Our next petition is PE736, from David Stay, on behalf of the Marchmont Action Group Promoting Initiatives for the Environment and Marchmont and Sciennes—I hope that I pronounced that correctly—community council. The petition calls on the Parliament to urge the Executive to make the necessary legislative changes to ensure that the impact on localities is taken into account when licenses are granted for all houses of multiple occupation. Before the petition was formally lodged, it was hosted on the e-petitions website, where it gathered 12 electronic signatures from 17 February 2004 to 27 March 2004. David Stay will give evidence in support of the petition. He is accompanied by Susan Agnew. I welcome you to the committee. You have three minutes to make a statement, after which we will ask questions and develop the issues with you.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Houses in Multiple Occupation (PE736)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stay Marchmont Action Group Promoting Initiatives for the Environment 9
- Michael McMahon Lab 8
- John Scott Con 7
- Linda Fabiani SNP 5
- Susan Agnew Marchmont and Sciennes Community Council 3
- John Farquhar Munro LD 3
- Susan Deacon Lab 2
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 1
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
The record
39 contributionsSusan Agnew and I are here today on behalf of a community in crisis. I trust that members have had the opportunity to read the supporting papers that we submitted. Members will see that we represent residents whose ability to stay in their own homes is under threat. Every year, the membership of our group alone suffers loss because members who can take no more move out of the area. Fortunately for our continuing existence, our limited publicity efforts have produced a crop of new members, some of whom are desperate for help and advice.The City of Edinburgh Council and the police have made big strides in dealing with major incidents of antisocial behaviour, although many residents are still unaware of the avenues of help that are available in such situations. However, there has been little impact on landlords who are absentees, indifferent or simply dishonest. Even the new Tenements (Scotland) Bill will not compel careless or rogue landlords to co-operate. The bill will merely provide a framework within which owners can take civil action against miscreants.As long as landlords can buy up tenement properties for rent simply as an investment, with no restrictions on the number of HMO properties in an area, conditions for permanent residents will continue to deteriorate, creating increasing incentives to move elsewhere. However, why should we move? Instead, we appeal to the Scottish Parliament to act.Susan Agnew will speak on behalf of the community council.
On behalf of Marchmont and Sciennes community council, I ask the Parliament to introduce legislation to restrict the percentage of houses in multiple occupation in an area, street or individual tenement. Scottish ministers have previously passed legislation to regulate HMOs. In 1991, HMOs were added as a category to the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982, but it was left to local authorities to decide whether to use the new power. In 2000, Scottish ministers made the licensing of HMOs mandatory. At the same time, the number of occupants that constituted an HMO was reduced from five to three.Paragraph 5 of schedule 1 to the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 contains provisions that could be applied to prospective HMOs to restrict the number of such properties. However, faced with the apparent reluctance of the City of Edinburgh Council to use those provisions, we ask the Scottish Parliament to legislate to impose mandatory restrictions on the escalating number of HMOs.
Why is the City of Edinburgh Council not prepared to take effective action in the way that Glasgow City Council has done, albeit that Glasgow City Council has had to justify its action in the courts?
Interestingly, I attended a meeting of the licensing committee in Edinburgh last week. I admit that most of the meeting was about liquor licensing, but HMOs also came up. The licensing committee's first reaction was to pass the buck to the planning department. Personally, I think that the planning department is pretty slow already, and asking the planning department to deal with HMOs would just block up the system completely.The licensing committee could apply the provisions in the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 that I mentioned. At the meeting, we went on about that a bit and asked the committee why it did not apply those provisions. At one point, Councillor Attridge said that the council wants students in Edinburgh and does not want them to go to Glasgow. At the end of that meeting, it was said that the council was waiting for legislation to tell it what provisions to apply. We had the feeling that the council was avoiding doing something until it is required to. Goodness only knows why that is, but perhaps the council believes that the economy of Edinburgh relies on students. The council is very much passing the buck.
Is Councillor Attridge the member for the Marchmont ward?
No, he is a member of the licensing board.
Is the councillor for Marchmont not prepared to help in any way?
The councillor for Marchmont is Councillor MacLaren, who is convener of the MAGPIE group. She has given us her full support and co-operation from day one. The group was formed after I wrote to her to ask that something be done about the state of the streets, which were manky. She put a notice in her local bulletin, a meeting was held in the City Chambers and we were launched in short order. She has been very supportive and co-operative, but she is not in the ruling party. Unfortunately, things tend to fall along party lines in Edinburgh. I am sorry to say that, but it is true.
Before I finish, I should declare an interest as someone who, as a student, stayed on Warrender Park Road in Marchmont 30 years ago. I was happy there, too.
It is perhaps just as well that HMO licences were not required then, as John Scott might have been tossed out.
They had landladies in those days.
