Agenda item 5 is consideration of an item of subordinate legislation under the affirmative procedure. Again, we will take evidence from the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change on the draft regulations. I invite the minister to make introductory remarks.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Town and Country Planning (Hierarchy of Developments) (Scotland) Regulations 2009 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Stewart Stevenson SNP 15
- David McLetchie Con 7
- John McNairney 6
- Mary Mulligan Lab 3
- Duncan McNeil Lab 2
- Bob Doris SNP 2
- Dr Alasdair Allan SNP 2
- John Wilson SNP 2
The record
42 contributionsI will speak fairly briefly. The Planning etc (Scotland) Act 2006 introduced in primary legislation the hierarchy for planning and defined the three categories—national, major and local—to which all developments will be allocated. The draft regulations describe and assign classes of development to the categories of major and local developments. National developments are designated through the national planning framework. The hierarchy is at the heart of the proposals for planning reform and the intention is that it will encourage a more proportionate approach to processing planning applications, and focus resources on proposals that involve greater economic benefit or environmental impact. The approach concentrates on making the system more fit for purpose and efficient.
I have a brief question. When you decide on thresholds, there is always an issue about cases that are a little on either side of the threshold. In the classification of transport infrastructure projects, the cut-off point for major developments is a length of 8km. Why was that length chosen? When I first considered the issue, I thought about the new Forth road bridge, but that is in the national planning framework and is therefore not just a major development. However, other bridges that are less than 8km might be seen as strategic and therefore as major developments. How would those be picked up in the system?
The point that we must remember in any event is that you can treat things that fall below a threshold as if they were above the threshold if it makes sense so to do. Having had a little think about it, although the Clackmannanshire bridge itself is not 8km, I am pretty confident—although not certain—that when the roads on either side of the bridge are added you probably get to 8km. If it did not come to 8km, I would nonetheless think that one would be likely to end up deciding to treat it as if it had. The thresholds compel us to treat things in a certain way, but if the development is below the threshold we could still take the view that it should be treated as a major development. None of my officials is disagreeing with me.
Why 8km?
All the figures that are associated with the thresholds are subjectively chosen. We try to strike the balance of advantage, which is why it was important to find out during the consultation process what the right numbers are for the different thresholds to establish whether a development is major, minor, national or whatever. To some extent, it is inevitable that the figure is not objectively supported by evidence that it must be 8km rather than 8.2km or 7.8km, because it is not that nature of figure. That is why it is important that, after the draft regulations have been in place for a while, we review whether they are delivering the outcomes that we expect. We expect to start the review process after one year. The review will not necessarily lead to changes, but given that the figures that have been chosen are derived from consultation rather than having been scientifically derived, we will certainly keep an eye on the matter. The previous Administration—this was supported across the Parliament—decided that the matter should be addressed in secondary legislation so that we can refine and adapt the thresholds in the light of experience.
I used the 8km threshold as an example, but for each threshold, if a development is below the threshold, will it be ministers or the local authority that can decide that it is more important?
There will also be schemes of delegation. Local authorities will form their own views on what they want in a scheme, but it must be approved by ministers, so they are not distant from the decisions that local authorities make. It is clear that planning in central Glasgow is very different from planning in, for the sake of argument, Dornoch in the Highlands. There would therefore be no expectation that each of the 34 planning authorities would come up with exactly the same schemes of delegation. There is flexibility, but we have set out our stall in the draft regulations.
link
If something is classified as a major development—the draft regulations contain the criteria and guidelines according to which such classification will be made—is there a difference in how local authorities would consult the communities concerned?
The development management regulations, which the committee will consider following this item, set out provisions for enhanced scrutiny. They explain that, along with national developments, a major development would be a candidate for pre-application consultation of the community. Major developments that are significantly contrary to the development plan would, at the end of the process, be subject to a pre-determination hearing and a decision by the full council of an authority. There is therefore a link to how planning authorities will process major developments.Major developments are also candidates for processing agreements, which are not contained in legislation, because existing provisions allow the planning authority to vary the timescale for processing a planning application. The intention is that, for major developments with a processing agreement, there will be a more realistic timescale for determining the application. At the outset, key agencies, the developer and the planning authority will get together and will be clear about the information requirements and the timescale for processing the application. Essentially, the draft regulations are about promoting efficiency by identifying the types of development that need to be project managed through the system, regardless of the outcome.
