Petition PE737, in the name of Stephen Harte, on behalf of the Holy Trinity Metropolitan Community Church, calls on the Parliament, before considering a Sewel motion in respect of the Civil Partnership Bill, to seek for the bill to be amended to provide for the possibility of solemnisation of a civil partnership in Scotland by a minister of religion in a way similar to that allowed for religious marriages under the Marriage (Scotland) Act 1977 or, failing that, the deletion of clause 89(2) of the bill so that registrars will be free to conduct civil partnership ceremonies in otherwise appropriate venues that have a religious connection. Stephen Harte is present to give evidence in support of the petition; he is accompanied by Rosemary Street. You have three minutes in which to make your presentation before we move on to questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Civil Partnerships (Solemnisation) (PE737)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 13
- Stephen Harte Holy Trinity Metropolitan Community Church 13
- Linda Fabiani SNP 13
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 2
- Jackie Baillie Lab 2
- John Scott Con 2
- Susan Deacon Lab 2
- Helen Eadie Lab 1
- Rosemary Street Holy Trinity Metropolitan Community Church 1
The record
49 contributionsI thank the convener and the committee for seeing us today. I also thank the clerk and his colleagues for fulfilling what must be the challenging task of dealing with a variety of enthusiastic petitioners who are trying to be heard.My colleague Rosemary Street and I are, as the convener said, from the Metropolitan Community Church in Edinburgh. We believe that Christ's gospel is good news for all people. Since the denomination was founded 35 years ago, we have had a special affirming ministry within the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender communities. Unlike some churches, our ministry is open to all people, whatever their sexuality or gender identity. Rosemary Street is also an active member of Parents Enquiry Scotland, which the committee may know is an organisation that works with parents of LGBT children.We appear before the committee today with some simple requests. In essence our petition asks that Parliament honour the place of religion in Scottish society, that the place of religion be honoured for all people, even sexual and gender minorities, and that Parliament comply with its obligations under the European convention on human rights, as the Scotland Act 1998 asks it to do.As the committee will know, Scots law currently allows mixed-sex couples to enter the civil status of marriage by way of a ceremony conducted by either a registrar or an authorised minister of religion. Although different religions have different views on marriage—each from their own theological perspectives—the civil status of marriage created in law by such a ceremony is governed solely by the Marriage (Scotland) Act 1977, irrespective of whether a registrar or a minister of religion conducts the ceremony. Our petition asks that the choice that is offered to mixed-sex couples be extended equally to same-sex couples and that the civil status of civil partnership be capable of creation by a minister of religion who wishes to do that.If it is not altered, the Civil Partnership Bill will go down in history as one of the few pieces of legislation that actively discriminates against people of faith. As the committee will know, the ECHR, which Parliament and the devolved Scottish state must follow, guarantees the freedom of religion. That expressly includes the freedom to manifest one's religion. The ECHR also requires that convention rights should be open to all people without discrimination and in particular without discrimination on the basis of gender. We submit that the current version of the bill is incompatible with the ECHR.We realise that it is true that not all churches will want to take part in civil partnerships. The committee will be well aware that even today some churches will not marry all mixed-sex couples who are perfectly legally entitled to be married. That is their choice; churches are free to decide those matters. We ask the Parliament to leave the decision to individual churches; they should be allowed to decide on the matter for themselves. We ask the Parliament not to dictate to Scottish churches the line that they should take. It should not do so any more than it should legislate on the concept of marriage that is to be adopted by any one denomination.We have had support from clergy and laity across Scotland and across the church spectrum. We have also had support from the Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement, which is an ecumenical organisation that seeks to ensure the inclusion of LGBT people in all aspects of life.We are given to understand that the bill was drafted in such a way because the Executive and the Westminster Government are frightened of the churches, particularly as a result of the backlash from some small but well-funded elements of the church community to the section 2A debate. We think that that is a crying shame. We urge the Parliament not to push churches to the margins of Scottish life because of the hostile words of some Scottish church leaders. We ask the Parliament to embrace enthusiastically the role of faith communities in this area as in other areas.Our biggest regret is that the bill as drafted appears to recognise implicitly the incorrect view, which is peddled by the Christian Institute and others, that it is not possible to be gay and Christian. We know that that is not true and we urge the Parliament to ensure that we do not end up with a bill that says that it is true.
