To ask the First Minister whether, in light of the Parliament's decision on the tendering of ferry services on 8 December 2004, the Scottish Executive will ensure that Caledonian MacBrayne is exempt from tendering for these services and is maintained as a publicly owned service. (S2F-1423)
Official Report · Chamber
Ferry Services
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Carolyn Leckie SSP 5
- Jack McConnell Lab 5
- George Reid 5
- Fergus Ewing SNP 3
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 1
The record
19 contributionsWe shall remain within the law, but further discussions are taking place between the Executive and the European Commission, and Mr Stephen will report back to Parliament on the issue as soon as possible. Our objective remains the long-term security and quality of ferry services, which are vital for our Scottish island communities.
The First Minister might not have signed the 1992 regulation that he hides behind as being the law, but will he confirm that he is signed up to the ideology? I have no objection to subsidising public services, jobs and decent terms and conditions, but I do object to subsidising the profits of companies that cut wages, pensions, jobs and services and go offshore to avoid national insurance and to paying more for the process of tendering. Will the First Minister tell me when he will publish the costs of tendering, and will he state that he will put passengers, communities and workers before his right-wing ideology; that he will put communities, passengers, workers, trade unions and public services before private profit; and that he will put the democratic will of those people and the Parliament before the ideology of privatisation, the European Commission and his neo-liberal masters in Westminster?
What a shocking thing to say about me, and I think that my Liberal Democrat colleagues might be concerned about the description of the current Westminster Government as neo-liberal. Many of us might also question Carolyn Leckie's interest in the law, given some of her recent exploits.
As someone who grew up on an island that depended on its ferry services, I know only too well the importance of Scotland's ferry services to the communities that they serve. I also know only too well about the hard work and commitment of the staff of Caledonian MacBrayne in delivering the ferry services that they currently deliver in Scotland. Our discussions with the European Commission will continue. We will stay within the law, but we will do all that we can to ensure that whatever process is put in place is a process that protects a high-quality workforce and protects services that are vital for Scotland's passengers, for local people and for tourists.
As someone who grew up on an island that depended on its ferry services, I know only too well the importance of Scotland's ferry services to the communities that they serve. I also know only too well about the hard work and commitment of the staff of Caledonian MacBrayne in delivering the ferry services that they currently deliver in Scotland. Our discussions with the European Commission will continue. We will stay within the law, but we will do all that we can to ensure that whatever process is put in place is a process that protects a high-quality workforce and protects services that are vital for Scotland's passengers, for local people and for tourists.
I would encourage the First Minister to break unjust laws, as I do. Let me be direct. Will the First Minister publish the legal opinion on the cost of tendering? Yes or no? Will he stand up to the European Commission and to the ideology of privatisation? Yes or no? Will he stand up for workers, communities and the will of the Parliament? Yes or no? Will he meet the members of the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers who are lobbying the Parliament today? Yes or no?
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
That is four questions, Ms Leckie.
Will he guarantee the terms and conditions, pensions and jobs of CalMac workers? Yes or no? Will he show some mettle—
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
That is about six questions, Ms Leckie.
I know that direct questions can sometimes be a wee bit of a problem, so I have brought some visual aids: will it be "Yes" or "No"?
Maybe. However, we must be serious, Presiding Officer, because the issue is serious and requires our full attention.
Serious discussions need to take place with the European Commission and serious attention needs to be paid to any tendering process that might take place. Serious action also needs to be taken by ministers, not only to protect the local communities involved but to ensure that, as far as possible, safeguards are put in place for those who work for what is a very important Scottish company. The Executive intends to take the matter seriously. Mr Stephen's discussions with the Commission will continue and he will make a statement to Parliament in due course.
Serious discussions need to take place with the European Commission and serious attention needs to be paid to any tendering process that might take place. Serious action also needs to be taken by ministers, not only to protect the local communities involved but to ensure that, as far as possible, safeguards are put in place for those who work for what is a very important Scottish company. The Executive intends to take the matter seriously. Mr Stephen's discussions with the Commission will continue and he will make a statement to Parliament in due course.
The First Minister said that the tendering process is required by law, but neither he nor the Minister for Transport has published any evidence to substantiate that assertion, yet it is an assertion that will determine the fate of the CalMac workers.
Does the First Minister believe that the Minister for Transport was being disingenuous in citing the comparison of Spain? Although the Spanish company, Transmed Shipping, was the subject of an adverse ruling, it suffered not one penny by way of a fine. Indeed, no cost whatever has been paid by Transmed or Spain; no loss of service—
Does the First Minister believe that the Minister for Transport was being disingenuous in citing the comparison of Spain? Although the Spanish company, Transmed Shipping, was the subject of an adverse ruling, it suffered not one penny by way of a fine. Indeed, no cost whatever has been paid by Transmed or Spain; no loss of service—
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Question, please.
