Does any member have a question on the regulations?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Town and Country Planning (Schemes of Delegation and Local Review Procedure) (Scotland) Regulations 2008 (SSI 2008/433)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John McNairney 9
- Mary Mulligan Lab 7
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 5
- Duncan McNeil Lab 4
- John Wilson SNP 2
- Norman MacLeod Scottish Government Legal Directorate 1
- David McLetchie Con 1
- Jim Tolson LD 1
The record
31 contributionsHow many local authorities operate a scheme of delegation?
All of them. I would like to bring in my official to say on the record whether the two park authorities operate such a scheme, given that they, too, are planning authorities.
One park authority has a scheme of delegation, but I think that the Cairngorms National Park Authority does not.
I thought that it was important to give a complete answer.
The national parks have different powers under the park orders.
At what stage do local elected members play a role in the scheme of delegation? How does a local member who does not agree with a decision on a delegated issue make that known?
The planning authority will agree on the scheme of delegation that sets the threshold up to which their officials will take decisions. The situation will vary throughout the country, as is the case at present. Under local government legislation, authorities have powers to operate schemes of delegation, although few of the current schemes allow officials to refuse applications. Under the new system, planning authorities will draft a scheme of delegation for ministers to endorse. Under such schemes, and subject to conditions that the respective planning authority will impose, officials will take decisions on local but not major developments. Depending on the number of objections that are lodged or representations that are made by community councils, officials will make decisions under the scheme of delegation.If an applicant is unhappy with the decision of a planning officer on—let us say—a hot-food takeaway or an office extension, they could seek a review from the planning authority. They will no longer have to appeal the decision to ministers as is the case at present. In the review process, members of the local review body will look afresh at the case. In future, members who sit on such a review body will engage in planning applications that have progressed down the scheme of delegation route.
You mention a review body. Will that be the planning committee?
The regulations refer to a committee of the planning authority that comprises no fewer than three members. Our original consultation proposal was that the review body should involve between three and five members of the authority, some of whom might be planning committee members. Following the consultation and workshops that we held with stakeholders last summer, we removed the ceiling, to give authorities more flexibility to establish local review bodies that are appropriate for their areas. In some areas, the membership might be small, whereas in other areas it might be larger. The regulations do not prevent the review committee from being much larger; that would be agreed by the planning authority.
The regulations permit a local authority to have multiple instances of the review committee, which might be required in geographically large areas such as Aberdeenshire and the Highlands, where council decision making has an area facet. The regulations allow but do not require councils to have several instances of such a committee.
John McNairney said that an applicant can appeal. If a planning officer takes a decision under delegated powers with which local elected members are unhappy, can councillors override that decision?
Once a decision is made, the question is whether the applicant appeals it. However, before a decision is made, flexibility is built into the primary legislation to allow the local authority to recall the decision—that is the terminology—for the committee or the full authority to make, rather than have a delegated decision. The mere fact that an application falls within the scheme of delegation does not require it to be determined by an appointed person. Planning authorities still have the flexibility to have a decision taken by a committee or by the full council.
That answer is helpful. Thank you.
I will ask about an issue that arises from the regulatory impact assessment, which says:"Scottish Ministers will have a role in the approval of schemes which each local authority will be required to review at least every five years."I suggest to the minister and his officials that such a review should take place at least every four years. That would coincide with, rather than be out of kilter with, the local authority election cycle. Changes that occur in local authorities because of the normal electoral cycle might require a review and newly elected members need to be brought up to speed with local delegated powers.Mary Mulligan asked how the local review body would be established, who its members would be and whether it would consist of planning committee members. An officer's delegated power to make decisions on planning applications might be challenged before a local review body whose members were not planning committee members. If the issue went to a full planning committee, the delegated officer's decision that had been challenged by the local review body might then be challenged by the planning committee. Is that scenario likely, or will the local review body be outwith the planning committee process? I am trying to pin down which body has the ultimate authority locally to determine appeals against planning application approvals or rejections.
John Wilson asked two questions. The first was about holding a review every five years. The regulations say:"The planning authority must prepare a scheme of delegation at intervals of no greater than every five years."Bearing in mind that current councils may serve for five years, I think that that is reasonable. Of course, the regulations therefore provide, but do not mandate, that such reviews can be done on a four-yearly cycle. It is probably right to have that flexibility. Mr Wilson's point about aligning reviews of schemes with changes in administration and personnel has some merit but, at the end of the day, it is probably appropriate that the councils are in the driving seat. I suspect that a five-year review cycle is fine. I invite Mr McNairney to respond to your question about the decision-making process.
It will not be possible for the planning committee to revisit the decision of the local review body. The process is that the official will take a delegated decision on an application in the local developments category. If an applicant is aggrieved by that decision, they will seek a review by the local review body. The decision of the local review body will be final, short of an appeal to the Court of Session. That will be the decision of the authority on review.The members who sit on the local review body will have had no previous involvement in the planning application that comes before them. Their focus will be on reviewing the decision that was taken under delegated powers. Is that helpful?