Thank you. Does any member have a question for the petitioners?
I do not know whether what I have to say is a question. The matter seems clear: I think that I understand everything that you have said. It seems that the issue is one of basic unfairness and inequality. Could you lay out simply why the bill would not give churches the freedom to exercise their beliefs?
You are correct to say that the situation seems unfair. I have explained the matter to MSPs, MPs and ministers. Indeed, I had a meeting with my MP, one of whose many hats is that he is Secretary of State for Scotland. When I presented the issue to him in a surgery, he said that our proposal seemed to be clear and fair. That is the response that we get until we reach the civil servants in the bill team and the ministers who are responsible for the bill, after which everything goes funny and we are told that our proposal is not necessary. The bill will not allow a minister of religion to be the person who solemnises the civil partnership—the person who creates it on behalf of the state.
Could you please explain solemnisation?
I am sorry; it is technical jargon.
Never having been married, I have never been solemnised.
I have not been married either. The technical term "solemnisation" refers not only to a church blessing of a relationship, but to the church service that creates the legal relationship in exactly the same way as happens in the registry office ceremony. For many people of faith, solemnisation is an important manifestation of their religion; the ceremony is grounded in their faith. In the same way as faith is important to many people in Scottish society, it is important to many LGBT people. As the bill is drafted, churches will be forced to send their same-sex couples down the road to a dingy registry office, whereas their mixed-sex couples can ground their relationship in their faith as part of the church community.
That was simply put. Thank you.
At the weekend, I was reading an issue of the Church of Scotland's "Life & Work" magazine. Next week, the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland will meet across the road from here. The new moderator is leading the church in an ecumenical direction. Given that various reports will go forward from the assembly, what is the ecumenical view across Scotland of the subject of your petition PE737? We like to pay regard not only to one church, but to all the churches and faiths of Scotland.
Unfortunately, we can speak only for ourselves. We have tried to seek out the views of others, as far as that was possible for a small organisation with small resources. All the Church of Scotland ministers, Methodist ministers and Unitarian ministers to whom we spoke and who confirmed that they would show their support of our petition have done so. Our submission is that, whatever a person's faith and whatever view they take of civil partnerships, they should support our position, even if their church is theologically opposed to same-sex couples. Our position leaves the decision on the matter to individual churches. It honours the important place of churches and other faith communities in Scottish society.
I support your right to be able to solemnise a marriage. I am not religious and would not choose to go down that route, but I respect your rights and think that that route should be open to all. The petition is obviously aimed at the Scottish Parliament as we consider the Sewel motion on the bill. However, are you aware of the lobbying situation and the amount of support that there has been in England and Wales for the bill to be amended?
We are conducting this campaign in Scotland, but there are also moves in England and Wales. As members know, the Scottish Parliament is much more accessible than the Parliament at Westminster. The bill is currently before the House of Lords, but how can the House of Lords be lobbied? We have tried to do so, but there are no lords who are ours to contact. The bill is being considered by a committee and the Westminster bureaucracy is tough. The existence of the Public Petitions Committee means that people's voices can be heard in Scotland. Colleagues in England are impressed by our freedom and our contact with our elected representatives and ministers. We do not always get what we want—no one does. However, lobbying in England is, unfortunately, hard.The other issue with respect to England—and the reason why the Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement has been happy to support us and let us take the matter forward in Scotland—is that there is a different legal position. In England, people were happy to let registrars do things. I am not an expert on English marriage procedure, but I understand that a registrar is a more fluid concept in England and that church ministers can become registrars in order to do certain things. That is not the practice in Scotland, where registrars are usually employees of a local council and accountable to the general registrar and where ministers of religions are authorised celebrants under the Marriage (Scotland) Act 1977. Therefore, Scotland is in a unique position, as it often is. There is a Westminster bill for reasons that members probably know more about than I do, but I would be happier for the bill to be dealt with in Scotland. However, devolution is a complicated concept.