Spain was given 12 months after the ruling in which to comply. Therefore—
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Question.
The scare story that the law will be broken if we do not tender is just that—a scare story with no evidence whatever behind it.
There is a fairly perverse logic in insisting that the families of those who work for CalMac and the local people who live on our island communities should face 12 months of uncertainty simply to make a political point, as Fergus Ewing seems to suggest they should. That would be entirely the wrong course of action to take.
The right course of action is to secure the best possible outcome for the island communities that are served by the ferries and for those who currently work—and work very well—for Caledonian MacBrayne. That is the responsible and right way in which to conduct ourselves in the situation.
To take risks with people's jobs and conditions, as Mr Ewing has consistently asked us to do, and—if there were to be a tendering process—to risk the possibility of the contract being broken up into individual contracts for individual services would endanger the lifeline services to our most vulnerable island communities. Mr Ewing might want that to happen, or at least might want to have that possibility on the table at the Commission, but we do not. We will not allow that to happen. We will continue to take the issue seriously. We will not make political points. Ultimately, we will secure the services for the future.
The right course of action is to secure the best possible outcome for the island communities that are served by the ferries and for those who currently work—and work very well—for Caledonian MacBrayne. That is the responsible and right way in which to conduct ourselves in the situation.
To take risks with people's jobs and conditions, as Mr Ewing has consistently asked us to do, and—if there were to be a tendering process—to risk the possibility of the contract being broken up into individual contracts for individual services would endanger the lifeline services to our most vulnerable island communities. Mr Ewing might want that to happen, or at least might want to have that possibility on the table at the Commission, but we do not. We will not allow that to happen. We will continue to take the issue seriously. We will not make political points. Ultimately, we will secure the services for the future.
As the First Minister knows, we have been locked into this tendering process for some five years. I know that he is fully aware of and appreciates the uncertainty that the situation is causing for the communities that Caledonian MacBrayne serves and those who work for the company.
Is Scotland the only European Union country that is going through this process? If that is not the case, can the First Minister detail how other EU countries are handling their subsidised ferry services?
Is Scotland the only European Union country that is going through this process? If that is not the case, can the First Minister detail how other EU countries are handling their subsidised ferry services?
Mr Ewing gave us an example of another European country that was forced to comply with the legislation. In the process, that country took the risk of its contractual arrangements being determined by the European Commission.
I congratulate Alasdair Morrison on insisting at all times that, should there have to be a tender for the services, it must encompass all the existing services to ensure that lifeline services are placed in the most secure position possible. The irresponsible suggestions from others that we should transfer responsibility to others by not taking responsibility ourselves might be consistent with the approach that they take on other issues, but they are wrong, because the best way to deal with the matter is to take it seriously and to stay within the law, but to push for the best possible outcome for Scotland.
I congratulate Alasdair Morrison on insisting at all times that, should there have to be a tender for the services, it must encompass all the existing services to ensure that lifeline services are placed in the most secure position possible. The irresponsible suggestions from others that we should transfer responsibility to others by not taking responsibility ourselves might be consistent with the approach that they take on other issues, but they are wrong, because the best way to deal with the matter is to take it seriously and to stay within the law, but to push for the best possible outcome for Scotland.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Question 4 has been withdrawn.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Feb 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 February 2005 Debate · 1
- Economy Debate · 183
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Ferry Services First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Terrorism (House Arrests) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Shipbuilding First Minister’s Questions · 12
- European Structural Funds Questions · 5
- Agricultural Diversification Questions · 10
- Royal Highland Showground Questions · 5
- Flood Prevention Questions · 4
- Fly-tipping Questions · 4
- Power Generation (Environment) Questions · 7
- Water and Sewage Questions · 4
- PFI/PPP (Costs to NHS Boards) Questions · 4
- Private Health Care Referrals Questions · 8
- Centralised Hospital Services (Assessment) Questions · 6
- Cancer in Children (Pollution) Questions · 4
- Smoking Questions · 6
- NHS 24 Questions · 9
- Psychiatric Care (Children and Young People) Questions · 4
- Community Transport Questions · 4
- Housing Questions · 6
- Community Planning (Rural Services) Questions · 5
- Scottish Water (Cowie Planning Application) Questions · 4
- Area Infrastructure Investment Plan Questions · 5
- Maritime Heritage Questions · 11
- Global Economy Questions · 4
- Laurencekirk Railway Station Questions · 9
- Enterprise Grant Awards Statement · 16
- Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2005 (SSI 2005/19) Debate · 82
- Inquiries Bill Bill debate · 7
- Business Motion Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 34
- Local Benefits Services Debate · 28
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.