
- Community Planning (Rural Services) Questions · 5
- Scottish Water (Cowie Planning Application) Questions · 4
- Area Infrastructure Investment Plan Questions · 5
- Maritime Heritage Questions · 11
- Global Economy Questions · 4
- Laurencekirk Railway Station Questions · 9
- Enterprise Grant Awards Statement · 16
- Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2005 (SSI 2005/19) Debate · 82
- Inquiries Bill Bill debate · 7
- Business Motion Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 34
- Local Benefits Services Debate · 28
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.