Efficiency is important to the communities involved. We are spelling out a plan that will promote efficiency in processing major developments and which will make it clear in advance how the process of decision making will be documented. People or bodies in the community who are engaged in the process of opposing the development will have greater certainty about how the development will be dealt with, and about timescales. That will not only help those who are involved in the planning process to prepare and to organise themselves; it will help those who are seeking to oppose the development to organise themselves and to structure their approach. It is important to bear it in mind that the process is not just efficient for the developer; there are potential efficiency benefits for opposition, too.
link
That is a useful point. In my experience, communities sometimes oppose developments, because they are sprung on them—the first thing people see is a poster on a lamppost. The provision of pre-application scrutiny and consultation could lead a lot of potential objectors to buy into projects, so I would encourage that as a positive measure for speeding up the planning process.I know that you had to pick numbers and criteria to distinguish between local and major projects. I was interested to see the threshold set at 50 housing units. I know that you had to pick a number—if you had set the threshold at 100 or 200, people might have had issues with that.If an area is zoned for housing and a developer comes along and builds 40 houses one year, 40 houses the next year and 40 houses the year after that, there would never be a major development as such, but the overall effect would be the same as that of a major development. How would such a situation be dealt with?
You are right to say that 50 is an arbitrary number. Mary Mulligan made a similar point earlier. We started the consultation process with the thought that 100 would be the right number, but the workshops that we held led to the conclusion that, on balance, the right number was 50.You asked about the cumulative effect. The plans that the local authority makes in designating areas for housing development are the right point at which that should be considered. The nearest village to me, which is 3 miles away, has 85 houses. There is a development there, involving—from memory—a dozen houses, which is a significant development for that community. Of course, the council can deal with that appropriately and can ensure that there are opportunities for the community to engage. What we are doing is setting the benchmark for what happens when a development comprises 50 houses. There is always flexibility for the local authority to consider things. The point at which a council designates land and says that it has been put aside for 282.5 houses is important. Of course, that does not take away the opportunity for people to be engaged in developments as they happen, because each development of 40 might have quite different characteristics.
The key is the plan-led system that we are trying to promote, in which communities are given a real opportunity to engage constructively in the process. It is difficult to predict whether a developer would want to submit an application for 49 houses to avoid the requirement for pre-application consultation, although I have to say that house builders increasingly accept the benefits to their scheme, and to the process, of engagement in pre-application consultation with communities. There is a lot of guidance out there, some of which we provided, on the best ways of doing that. The landscape is generally much more positive. There are, of course, benefits for the developer in putting in an application that is above the threshold, simply because of the focus on front-loading the system and processing the application through it.
Is it correct to say that minor developments will now fall outwith the scope of the planning system or will no longer require planning consent?
No, no—not at all. A separate piece of work relates to permitted development rights, which could be described as you suggested in your question, but it will come later. We expect a scheme of delegation to deal with many minor developments. Under such a scheme, the decisions will be made by officials, but the appeal process will involve councillors. Minor developments will certainly not drop out of the planning system.
In that case, do you plan a public education programme on that process so that the public understands the point that you just made?
We are delivering more powers and responsibility to community councils across the planning reform agenda in general. We will work with them, in particular to ensure that they understand their additional responsibilities and role in the system and are equipped to deal with it, because it is an important part of that agenda.How do people engage with the planning system? It is likely that they engage when there is a development that they feel affects their interests. The financial support that successive Governments have provided for organisations such as Planning Aid for Scotland is probably the best way of ensuring that the public have access to the advice, training and education materials that such organisations provide.
Once the regulations are in place, we will work on an easy-read guide to the new system in order to set out the principles more effectively for the general public. There is on-going consultation on increasing permitted development rights for householder developments. Once we finalise the regulations, we will back them up with images that make them more user friendly and easier to understand. That material will come out of the planning system.
Can we look at the hierarchy with reference to a specific example with which the committee is familiar? I ask the minister to confirm whether the application for the Menie estate development—otherwise known as the Trump development—would have been classified as a major development under the hierarchy, had it been in operation at the time.
I speak from memory, but I think that the number of houses involved in that development is substantially in excess of 50, which would elevate it from being a minor development. In that sense, it would certainly be classified as a major development.
If I remember the circumstances correctly, that major development was contrary to the local plan, and it would also be contrary to the local development plan under the new system. Is that correct?
I was not part of the decision-making process, although I could have been. The development was so close to the boundary of my consistency and was to have such an impact on it that I was not part of the process. As I know about the details only informally, I do not wish to take the risk of misleading the committee. Although I accept the generality of what you are saying, I speak more as a constituency member with an informal understanding than as a minister involved in the detailed consideration of any of the material associated with that application.
Your caution is welcome. For the purpose of this discussion, let us assume that the Menie estate application was a major development that was contrary to the local development plan, which I think we will find is the case. Would that mean that, under the draft regulations, a sub-committee of a council, pursuant to a scheme of delegation, could never again take the final council decision on the matter and that, were we rerunning the Trump application under the new system that is being introduced, the final local decision would be taken by the full council of Aberdeenshire Council and not by a committee?
Yes.
So we will have no more Trumps.
