Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Town and Country Planning (Appeals) (Scotland) Regulations 2008 (SSI 2008/434)

Wednesday 28 January 2009 Local Government and Communities Committee Subordinate legislation 15 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

Do members have any points that need clarification on the regulations?

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

What volume of appeals do you anticipate, based on previous experience? How many of those are likely to lead to a hearing or an inquiry session? How do you expect the differentiation to be made between a hearing and an inquiry session?

Oonagh Gil Scottish Government Directorate for Planning and Environmental Appeals
link

Currently, the directorate for planning and environmental appeals deals with around 1,400 cases per year. Of those, approximately 80 per cent are dealt with through an exchange of written submissions or in writing. The remainder go through some form of oral process.In recent years, there has been a move towards more informal hearings rather than formal inquiries, with reporters encouraging parties to discuss in a hearing environment the case that is in front of them rather than using formal cross-examination. We have seen a shift towards hearings, particularly for smaller cases, and we expect that trend to continue.The driver for deciding which process is used for cases under the new regulations will be that the decision maker needs to be clear that they have sufficient information to make the decision. It will be for the appointed person to review the papers that they receive with the appeal and consider what the issues are that will require further examination, and then what the best process will be to get the evidence that will allow them to make the decision.We expect to default to the most straightforward procedure, so our initial response would be to gather further information in writing from parties and allow them to comment on each other's papers. A discussion of some issues will help to get to the root of them and get a clearer understanding of the situation. The first step would be to consider a hearing, but certain issues will undoubtedly be best explained and explored through formal cross-examination. In particular, detailed evidence, perhaps on retail impact or consideration of a scientific issue on which there is a clear difference of opinion between expert witnesses, may be best explored through cross-examination, but the main point is that it will be for the appointed person to identify the best way forward, although they will do so informed by the main parties' views on how the issues would best be explored and examined.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

Am I right in thinking that the working assumption is that, if a local authority refuses permission for what is classed as a major development in the hierarchy of applications and the applicant appeals against that refusal, it is more likely than not that consideration of the appeal would be conducted through an inquiry session rather than a hearing session?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banff and Buchan
link

I certainly hope that the balance would be that it could be resolved without a hearing.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

That might be rather optimistic, because in the scenario that I describe a major development, which falls into one of the categories that we discussed under the previous item, has been refused by a local authority. It is therefore almost certainly contrary in some respects to a local planning policy or has raised a considerable amount of local controversy. The likelihood of such an appeal not being considered in a public forum must be minimal.

Oonagh Gil Scottish Government Directorate for Planning and Environmental Appeals
link

Under the new regime, the expectation is that even with a major development we will look closely at the case, identify the issues that require examination and consider the best way to take evidence and consider it. It may well be that, for a major development, one part of the scheme is such that an oral process would be beneficial but other aspects that are in dispute may still best be dealt with through written submissions.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

Although it may be wonderful to have such a hearing, we know from our parliamentary experience that the veracity and accuracy of assertions often require to be tested. We all know from experience of such situations that it is not unknown for people—in all good faith and because of their passionate beliefs about how their community should develop—to make, shall we say, exaggerated or inaccurate statements in the context of the consideration of planning applications. How are such statements to be tested in an environment in which everyone is just sitting around having a cheery little discussion, in the course of which people can make assertions one after the other without any kind of challenge as to whether their assertion is factually accurate or in any way consistent with other assertions that are being made in relation to the application?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banff and Buchan
link

I draw the member back to the process of dealing with the written submissions, when the submissions are put from one party to the other and there is a process by which the assertions are either accepted or rejected and reasons are provided for why that is the case. Mr McLetchie will be familiar with that process, which is a standard part of, for example, house buying, when it is decided what conditions will apply to offers and acceptances. Assertions will not escape unchallenged, however the issues are dealt with—there is a range of ways, which Ms Gil will address.

Oonagh Gil Scottish Government Directorate for Planning and Environmental Appeals
link

I would not describe a hearing as a cosy little discussion; they are reporter-led, reporter-managed events, at which the reporter's duty is to set the agenda and lead the discussion. That is to ensure that, at the end of the session, they have sufficient information to come to a conclusion. They are expected to challenge and follow up any arguments if they feel that there is a lack of clarity, or that people are not providing the full picture or are presenting it from a particular viewpoint. Hearing sessions allow for rigorous debate and discussion. As you can imagine, parties in that environment will still wish to disagree with each other, and they are invited to do so. The difference is that there is no formal cross-examination, as would be expected in a formal inquiry.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

We are placing a heavy onus on the reporter, as the conductor of the discussion, to ensure that the assertions are properly tested, that the facts are put and that, if need be, people are challenged on their assertions. Can we be clear that the intention is to have a rigorous system in that respect, rather than one that simply takes at face value all manner of assertions—from whatever sources they might come—that have no foundation in fact?

Oonagh Gil Scottish Government Directorate for Planning and Environmental Appeals
link

My colleagues in the directorate are well used to rigorously assessing evidence from a variety of forums. The expectation is that they will continue to do so.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

There are no further requests for clarification from members. I invite members to agree that they wish to make no recommendation on the regulations.

Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Local Government and Communities Committee Wednesday 28 January 2009 Committee business · 1
  2. Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 4
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 38
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
  7. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
  8. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  9. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
  10. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 15
  11. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.