The first new petition is PE735, from Vivien Dance, which relates to the national health service. The petition calls on the Parliament to urge the Executive to require NHS Argyll and Clyde and NHS Greater Glasgow to make a special agreement on transferring responsibility for the design and provision of health services in the north Clyde area and, where appropriate, to amend existing legislation so that the boundaries of the two health boards are adjusted in order to transfer authority for the north Clyde area from NHS Argyll and Clyde to NHS Greater Glasgow. Vivien Dance is present to give evidence in support of her petition. She is accompanied by David Bruce and David Morrell. I welcome them to the committee. You have three minutes in which to make a presentation, after which we will ask questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Health Service Provision (North Clyde) (PE735)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 7
- Vivien Dance 5
- Linda Fabiani SNP 5
- John Scott Con 5
- Susan Deacon Lab 3
- David Bruce 2
- Jackie Baillie Lab 2
- David Morrell 2
The record
31 contributionsGood morning. I thank all of you for inviting us to the committee and for giving us the opportunity to address you today. We are joined—in the body of the kirk—by two of the other principal petitioners, Leila McKichan and Eileen Gorie. We are delighted to be here. We are not, in any sense, an elected group. We have all carried responsibility for NHS governance, both locally and nationally. Based on our collective experience, we are confident that we have a thorough understanding of the issues that have resulted in the need for us to make a direct appeal to our elected Government. There is a serious crisis affecting NHS provision in our area and we believe that our petition gives you a unique opportunity to stop what is a rapidly deteriorating situation. We look to you to give our fellow patients in the north Clyde area a bold and constructive solution to this crisis. That solution would be welcomed by the vast majority of the population. The theme of our short presentation is organising for reform, which is taken from the Scottish Executive's "Partnership for Care: Scotland's Health White Paper". I have asked Mr David Bruce to read our agreed statement.
Good morning. I will be clear about what exactly it is that we are asking for. We are looking at the needs of the 140,000 patients who live north of the Clyde estuary, in the catchment area of NHS Argyll and Clyde. They are a third of that health board's patients, so they account for about a third of its budget—about £200 million. We want responsibility for those patients and that budget to be transferred to the Greater Glasgow NHS Board. Our reasoning for that is laid out clearly in chapter 7 of "Partnership for Care", which states:"To support the development of integrated, decentralised healthcare services that meet the needs of individual patients and local communities, we need to remove unnecessary organisational and legal barriers."We are here today to ask you to intervene to ensure that one particular barrier, which at present prevents patients from being treated in the geographical area of their choice, is removed. Vivien Dance said that we face a crisis—that is not an exaggeration. Public concern is running increasingly high as patients and carers see their services being withdrawn from local hospitals and relocated across the river.We understand fully that many district general hospitals—including Vale of Leven hospital and Lorn and Islands district general hospital—face change as a result of developments in modern medicine and population changes. Many services are being centralised to enable clinicians to give patients better-quality care, but we question why an historically illogical organisational boundary—which can be seen from any map—should determine where patients are treated. By demanding that patients go to Paisley, NHS Argyll and Clyde requires them not only to cross a major geographical barrier, but to go against the natural connection, the continuity of community and the well-established and reliable infrastructure of road and rail transport into Glasgow.Why has Paisley emerged as the service provider for patients from north of the river when that is clearly against the resident population's wishes? It is because our area was made part of what was Argyll and Clyde Health Board's area. From the outset, the relationship was never happy, especially because of the problem of allocating equitable budgets and services across the divide. We ask that patient care and convenience take priority over an illogical boundary and that common sense prevails. The present situation does not conform to the stated aims of "Partnership for Care: Scotland's Health White Paper". We ask the committee to examine the root of the problem: the administrative structure.The issue is much more than merely technical; it causes much unnecessary pain—often literally—to many patients and their carers. Members have the power to begin the process of rebuilding patient confidence by transferring responsibility for patients from north of the river and their budget to NHS Greater Glasgow. We ask the committee to endorse our petition and to find a way to ensure that its requests are met as a matter of urgency.