Let me start with a comment. I sat on the Social Justice Committee when it took evidence on the licensing of houses in multiple occupation. As I remember, a steady stream of landlords' representatives told us that we would kick rented housing out of Edinburgh. However, it seems that the opposite has happened.What percentage of the houses in your area are HMOs?
I got a fright yesterday, when I had the spare time to sit down and examine the statistics—which I seldom have time to do—in preparation for today. I was staggered to discover that, in several major streets in Marchmont, just under 50 per cent of the houses are HMOs. In some cases, such as in one smaller street, the proportion is considerably more than 50 per cent. That is the kind of figure that we are talking about. The overall figure that I have for the area is 34 per cent, based on the council figures. However, I have done my own homework and read through voters rolls, and I think that I know of more HMOs—unlicensed ones—than the council does. Based on that information, I would say that the figure is more than 34 per cent. My percentages—all of which I have with me—are staggering, when we realise the numbers that there are. I would say that, in reality, we are almost up to 50 per cent in the area.
I take it that the vast majority of HMOs are student accommodation.
Yes. We try not to be pejorative, because we are quite genuinely not against students. We have good relations with students, but there are just too many. We are being overloaded. That is the problem.
How significant is the problem of trying to get absentee landlords to co-operate when seeking to get repairs sanctioned or actioned? I am aware that that is a problem. Would you like to expand on that point?
I am reluctant to say too much, because I have to deal with such a landlord. The typical response is zero. Letters are just not replied to. Fairly minor repairs have had to be done to our building twice in the past four years, and on each occasion it has been like getting blood out of a stone. He is an absentee, but he lives in the city and I happen to have his address. Finally, I presented myself at his address. He immediately named the problem and said, "Oh, do you want a cheque?" He had never replied to my letters, but he paid up; I was amazed that he did. I know that he owns several properties in the area, and every one of the self-appointed factors—namely an owner-occupier from the stair—has had difficulties getting money out of him. We know where that man is and we can go to his door, but there are other absentee landlords who are very difficult to find. But for the fact that I have been living there for a long time, I would be obliged to use the site notices that are put up. However, site notices are inadequate. In many instances, the address that is given for the landlord is in London. There is no name and no signature and the notice does not name a day-to-day agent who is responsible for the building. One of the things that should happen after the licence has been granted is neighbour notification. The law requires that every conjoining owner be notified of the fact that a licence has been granted, the number of residents for which it has been granted and the name, address and 24-hour telephone number of the local agent. I have to tell you that I have only ever seen one neighbour notification. The law is ignored. Residents often do not see a site notice, because one is not displayed, so they do not know that a licence has been granted. How can they object when they do not receive a neighbour notification? The system is really shocking.
What I have to say is more of a comment than a question, so perhaps I should wait until the committee discusses what action to take on the petition.
We can take ideas, if you want to suggest something. The petitioners have been quite clear in presenting the issue and making the points that they wanted to make. I think that we can judge what to do with the petition once we have heard some comments.
I have listened with interest to what the petitioners have told us. I represent a constituency that covers part of the Edinburgh area, and what they have said has certainly got me thinking. I very much recognise the extent to which properties in Edinburgh are now being bought as investment opportunities simply because of the shifts in the market. I note that that is having all sorts of knock-on effects in different parts of the city. The fact that the situation is quite specific to the Edinburgh area should probably be factored into any questions that we ask when we advance our consideration of the petition.Much of the information in the petition was fairly new to me. I am particularly interested in exploring the difference in approach to such issues between Edinburgh and Glasgow. It is always interesting to explore such differences without being partisan about which is better or worse; it is necessary to recognise that different conditions apply and that different situations need to be addressed.The third point that I want to factor into our thinking is whether we should ask the Executive or relevant local authorities wider questions about—to use the petitioners' word—overload, which is a wider planning issue. The petitioners have brought to our attention the fact that certain types of HMO are a concern in Marchmont, but in parts of my constituency the number of hostel and bed-and-breakfast facilities is an issue. I make those observations on the basis that I think that it would be useful if they could be woven into our consideration of the petition appropriately and in a relevant way.
Following on from Susan Deacon's points, there are wider issues at stake about the composition of housing and the mix of social housing and student accommodation. It strikes me that the problem would not have arisen if there had not been such a decrease in student accommodation. I am interested in finding out how much accommodation that was designated as student accommodation has been lost in Edinburgh. If it had not been for the loss of that accommodation, the opportunities would not exist for so many landlords to buy it up and rent it as HMOs.Bigger issues are involved. I think that the lack of social housing and student accommodation is a major concern. It strikes me that the licensing strategy is a bit too late, because the houses are being bought up by one landlord instead of by different individuals who want to live in them or—in the case of social housing—by the council, for example. I would like to get some background information about the mix of social housing and student accommodation in the area and to find out how much student accommodation has been lost. Unless the loss of such accommodation is tackled, the opportunities for the landlords will still exist.
