To ask the First Minister what action the Scottish Executive is taking to support the shipbuilding industry on the lower Clyde. (S2F-1410)
Official Report · Chamber
Shipbuilding
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 4
- Annabel Goldie Con 2
- Trish Godman Lab 1
- Jim Mather SNP 1
- George Lyon LD 1
- George Reid 1
The record
12 contributionsWe have in place a Scottish shipbuilding strategy and a marine industry steering group, both of which address the issues facing Scottish shipbuilders and, through the enterprise agencies, offer Scottish shipbuilders—like other industries—appropriate business support. Scottish ministers and Executive officials are in regular contact with UK ministers to support and promote Scottish shipbuilding interests, including those on the lower Clyde.
The First Minister will be aware that Ferguson Shipbuilders of Port Glasgow faces a critical situation in the immediate future. He will also be aware of concerns expressed by the yard that in the past six months £80 million-worth of Government contracts has been lost directly or indirectly to Poland. How do the Governments of France, Germany, Holland, Italy and Spain manage to place their shipbuilding contracts with indigenous yards? Is he satisfied that Ferguson's is being asked to tender for Scottish Executive work against fair competition? Why cannot a Scottish fishery protection vessel—a little navy boat to the rest of us—be classed as a grey hull, with the consequent tender benefits to our own shipbuilding industry?
Because our fishery protection vessels do not include naval personnel and do not have armaments on board, which are a clear part of the definition used by the European Commission. If there is evidence that countries in the European Union are diverting or awarding inside their own countries contracts that are not for naval shipbuilding or shipbuilding that has a naval content, I, along with everyone else, would be interested to see it. We keep the matter under constant review. We are constantly in discussion with the UK Government about the best way to promote, protect and enhance the opportunities that are available to Scottish shipbuilding interests, and we will continue to take that approach.
Does the First Minister agree that Ferguson's in Port Glasgow in my constituency is an important yard to the local economy? In an area of population decline, we cannot allow it to close. I stress that the shop stewards, the management and the workforce are not looking for a handout. They do not want charity; they want contracts for ships. Will the First Minister assure me that he and Ross Finnie will give the yard a fair go, as far as a share of state contracts is concerned, because the workers deserve no less?
Of course Ferguson's, like other Scottish shipbuilders and yards, is treated fairly by Scottish ministers. The objective has to be not just to treat them fairly, but to ensure that they are well placed to win orders and contracts. That is why we have a shipbuilding strategy in place and why we have a steering group, on which Ferguson's, along with other interests, is represented. That is why we have constant dialogue with the industry, the enterprise agencies and the UK Government to promote Scottish shipbuilding interests. I am sure that if we can take forward any initiatives or ideas from those discussions, we will certainly do so.
By winning many orders from the private and public sectors, Ferguson's has proved that it can compete and can win an array of satisfied customers such as Western Ferries (Clyde) Ltd. In the current climate, what confidence does the First Minister have that Polish state aid meets EU rules?
Of course, we have been looking into the matter, but we have been unable to uncover evidence that the Polish decisions break EU rules. It has been suggested that other countries throughout the European Union are awarding contracts in their countries for the use of boats without a naval content. If that is the case, I would welcome evidence of it, because we could use it in our discussions. It is important that we ensure not only that our shipyards are competitive and can compete for the contracts, but that they can get the contracts in the first place. I say with all due respect to Mr Mather that pulling Scotland out of NATO and ensuring that we are no longer part of the United Kingdom and its defence contracts would not benefit Ferguson's, or any other Scottish shipyard, in any way.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. Will you clarify the criteria for selecting follow-up questions at First Minister's question time? As the MSP for Argyll and Bute, the constituency in which 60 per cent of Caledonian MacBrayne routes originate, I thought that, at the very least, I would get an opportunity to question the First Minister on what is an important constituency issue.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
The criteria are as set out before. I have many variables to take account of, not least time and balance. I am sure that, over the course, balance, time and constituency interests are well served.
Meeting suspended until 14:00.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Feb 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 February 2005 Debate · 1
- Economy Debate · 183
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Ferry Services First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Terrorism (House Arrests) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Shipbuilding First Minister’s Questions · 12
- European Structural Funds Questions · 5
- Agricultural Diversification Questions · 10
- Royal Highland Showground Questions · 5
- Flood Prevention Questions · 4
- Fly-tipping Questions · 4
- Power Generation (Environment) Questions · 7
- Water and Sewage Questions · 4
- PFI/PPP (Costs to NHS Boards) Questions · 4
- Private Health Care Referrals Questions · 8
- Centralised Hospital Services (Assessment) Questions · 6
- Cancer in Children (Pollution) Questions · 4
- Smoking Questions · 6
- NHS 24 Questions · 9
- Psychiatric Care (Children and Young People) Questions · 4
- Community Transport Questions · 4
- Housing Questions · 6
- Community Planning (Rural Services) Questions · 5
- Scottish Water (Cowie Planning Application) Questions · 4
- Area Infrastructure Investment Plan Questions · 5
- Maritime Heritage Questions · 11
- Global Economy Questions · 4
- Laurencekirk Railway Station Questions · 9
- Enterprise Grant Awards Statement · 16
- Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2005 (SSI 2005/19) Debate · 82
- Inquiries Bill Bill debate · 7
- Business Motion Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 34
- Local Benefits Services Debate · 28
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.