Jackie Baillie has expressed an interest in the petition. Does she want to speak before the committee asks questions?
link
As the local member for the area involved, I support the principles that underlie the petition and its desired outcome, which is to deliver quality health care as locally as possible and, when local services are not possible, to ensure that people have reasonable access to services. The petitioners have helpfully recognised some of the pressures, such as junior doctors' hours, the shortage of consultants and the increasing drive to specialisation, which all lead to a need for review and reform of future health service provision. The key issue is reasonable access, as well as regional planning. People in my area must make a five-hour return journey by public transport to access a district general hospital in Paisley. I am sure that the petitioners will be able to expand on that. It would take 20 minutes by public transport for them to access a similar standard of facility in Glasgow. It is nonsense to expect people to conform to boundaries drawn on maps by bureaucrats to organise services when we should focus on the patient journey through the health system. Therefore, I am keen that we should recognise natural travel-to-work areas and the natural transport links that flow from north of the River Clyde into north Glasgow and south of the River Clyde into south Glasgow. There is no relationship between the two areas and that needs to be reflected. Regional planning has exercised not only this committee but the Parliament as a whole. I do not understand why two major hospitals—the Southern general and the Royal Alexandra hospital in Paisley—are five minutes away from each other, when we could have little north of the River Clyde for a swathe of the population. If the health boards concerned had talked to each other much earlier, we would not be in the present situation.My bottom line is that a reality check is needed. Health boards should focus not on service provision within their boundaries, but on patients' needs. Closer co-operation between NHS Argyll and Clyde and NHS Greater Glasgow is desirable. We want to achieve that in the short term and the long term.
Jackie Baillie rightly used the phrase "reality check". At one time in my life I lived in Clydebank and at another time I lived in Argyll, so I am aware of how vast an area Argyll and Clyde NHS Board covers. Asking people from Clydebank or Helensburgh to go to hospital in Paisley, either as a patient or a visitor, is just ridiculous. I do not mean anything against Paisley, but there is even a psychological issue involved. There is a natural divide between the north of the Clyde and the south of the Clyde; they are separate localities. I am amazed that people from Helensburgh have to go to Paisley to go to hospital. I did not know that that happened and it seems very silly. It is as though someone has sat down, looked at an area on a map and, without considering the realities, said, "Oh, that's achievable."I am out of touch with the area; what kind of provision does Vale of Leven hospital offer, compared with the provision offered in Paisley? Is there a split in skills and services? Is that why people have to travel?
You have used an important word there—"split". Patients who are served by the Vale of Leven district general hospital now have to get a lot of services south of the river in Paisley. That is focusing people's minds on which services they can receive locally. There has been a downturn in such services, which is causing great concern. Many of you will have read press reports and responses from the public in the local area. Our petition has been necessary because we now face more and more journeys south of the river to access services. The problem is becoming even more acute—no pun intended.You said that you are out of touch with the area and you mentioned people from Helensburgh having to travel across to the Royal Alexandra. As Jackie Baillie mentioned, that is a considerable journey. However, the area north of the river that we are talking about stretches out to cover the whole of Argyll. It can take two or three hours to get from some areas to the Vale, before you then have to cross the river to Paisley. Transport is at the heart of the issue for the whole area. We are questioning the accessibility of health services. We have debated access and quality and are putting forward the population's point of view that quality and access are fundamental to patient care. That is why we have submitted our petition.
If someone in Lochgilphead needed a specific hospital service, where would they end up?
People in Lochgilphead can access many services locally because there is a community hospital there. We are fortunate that that will still be provided for in the next few years. In addition, local general practices may take community health care to the level above what is offered at the Lomond end, for example. If people require acute care they can come down to the Vale as day patients. However, they will have a difficulty now in that they may have to travel to Paisley.The natural travel links for people from Lochgilphead are into Glasgow—even more so than for the communities in Helensburgh and Lomond. There are natural transport links from Argyll into Glasgow but not into Paisley.
In essence, where are you now? I appreciate that people have lacked confidence in Argyll and Clyde NHS Board; Jackie Baillie has brought that to the attention of Parliament. How does Greater Glasgow NHS Board feel about you going to them? Has that board expressed views? I appreciate that you have expressed your views in public in forums such as this, but have you been in communication with the Glasgow board to find out its views on the commonsense solution that you seek?
That is a reasonable question, and the fair answer is that we have not consulted the health boards. We thought that we might be asked that, but the issue is about the constitutions of the health boards, namely, their boundaries, and we felt that it was necessary to take it a stage further. Each of the health boards will have a special interest in the petition one way or the other, and that is why we are bringing the matter to the committee. It is obvious from immediate reactions and discussions that the health boards think along conventional lines—they think in terms of service agreements, for example—which do not take into account the radical differences between the areas. Vivien Dance and I have been on the boards on both sides: we have been on Lomond Healthcare NHS Trust and also Argyll and Clyde Health Board. It is the latter experience—in my case, for two years—that convinces us that, from Paisley, it is not possible to digest, understand and cater for the special needs of those north of the river. The situation is different, and that is the basis of our argument. In answer to Linda Fabiani's first comment, I will add a little vividness to the reality check: it is 30 years since the Erskine bridge was built and there is still no scheduled bus service across it. That shows how separate the communities are. That might be a pity and perhaps it should not be that way, but that is the way it is. Three of the major Glasgow hospitals are within 10 minutes' walk of a station on the Helensburgh to Airdrie line. That is the contrast that produces the statistics to which Ms Baillie referred.