We have had the suggestion that we write to the Scottish Executive and the two local authorities. I do not think that it would be too difficult to ask specific questions such as those that Carolyn Leckie has suggested. If we can get some statistics to provide an analysis of the change and of how things stand at the moment, it would help us to understand the situation.
I have a point of information. I think that we should add the student accommodation services in Edinburgh on to the list of the people to whom we write. We should not ask them about what Carolyn Leckie was saying, as that is a separate issue; I am interested in what the student accommodation services think that the effect on students in Edinburgh would be if the licensing system were operated in the same way as it is in Glasgow.
Are you talking about the services that are provided by the University of Edinburgh?
Yes. It will be possible to find the references in the Official Reports of the Social Justice Committee.
Perhaps we should also write to the minister to ask him whether he is considering whether any changes need to be made to the guidance or to the relevant legislation. He said that he would do that when reviewing the matter.
I am sure that she will consider whether any such changes need to be made.
I beg your pardon. I was looking at the news release from the Executive, which is among our papers. It says that Hugh Henry, the Deputy Minister for Social Justice, had said that he would respond, so I think that we should write to him as well. We should seek the views of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities in addition to those of the people who have already been mentioned because, as Carolyn Leckie and Susan Deacon have said, we are talking about a wider issue. The problem in Marchmont is about HMOs and a group of people colonising—for want of a better word—the area, but there will be other, similar groups elsewhere in Scotland that are doing the same thing, to the exclusion of those who regard themselves as the indigenous population. That might be an issue on which COSLA wants to comment.
link
We need to be clear that the licensing regime that has been put in place for HMOs is about safety and standards; it is not—and never has been—about preventing people from buying up property and converting it into HMOs. Linda Fabiani is quite right—when the licensing of HMOs was being discussed, all the talk was that we could not put the regime in place, because it would prevent the creation of HMOs. Thankfully, the Social Justice Committee saw the sense of having the regime. Having said all that, it is legitimate to ask, "If one area can deal with issues of density, why can't another?" Therefore I support the view that we should write to COSLA about that.There is the wider issue of how we use local housing strategies. Local authorities are responsible for producing local housing strategies and plans that are about balancing needs and demand in communities, creating a range of both affordable social housing and housing that is available for purchase. It might be useful to ask COSLA whether it is using local housing strategies to plan such a balance with reference to HMOs.
Are members happy with that? Are there other suggestions?
I am quite surprised that the commercial activity that we are talking about is permitted without people having to follow the due process of planning or regulation. I understand from the petition that properties that are in the ownership of particular landlords can be converted into houses in multiple occupation without due notice being given to the local planning authority, which seems strange to me. Any other commercial activity would be subject to planning and neighbour notification, to which one of the petitioners' complaints relates.I see that the petitioners suggested that in particular areas, such as university areas, the occupancy rates should be more relaxed. You say that they should be 10 per cent in some areas and 5 per cent in others. What are the rates a percentage of?
Those are the percentages that Glasgow City Council has applied, although I do not know whether the rate is applied to each street. The council has said that proportion of properties that are HMOs will be 10 per cent in the university area and 5 per cent elsewhere. I do not know how that has been achieved.
Surely there could be anomalies in defining the boundary between where 10 per cent would apply and where 5 per cent would apply. Who determines what the university area encompasses?
There is a map and the council has specified which streets are in the university area.
In your petition, you highlight the fact that the HMO regulations have been challenged in court and that the Court of Session has upheld the views of Glasgow City Council. However, the City of Edinburgh Council is not prepared to follow what Glasgow City Council has done, saying that it would be challenged in law, despite the fact that the Court of Session's decision supports Glasgow City Council.
It is a mystery to me why City of Edinburgh Council is able to plead that it would be challenged in law. As you said, there have been appeals against Glasgow City Council; it has lost some of those cases, but in most cases its decision has been upheld. The City of Edinburgh Council, with its much softer regime, has had a smaller number of appeals, and I think that it has won two cases and lost two cases.The City of Edinburgh Council planning development control handbook says:"Multiple occupation … will only be acceptable where the Council is satisfied that: the intensity of use proposed is not excessive in relation to property size; there will be no loss of residential amenity in the neighbouring area … adequate supervision is provided; and, the proposal will not result in an excessive concentration of such uses in any one locality."That is what applies to HMOs with six or more residents, which are the only ones that require planning permission for a change of use. We say that if that applies to HMOs with six residents, why should it not apply to HMOs with five, four and three residents?
We have had a few suggestions about who we should write to on the petition. Are members happy that we take up the matter with the Executive and the local authorities in the way that has been recommended?Members indicated agreement.
Okay. We will await those responses.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 May 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 12 May 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 49
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.