I am not sure that it is because what you describe might muddy the waters slightly in relation to the local review body and the delegation of powers. You referred to an applicant whose planning application is rejected. Another aspect is what happens when a planning application is approved and objectors wish to object to the decision being made by the delegated officer.I have a vested interest as a local elected member who is not on a planning committee but who has some influence on aspects of planning applications that come before us on a local ward basis and must declare whether I am happy with the delegation of authority over planning applications. I would like clarification because I am not clear how a local review body can make a decision when the local authority's planning committee is excluded from reviewing the local review body's decision-making process. In the hierarchy of decision making, where does the planning committee sit in relation to an officer's delegated powers? Given that we are talking about minor developments, I suppose that we will not end up with a Menie estate scenario if the local review body makes the final decision with no right for the full planning committee to intervene, but will you make it clear that local review bodies will not be subject to scrutiny or decisions being overturned by the full planning committee or the full council?
It is important to go back to the point that there is no limit to the number of people who can be on the review body. When a planning application goes to the review body, it will be the first time that politicians will have considered it. If a local council decides that the membership of the review body should be identical to that of the planning authority, it will be a matter for that council. The regulations offer councils the flexibility to structure things in a way that they determine meets their needs. The only requirement is that at least three people should be on the local review body. I invite Mr McNairney to expand on that.
The planning committee will delegate to its officials the authority to take decisions on certain planning applications, as they do now. The key change that the 2006 act brought about is that there is a new scheme of delegation and a link to local review. Through the scheme of delegation, the planning committee will already have agreed which applications it has entrusted to officials to take decisions on. It is the challenge that is new.In some planning authorities, virtually all their councillors might be members of the planning committee. There are some merits in the local review body having on it councillors who have built up planning expertise over time, but the decision on which councillors should be on the local review body will largely be for the planning authority to take.As regards the point that you made about people who make representations, there is at present no third-party right of appeal and the package of reforms of the planning system contains no such proposal. When an applicant is unhappy with the terms of a decision on a local application, the review body will look at his case. It might well also take into account any representations that have been made. In those cases in which the local review body decides that it wants to hold a hearing—which I think will be few and far between—it might well take representations on certain matters from people who are not the applicant, such as officials or third parties but, as is the case at present, a third party will not have the right to seek a review of a decision with which they simply disagree. The right to review sits with the applicant.
Are there any other questions or points of clarification for the panel?
You just said that you would not expect the applicant to speak at any hearing that was held. Why is that?
At the moment, if someone is aggrieved at a planning decision, they can appeal it and they have a right to be heard, but the 2006 act changed that. Whether an appeal is made to ministers or a review is carried out by the local review body, the future landscape will be that the applicant will be asked how they would like their case to be dealt with, but they will no longer have an automatic right to be heard.As is likely to be the case with appeals to ministers, the focus will be on a review. It will be for the decision taker, whether that is a reporter, ministers or the local review body, to consider how the case could be examined most effectively. In the majority of cases, that will probably be through written submissions, as happens at the moment, but there might well be circumstances—perhaps when a decision was not taken by an officer within the period—in which the local review body needs more advice or wants to interrogate an issue a bit more carefully. In those circumstances, the regulations provide for a fairly straightforward procedure that will allow the review body to hold a hearing, which amounts to a structured discussion, in which the parties who have an interest in the issues will be able to put forward their views for consideration.However, the local review process was never intended to be adversarial or to involve cross-examination. Even when appeals are made to ministers, we think that the number of cases in which the more adversarial approach that is adopted in a public inquiry is required will be extremely limited.
I understand that we want to move away from adversarial situations and I appreciate what the minister said about the difficulty of resolving planning issues when there are strongly held views, but I wonder about not involving all the parties, including the applicant. Perhaps that is an issue for another discussion.
I will try to deal with that point. The local review body must meet in public, even if it is considering how a case will be dealt with. In circumstances in which the local review body considered that a hearing was necessary, it would invite the parties that it thought needed to participate to come to the hearing and to make their views known. The regulations allow for that to happen.
Are we asking about appeals?
No. We have drifted a wee bit, but we are not quite at the appeals regulations.
We are going into quite a bit of detail, but I want to ask a more general question. When do you envisage that the changes under the 2006 act and the SSIs arising from that act will come into force? What information about the changes will be fed to the officials in the local authorities or planning authorities, to the members of those authorities, and to the public and community councils? What process is envisaged for all that information?
The key provisions on development management will take effect in August. We will revise and publish the circulars at the end of the current parliamentary process. We will then hold forums to promote the changes and discuss issues that practitioners and communities are concerned about. We will make more information available on our website and we have a database containing more than 7,000 contacts to whom we provide e-alerts of changes to the planning system.There is therefore a variety of means by which we can support the changes. We will be going out to the authorities and holding more public forums. In the past, at the outset of a change, we might have provided a planning advice note. Planning advice notes will still have a role in planning guidance and advice, but we want to promote a more practical, living form of giving guidance to people. We might well signpost best practice in one part of the country to those in another part who might be interested. We have a range of mechanisms to promote the changes and we will support people through effective guidance.
As members have no more questions, are we agreed that the committee wishes to make no recommendation on the regulations?
Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Local Government and Communities Committee Wednesday 28 January 2009 Committee business · 1
- Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 4
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 38
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 15
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.