Jackie Baillie has made the not unreasonable criticism that there has been a breakdown in regional planning. That issue has exercised the committee over almost the past year. Do you agree that your situation is another example of a complete breakdown in regional planning and that there is a huge need for people to think outside the box, to use that rather nasty jargon phrase?
Yes, I agree, but we cannot expect those who are in the box to do the thinking. That is why we have not gone to the health boards themselves. The question is bigger: in our view, the focus and the root of the problem are the boundaries. Whatever arrangement can be made in the meantime to get round that would be appreciated, but the boundaries are the problem. Some of us are old enough to remember that there seemed to be an idea some decades ago—presumably in Edinburgh—that regions should be defined around river basins. We have got caught up in that and have somehow been left with a region that has a major river right through its middle. That is no longer tenable in the modern situation of increased, and obviously desirable and necessary, centralisation of services, which we understand. The problem is continually being aggravated to a serious point.
My questions build directly on John Scott's. You have all indicated that you have had considerable individual and collective experience in national health service governance over the years and so know your way around the system. That prompts me all the more to reinforce John Scott's question about what level of discussion and dialogue there has been, not only with the two NHS boards concerned, but with the Scottish Executive and other bodies with an interest. It is always of interest to the Parliament to know what local attempts to make progress and resolve issues have been made before we consider the issues, so will you elaborate on what you have already told us on that point?
We have followed with interest the debates on the clinical strategy that Argyll and Clyde NHS Board is currently developing. We have been kept informed of the discussions that underpin that clinical strategy, and the timing of the petition is designed to ensure that it has an impact on decisions taken on the clinical strategy. The strategy will not be finalised until June but, as far as we are aware, the transfer of population base and budget to Greater Glasgow NHS Board will not be an option—I say that knowing that somebody will now write it in to ensure that it is an option. The white paper seeks to undermine the command and control mentality and remove it from health services, particularly in relationships between managers and the bureaucrats, but the decisions that are currently being taken reinforce the attitude of, "We will refer to Glasgow if patients insist and if we have to." A complete transfer of budget and population to the control and responsibility of Greater Glasgow NHS Board has never been proposed and has not come out of discussions on clinical strategy, management, moving forward or reinforcing the terms and conditions of the white paper.The white paper is clear. It drives towards regional planning and reminds health boards of the need to work together and co-operate. The population north of the River Clyde has not seen any tangible examples of that. There are still patients who wish to be cared for and receive their quality of care in Glasgow being directed across to Paisley. Patient choice is being negated.
I appreciate the wider points of substance that you make, but I would like clarification on the specific points that I asked about. Extensive discussion and consultation have taken place, and continue to take place, at local and national level on the issues that you have mentioned. Have you had a dialogue with those who are involved in such discussions and consultation to attempt to influence the outcome of the various processes?
The question is: to whom can we talk? We all have experience within the system and talk to people all the time about such issues, but there is no place to go to propose the concept that we are discussing, except to the Parliament. Such matters can only really be addressed to the Parliament because all the other people to whom we might talk have a vested interest and a position to defend. We can go to Greater Glasgow NHS Board and say, "Look, we have this great idea. We want to come and be part of your scene." Greater Glasgow NHS Board will say, "That sounds like a good idea, but hang on a minute. What will that do for our relationship with Argyll and Clyde NHS Board?" Equally, we could go to Argyll and Clyde NHS Board and say, "We have this great idea. We want a third of your budget to be taken away and given to Greater Glasgow NHS Board," but what would it say to that? We are in a fix. The great blessing is that we can come and talk to MSPs, which is wonderful. However, our central problem is to whom we can talk.
Thank you for your answer, which I take as a no. You have given reasons for that answer.I would like you to comment on a fundamental point, which Jackie Baillie raised. She alluded to regional planning. Given that there are many examples throughout the health service in Scotland of services being delivered sensibly across boundaries, why are transfers of budgets and changes to boundaries now required to get that to happen in your part of the country, when it happens through co-operation elsewhere? I want to address precisely the geographical issues that you have clearly set out today.