I am simply confirming the question about the specific process. My ability to look into the future may be more restricted than my ability to answer questions about the instruments that are in front of the committee.
We know how far sighted you are.I will ask a final question to give me an idea of scale. Is there any estimate of how many applications a year in Scotland are likely to be major developments?
It is difficult to be precise, particularly in the current climate. Of the 50,000 planning applications that go through the system annually, half are householder developments. Between 4 and 10 per cent might be major developments, although it is difficult to predict how many will be submitted over the next year or 18 months.
I accept that it is dependent on the level of economic activity, but how many major developments were there among the applications that were processed in 2007, for example, when the economy was buoyant before the credit crunch hit?
The figures that we collect from planning authorities are based not on the hierarchy in the regulations but on lower thresholds. We take figures on developments of 10 houses and more, for example. However, about 5 per cent of last year's applications were major developments.
In broad terms, that means about 2,500 a year.
That is the figure that I have worked out.
I was heartened by your comment about engagement with community councils in the planning process, but those bodies do not cover all of Scotland. What remedies will be put in place to enable people to engage in the planning process in localities where there is no community council? Are you saying that the Scottish Government will campaign throughout Scotland for more community councils to be established to allow for local democracy in the planning process?
I suspect that, whatever efforts might be made, it would be impossible to achieve 100 per cent coverage. My constituency—I have no particular knowledge of other members' constituencies—probably has approximately two thirds of the community councils that it might have. I have a highly diverse constituency, with urban, rural and even remote areas. I am not sure that community councils are my responsibility—nobody present is suggesting that they are—but I would be happy to speak to the relevant minister when I have checked exactly who it is.
The primary legislation requires that, before a planning application for a major development is submitted, the developer must give the planning authority notice of his proposal and an outline of the organisations that he intends to consult. The planning authority might request that consultation takes place with another body of interest in the community, in addition to the community council. Under the Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure) (Scotland) Regulations 2008, to which we will come, the developer will need to carry out a range of consultation that involves holding one public event and advertising the proposal to hold such an event.There is a basic framework that provides authorities with the scope to ensure that any proposals for a major development are subject to pre-application consultation that is fit for purpose. When the application for a major development is submitted, it must be accompanied by a report on that consultation process, which the authority will take into account in due course. That does not supersede or remove the need for communities to engage with the process later on and to make representations, but there are safeguards at the start of the process to ensure that a major developer undertakes appropriate, proportionate consultation with the local community.
I welcome that response. Local authorities are responsible for determining the geographical size of the areas served by community councils and how community councils are established. However, a development of more than 50 housing units, which may be seen as a major development in a local area, may involve not a community council, which deals with a larger area, but a tenants or residents association. Would it be appropriate to give guidance to local planning authorities suggesting that, where appropriate, such bodies be included in the consultation process, instead of leaving that to chance? A developer may say that, because there is no community council in the area, there is no local organisation with which it can consult, ignoring the fact that there is an active tenants association or residents association.
Councils have a duty to identify appropriate bodies. In my constituency, as well as those of other members, there are a number of community associations that are essentially indistinguishable from community councils. Some communities have decided, for whatever reason, to take that bottom-up route instead of setting up a community council under the aegis of the local authority. If there were a major development in Gigha, it is likely that Argyll and Bute Council would deem it appropriate to consult the Isle of Gigha Heritage Trust, which was responsible for the buyout there; the same might be true elsewhere. I would be surprised if councils did not want to involve community associations and tenants associations in the process.You asked whether we will provide guidance on the issue. At this stage, the answer is that we will consider what you have said and seek to identify the appropriate way of ensuring that councils make the right decisions—decisions that are sustainable and supportable. Of course, everything that happens will be part of a published plan. If a local council does not do the right things, that will be evident to the public, as it will be on the public record; the plan will also inform the way in which the public engage with the application as it goes through.John McNairney made the important point that, increasingly, developers see that there is huge merit in engaging with communities in advance, as that smoothes the way, enables them to refine their plans and provides them with an indication of assurance in relation to how the process will move forward and the resources that they need to commit to it. I suspect that, if councils fail to identify all the bodies that should be involved, developers may assist with that. The fact that this is all in the public domain and on the record and that there is a benefit to everyone involved in the process early on means that all the prospects are in place for the process to work reasonably well.
As there are no further questions, and it seems that no member wishes to debate the draft regulations, I invite the minister to move motion S3M-3181.
Motion moved,
That the Local Government and Communities Committee recommends that the draft Town and Country Planning (Hierarchy of Developments) (Scotland) Regulations 2009 be approved.—Stewart Stevenson.
Motion agreed to.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Local Government and Communities Committee Wednesday 28 January 2009 Committee business · 1
- Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 4
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 38
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 15
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.