We move on to agenda item 2, which is evidence from the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change and his officials, on draft regulations. During this agenda item, the minister and his officials can respond to members' questions. I welcome Stewart Stevenson and, from the Scottish Government, John McNairney, deputy director of planning; Stephen Hall, senior planner; Alan Cameron, senior policy officer; Norman MacLeod, senior principal legal officer; and Oonagh Gil, deputy chief reporter. I remind the witnesses that we have requested that they remain at the table until all the agenda items on subordinate legislation—items 2 through to 9—have been considered.I invite the minister to make introductory remarks.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Town and Country Planning (Grounds for Declining to Follow Recommendations) (Scotland) Regulations 2009 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Stewart Stevenson SNP 9
- Stephen Hall Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment 7
- Bob Doris SNP 5
- David McLetchie Con 4
- Duncan McNeil Lab 3
- John McNairney Scottish Government Directorate for the Built Environment 3
- Dr Alasdair Allan SNP 2
- John Wilson SNP 2
The record
38 contributionsI very much welcome the opportunity to answer questions from the committee on the complete package of planning regulations that were laid at the end of last year. The regulations are required to implement a major element of planning reform and will, if they are agreed to, put in place a new planning system for development planning and development management, and a new appeals structure.That is just one area of our drive to reform the planning system, so the regulations should be considered in that wider context. For example, the Parliament is considering national planning framework 2, which sets out a strategy for Scotland's long-term development and identifies priorities for the improvement of national infrastructure. We are consolidating and rationalising national planning policy. The first two parts were published last year and we will consult on the final thematic section in March.We have a shared commitment by the Government, local authorities, key agencies and the development industry to agree, and to keep under review, positive actions to support reform. Once they are introduced, the regulations will help to create a planning system that is effective and efficient, but which acknowledges the important role that communities have in the decision-making process. We have consulted widely, and the clear message from responses is that things need to be simplified. We have done that to as great an extent as possible, given the provisions of the Planning etc (Scotland) Act 2006.The planning system is process driven, but it is important to remember that it plays a particular role in creating high-quality environments, and that it should be a positive force for shaping our communities, in which it is crucial to the delivery of strong and sustainable economic growth.
I offer committee members the opportunity to ask questions of the panel.
Good morning, minister. You were right all along—in comparison with this lot, the national planning framework is, indeed, "a rattling good read".Something puzzles me slightly about the first set of regulations. The recommendations that would be declined would have been made by a person appointed by the Scottish Government. One would expect that person to be conversant with, and expert in, planning law—for example, someone who was attached to the inquiry reporters unit. How could such an appointed expert person reach a conclusion that was inconsistent with the national planning framework, the strategic development plan or a national park plan, that was incompatible with the Conservation (Natural Habitats, &c) Regulations 1994 (SI 1994/2716) and which was somehow so unreasonable that it bore no relation to the evidence that was considered? How could such a situation arise?
David McLetchie puts his finger firmly on an important point. That eventuality is extremely unlikely, because the professional people who are involved have the necessary skill set and do not get such things wrong. However, that distant and unlikely prospect exists in any system that is based on the work of human beings. In the tens of thousands of parachute jumps that are made every year, the reserve chute is used extremely rarely. The provision falls into the same category.I invite Stephen Hall to expand on my answer.
I will add just that we expect most of the people whom ministers appoint to be reporters from the directorate for planning and environmental appeals. As David McLetchie said, they will be extremely experienced in undertaking such appeals. The directorate is held in high esteem by the planning profession and is widely trusted. As the minister said, we expect the regulations to be called into play rarely.
I accept that and I agree with what you said about the quality and qualifications of the personnel who are likely to be involved.I am slightly puzzled as to why the arbiter of whether the expert has got it wrong is the planning authority and not the minister. In straightforward terms, why is the local council the arbiter of a test—of whether a decision was completely contrary to the evidence—that a court would normally apply in the judicial review of decisions? Why is the council the determiner of the national planning framework's content? In the rare situations in which something goes badly wrong, surely the arbiter of whether the decision was wrong should be the Government—not the council whose development plan is involved. Surely ministers are competent in that regard.
Thank you for your kind words. Ministers can call in plans, when that is appropriate. Ultimately, whether the process was correctly applied can be reviewed in the Court of Session. Matters can be resolved through a hierarchy.I take this early opportunity to say that we place a high value on local accountability. The core of the planning system is the local authority. We must trust councillors to make decisions that are in the interests of the people whom they were elected to represent. I suspect that we will return to that subject when we deal with the other statutory instruments, and that I will repeat that statement.Matters can be progressed through a hierarchy, so Mr McLetchie's well-founded confidence in ministers is backed by our ability to call in plans when necessary.
If the examination process had been followed, the local authority had declined a recommendation on the basis of a reason in the regulations and ministers were unhappy with the local authority's declinature, then they could call in the local plan and correct the situation. Is that correct?
At the end of the process, when a local authority wishes to adopt its plan, the authority informs ministers of that. Ministers then have 28 days in which to tell the authority that it cannot adopt the plan and to call in the plan for approval by ministers or to ask the authority to modify the plan.