Historically, we have all suffered because health boards do not seem to be able to communicate at that level without direction from the Parliament and ministers. When that direction comes, I think that it will give greater clarity to what is happening to patients north of the river. We express on behalf of the population the dissatisfaction with the status quo and the fact that, historically, things have simply never worked. We have all been part of a system in which governance has been an issue and we have sat in many meetings in which we have discussed the funding deficit in respect of Argyll and Clyde NHS Board and Greater Glasgow NHS Board. I do not understand how good patient experience and good quality regional planning can be taken forward on the basis of such a premise, or how, without direction from the Parliament, managers will be made to deliver what is in the white paper.
I will take Linda Fabiani and Jackie Baillie, then try to get some direction on what to do with the petition.
It is obvious that Jackie Baillie has been working on the issue. I notice that, in an answer to her, Malcolm Chisholm said that the boards would write with detailed responses to the questions that she had asked. Have there been any responses? Could the kind of voluntary cross-border arrangements that Susan Deacon alluded to happen elsewhere? I have asked those questions of Jackie, but perhaps I should not have.
link
In an attempt to be helpful I will address some of the issues that have been raised, including Linda Fabiani's. It is fair to say that the subject of the petition is the single issue that has dominated debate and discussion not just in the local community, but at GP surgeries and among consultants. It is the talk of the steamie, because people care so much about what is happening. It is one thing to explain to people some of the national changes that are happening, why it is right that quality of care should be paramount and why we cannot provide things in the way in which they have always been provided—rightly so, because medicine advances and we are living longer. However, no matter whom one talks to, they do not understand the issue of reasonable access.The issue has been raised until we are blue in the face at board level, locally in the community, at public meetings and with the Executive. We have to be clear that the petition has not come out of nowhere. The Executive is well aware of the issues and the health boards are well aware of them. We did not need to have a specific dialogue with them about the petition for them to realise what is going on, because we have had an on-going dialogue. There has been a failure of regional planning, simply because there has not been the kind of co-operation that has been experienced elsewhere. Regrettably, that was down to some well documented management failures which, thankfully, have now been addressed. Nevertheless, that legacy is there. The difficulty and the lack of co-operation are witnessed on a daily basis.I do not necessarily want all the boundaries to change, because that implies a legislative process that will not achieve the outcome immediately, but unless we put that suggestion on the table, the kind of co-operation that other areas enjoy will not happen. At the back of the minds of politicians and consultants across the board is the issue of the health boards being too small. We need to consider making health boards bigger. The petition fits firmly into that argument.I received a response from the chief executive of NHS Argyll and Clyde, which described graphically the process by which officials from NHS Argyll and Clyde participate in the NHS modernisation board in Glasgow and vice versa. Unfortunately, the reality on the ground is that clinicians are not talking to each other, and unless they talk to each other about the shape of services and what is possible, we will get what fits within existing boundaries and budgets. We are asking people to think out of the box and to focus not on boundaries and budgets but on patients, who after all are what the NHS is all about.
Whom do you suggest we write to to get them to think outside the box?
I suggest that we write to the Scottish Executive and NHS Scotland, seeking their comments on the petition. We should ask not only about PE735 but about the other petitions that we have received that have illustrated a lack of regional planning. Jackie Baillie says that other areas have co-operated and that there have been better results, but I argue that other areas could be better served even if there has been co-operation. The Executive needs to knock heads together. We all understand the impact of the working time directive and the lack of consultants and junior doctors, but we cannot escape the fact that satellite areas around Glasgow have just as much right to health care provision as does Glasgow itself.We need to get sorted out not only the hospitals in Glasgow—which have been the subject of much debate in this committee—but the satellites. That can be done only from a regional planning perspective, which does not appear to be being applied at present. Will the Executive address that issue?
We must ask that.
In general, I agree with everything that John Scott has said, but we cannot let the particulars of PE735 get lost in the wider issue. We must deal with the specifics of the petition, which seem to indicate an obvious example of good intentions going wrong. We can ask the Executive and the health boards to consider the wider issue, but we must remember where the petition came from and what it is about and not allow that to get lost. We must make it plain to the Executive that, as well as wanting it to address the wider issues, we require answers quickly to our questions on the petition. As Jackie Baillie said, the issue will not come out of the blue for the Executive, so we should put a time limit on getting its response to our request.
We should also write to the two health boards involved.
They can just copy the letter that they sent to Jackie Bailie and send it to us.
Whatever.
We would normally expect a response within six weeks and we can stipulate that we expect that timescale to apply in this case. Are members happy for us to write to the Executive, NHS Scotland and the two health boards and to get them to respond as quickly as possible?Members indicated agreement.
I thank the petitioners for coming to the meeting and bringing the issue to our attention.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 May 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 12 May 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 49
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.