The next petition is PE729, on a conference on autism treatments. The petition is in the name of Bill Welsh, on behalf of Action Against Autism. The petitioner calls on the Parliament to urge the Executive to fund as a matter of urgency a two-day conference on autism treatments so that parents, professionals and medical doctors can receive information and practical advice on the screening and testing of autistic children and adults, leading to individually tailored treatment protocols, which are emergent in the United States of America. The petitioner suggests that the conference should be based on the "Defeat Autism Now!" two-day mini-conference programme, which focuses exclusively on a protocol for testing and treatments for autism spectrum disorder.On 3 March, the Deputy Minister for Health and Community Care announced a funding package of almost £2 million to provide opportunities for training, awareness raising and better service provision through multi-agency working to support people with ASD throughout Scotland. The Scottish Society for Autism and the National Autistic Society Scotland have welcomed the minister's announcement.What do we do with the petition?
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Autism Treatments (PE729)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 7
- John Scott Con 4
- Linda Fabiani SNP 3
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 3
- Jackie Baillie Lab 2
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Susan Deacon Lab 1
The record
24 contributionsI wonder whether the Executive has already turned down a request for such a conference and that is why the request has come to us, or whether the request has come straight to us. Do any members know?
Although it is a worthy idea to have a conference to examine the ways of treating ASD, we should write to the Scottish Society for Autism and the National Autistic Society Scotland before we write to the Executive seeking a conference, because there is only one petitioner. It would be worth while garnering the views of those two organisations before we write to the Executive so that we can at least be sure whether their view, not only that of the single petitioner, who is apparently only one voice, is that we should write and request a conference.
link
The central question was asked earlier. I have no problem with John Scott's recommendation, but we do not know whether the petitioner has approached the Executive and I would have thought that common sense dictates that if somebody wants the Executive to fund something, they should approach it directly in the first instance. I would expect the Executive to take wider soundings from organisations such as those that John Scott mentioned so, although I endorse that proposal, we should tell the petitioner that he should perhaps write to the Executive.
We do not know that the petitioner has not done that. I remind the committee—although I hope that it is not necessary—that we refer petitions to the Executive for comment on the basis of a single petitioner's request all the time, so I do not know why PE729 should be any different.The bullet points that we have in our briefing on what the Executive is already doing do not address the issues in the petition, which concern treatments. There is a question about the funding, energy and resources that are devoted to developing and examining treatments that are still in their infancy but showing signs of success in America, and the petition is a mature way of posing that question. Rather than saying that we should make funding and energy available to develop such treatments—which we should—it says that, because people need to be persuaded, we should bring the experts to Scotland, have a conference and involve all the health professionals and interested parties in Scotland in discussing the merits of treatments. Then we can have the debate about the amount of funding and resources that are made available for, and the energy that is put into, the development of treatments.We should not put any obstruction in the way of that request, but we should seek clarification. I thought that the terms of submission for a petition included asking whom the petitioner had already approached, so I would hope that we have that information. If we do not, we should clarify what approaches have been made, but there is no harm in writing to the Executive to seek its views. For its response, whether affirmative or negative, it would seek other organisations' views. That should not prevent us from asking the question.
We should do something else in tandem with what John Scott suggested. The Executive has confirmed funding for addressing various elements of autistic spectrum disorder. There is nothing to prevent us from writing to the Executive and asking whether it would be minded to fund the proposed conference from the agreed funding. I note that the petition uses the word "urgent", so it would be good to get the Executive's answer to the funding question at the same time as its response to the rest.
I have just a couple of comments. I am conscious that I am a novice on the Public Petitions Committee, which has probably been obvious from my contributions already today. Within the parameters of health bodies, let alone more widely throughout Scotland, there are hundreds of organisations that might want to hold what could be an important and valuable conference. If I were a full member of the committee rather than a substitute one, I would be concerned about people always coming here to ask the kind of question that PE729 asks.It is important to think about the best way of making things happen in Scotland. Encouraging direct approaches to the Executive or to other funding bodies is a valuable thing to do, but so is encouraging different groups to form coalitions. Some superbly successful conferences were held during the first parliamentary session. For example, the big cancer conference, which the cross-party group in the Scottish Parliament on cancer promoted, brought together a tremendous coalition of people. There is also the cross-party group in the Scottish Parliament on autistic spectrum disorder, but I do not know whether it is part of the petition's equation.I realise that it is perhaps a hard message to convey, but putting responsibility back on to an organisation can sometimes be the right thing to do to get the best results.
I am sorry to cut Helen Eadie off before she speaks, but I have one observation to make. Although, as John Scott noted, the petition is in one person's name, it is clear that the petition is on behalf of Action Against Autism. The petitioner is the chairperson of that organisation, so we are not talking about just one individual who has come up with a bright idea. The petition is on behalf of a group that obviously feels that it has an input to make. We must try to find out how we can assist in raising the question that the group has put in the petition.
I hear what you are saying, convener, but I have much sympathy with Susan Deacon's point. I take Carolyn Leckie's point about bringing people together, which is a good thing to do. However, we should not always think that it is the job of Government to bring people together to undertake conferences. Only two weeks ago in this room, I hosted a conference on skin cancer, which more than 100 people attended. There is nothing to prevent any individual MSP or any group of people from facilitating a conference of that sort. Those groups that Jackie Baillie highlighted should rightly form a collective to organise and facilitate a conference. In many ways, it can be better for a group to organise its own conference because it can do so to its own prescription rather than to that of the Executive. Therefore, I am in the camp of following John Scott's suggestion and of clarifying, as Linda Fabiani and Jackie Baillie said, whether the petitioners have made a direct approach to the Executive.