It is a pity that the committee's own lord is not here.
link
I do not want to spoil the party and I entirely appreciate what you have said about the Parliament's openness. Nevertheless, we are dealing with a Sewel motion and, whether that is right or wrong, that is the context in which we are operating. I might agree with some of what you have said about how one can lobby the House of Lords—or, indeed, the House of Commons—but that is where there must be lobbying if the kind of change that I think you want can be created. There may well be a mechanism in Scotland that gives powers to amend a Sewel motion, but I would have thought that you should focus your tactical attention elsewhere.
You may know that the Equal Opportunities Committee did a lot of work on the issue before Christmas. I understand that it obtained an agreement from ministers that the bill team that would consider the Scottish parts of the bill would consist of civil servants accountable to Scottish ministers. There is a separate Scottish part of the bill and the civil servants dealing with that part are in Victoria Quay and are accountable to the Minister for Justice, which is why we are making our efforts in Scotland.It should also be remembered that the Scottish Parliament is different from the Westminster Parliament. The Scottish Parliament is not free to decide whether to comply with the ECHR—it would be ultra vires to do that. Westminster can decide to depart from the ECHR if it wishes. It would be for people other than me and the Parliament's legal representatives to ask, "Can Parliament pass a Sewel motion, the effect of which would be to deviate from the Parliament's obligations under the convention?" If so, when the Parliament wanted to do something that would be contrary to the convention, it would, through a Sewel motion, get Westminster to do it. That could be a recipe for an unscrupulous Administration—I am not suggesting that this Administration is unscrupulous—to circumvent the Parliament's clear obligations under the Scotland Act 1998 to comply with the ECHR. Therefore, before considering the Sewel motion, the Parliament should find out what representations it needs to make to Westminster so that the Parliament is not put in an awkward position by the motion that the Minister for Justice is asking it to consider.
I have a point of clarification that builds on Jackie Baillie's question. If a Sewel motion were introduced for the Civil Partnership Bill, would it allow same-sex marriages to be solemnised? If so, would that solve your problem?
First, the Minister for Justice has already lodged the Sewel motion, which means that it is already before Parliament. Much though I would love to debate the term "same-sex marriages"—
Define it as you wish.
As I say, I would love to have that debate at some point. Unfortunately, that is not what the Executive has put on the table.As drafted, the bill allows only for a registrar to conduct these ceremonies. There is also concern that the Westminster Government appears to be pushing the notion that those will not even be ceremonies, but a kind of bureaucratic form-filling exercise. It would be very sad if that were the case. Indeed, it would rain on our parade—and our people like a parade.As the petition points out, the bill replicates certain parts of the Scottish Parliament's Marriage (Scotland) Act 2002 allowing registrars to wander, if you like, and officiate at civil marriages elsewhere. However, our further objection to the bill is that it includes in primary legislation the provision set out in secondary legislation prohibiting people from having a civil ceremony in a church—which is bizarre in itself—and prohibiting a registrar from going to a church to carry out such a ceremony. Not only will our ministers be unable to conduct such ceremonies—which is what we want and what we feel is demanded by the ECHR—but we will not even be able to have a registrar present at the church. People could have their civil partnership ceremony on a golf course, in a balloon or anywhere else, but not in a church.
I am horrified by what I have heard this morning, because it seems like a basic denial of rights. It simply confirms the point behind the argument that the Civil Partnership Bill should not be dealt with through a Sewel motion. After all, so many aspects directly affect Scotland and the Scottish people. I guess that that argument will be raised when the matter comes up again.I know that you have given evidence to the Equal Opportunities Committee. What was its response? Has it decided to lobby on behalf of the issues raised in the petition, as it should do?