So the local authority's decision is not necessarily the end of the road.
That is correct.
For clarity, the minister does not need to take action. The plan is adopted if the minister takes no action within 28 days. We should consider what has happened in the past and what would be likely to happen in the future. The minister will take no action if the plan is satisfactory; therefore, it would be adopted.
Will the proposals effectively restrict the grounds for declining to follow recommendations?
Currently, a reporter's recommendation might be set aside and not taken on board by the planning authority. The roots of the legislative change are in trying to ensure that the public have more faith in the system and are more willing to engage in the development plan examination process. Essentially, we are looking to restrict tightly the grounds on which planning authorities can set aside a reporter's recommendations. That is what the regulations will do.
I would like to confirm the thinking behind the regulations. Is the aim to make the public understand the process more clearly or to ensure that they have more confidence in it?
The objective is to ensure that members of the public can have more confidence in the system than they currently have.
That takes us back to where Mr McLetchie started. Professionals are engaged in the process. Therefore, we need clear reasons why their views have been rejected, and we need clear documentation on why. The regulations simply draw together what people probably think is a normal and natural way to deal with things in any event. They redraw the line of balance a little bit.
link
You have gone some way towards answering most of the questions that we wanted to ask. However, will you give a little bit of clarity on the current situation and the situation that we are moving to? Currently, a planning authority can set aside a reporter's recommendation on a local plan. Does it have to give detailed reasons for doing so?
We want people to explain at every stage of the planning process why they have reached their conclusions. That is an important thread that runs through what we are trying to do.
link
Does the Government currently have specific criteria that must be adhered to in setting aside recommendations?
If I, as a minister, approve or reject a recommendation, I must give reasons for my decision. The regulations will extend what should be done a little bit further.
As the minister said, under the current system, an authority can depart from any reporter's finding, but it must give its reasons for doing so, as it will have to do under the new system.
link
Are reasons for doing so laid down under the current system? Is there a set of guidelines that local authorities must follow?
No.
link
Are the local authorities unfettered? Can they cite any reasons they want for departing from a finding?
Yes. There is no description of what their reasons should be. Any reason can be given.
link
Right. So is this the first time that criteria will be set out for setting aside a recommendation?
Yes. That is correct.
I am interested in what Mr McNairney said about trying to instil public confidence in the process. What is the problem with public confidence in the planning process at the moment? Much play has been made of planning professionals and the public being against each other. In the past 18 months, I have been involved in a number of cases in which the public have felt that planning decisions have not gone the way they wanted them to go. How can we instil confidence in the public if the previous planning regime failed?
Because of their experience, I am sure that all members will understand that not everyone will get from the planning system the answers that they seek, whether they are seeking to promote or oppose a scheme. The debate is not about changing the nature of the decisions: it is about changing the nature of the decision-making process, so that the basis upon which decisions are reached is more clearly focused along auditable, understandable, documented and rational process paths. At the end of the day, the decision might not necessarily be different, but we should have a process that is clear about why the decision was reached. We will certainly never get ourselves to the position where everyone gets what they want out of the planning system, because that is not in the nature of planning.
I accept that not everyone will get what they want out of the planning decision-making process. I am trying to draw out how the proposals that are before us today will instil more confidence in any member of the public who engages with planning decision-making structures and feels that they will show no major difference from the existing procedures, apart from getting more detailed reasons for decisions, which I thought people who object to planning proposals already get through the local authority planning process. When a planning proposal is made, officers have to outline the reasons for accepting or rejecting it to applicants, local authorities and objectors to the proposals. I am just trying to get at what is so different about the new proposals compared to the existing regime.
One of the key issues is that, by defining the grounds for rejection and thereby not allowing open season for something to be rejected for any reason whatever, we are building confidence in the process and in the individuals who make the decisions—particularly the councillors—by giving them the protection of a rational set of reasons from which they can choose to reject a plan. That is as important as anything else, and it will build confidence in the councillors who make the decisions. Mr McNairney would like to expand on that.
For many individuals and communities, it takes a lot of energy, commitment and courage to engage with an examination process that can be quite daunting, particularly to a lay person. If, having committed to engage with the system, you complete that lengthy process and an independent report has made a clear-cut recommendation, it can be surprising and disappointing, and it can prevent you from engaging with the planning system in the future if the recommendation is set aside on a basis that you consider to be arbitrary. That is why I said that the regulations are, in part, about building confidence in the system. They will provide clarity by condensing to a few grounds the bases on which the planning authority can set aside reporters' recommendations.
As there are no other questions to the panel, we will move to the debate on the motion. I invite the minister to move the motion.
Motion moved,
That the Local Government and Communities Committee recommends that the draft Town and Country Planning (Grounds for Declining to Follow Recommendations) (Scotland) Regulations 2009 be approved.—Stewart Stevenson.
Motion agreed to.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Local Government and Communities Committee Wednesday 28 January 2009 Committee business · 1
- Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 4
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 38
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 15
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.