For the avoidance of doubt, I state that I am in favour of having a conference, but it would be better for the committee to write to the Executive with the evidence from the Scottish Society for Autism and the National Autistic Society Scotland in support of the petition. We would be more likely to get a positive result by doing that. The Executive is aware of the problem of autistic spectrum disorder and it is putting £2 million towards addressing it. However, if a conference were organised with money from that budget, something else would suffer. Therefore, I presume that new money would be sought.
I have a couple of points. I am a wee bit disappointed, given the sort of experience that I have had in this committee, which generally operates on the basis of consensus and being positive about petitions that offer new ideas and seeking to facilitate rather than obstruct them. The petition is from an organisation that has a specific request for the Executive and on every other occasion when we have been in this position we have agreed at least to write to the Executive before we decide to do anything else, such as referring the petition to a committee.The conference that has been asked for is an international conference that would bring experts from other countries. It is one thing to ask a charity to organise a one-day or half-day event that brings together Scottish health professionals, but it is another to say to a charity, "It's your responsibility to go and organise an international conference." The point is the willingness of the Executive to recognise that there is an area of discussion that it is required to facilitate and support. That is a political point that the Executive should address, because there is a particular area that the Executive has not given enough attention to.Lastly, if members are concerned to receive clarification, the petitioner is here, so we can seek clarification directly. The request is for a conference by 2005. We should not do anything that might delay that.
We would not do anything to delay that, but we cannot accede to your request, because we would have every petitioner turning up and sitting in the public gallery hoping that they would have the opportunity to give evidence. That is why we operate in the way that we do. We take requests to speak and we choose. I know that it is difficult, but we have to do that, and on the basis of the information that is in front of us.
link
We are in danger of saying that there is something about the issue with which we do not find favour. We need to set that aside because, as Carolyn Leckie rightly said, in the past the committee has been sympathetic, not just to this issue, but to a wide range of issues.It is not about whether there is one petitioner or 100 petitioners—let us set that aside, because it is a red herring—it is about the nature of the request. Are we saying that we welcome petitions that make requests of the Executive that are not about policy changes—be they complex or simple—but about day-to-day operational matters and which ask whether the Executive will support a conference on a particular subject? If we are saying that, we will open up the floodgates to a whole series of petitions that make similar requests.As a parliamentary committee, we should not intervene in what should be a direct relationship between organisations and the Executive. It may well be that if we took a considered view, it would be that the Executive should support the request, but the question is whether the petitioners have approached the Executive directly. I do not think that we should be some kind of clearing house that says, "These are the things that we like; therefore, Executive, will you fund them?" I would much rather that there was a direct approach. That is all that we are unclear about at this stage.
In the submission from the petitioner there is no indication that a request was made to the Executive and there is no information that a request was turned down. To help things along, we could write back asking for that information. We can encourage the petitioners to go to the Executive and then, if they fail, they could come back to us and ask for support in making the conference happen.There is a general feeling in the committee that the proposed conference would be a good one and that it is what should be done on the issue, but that it is not for us to request on behalf of organisations that the Executive should pay for their conferences. It is for such organisations to seek support from the Executive. We can help them if they fail, but we have no evidence that the petitioners have sought funding from the Executive to hold the conference. We have to clarify that. Most members are saying that, if not you, Carolyn.
If we seek clarification on whether an approach has been made to the Executive and it transpires that an approach has been made and the response has not been favourable, we should not have to wait until we have another meeting before we write to the Executive.
I want to try to find a solution to this. I am perfectly happy for us to write to the Executive in addition to writing to the two other organisations along the lines that Carolyn Leckie suggests. If we believe that having a conference is a good idea—as I believe that we do—our case would be strengthened when we write to the Executive if we had the support of the other organisations in addition to Mr Welsh's view. It is a question of semantics. We are all agreed, so if Carolyn Leckie or the rest of us want to write to the Executive, that is not a problem.
It is not a problem, but I have to agree with Jackie Baillie that we would be setting a dangerous precedent if the committee was the first port of call in setting up a conference of this nature. We can assist organisations that are experiencing difficulty, but I do not think that we should be the conduit through which a request to hold a conference would go. That is what I am concerned about. We have to try to be helpful, but we could do so by encouraging the organisation to go to the Executive to make its request. We can then assist once we know the answer to the request if the organisation is not happy with the outcome. We have to be careful that we do not become the sounding board for requests to the Executive for conferences. I agree with Carolyn Leckie that as we have discussed the subject at great length, we will not need to take a lot of time to address the matter again if it comes back to us. However, it might not have to come back to us if the organisation writes to the Executive itself.
I agree.
I agree completely with what the convener has just said. We can bring the matter back to the next meeting, which is only two weeks away.
I am sure that we will get a speedy response.
Will we write to the other organisations in the meantime?
Yes. We do not have any difficulty with that. We will await the outcome and try to be as helpful as we can to all the organisations.We have completed our consideration of new petitions. We have eight current petitions to consider. Do members wish to have a break before we start on them?Members indicated agreement.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 12 May 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 12 May 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 49
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.