We made a submission to the Equal Opportunities Committee's consultation and the Executive's consultation. However, as is often the case with Executive consultations, our response disappeared into a black hole. I am not saying that it was ignored, but one never knows what happens to such things after they are submitted.On the other hand, the Equal Opportunities Committee noted our comments in its report "Civil Partnership Registration—Response to the Scottish Executive Consultation", which was published on 25 November 2003. Recommendation 9 says:"The Committee recommends that the Scottish Executive use the Marriage (Scotland) Act 1977 and the Divorce (Scotland) Act 1976 as the basis for the procedures for civil partnership registration and dissolution in Scotland and adapt the specific rules as required to reflect the realities of same-sex relationships."The logic of that recommendation is that, if we follow the Marriage (Scotland) Act 1977, we should offer the same choice of authorised celebrant or registrar to same-sex couples as is offered to mixed-sex couples.
And that is a straight recommendation from the Equal Opportunities Committee to the Executive.
Yes. It is recommendation 9.
You have explained some important issues very well this morning. However, the matter leads us into a moral and legislative maze. We also need to remember that, for good or ill, the bill that you are talking about is being considered at Westminster.As a result, I want to raise a bigger question with you as petitioners and in order to find out where the committee can go on this matter. Given where we have reached with the proposed legislation, can you tell us where some of the wider debates on the matter take place in Scotland? After all, this debate has other dimensions. I have taken quite an interest in the matter; indeed, I am interested in the gap in the various legal rights of mixed-sex cohabiting couples that has opened up because of the route that has been chosen.As I have said, a whole host of moral and legislative issues still need to be addressed in Scotland. However, it is not immediately obvious how to do so given our current position. Do you want to comment on that? Do you think that the family law proposals in Scotland will be a vehicle, if not for legislative change, then for discussion of these issues?
You correctly refer to the legislative realities. As we sit here, the Justice 1 Committee is also considering the procedures relating to the matter. I regret that I am unable to attend that meeting. We believe that a great injustice is being done and that ECHR-guaranteed rights of people of faith in Scotland are being trampled on. That is the reality for us.There is a remedy. If Parliament is not willing to give us that remedy by honouring convention-guaranteed rights in the legislation, our people will await an opportunity to go to court. In the case of Macdonald v Advocate General for Scotland, the Westminster MP for Edinburgh Pentlands decided personally to argue against the right not to suffer discrimination of lesbian and gay people. In the same way, the power and financial might of the state would be used against any poor couple who decided to enforce their convention rights. Those people might also be opposed by the MP for Edinburgh Pentlands, as Advocate General. They might have to find money to fund legal representation, which is not easy. If they lost—and the case might go all the way up to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg—the state would seek expenses against them. That is the reality. If the Scottish Parliament does not take seriously its obligations under the convention and decide what conversations it must have with Westminster to ensure that it does not abdicate its responsibilities, our people will have to dig deep into their pockets and risk their houses to guarantee their rights.
As has been mentioned, the Minister for Justice, Cathy Jamieson, lodged a Sewel motion on the Civil Partnership Bill on 26 April. The Justice 1 Committee will consider the motion and take oral evidence on it. As far as I am aware, it is doing so this morning. I am not sure that the committee will not consider the issues that we have been discussing this morning. It would be appropriate for the points that Mr Harte has made, the questions that have been asked and the information that we have gathered to be presented to the Justice 1 Committee, to allow it to consider that evidence before the Sewel motion comes before Parliament. What do members think about the tight timescale to which we are working? I believe that the Sewel motion may come before Parliament in June.
link
I agree with your recommendation. The matter needs to be turned around quickly because, as the petitioner has indicated, the Justice 1 Committee is considering the bill now. It is crucial that we get the evidence that we have received to the committee, so that the committee can take it on board. The petitioners should not forget that, ultimately, they need to lobby Westminster. That is the point that I was trying to make to them.
I beg the committee's indulgence. I hoped that the issue of families would come up in the questions, but it did not. My colleague Rosemary Street, who is a member of our church, is also an active member of Parents Enquiry Scotland and would like briefly to share with the committee some information on the impact of the bill as drafted on Scottish families.
I do not know whether we can spend much more time on questions, but if you want to say something that you think will add to the information that we refer to the Justice 1 Committee, I am more than happy for you to do so.
I will bring the debate to a personal level. I cannot emphasise enough what I feel about the unfairness of the wording in the bill. I have been a member of the Metropolitan Community Church for nine years and have met many lesbian and gay people of wonderful, true faith. My son and daughter also attend the church. They are both in stable, loving relationships. They wish very much to follow my husband and me in affirming their relationships in a place of worship in front of God with a minister. My daughter has that choice, but if the bill is passed my son will not have that choice, and that upsets him, and us as a family, greatly. Because of his sexuality, he has been sidelined and not allowed to stand up in a place of worship. To me, that is grossly unfair.
Are there any other comments before we bring this item to a conclusion? I do not want to keep the debate going. We are trying to decide what to do with the petition.
In the context of those final comments about families, I raised the issue of family law and made the point that there are plans for devolved legislation on family law, on which a consultation process is currently taking place. I repeat the point that the moral issues and the legislative debates that today's discussion has touched on are all germane to that process and to the legislation that will eventually be passed. There has been enormous focus on the Civil Partnership Bill, but there are other ways and other places in which some of the issues can be raised. The current debate may or may not eventually lead to further legislative changes, but there are other vehicles for debate, discussion and potential statutory change here in Scotland. In a sense, I am disappointed that the petitioners did not address my question on that. I know that time is limited, but perhaps that is something that the committee could bear in mind.
I agree with the recommendation that the petition should be sent to the Justice 1 Committee, but I also recommend that we write to the Minister for Justice asking her whether she has taken those issues on board in making her decision about what to put before Parliament. We should ask whether she has raised those issues with Westminster, in relation to the Sewel motion that will be lodged and in relation to the bill. If there are issues that are not being addressed in the Civil Partnership Bill, we need to know whether she has plans to cover those issues in further legislation that is now being considered.
I have just one point to make on that, Linda. First of all, the timescale would not allow us to get a reply back from the minister or—
We have two weeks. The minister's officials must know whether what I am asking about is being done.
Given that the minister has already given us a response in relation to that, it would be for the Justice 1 Committee—
Yes, but it does not answer the question.
It would be for the Justice 1 Committee to take those questions to the minister once we have referred the petition to that committee. We have said previously in this committee that we either send a petition to the minister or we send it to another committee. We cannot delay the timescale to which the Justice 1 Committee is working; if we asked for a response from the minister, that would not meet the Justice 1 Committee's timescale. The Justice 1 Committee will have to take up the matter with the minister in relation to the Sewel motion. If we refer the petition to the Justice 1 Committee, we will effectively be doing what you are suggesting by demanding a response from the minister.
If you are talking about the response from the minister and you mean the letter that is among our papers for this meeting, that is a news release that was put out by the Scottish Executive in September last year. That is a long time ago and things could have happened since then. Let us give the minister the benefit of the doubt; perhaps she has taken the issue on board. If you are saying that a Scottish Executive news release is a response from a minister to a formal committee of the Parliament, I do not think that that is on.
Okay, but we know what the minister's position is on the issue. What we do not know is the minister's response with respect to the issues that the Justice 1 Committee is considering. When writing to the Justice 1 Committee, we can ask it to take up the points that have been raised this morning by Mr Harte and Mrs Street. In that way, we could elicit a response from the minister.
Could we also ask the Justice 1 Committee to ask those specific questions?
That is what I said.
Well—
If we write to the Justice 1 Committee and give it a copy of the Official Report of our meeting, as we always do, and ask it to take on board the points raised by Mr Harte and Mrs Street this morning, those are the questions that the committee will put to the minister, if we ask it to do that specifically.
That covers one element of the issue. I shall take it on myself to cover some of the others. That is fair enough.
Are members happy with that?Members indicated agreement.
I thank the petitioners for coming along this morning.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 May 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 12 May 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 49
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.